Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

You're assuming every resident of the county is stupid. Most people realize it takes money to supply and man a fire station, and I bet most people would happily still voluntarily pay the $75 charge even if firefighters had to occasionally respond to a fire started by someone who hadn't bothered. Most people don't need to see somebody "taught a lesson" to understand how important it is to keep the fire dept. funded.

See the Prisoners Dilemma. Just because it’s in everyone’s best interest to pay the $75 to properly maintain a fire department doesn’t mean it makes sense to do so.
 
Except, that in this case extra risk and costs for the firemen were minimal (at least until fire reached the house) compared to those of insurance company. And guy wasn't buying insurance, he was buying fire extinguishing service and firemen just didn't want to sell. Instead, they chose to out-Rod the unpaying rod which they successfully did.

No.

He did NOT buy fire extinguishing service. He REFUSED to buy fire extinguishing service, which was on sale for $75 per year. End of story. He refused what he was offered, so the fire brigade was under no obligation whatsoever to agree to any offer coming from him. They made it perfectly clear to him under which conditions he could buy their services, and he intentionally and deliberately refused.
 
What I want to know, is why this thought never crossed anyones freaking minds:

Put the fire out, and BILL the guy for the services.

Gee, neat concept. You bill the person for services rendered.

People have to pay when the amublance comes to pick them up at their home, and is covered under insurance, and NO one pays in advance for ambulance services.


Really, what's so hard in saying "Screw the list, let me put this fire out, and its between the COUNTY and the man to have him pay for it"

I think it boils down to the fact the guy is an a-hole. Really, the firefighters probably know the names of every tightwad, freeloader that refuses the 75 dollars per year, and are tickled pink to see them get bitten in the ass by their extremely poor descision.

Putting out the fire, and saving this guy's house would be a service, a service this guy could easily have bought. But he thought it was more important to save the 75 dollars a year. And he got exactly what he paid for, which is a fire department that stood by.

Not paying the 75 dollars is a pretty big **** you to the firefighters, why would this guy be surprised at all, when they refuse to stop property damage?

Let's be real here, this guy didn't think he was going to have a fire so he didn't pay. Knowing full well ( despite his lame statement) that the firefighters were under no obligation to save his house should he not pay.

My parents owned a video store during my high school days and i saw crap like this all the time. We charged a standard 1.25 fee per rental for "tape insurance" ( yes it was tapes back then.) most people were fine with it, especially after being told how much rental copies are worth ( at the time anywhere between 1 and 5 hundred dollars, if it was not a sell-through.). But you had the odd knob that demanded that this fee be removed. We removed the fee, and every single time , when one of these people did damage a tape, it was the same story. " Well that price is way too much, i am not paying it. ". And then came the yelling, the pleading, the whining , etc.

People like that deserve what they get, they know what the fees are for, and they chose to not pay them. So they should deserve no sympathy ( when it comes to monetary loss) when they do not have the benefits of the insurance/service.
 
I think it boils down to the fact the guy is an a-hole. Really, the firefighters probably know the names of every tightwad, freeloader that refuses the 75 dollars per year, and are tickled pink to see them get bitten in the ass by their extremely poor descision.

[...]

People like that deserve what they get, they know what the fees are for, and they chose to not pay them. So they should deserve no sympathy ( when it comes to monetary loss) when they do not have the benefits of the insurance/service.

That may all be true, but we need to have some sense of proportionality. Should refusal to pay a $75 fee really be punished with the death of pets and total annihilation of property?

They should have put out the fire and fined him. $75 + money to cover the cost of filing court papers to place a lien on the property or garnish wages + something punative, like a speeding ticket.

Letting it burn to teach him a lesson is insane.
 
Obviously, paying costumers should get priority, but in this case there was no paying customer to take it. Also, as mentioned before it is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_rider_problem but wasn't applicable in this case.

But the problem is fires don't give notice. A fire doesn't call up the fire department a few hours before hand and say " excuse me, i am going to ignite at john smith's place in about 3 hours, he has paid his fee and you fellows should come out. "

They could strike at any time, in any area. And if someone is out serving Mr. No Payment, they cannot come and put out my fire.

And then there is the issue of Person A who doesn't pay the fee gets their fire put out because there was no other fires at the time. Person B does not, now person B will inevitably complain and cause a ruckus about how Person A , in their situation got service, and they didn't.

And as we can see, even when the fire department was in the right, the headline is still basically " fire department are heartless and evil. ". Imagine how much more crap they would be taking if instead of not putting out the fire , they started to, then stopped and went to another fire.

The only logical solution is the one the followed. Once human life is saved, mr no pay becomes mr no service.
 
See the Prisoners Dilemma. Just because it’s in everyone’s best interest to pay the $75 to properly maintain a fire department doesn’t mean it makes sense to do so.
It makes sense for me to not want my neighbor's fire to become my fire. If hosing down his property will protect mine and others' homes and land from destruction, then his property should be hosed down. Fires tend to spread if they're not properly contained, and a slow response by the fire department because the 911 call came from a non-paying resident could very easily also cost responsible people their homes.

I agree Mr. Cranick is an idiot. What I don't agree with is risking the property of others to take him down a peg or two.
 
Last edited:
Sure you can. You just have to charge what it actually costs.

A quick google indicates that about 1 in 1000 houses catch fire each year in the US. Average cost of fire protection service per household is hard to find, but based on a quick survey of local numbers, it appears to be slightly over $100 per year. So to fund fire departments by charging for service, the average charge would have to be at least $100,000.
 
That may all be true, but we need to have some sense of proportionality. Should refusal to pay a $75 fee really be punished with the death of pets and total annihilation of property?

They should have put out the fire and fined him. $75 + money to cover the cost of filing court papers to place a lien on the property or garnish wages + something punative, like a speeding ticket.

Letting it burn to teach him a lesson is insane.

But then we have the situation in which they are charging him for something he didn't order. This guy could very validly sit back and say " i didn't ask them to put out squat, i am not paying anything to them. I don't pay the annual fee, what would make you think i am paying a large fee?". Not to mention the fact that the guy could make a valid case that any agreement he made on the spot was under duress.

Why should the firefighters, and maybe appropriate city officials have to waste their time in court because this guy is a cheap a-hole?

If i chose not to get travel insurance on a school trip, and then break my arm and have to pay a large fee should i have the option of paying a smaller fee after i break my arm? No, of course not, there is already a fee in place set up by the medical people. And if i don't have the insurance i am not entitled to any smaller fee. That is what the insurance is.

The intent of letting it burn is not to make an example out of the guy, that is just a pleasant side effect. It was left to burn because he didn't pay the fee. And by putting it out, and making up an a la carte fee, it would be exposing the fire department to further hassle from a person that is obviously about getting something for nothing. ( as evidenced by his unbelievable statement that he thought not paying the fee wouldn't impact his service.)

It all comes down to MR No Pay, wanting services he didn't pay for. Which is the saving of his property and home. If Mr. No Pay died, sure i would be angry. But when Mr No Pay was bank-raped because of his own stupidity, i have no sympathy for the guy.
 
Sure you can. You just have to charge what it actually costs.

The FD would never see that money.

Fire services are simply something you shouldn't be able to opt out of is basically all there is to it.
 
It makes sense for me to not want my neighbor's fire to become my fire. If hosing down his property will protect mine and others' homes and land from destruction, then his property should be hosed down. Fires tend to spread if they're not properly contained, and a slow response by the fire department because the 911 call came from a non-paying resident could very easily also cost responsible people their homes.

I agree Mr. Cranick is an idiot. What I don't agree with is risking the property of others to take him down a peg or two.

Yeah, i am sure fire fighters have no idea how to tell if a fire is spreading. It is not like they have any clue how fire works.

That is why they showed up, to make sure there was no risk to other property. The argument you make would be valid, if , they didn't show up, but that is not the policy they have.

People keep painting the picture as the fire department showing up there with a stage and dice clay to make jokes about the guy. While i have no doubt there was some smug smiles as it happened, they were there to make sure that they did their jobs, and that the fire was contained on the idiot's property.
 
I never said it was the fire departments fault, it’s clearly the fault of the county for buying into a bad solution.

It seems to me the county didn't buy into any system. That's the problem.

The guy lost his house . . .

Yes.

. . . the fire department was forced to deploy in response to a fire caused by someone not paying into their system . . .

They are getting paid anyway. The costs come with fighting the fire. One could say that, at most, it was the cost of the fuel in the truck the fire department is out.

They would have been out far more had they fought the fire, if equipment was lost, if a firefighter was hurt or killed.


. . . and the neighbours land values decline because of the burnt out building near their property. . .

One can't sy this would have much of a negative impact on value but if it did, it would only be in the short term. One doesn't know what would happen after. Also, the neighbour might be able to purchase the land at a very good price which is an increase in value for them.

. . . the bank will be out the money it lent him to buy the house and the banks customers will be passed along this expense . . .

That's already been paid. The bank calculates a certain bankruptcy rate into the price of everyone's morgage.

It’s ridiculous to suggest the owner is the only person to pay the price here.

I don't think so.

Taxpayers still need to pay for the fire department to deploy . . .

Why should the city taxpayers pay the cost of fighting a fire outside their taxation area when the person refused to pay the fee? Fighting this fire is what would have put the burden onto the taxpayer.

. . . the neighbours hopuse that caught fire will have to be repaired . . .

No, it didn't. It was just a field.

. . . when the owner declares bankruptcy he will stop paying his mortgage and no longer be responsible for fixing the burnt out house on his former property.

No, he is covered by insurance. We don't even know that he has a mortgage. Could be paid in full. In which case there would be no bankruptcy.

These costs will be passed along to the banks other customers and his former neighbours, they don’t vanish just because he goes bankrupt.

There is nothing to pass on, they are all imagined costs.
 
I think it boils down to the fact the guy is an a-hole. Really, the firefighters probably know the names of every tightwad, freeloader that refuses the 75 dollars per year,
This part is almost certainly true.

and are tickled pink to see them get bitten in the ass by their extremely poor descision.
This part, not so much. At least, not out on the fire scene. If this had been in my department, yeah, after the fact we'd probaly joke around that he'd gotten what served him, but it would be murder on all of us out on the scene watching a perfectly good trailer go up in smoke that we could had saved had the incident commander not belayed the order.

I can't find if SFFD is volunteer, paid1 or a mixed department, but considering the area (rural Western Tennesee, right on the Kentucky boarder), it's most likely a volunteer department. They aren't "tickled pink", they joined the department to help the community this guy included. While I can understand why the Chief made the decision he did, I would have had a difficult time being on scene and not cracking the pumps open. Here's the thing though, when you're out there, you have to follow command. It does no one any good in the long run to buck it. Too many injuries on a fire scene are caused because someone decided to wildcat it.
ETA: I found them on Firehouse. They appear to be paid volunteers. Damn, I wish that would work in my state.






1The SFFD's page says that the current Chief going as a volunteer back in the 90's. So it wasn't a full paid department then. It could be a mixed department, like what they do in Alabama a lot, where they have a couple of full-time paid members who rotate firehouses inthe county and then the rest of the members are volunteer.
 
Last edited:
A quick google indicates that about 1 in 1000 houses catch fire each year in the US. Average cost of fire protection service per household is hard to find, but based on a quick survey of local numbers, it appears to be slightly over $100 per year. So to fund fire departments by charging for service, the average charge would have to be at least $100,000.

You would also need to charge extra for the possibility that some people would not be able to pay
 
But then we have the situation in which they are charging him for something he didn't order. This guy could very validly sit back and say " i didn't ask them to put out squat, i am not paying anything to them. I don't pay the annual fee, what would make you think i am paying a large fee?". Not to mention the fact that the guy could make a valid case that any agreement he made on the spot was under duress.

This is just not an accurate description of the law.

If your neighbor hires someone to paint his house and they paint yours by mistake, you can still be charged for the service, especially if you were aware they were working and didn't make them stop. This guys was watching his house burn and begging the firefighters to douse the flames.

This is just true under basic contract law. It's the concept of unjust enrichment. When dealing with government services, the legal history is even more firmly against your claim.

There would be no legal basis for this man to argue against any fee levied against him. The firefighters can quite easily argue that the fire needed to be extinguished to protect others in the area, and based on how the county pays for fire services, he should receive such a fine.

I didn't sign anything declaring that seat belt laws apply to me, but I can still receive a ticket.
 
Last edited:
1The SFFD's page says that the current Chief going as a volunteer back in the 90's. So it wasn't a full paid department then. It could be a mixed department, like what they do in Alabama a lot, where they have a couple of full-time paid members who rotate firehouses inthe county and then the rest of the members are volunteer.

Probably, the county population is only 30,000 at 60 square miles population density.
 
First:

They are getting paid anyway. The costs come with fighting the fire. One could say that, at most, it was the cost of the fuel in the truck the fire department is out.

They would have been out far more had they fought the fire, if equipment was lost, if a firefighter was hurt or killed.

And then:

Why should the city taxpayers pay the cost of fighting a fire outside their taxation area when the person refused to pay the fee? Fighting this fire is what would have put the burden onto the taxpayer.
Ok, I'm a taxpayer in South Fulton. The town pays, I dunno, $500,000 per year to fund the fire department.

The town says, hey, we have enough excess capacity to also cover this outlying area of the county. We'll charge anyone we assist out there, let's say, $500, to cover marginal costs (the extra gas it takes, extra wear and tear on the engine, whatever risk we can monetize, etc.).

Total cost to the town: $500,000.

It strikes me as remarkably stingy not to offer a service if it doesn't cost you anything to do so. It would be nice to increase the pool of 'paying customers', so that my individual share goes down a little, so that everyone is chipping in. But if they only way anyone can think of to do that is to occasionally watch someone's house burn to the ground, I'll go for the first option.
 
Last edited:
They should have put out the fire and fined him. $75 + money to cover the cost of filing court papers to place a lien on the property or garnish wages + something punative, like a speeding ticket.
Just out of curiosity...

Would it even be possible to place a lien on the property? As someone else mentioned, that might not be payable until the land is sold (which could take many years, if its a principle residence.)

Plus, you have the fact that the guy's property was outside the city limits. That might further complicate things, as the municipality that runs the fire department does not have jurisdiction in his area.

And even if they do manage to sue, and the fire department does win the case (this is assuming the guy doesn't claim "duress" as others have suggested he might), what guarantee do they have that he'll pay and not just claim bankruptcy?
 
It makes sense for me to not want my neighbor's fire to become my fire. If hosing down his property will protect mine and others' homes and land from destruction, then his property should be hosed down. Fires tend to spread if they're not properly contained, and a slow response by the fire department because the 911 call came from a non-paying resident could very easily also cost responsible people their homes.

I agree Mr. Cranick is an idiot. What I don't agree with is risking the property of others to take him down a peg or two.

Except, according to the story, the reason the FD deployed was to make sure the fire did not spread to the neighbor's (who had paid the fee) property. They had an obligation to protect the property of their paying customers and they did. By being present and monitoring the fire, they were ready to deal with it if it should start to threaten the neighbor's property. They had no obligation to protect the Cranick's property, though.
 
Congratulations, you just presumed 100% of the population is stupid and unable to recognise a good deal when they see one. Good job!
The good deal and smart decision is to pay nothing, because the odds are far less than 1% that your house will catch fire, and $75 is way more than 1% of your proposed fee for paying once it's on fire.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom