It works because people agreed to enact a proper political solution. Not because "putting themselves at risk for property" is "what fire departments do".
I'd prefer it if you could refrain from divorcing that comment from context and pretending like I was responding to something other than "You want them to put themselves at risk for property."
Let's not be naive. Fire fighters put themselves at risk to protect life and property because there's a system in place to support their risk.
There is a system in place because firefighters put themselves at risk.
This mutual dependency suggests that volunteers needn't always defer to the people cutting the check.
And letting someone's house burn down is such an idiot solution to a political problem that firefighters should
actively undermine it by completely ignoring this policy wherever they can.
You can't blame people for refusing to walk where there ain't no floor.
This is rustic, but it's a poor analogy that captures nothing relevant about the circumstances.
By now, you should know good and well why this analogy is not relevant.
It is a simple illustration of the general moral principle that we should help to prevent serious harm where there is no cost to us, trivial risks notwithstanding. If you accept that, we can move on. If you don't, we're never going to reach any kind of agreement.
Once again -- tho denying upthread that you're blaming the fire fighters -- you're insisting on focusing on only the immediate situation.
Where did I deny that I was blaming the firefighters? I am blaming the firefighters, I've said so at least twice. I'm also blaming the dumbass who didn't pay his subscription, the idiot fire chief who told them not to put it out, the petty town that adopted this absurd policy, and the freeloading county residents.
There's a lot of blame to go around here. No need to be stingy.
But this decision was not based on the immediate situation.
And this is not a
good thing.
The risks of continuing to provide services for those who opt not to pay were, in the long term, untenable for the fire fighters.
Nah. This is all about how to distribute costs. I'm sure the fire fighters would have gladly put themselves at whatever trivial risk turning on a hose and pointing it at a trailer incurs. Someone told them not to, because they were trying to enforce subscriptions. That's not about risk, it's about who pays the bills and how much they pay.
Neither you, nor I, nor anyone else has the right to demand that they put themselves in that position.
Don't need to. They volunteered. And I don't believe for a second that they wouldn't have helped if they hadn't been told not to.