Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Nobody got hurt.
Sure they did, in the sense of 'harm'.

You want these guys to put themselves at risk for property.
Yes. That's kind of what fire departments do (among other things).

However, I think the chances of injury when spraying down a double-wide are pretty remote. We're not talking about rushing into a burning building to save people here.
 
I reckon you have to say it exactly one fewer times than we have to say that it may not, in fact, cost a firefighter nothing to engage a blaze, and that there are longer-term costs to be considered.
That's utterly non-persuasive. The risks are so remote as to be negligible. This is like saying that you shouldn't rescue a child drowning in a swimming pool, because there are utterly trivial risks to you (you might slip on the tiles, knock yourself out, fall in the pool and drown).

We can play this game forever.
You can. I've got better things to do.
 
Sorry it is a fee for service based contract. Not ethical but that is capitalism for you.

Segregation used to be law. Sorry, it's just the law, what can you do?

I understand what the situation was, I'm not arguing the firefighters behaved illegally. I'm saying they made an absurdly stupid decision given the spectrum of available remedies.
 
How many times do I have to say this? I am not arguing that they have legal obligations to help. I am saying that if you can help and it costs you nothing to do so, then you should help. And you're an ******* if you don't. That goes for everybody.

This is a red herring. It does in fact cost a lot of money to fight a fire so it does cost somebody and your argument is vacuous.
 
I'm saying they made an absurdly stupid decision given the spectrum of available remedies.

Not according to the other fire chiefs, the county mayor, the municipalities, the owner herself and many here who completely disagree with your assessment of the event.
 
Not according to the other fire chiefs, the county mayor, the municipalities, the owner herself and many here who completely disagree with your assessment of the event.

Oh crap, I didn't realize more than one person disagreed with me. Since the wisest people determine the correctness of an action by popular agreement, I guess I'm wrong.

And since rural mayors and sheriffs in Tennessee are legendary for their reasoned, knowledgeable positions, all you have to do is cite their opinion and we should fall in line...
 
Last edited:
This is a red herring. It does in fact cost a lot of money to fight a fire so it does cost somebody and your argument is vacuous.
No, it doesn't. It costs a lot to fund a fire department. Most of these costs are fixed, and independent of the number of people served, up until the point where you need more equipment to adequately serve them.
 
I've asked this a couple of times and I'm curious:

For the "This is how capitalism works" crowd, should the fire department be allowed to negotiate its fees as the house is burning? Certainly people would be willing to pay more at that moment.

What stops them from doing that now? Surely we haven't constrained the free market.
 
This is like saying that you shouldn't rescue a child drowning in a swimming pool, because there are utterly trivial risks to you (you might slip on the tiles, knock yourself out, fall in the pool and drown).

Sorry, but it's already been quite well established that these guys would have immediately gone in to help any person at risk. There were no such persons. Only property was at risk.

(Sadly, we consider animals to be "property" in the USA, but that's another story.)
 
For the "This is how capitalism works" crowd, should the fire department be allowed to negotiate its fees as the house is burning? Certainly people would be willing to pay more at that moment.

You seem to be under the curious impression that anyone here thinks the absurd system these idiots have chosen for themselves is a good thing. I'm not sure where you picked it up from, far as I can tell it's the people of the area that has chosen a capatalist system to provide fire protection, maybe you should go and ask them this question?
 
Idealism is a beautiful thing.
There is nothing idealistic about this. It's exactly the system in place in rural counties all across the country. It works. Right up until taxpayers shoot themselves in the foot out of resentment.

Sorry, but it's already been quite well established that these guys would have immediately gone in to help any person at risk. There were no such persons. Only property was at risk.

(Sadly, we consider animals to be "property" in the USA, but that's another story.)
The relevant distinction is between trivial and serious harms, trivial and serious risks. If you need me to contrive an example with property, fine. If you see some neighborhood kids trying to set fire to your neighbors house, knowing that no one is home, do you yell out your window at them to stop? Or do you go back to reading your newspaper because one of them might have a gun and mighttry to shoot at you? The risks of harm to yourself are remote, the risks of harm to your neighbor due to your inaction are nearly certain.
 
There is nothing idealistic about this. It's exactly the system in place in rural counties all across the country. It works. Right up until taxpayers shoot themselves in the foot out of resentment.

Well, there you go.

It doesn't work because of the reasons you were touting.

It works because people agreed to enact a proper political solution. Not because "putting themselves at risk for property" is "what fire departments do".

Let's not be naive. Fire fighters put themselves at risk to protect life and property because there's a system in place to support their risk.

This county decided to adopt a partial, piecemeal approach.

Kind of like a house with a partial floorboard.

You can't blame people for refusing to walk where there ain't no floor.
 
The relevant distinction is between trivial and serious harms, trivial and serious risks. If you need me to contrive an example with property, fine. If you see some neighborhood kids trying to set fire to your neighbors house, knowing that no one is home, do you yell out your window at them to stop? Or do you go back to reading your newspaper because one of them might have a gun and mighttry to shoot at you? The risks of harm to yourself are remote, the risks of harm to your neighbor due to your inaction are nearly certain.

By now, you should know good and well why this analogy is not relevant.

Once again -- tho denying upthread that you're blaming the fire fighters -- you're insisting on focusing on only the immediate situation.

But this decision was not based on the immediate situation.

The decision was made that these fire fighters would no longer put themselves at risk for non-subscribers.

It just so happened -- thank you, Jesus -- that this fire was of relatively low risk.

The risks of continuing to provide services for those who opt not to pay were, in the long term, untenable for the fire fighters.

Neither you, nor I, nor anyone else has the right to demand that they put themselves in that position.
 
No, it doesn't. It costs a lot to fund a fire department. Most of these costs are fixed, and independent of the number of people served, up until the point where you need more equipment to adequately serve them.

If only it worked that way. As the Obion City fire chief said, "If there is an accident, if we lose a piece of equipment, someone is hurt, or we get sued, the service to the county ends like that [snaps fingers]."
 
Oh crap, I didn't realize more than one person disagreed with me. Since the wisest people determine the correctness of an action by popular agreement, I guess I'm wrong.

Not popular agreement, by facts. You seem to want to ignore how the system operates and replcae it with some idealistic wishful thinking.

The system is what it is. If you want to change it, you need to change the minds of the people in the county who chose to go without fire protection. You need to get them to pass a tax in a referendum because that is how the system works, and by law it must be followed.

And since rural mayors and sheriffs in Tennessee are legendary for their reasoned, knowledgeable positions, all you have to do is cite their opinion and we should fall in line...

Yeah, they're smart enough to have people elect them and to be in charge of multi-million dollar budgets but not smart enough to know that someone who didn't want to be taxed for a service or pay for that service is entitled to it regardless. :rolleyes:
 
The Firehouse.com thread I linked to has people discussing this exact issue. It is really very interesting

Here is the link again.
I read the whole thread, and it was very interesting. There seems to be a pretty equal split between "put out the fire" and "don't put out the fire." Things got pretty heated as the thread progressed; nobody seemed to change their mind from their starting position. Sounds like this thread.

<snip>
I would add to this that firefighters are risking personal injury any time they directly engage an active blaze.

The bleeding hearts here are asking them to take this risk in order to save property on behalf of someone who has not even bothered to pay the subscription fee.
I would rather be a bleeding heart than be heartless. By the way, there were animals in the home. I don't consider living beings property.

Suppose this had been a fully engaged two-story home instead of a trailer. Are we really going to ask the spouses and children of firefighters to accept the risk of their spouses and parents getting hurt or killed in order to save the property of someone who declined to compensate them for their services? I sure hope not.
A little "hand waving" on your own part?

I believe the fire started outside. I don't think the firefighters were in much danger; they wouldn't have had to go into a burning building. One of the firefighters in the thread linked above estimated about an hour to deal with the fire.
Is it? I do alot of porch repair as part of my job. A few weeks ago we got a call from a property management client to repair holes squirrels had chewed into the side of an enclosed porch, and were getting inside.
<snip>
We told the property manager the porch was beyond repair, could not be made to comply with new city building codes, and was in a dangerous condition. All of which is 100% true, people could get killed on that porch. It will cost ~$27,000 to build a new porch which complies with the building code.

So far, the building owners are balking.
<snip>
Do I have an obligation to build them a new porch for free, and then send a bill after the fact?
No; but you are not a public service, your company is a private enterprise.

They still shouldn't have let the home burn down.

<snip>
These guys are volunteers. If someone told me to stand by while a house burnt down, I'd tell him to get bent. Let them 'fire' me if they don't like it.

Refusing to obey that order is a kind of virtuous civil disobedience. It forces the town to adopt a saner policy.
<snip>
I agree.

Idealism is a beautiful thing.
Finally! You said something I can agree with.
 
A little "hand waving" on your own part?

I believe the fire started outside. I don't think the firefighters were in much danger; they wouldn't have had to go into a burning building. One of the firefighters in the thread linked above estimated about an hour to deal with the fire.

Yes, that's correct.

Which was my point, actually.

Clearly, the FD didn't decide on the spot, "This fire, we're not going to put out." They had already made the decision that the next unsubscribed fire that called in, they were not going to respond to.

So it's lucky that it was only a trailer.

Which is why it's so easy to say, "Oh, well, look, it was just a little trailer, what's the harm in going in?"

My point is that the circumstances of this particular fire are not what's really at issue.

What if the next fire had been a 2 story home with serious risk of injury to the fire fighters?

So the argument of "What was the risk?" is a false argument.

Just because this particular fire turned out not to be particularly risky doesn't change the fact that demanding a response to any unsubscribed property does indeed pose a risk to these fire fighters which nobody has a right to demand that they take on.

So it's actually good -- relatively speaking -- that this turned out to be the test case.

Although I still feel horrible for the animals.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom