Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

I think it's probably quite rare that a fire department will let your house burn for non-payment. Why? Because it's insane.

The thread I refereed had a town that had someone put a development in 10 miles away in an unincorporated area. The town got tired of sending them all their fire equipment and stripping the town of its own pubic safety when the people did nothing to support it. So they stopped responding unless there was a life in danger. Loosing multiple houses did not get that development to form their own fire department or pay for the use that they put on one.

But in these times of tight budgets it seems like a good idea for towns to close down their fire departments and sponge off their neighbors. After all if they get cut off it would be insane.
 
I am a liberal but I don't think this is a fallacy. Many firefighters agree with me.
From the firehouse thread it seems the firefighters who agreeare the ones who never have to deal with this situation. The ones in rural areas seem to understand the issues involved.

Bottom line is the bottom line - without adequate funding everyone's fire service eventually suffers, unless you make those who do pay pay even more to make up for the freeloaders. People don't like being taken advantage of for years and years, the residents of South Fulton finally said "enough is enough". Pay the fee, or go without fire service.
 
No, it would only make your department's situation worse, and do nothing to encourage the adoption of a "saner policy" since we can see that the practice of offering free services to nonsubscribers did not have that effect.

Come on this is a volunteer organization clearly the volunteers will spend what ever it takes from their own pocket to keep the fire department afloat. So what if it means they get substandard equipment and training, they are providing a vital public service to people who don't want to pay for it. They should be happy at the way this increases their personal risk and likelihood of injury.
 
Segregation used to be law. Sorry, it's just the law, what can you do?

I understand what the situation was, I'm not arguing the firefighters behaved illegally. I'm saying they made an absurdly stupid decision given the spectrum of available remedies.

So put your money where your mouth is then.
 
Oh crap, I didn't realize more than one person disagreed with me. Since the wisest people determine the correctness of an action by popular agreement, I guess I'm wrong.

And since rural mayors and sheriffs in Tennessee are legendary for their reasoned, knowledgeable positions, all you have to do is cite their opinion and we should fall in line...

Clearly you need to take over the county by force, end elections so you can institute your policies there.
 
No, it doesn't. It costs a lot to fund a fire department. Most of these costs are fixed, and independent of the number of people served, up until the point where you need more equipment to adequately serve them.

So we are back to Yonkers canceling their fire department and just calling in FDNY when ever they need to. After all that will not cost you anything by your own logic.
 
So put your money where your mouth is then.
That's a good idea. I propose that all the JREFers who think they should respond regardless adopt a non-paying homeowner and pay the fee for them every year.

Who will be the first to send a $75 check?

Anyone?

Bueller?

Because this is basically what they're demanding the residents of South Fulton be forced to do.
 
That's a good idea. I propose that all the JREFers who think they should respond regardless adopt a non-paying homeowner and pay the fee for them every year.

Who will be the first to send a $75 check?

Anyone?

Bueller?

Because this is basically what they're demanding the residents of South Fulton be forced to do.

Exactly, I firmly believe that the fire fighters would love it if they had plenty of money that they didn't have to worry about who paid or not. But for what ever reason they are not in that situation. Fire departments need a lot of money to run, that money has to come from somewhere. It seems that Mumblethrax and Tranewreck are happy at making others cover the deadbeats as long as it is not them. See how different Mumblethrax is when I change the situation to his locality.
 
I didn't say it was a liberal fantasy. I said it was an example of the liberal fallacy. Which it is.

The fact that some other people agree with you only demonstrates that there's more than one person in the world who subscribe to the same fallacy (if it is a fallacy, which I contend that it is).

And funnily enough the problem itself it caused by conservative knee-jerk voting down taxes.

There are plenty of people on both sides of that place ideology ahead of the real world.
 
It soulnds as though you were offering them a chance to pay when something happended. Also, were you a case manager for a private company or a public service?

Iwas a case manager working on an outreach basis to individuals living with a persistent and severe mental illness. It was a private not for profit 501c (I believe) that received funding through state grants and medicaid and medicare contracts. It was originally totally grant funded but in the 80s and 90s there was a shift to fee for service and a reduction in the grant based portion of state funding, especially around 93-97. Services that were blanket services and state mandated were still 9and still are provided) with no fee for service (i.e. crisis intervention and screening), many grant services had only targeted application by that time.
So we had a sliding fee scale that was nominal for most clients ($3 for case management/hour and $10 for MD/20 mins.), and we refused services to those who refused to pay.
Now since mine was not an office based service, my portion would be billed, but the office based services were not. If you did not settle your bill by the next month (after the SSA checks, then no services)
If you did not pay you did not see the MD , in office case management or counseling.

Now unbeknownst to almost every one, there are almost no blanket services in teh US, EMTLA covers hospitals but almost no other service providers, dentist and doctors can and do refuse services to people in need all the time.
Even ambulance services can refuse to transport you for lack of insurance, unless you are in a life threatening situation, they can and will turn you over to collections.
Medicare will refuse payment of services all the damn time.
Most of our local food panties (not all) require a referral from a social service agency and have limits on how many times you can receive help in a given 90 day period.
Most homeless shelter have strong requirements and rules. You can be banned from them as well.
Domestic violence shelter refuse people admission for a variety of reasons (not seeking your local provider first, being homeless and not a victim.)
The local power company can and will cut off your power for non-payment as soon as the temperature rises above freezing.
 
I understand wanting to discourage people from free-riding -- this guy is stealing, playing chicken with taxpayers -- but there are other vastly more efficient and humane approaches. It's not enough to say "he knew the consequences." Thieves in Saudi Arabia also know the consequences. In any event, they could always put out the fire, make sense of the mess/demand payment, then in a worse case scenario come back on a slow Tuesday morning and burn the place down. They could even blast this song:

 
Now unbeknownst to almost every one, there are almost no blanket services in teh US, EMTLA covers hospitals but almost no other service providers, dentist and doctors can and do refuse services to people in need all the time.
Even ambulance services can refuse to transport you for lack of insurance, unless you are in a life threatening situation, they can and will turn you over to collections.

This depends on dispatching and such. If you call 911 for an ambulance you will be taken to the closest hospital, with out regard for your condition or ability to pay. It is also hard for a paid ambulance to refuse taking someone to an ER if they can't pay at least once an ambulance is there and the EMT's are talking to the person.

An EMT has to discharge care in one of two ways, either to a doctor or that the patient signed the Refused Medical Assistance form on the back of the PCR.

But it really pisses you off when someone calls 911 instead of a taxi to go to the hospital for their appointment.
 
I understand wanting to discourage people from free-riding -- this guy is stealing, playing chicken with taxpayers -- but there are other vastly more efficient and humane approaches.

Yes, and the county keeps voting them down. So why don't you start coughing up the money to implement those approaches?
 
I've asked this a couple of times and I'm curious:

For the "This is how capitalism works" crowd, should the fire department be allowed to negotiate its fees as the house is burning? Certainly people would be willing to pay more at that moment.

What stops them from doing that now? Surely we haven't constrained the free market.

Not for the people who already paid $75.

For someone who refused to pay and now suddenly wants the service? Sure, why not? Rush jobs always get charged more.
 
We generally put them in jail, don't we? :confused:

Yes, because of Constitutional rules of proportionality.

Allowing someone's home to burn for want of $75 is insanely disproportionate. What crime, committed with malice, would justify such a punishment?

Now obviously the firefighters didn't commit a crime, so don't get ridiculously literal like others have. I am arguing that this sense of proportionality should extend throughout society even when the behavior isn't bound by law. This is one of the ways we create a civil, humane country.
 
Not for the people who already paid $75.

For someone who refused to pay and now suddenly wants the service? Sure, why not? Rush jobs always get charged more.

I didn't bring up that thought experiment for this specific case.

Fire departments are now for profit, private industries. There are no fees, no dues, they're just allowed to use the free market to dictate their payment. THey wait until a house is on fire, if no one is there, they put it out and leave a bill. The bill will be enforce through the doctrine of unjust enrichment.

If an owner of the home is present, they begin bargaining before the hoses are turned on. That's maximizing their earning potential. Anyone have a problem with that system?
 
Not popular agreement, by facts. You seem to want to ignore how the system operates and replcae it with some idealistic wishful thinking.

The system is what it is. If you want to change it, you need to change the minds of the people in the county who chose to go without fire protection. You need to get them to pass a tax in a referendum because that is how the system works, and by law it must be followed.

No, I don't. People keep saying this, out of pure naiveté with respect to the law.

They put out the fire, leave a bill, it's enforced in the courts. That was the proper treatment, not allowing the house to burn.


Yeah, they're smart enough to have people elect them and to be in charge of multi-million dollar budgets but not smart enough to know that someone who didn't want to be taxed for a service or pay for that service is entitled to it regardless. :rolleyes:

Man, this was the best PR campaign rural politicians could have run. This area, doubtlessly full of anti-evolutionists and Bible literalists, is now being defended as wise and intelligent on the JREF boards. The power of ad hoc argumentation can never be fully appreciated.
 
No, I don't. People keep saying this, out of pure naiveté with respect to the law.

They put out the fire, leave a bill, it's enforced in the courts. That was the proper treatment, not allowing the house to burn.

Proper treatment as defined by you. There are other people, equally knowledgable of the law, who think you are completely wrong.

Man, this was the best PR campaign rural politicians could have run. This area, doubtlessly full of anti-evolutionists and Bible literalists, is now being defended as wise and intelligent on the JREF boards. The power of ad hoc argumentation can never be fully appreciated.

Nice emotional appeal. Now you want to drag backward people into your enlightened world because you are so much smarter than the hicks from Obion County. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom