Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

If you are referring to trades such as plumbers and electricians, that is a different category than public services. You're comparing peaches and peanuts.
Is it? I do alot of porch repair as part of my job. A few weeks ago we got a call from a property management client to repair holes squirrels had chewed into the side of an enclosed porch, and were getting inside.

Now, this is a big porch on a 6-flat. It's about 15 feet in depth, 35 feet high (3 stories), and 30 feet or so long. It's also in major disrepair, rotten, and IMHO on the verge of collapse. We told the property manager the porch was beyond repair, could not be made to comply with new city building codes, and was in a dangerous condition. All of which is 100% true, people could get killed on that porch. It will cost ~$27,000 to build a new porch which complies with the building code.

So far, the building owners are balking. Apparently they're 2 old ladies who don't want to spend another nickel on it until they die. The tenants don't report it to the city because their rent is low, and they're worried the building will be condemned and they'll have to move to a crappy neighborhood to find a place they can afford.

Do I have an obligation to build them a new porch for free, and then send a bill after the fact?

Sue him if he ignores it. And why would he? The family offered to pay when they called 911.
He did ignore it, several times:
Vowell said people always think they will never be in a situation where they will need rural fire protection, but he said City of South Fulton personnel actually go above and beyond in trying to offer the service. He said the city mails out notices to customers in the specified rural coverage area, with coverage running from July 1 of one year to July 1 the next year.

At the end of the enrollment month of July, the city goes a step further and makes phone calls to rural residents who have not responded to the mail-out.

“These folks were called and notified,” Vowell said. “I want to make sure everybody has the opportunity to get it and be aware it’s available. It’s been there for 20 years, but it’s very important to follow up.”

Mayor Crocker added, “It’s my understanding with talking with the firefighters that these folks had received their bill and they had also contacted them by phone.”
http://www.ucmessenger.com/news.php?viewStory=46801
 
Last edited:
Stop blaming the fire department.
I'm not inclined to. I don't see any reason not to apportion at least some blame to the fire department.

These guys are volunteers. If someone told me to stand by while a house burnt down, I'd tell him to get bent. Let them 'fire' me if they don't like it.

Refusing to obey that order is a kind of virtuous civil disobedience. It forces the town to adopt a saner policy.

These guys don't decide to become fire fighters because they want to watch property get destroyed.
Yet that's exactly what they did. They are a but-for cause, just as several other people are. So they get some blame.
 
Refusing to obey that order is a kind of virtuous civil disobedience. It forces the town to adopt a saner policy.

and following the order is not only virtuous civil obedience, it also forces the county to adopt a saner policy.
 
But that is not the arrangement that the county in question decided to enter into.
The county in question didn't enter into any kind of arrangement.

People have this tendency to assert a fact as justification of that same fact. "It is what it is, that's just the system." This fails to recognize that any system of human organization has a degree of built-in ambiguity, or that the system itself is unjust. We don't have to robotically follow 'the rules', and we shouldn't where we can address a substantial injustice.
 
Is it? I do alot of porch repair as part of my job. A few weeks ago we got a call from a property management client to repair holes squirrels had chewed into the side of an enclosed porch, and were getting inside.

Now, this is a big porch on a 6-flat. It's about 15 feet in depth, 35 feet high (3 stories), and 30 feet or so long. It's also in major disrepair, rotten, and IMHO on the verge of collapse. We told the property manager the porch was beyond repair, could not be made to comply with new city building codes, and was in a dangerous condition. All of which is 100% true, people could get killed on that porch. It will cost ~$27,000 to build a new porch which complies with the building code.

So far, the building owners are balking. Apparently they're 2 old ladies who don't want to spend another nickel on it until they die. The tenants don't report it to the city because their rent is low, and they're worried the building will be condemned and they'll have to move to a crappy neighborhood to find a place they can afford.

Do I have an obligation to build them a new porch for free, and then send a bill after the fact?

Reminds me of a landlady I had once.

My house was in serious need of repair.

Every spring, termites would swarm inside the house!

I'd come home to a cloud of termites, and they'd be popping out of the floorboards like pez candy.

I'd call her up and tell her, "You're going to have to take care of this or the floor is going to fall in." She'd say, "Well, I don't know, I can't spend that kind of money...."

Ditto the roof. I actually offered to put the roof on for free, if she'd buy the materials, and she turned me down! "Well, I don't know, I can't spend that kind of money...."

I went back a couple years ago and the house was in ruins. The house her grandfather built with his own hands.

Damn shame.
 
I'm not inclined to. I don't see any reason not to apportion at least some blame to the fire department.

These guys are volunteers. If someone told me to stand by while a house burnt down, I'd tell him to get bent. Let them 'fire' me if they don't like it.

Refusing to obey that order is a kind of virtuous civil disobedience. It forces the town to adopt a saner policy.

No, it would only make your department's situation worse, and do nothing to encourage the adoption of a "saner policy" since we can see that the practice of offering free services to nonsubscribers did not have that effect.
 
and following the order is not only virtuous civil obedience, it also forces the county to adopt a saner policy.
Sorry, letting someone suffer a serious loss where it would cost me nothing to prevent it isn't virtuous, unless you adopt some truly sociopathic 'virtues'.
 
The county in question didn't enter into any kind of arrangement.

People have this tendency to assert a fact as justification of that same fact. "It is what it is, that's just the system." This fails to recognize that any system of human organization has a degree of built-in ambiguity, or that the system itself is unjust. We don't have to robotically follow 'the rules', and we shouldn't where we can address a substantial injustice.

Uh... yeah... that's my point... the county did not enter into the kind of arrangement that would ensure protection for everybody.

And it's no use pleading to the inherent imperfection in all human systems. That's just hand waving.
 
Sorry, letting someone suffer a serious loss where it would cost me nothing to prevent it isn't virtuous, unless you adopt some truly sociopathic 'virtues'.

It might not have cost you anything -- then again, you have no way of knowing that going in, since there is always the risk of injury -- but it may well have cost other people something down the road.
 
It was wrong, whether intentional or forgetful, not to pay the $75 in a timely manner.

No, it wasn't. It was a choice, maybe a bad one but a choice none the less. I definitely wasn't a wrong that they were being punished for.
 
No, it would only make your department's situation worse, and do nothing to encourage the adoption of a "saner policy" since we can see that the practice of offering free services to nonsubscribers did not have that effect.
How would it make the fire department's situation worse? They have never offered free services to non-subscribers. It does not follow from "A leads to B" that "B does not lead to A", and there is such a thing as institutional knowledge. Yes, they adopted a disastrously inequitable policy, possibly out of resentment of an mildly inequitable policy.

I hope they eventually wise up and return to the mildly inequitable policy.
 
The county in question didn't enter into any kind of arrangement.
Exactly. The county, the only legal authority governing the unincorporated areas, has 0 arrangements to provide Fire Protection for its residents.

To make up for that, the town agrees to provide services to them via a subscription plan. The county resident's love this because it means that they they don't have to pay for it if they don't want to (or forget to) because it is not a tax and not mandatory. Unfortunately, they (and you) seem to forget that if paying for the service is not mandatory, neither is providing the service.

The simplest way to avoid this from happening again is for the county to increase property taxes and use those revenues to contract with the cities to provide service for everybody.

If the county residents agree that fire protection is a public service and everybody has the right to receive it, then there will be no difficulty passing such a measure. The fact that such has failed to pass in the last 20 years, I think it is clear where the county residents are on this issue.
 
Sorry, letting someone suffer a serious loss where it would cost me nothing to prevent it isn't virtuous, unless you adopt some truly sociopathic 'virtues'.

Well, of course, when it costs YOU nothing. However, it costs somebody and that somebody said "no pay, no spray."

How about you put your holier than thou, moral superiority to work and pay the $75 fee for each of the 800+ residence of the county who live outside the fire protection area. That is essentially what you are insisting the people of South Fulton do.
 
Last edited:
It might not have cost you anything -- then again, you have no way of knowing that going in, since there is always the risk of injury -- but it may well have cost other people something down the road.
As Cain explained, uncertainty suggests that we should err on the side of helping people, not hurting them.
 
The county in question didn't enter into any kind of arrangement.

Not true. According to the county they entered into an agreement with three of the departments to provide subscription service at $75 per property.

The County has since expanded that agreement to the other five fire departments.

The county mayor also stated that the plan to bring in a tax to provide fire protection for the entire county was shot down in a referendum.

It isn't the municpalities, it isn't the fire departments, it isn't the county administrators, it's the county residents who don't want fire protection. The ones who do can get it by paying the fee.

The homeowner in question didn't pay the fee.
 
As Cain explained, uncertainty suggests that we should err on the side of helping people, not hurting them.

let's look at that uncertainty. Nobody in house, only property.

Nobody goes in to fight fire, nobody risks injury or death, everybody lives, but somebody loses a valuable asset.

Firefighters go in to fight fire. reduce damage to already damaged assert, risk of serious injury or death to firefighters
ETA: Firefighters typically assume this risk, because they are paid to do so. Not so in this case.

I choose the one that does not risk somebody getting injured or dieing every day of the week. People cannot be replaced, homes can.
 
Last edited:
As Cain explained, uncertainty suggests that we should err on the side of helping people, not hurting them.

Nobody got hurt.

You want these guys to put themselves at risk for property.

Their wives and daughters might have a different opinion on the matter.
 
Unfortunately, they (and you) seem to forget that if paying for the service is not mandatory, neither is providing the service.
How many times do I have to say this? I am not arguing that they have legal obligations to help. I am saying that if you can help and it costs you nothing to do so, then you should help. And you're an ******* if you don't. That goes for everybody.

The town has already demonstrated a willingness to fund a fire department. There is absolutely no evidence that they incur significant new costs to extend this service to outlying regions, and significant evidence that they do not (they have only the bare minimum of equipment to provide reliable coverage to anyone). They can, and do, charge non-subscribers on a per-trip basis. It costs them nothing to do this.

The problem is that the municipalities resent the freeloaders. If they think periodically selecting a non-subscriber at random (or worse) to have his house burnt down is a good solution, they have so thoroughly lost sight of the concept of fairness as to render any opinion they express on the topic moot. They're like plantation owners complaining about self-determination while their slaves toil away in the field.

Tolerating free-loaders is less than ideal, but there is not a better solution until the county residents can be persuaded by means that are not egregiously unjust to foot their share of the bill.

The simplest way to avoid this from happening again is for the county to increase property taxes and use those revenues to contract with the cities to provide service for everybody.
Yes, that would be ideal.
 
How many times do I have to say this? I am not arguing that they have legal obligations to help. I am saying that if you can help and it costs you nothing to do so, then you should help. And you're an ******* if you don't. That goes for everybody.

I reckon you have to say it exactly one fewer times than we have to say that it may not, in fact, cost a firefighter nothing to engage a blaze, and that there are longer-term costs to be considered.

We can play this game forever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom