Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

They still shouldn't have let the home burn down.

And that, my friends, is the liberal fallacy in a nutshell: Regardless of the broader ramifications, they still should have responded to the immediate need, even if it means greater risks down the road.
 
Yes, that's correct.

Which was my point, actually.

Clearly, the FD didn't decide on the spot, "This fire, we're not going to put out." They had already made the decision that the next unsubscribed fire that called in, they were not going to respond to.

So it's lucky that it was only a trailer.

Which is why it's so easy to say, "Oh, well, look, it was just a little trailer, what's the harm in going in?"

My point is that the circumstances of this particular fire are not what's really at issue.

What if the next fire had been a 2 story home with serious risk of injury to the fire fighters?

So the argument of "What was the risk?" is a false argument.

Just because this particular fire turned out not to be particularly risky doesn't change the fact that demanding a response to any unsubscribed property does indeed pose a risk to these fire fighters which nobody has a right to demand that they take on.

So it's actually good -- relatively speaking -- that this turned out to be the test case.

Although I still feel horrible for the animals.
I think that they had decided that earlier. When the 911 call originally came in, they didn't respond per city ordinance. My point is, because they went out when the neighbors field was threatened, they were already on the scene, and should not have let the home burn down. Personnel were there. Equipment was there. The threat was minimal. Screw the mayor's orders, PUT OUT THE FIRE AND SAVE THE HOME.
 
My point is, because they went out when the neighbors field was threatened, they were already on the scene, and should not have let the home burn down. Personnel were there. Equipment was there. The threat was minimal. Screw the mayor's orders, PUT OUT THE FIRE AND SAVE THE HOME.

Yes, I did not fail to understand your opinion on that matter.

Again, it's the liberal fallacy: Meet the immediate need, regardless of moral hazard, regardless of people's choices, regardless of future consequences.

It's not a good idea.
 
And that, my friends, is the liberal fallacy in a nutshell: Regardless of the broader ramifications, they still should have responded to the immediate need, even if it means greater risks down the road.
I am a liberal but I don't think this is a fallacy. Many firefighters agree with me.

If by broader ramifications, you mean threatened loss of income for the Fire Department, I've already said that I think the homeowner should have been billed costs plus a penalty. I wasn't aware until I read the firefighters' thread that a $500 charge was made when a fire was put out on top of the $75 service fee; that may be for actual costs. So bill the homeowner $575, plus a $2000 penalty. That should make it worthwhile for others to pay their $75.

Some of the firefighters on their forum said they were in subscription situations. While not all agreed, some said they would just put out all fires and bill later. So this is not just a "liberal" fantasy.
 
Last edited:
Hey, folks, let's set up our own rural fire department!
No.

Well, let's pass a mandatory tax and contract with an existing fire department!
No.

How about a system where we voluntarily pay about 25 cents per day to get fire protection?
Okay.

Here's your envelope. Send in your payment.
No.

<ring> <ring>Hello? Sir? You haven't sent in your payment for fire protection. Can you please send it in now?
No.

<Idiot starts fire in his own yard and catches trailer on fire.>
How come nobody tried to help us?
 
So this is not just a "liberal" fantasy.

I didn't say it was a liberal fantasy. I said it was an example of the liberal fallacy. Which it is.

The fact that some other people agree with you only demonstrates that there's more than one person in the world who subscribe to the same fallacy (if it is a fallacy, which I contend that it is).

The obvious problems with setting up an FD as a collections agency have already been discussed upthread.
 
Hey, folks, let's set up our own rural fire department!
No.

Well, let's pass a mandatory tax and contract with an existing fire department!
No.

How about a system where we voluntarily pay about 25 cents per day to get fire protection?
Okay.

Here's your envelope. Send in your payment.
No.

<ring> <ring>Hello? Sir? You haven't sent in your payment for fire protection. Can you please send it in now?
No.

<Idiot starts fire in his own yard and catches trailer on fire.>
How come nobody tried to help us?

Exactly.

And then so many people in the media have the stones to make the fire fighters out as the bad guys.

Makes you sick.
 
Hey, folks, let's set up our own rural fire department!
No.

Well, let's pass a mandatory tax and contract with an existing fire department!
No.

How about a system where we voluntarily pay about 25 cents per day to get fire protection?
Okay.

Here's your envelope. Send in your payment.
No.

<ring> <ring>Hello? Sir? You haven't sent in your payment for fire protection. Can you please send it in now?
No.

<Idiot starts fire in his own yard and catches trailer on fire.>
How come nobody tried to help us?

You forgot that (as I understand it) the Fire Dept had responded to another fire at this property in 2007 - wherein a similar situation occurred: The owner had not paid the yearly fee and resorted to begging for assistance, which was provided.

It is apparent that the Homeowner had no intention of changing his/her ways as they felt no incentive to pay the fee until a fire threatened their property (again).

Kind of puts that whole "bill them after the fact because that will encourage everyone else to pay upfront" to bed, don't you think?
 
It works because people agreed to enact a proper political solution. Not because "putting themselves at risk for property" is "what fire departments do".
I'd prefer it if you could refrain from divorcing that comment from context and pretending like I was responding to something other than "You want them to put themselves at risk for property."

Let's not be naive. Fire fighters put themselves at risk to protect life and property because there's a system in place to support their risk.
There is a system in place because firefighters put themselves at risk.

This mutual dependency suggests that volunteers needn't always defer to the people cutting the check.

And letting someone's house burn down is such an idiot solution to a political problem that firefighters should actively undermine it by completely ignoring this policy wherever they can.

You can't blame people for refusing to walk where there ain't no floor.
This is rustic, but it's a poor analogy that captures nothing relevant about the circumstances.

By now, you should know good and well why this analogy is not relevant.
It is a simple illustration of the general moral principle that we should help to prevent serious harm where there is no cost to us, trivial risks notwithstanding. If you accept that, we can move on. If you don't, we're never going to reach any kind of agreement.

Once again -- tho denying upthread that you're blaming the fire fighters -- you're insisting on focusing on only the immediate situation.
Where did I deny that I was blaming the firefighters? I am blaming the firefighters, I've said so at least twice. I'm also blaming the dumbass who didn't pay his subscription, the idiot fire chief who told them not to put it out, the petty town that adopted this absurd policy, and the freeloading county residents.

There's a lot of blame to go around here. No need to be stingy.

But this decision was not based on the immediate situation.
And this is not a good thing.

The risks of continuing to provide services for those who opt not to pay were, in the long term, untenable for the fire fighters.
Nah. This is all about how to distribute costs. I'm sure the fire fighters would have gladly put themselves at whatever trivial risk turning on a hose and pointing it at a trailer incurs. Someone told them not to, because they were trying to enforce subscriptions. That's not about risk, it's about who pays the bills and how much they pay.

Neither you, nor I, nor anyone else has the right to demand that they put themselves in that position.
Don't need to. They volunteered. And I don't believe for a second that they wouldn't have helped if they hadn't been told not to.
 
I'd prefer it if you could refrain from divorcing that comment from context and pretending like I was responding to something other than "You want them to put themselves at risk for property."

No problem. Your response is "that's what fire departments do". Which is pure idealism. Ignoring the actual situation surrounding this actual particular incidence of fire departments putting themselves at risk. Or, more to the point, ignoring the broader implications of what engaging here would end up having them being obliged to do if they followed your philosophy.

Sure, it's true that fire dept's do put themselves at risk for property.

But not without some measure of reciprocation, some measure of compensation and appreciation on the part of the people they're risking their safety for.

Isn't that enough for you? Good God, man, what else do you demand from these flesh and blood people to satisfy your armchair idealism?

You want them to go out and expend city resources -- that other folks have paid for -- and risk injury to themselves to protect people who choose not to pay them one single penny, people who simply assume that others will take on the risk when they have been negligent, and for what? For what? To perpetuate the illusion that protection is without cost?

Sounds like a right bad deal to me.

Better to disabuse people of that notion sooner rather than later.
 
There is a system in place because firefighters put themselves at risk.

You've got that backwards, my friend.

Firefighters put themselves at risk because there is a system in place.

It's a system that compensates them for their bravery, and for the sacrifice of their time and effort.

Hey, I tell you what, let's apply your reasoning to the military, and law enforcement.

Let's have our armed services and our sheriffs and deputies and cops and detectives work for free, and then hand out bills to people whose bacon they save.

Let's burden them with that, turn them into collections departments, have them battle to claim the compensation for their efforts after the fact.

And hey, if they get injured or killed, their families can just cool their heels while the litigation works its way through the courts and they try to extract compensation from people who were not inclined to pay in the first place.

That ought to work out just fine and dandy.
 
And letting someone's house burn down is such an idiot solution to a political problem that firefighters should actively undermine it by completely ignoring this policy wherever they can.

Wait and see, brother. Wait and see how "idiot" it is. Wait and see whether or not it results in forcing people to get their act together and pony up for well deserved compensation for folks who risk life and limb to protect other people.

Because obviously, the alternative wasn't exactly going great guns now, was it?
 
It is a simple illustration of the general moral principle that we should help to prevent serious harm where there is no cost to us, trivial risks notwithstanding. If you accept that, we can move on. If you don't, we're never going to reach any kind of agreement.

I do not care one iota whether or not you and I reach an agreement. I have absolutely no investment in agreeing with you on this matter.

You keep talking about no cost, no risk, but that's only within the very narrow scope you choose to view -- this one single incident. The world ain't so simple.

If you can't consider any broader considerations, well, that's between you and Jesus. But it certainly doesn't require me to put on blinkers.
 
Where did I deny that I was blaming the firefighters? I am blaming the firefighters, I've said so at least twice. I'm also blaming the dumbass who didn't pay his subscription, the idiot fire chief who told them not to put it out, the petty town that adopted this absurd policy, and the freeloading county residents.

There's a lot of blame to go around here. No need to be stingy.

And apparently in your case there's also no need to actually think about who really does deserve the blame and who does not. Just line 'em all up against a wall and spray 'em with blame.

Sure is easier that way. No doubt about it.

But a skeptics' forum is a funny place to go about relieving yourself of the burden of critical thought.
 
I do not care one iota whether or not you and I reach an agreement. I have absolutely no investment in agreeing with you on this matter.

You keep talking about no cost, no risk, but that's only within the very narrow scope you choose to view -- this one single incident. The world ain't so simple.

If you can't consider any broader considerations, well, that's between you and Jesus. But it certainly doesn't require me to put on blinkers.
I certainly have no wish to agree with most of the views in your posts. The reason there is talk of no cost, no risk is because of the "narrow scope" of this thread. The OP presented a single, specific incident. That incident involved specific circumstances. Under those circumstances, with the firefighters on the scene, there was no moral reason not to save the home. This thread isn't addressing the whole world, nor does this situation have anything to do with Jesus.

Where did I deny that I was blaming the firefighters? I am blaming the firefighters, I've said so at least twice. I'm also blaming the dumbass who didn't pay his subscription, the idiot fire chief who told them not to put it out, the petty town that adopted this absurd policy, and the freeloading county residents.

There's a lot of blame to go around here. No need to be stingy.
And apparently in your case there's also no need to actually think about who really does deserve the blame and who does not. Just line 'em all up against a wall and spray 'em with blame.

Sure is easier that way. No doubt about it.

But a skeptics' forum is a funny place to go about relieving yourself of the burden of critical thought.
How is it wrong to say that all the parties in this mess had a share in the blame? It has nothing to do with "easier." And why do you assume that only those who agree with you are taking on the "burden of critical thought?"
 
.
I got one back that had the proper stamp, but the address wasn't visible in the window in the envelope.
The Post Office opened the envelope, determined I had sent it.. it was a bill.. and -returned- it to me to re-send... with another stamp of course.
When I took it to the P.O., the postmaster said "You might be wondering why after opening it and finding the address, we didn't then handle it properly".
"Yes, that thought did cross my mind".
"We didn't do it that way".
Ah don't you love bureaucracy......
I bet you folded the bill so the address was visible in future though?
 
You're wrong. There is a difference between public services offered to a community and private enterprise.

I don't know exactly how this is set up but it most likely legally a non profit organisation. It might contract and have a charter with the town to provide service but it is likely no more a community enterprise than habitat for humanity.

Hey maybe they can be forced to fix someones house if they don't want to pay for it.
 
Why would the townies want to participate in a plan which included twice as many people and orders of magnitude more territory when they can sit behind their town borders and collect coupons at $75 a pop? They've already got the equipment. Remember, according to our diligent researchers there's only one chance in a thousand that any of those premiums will ever be called in, and even if one is it may only cost them the fuel for the drive. If Cranick had been up on his payment they would have driven out three whole miles (or less) and watered his lawn, and apparently billed him another $500. They probably could have used the practice.

Sounds like a cash cow to me. They'd be nuts to give it up.

It might barely cover expenses, $1000 to show up and $1000 an hour per truck might be better. You have a lot of overhead to cover

But people don't think that is reasonable so they cover those charges in regular fees like taxes and subscriptions.
 
I keep mentioning this.

That's so easy that there must be some other explanation for the system the towns are engaging in.

We know it isn't out of charity, or the kindness of their hearts, or any sense of community spirit. The evidence against that is why this thread exists.

And that is not enough, you need hundreds of thousands of dollars in equipment and someone has to pay for it. Would you let your neighbor take your car when ever they wanted, provided that maybe half the time they pay for gas? Of course they don't check with you to see if you might need the car at the same time as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom