Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

So you are simply lying? If someones life was at risk they would have acted anyway. You don't seem to recognize the difference here. I am thinking you would think heroes nobly sacrifice their own life to save a bunch of houses.


I think that the kind of person who chooses to be a fire fighter is the kind of person who would feel compassion for the family losing a home. I think that someone who voluntarily chooses a job where putting their lives in danger for the welfare of strangers is a little bit different than the average Joe. I think that they will feel, at least a little bit, that they have somehow diminished themselves by standing aside while the kind of destruction they trained to prevent goes on unchallenged.

I'm not sure if you are just arguing for argument's sake, or if you really can't grasp the concept. If it is the latter case then I feel very sorry for you.

Here's what I think real life heroes feel like. They don't feel noble. Sometimes they feel scared. Often they feel uncertain. They worry a lot about whether they'll be good enough to do the job they've taken on. They worry about other people more than they do themselves. Not just because it makes them feel good, and not because they'll be admired for their nobility, but because they really, honestly give a damn. That isn't what feeling noble is about.

Deriving some sort of twisted sense of vindication because some guy didn't pay seventy five bucks on time and lost his home. That's the sort of thing I seem to be seeing people feel noble about, here. Noble is about self-righteous. Noble is about approbation. Noble is about pride of place, not pride of achievement. I'm not very impressed by noble. I don't think most firemen are in that line of work so they can feel noble.

I'm pretty sure those firemen didn't feel noble.

How do you think they felt?
 
Given that $75 would have turned the hoses on, this is a much more reasonable course of behavior than letting the house burn to the ground.

Sorry it is a fee for service based contract. Not ethical but that is capitalism for you.

I can't get food without paying for it in a grocery store either. they is no implied contract for a municipality to provide services to somoen outside of teh taxing district.

Sad but true.

he did not pay for the service, that is what happened.

****, I have had friends have to put out fires because they lived outside of any protection district.
 
If you are referring to trades such as plumbers and electricians, that is a different category than public services. You're comparing peaches and peanuts.

It is all about punishing people for not payment by the destruction of their property.
Sue him if he ignores it. And why would he? The family offered to pay when they called 911.

People often offer to pay when stressed and then don't when the stress is removed.
 
I'm pretty sure those firemen didn't feel noble.

How do you think they felt?

I think they felt about the same way that paramedics feel someone who assaults a paramedic deliberately is arrested.

Sorry, I as a compassionate case manager was forced to cut services to clients who did not pay their fees.

I did not like it, but I did it. (Most of them chose to pay.)
 
Exactly, which is why this whole "charge him on the spot" or "bill him for it" business is a nightmare waiting to happen.

It means the FD would then have to turn intself into a collections agency.

The Firehouse.com thread I linked to has people discussing this exact issue. It is really very interesting

Here is the link again.
 
Except according to the chief of another FD in the same county:
The problem has been, that once those people have been provided the service; they often seem to choose not to reimburse. Attempting to charge on a per call basis does not generate the needed funds nor does it give county residents an incentive to support the cities, if they can wait until they actually have a fire to pay anything.
As I suggested in a previous post, have fire trucks equipped with blank promissory notes at a fixed rate for non-subscribers that include Fire Department costs as well as a disincentive penalty. Isn't a promissory note a legal document and enforceable by a court? I'm not sure what the highlighted phrase means.

Also that's a very interesting definition of punishment. Is a homeowner who shoots an intruder punishing him or protecting his family?
Protecting his family in a way that punishes the intruder.

What if because of the situation none of the municipal FD offered subscription service and the guy's house burned down because no fire trucks were available to answer the call? would that have been punishment?
No. There would not have been an expectation of service; there would not have been firefighters there watching the home burn down. Also, if all the local towns' fire departments refused to offer services in the county, the county residents would probably vote for some other solution; it would be hard for any residents to get homeowners insurance in an area with no fire protection.

If I live in an area where I vote to lower my taxes by cutting the PD budget to 1/10 of its previous amount, then get mugged because of an increase in crime due to lower PD presence, did the PD punish me by not having officers available to protect me?
Only if they were standing there watching you get mugged and didn't do anything about it.

The point is that often wrongdoing carries inherent risk of ill being suffered as a consequence without need for any active agency to step in and mete out punishment.

If you don't want your house to burn down to the ground, make certain that you have fire protection services available to you. If such requires that you pay $75 a year, pay it. Not paying it, then complaining that somebody was being cruel for not providing you the service anyway just makes one sound like a 3 year old.
Saying it's ok to stand by and watch a home burn down when the personnel and equipment are there to save it makes one sound stone-hearted.
 
I think that the kind of person who chooses to be a fire fighter is the kind of person who would feel compassion for the family losing a home.

Even if people like that hamstring the department from getting the equipment it needs to make them safe.
 
If, as you say, the fire department was the punisher and they were punishing the owner for wrongdoing . . . what was the wrong that the owner done?
It was wrong, whether intentional or forgetful, not to pay the $75 in a timely manner; that is no excuse for standing by a watching the home burn down.
 
It is all about punishing people for not payment by the destruction of their property.
You're wrong. There is a difference between public services offered to a community and private enterprise. The trades you're talking about are optional choices on the part of a homeowner. They choose when and who they will hire. Public services, on the other hand,
. . . tend to be those considered so essential to modern life that for moral reasons their universal provision should be guaranteed, and they may be associated with fundamental human rights (such as the right to water). An example of a service which is not generally considered an essential public service is hairdressing.The Volunteer Fire Dept. and Ambulance Corps. are institutions with the mission of servicing the community. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/public_services
Society usually decides that some services should be available to everyone. In the U.S., we usually consider police and fire departments as public services.

People often offer to pay when stressed and then don't when the stress is removed.
Get them to sign promissory notes.
 
<snip>
Sorry, I as a compassionate case manager was forced to cut services to clients who did not pay their fees.

I did not like it, but I did it. (Most of them chose to pay.)
It soulnds as though you were offering them a chance to pay when something happended. Also, were you a case manager for a private company or a public service?
 
That makes no sense whatsoever.

Yes lets keep a subscription service that only half (or whatever the percent is, its less than 100) the unincorporated county residents pay, rather than passing a tax that forces them all to pay it and fully fund our FD.

Also see Wildcat's several posts that likely only unincorporated residents would be able to vote on such a tax since it would only apply to them.

Passing such a tax would likely reduce costs for city residents, because they would no longer have to foot the bill for any freeloaders in the unincorporated areas.

<snip>


Why would the townies want to participate in a plan which included twice as many people and orders of magnitude more territory when they can sit behind their town borders and collect coupons at $75 a pop? They've already got the equipment. Remember, according to our diligent researchers there's only one chance in a thousand that any of those premiums will ever be called in, and even if one is it may only cost them the fuel for the drive. If Cranick had been up on his payment they would have driven out three whole miles (or less) and watered his lawn, and apparently billed him another $500. They probably could have used the practice.

Sounds like a cash cow to me. They'd be nuts to give it up.

The only problem is watching people's homes burn down every once in a while.

But that's a good thing. Right? Shows 'em about personal responsibility ... and stuff. That'll teach the lazy, good-for-nothing, no-account, freeloading wastrels.

Definitely a win/win situation.

:boggled:
 
You're wrong. There is a difference between public services offered to a community and private enterprise. The trades you're talking about are optional choices on the part of a homeowner. They choose when and who they will hire. Public services, on the other hand,
Society usually decides that some services should be available to everyone. In the U.S., we usually consider police and fire departments as public services.
"Provide for the common welfare..."
Get them to sign promissory notes.
Bill 'em. See what the Colorado Dept of Natural Resources and USFS do to people who start fires...
 
<snip>

No. There would not have been an expectation of service; there would not have been firefighters there watching the home burn down. Also, if all the local towns' fire departments refused to offer services in the county, the county residents would probably vote for some other solution; it would be hard for any residents to get homeowners insurance in an area with no fire protection.

<snip>


I keep mentioning this.

That's so easy that there must be some other explanation for the system the towns are engaging in.

We know it isn't out of charity, or the kindness of their hearts, or any sense of community spirit. The evidence against that is why this thread exists.

I expect they'd hate to see all those $75 dollar premiums quit coming in every year.

They've got themselves a cookie jar they can't keep their hands out of.

Until they do the county's need for a service of their own will always fry on the third rail of "new taxes".

It's probably not gonna happen until something (or someone) important enough burns up while they're standing around watching.
 
The Firehouse.com thread I linked to has people discussing this exact issue. It is really very interesting

I think some of the first comments on that thread really sum it up perfectly:

Tell you what -- just cancel your insurance on your vehicle and when you have a wreck --- offer to pay your premium.

That's obviously outrageous -- which is the poster's point -- but because it's a home instead of a car, people's emotions kick in and override reason.

Usually subscription departments would make a rescue if there were trapped occupants, but if it's just property, sorry it's gone... if you're not a subscriber.

I would add to this that firefighters are risking personal injury any time they directly engage an active blaze.

The bleeding hearts here are asking them to take this risk in order to save property on behalf of someone who has not even bothered to pay the subscription fee.

Suppose this had been a fully engaged two-story home instead of a trailer. Are we really going to ask the spouses and children of firefighters to accept the risk of their spouses and parents getting hurt or killed in order to save the property of someone who declined to compensate them for their services?

I sure hope not.
 
Bill 'em. See what the Colorado Dept of Natural Resources and USFS do to people who start fires...

What's their recoup rate?

And what would be their recoup rate be if all their targets were rural folk from unincorporated county areas of Tennessee?

Can't get blood from a turnip.

Plus, what would the net gain be for the FD if it had to attempt to legally force non-compliers to pay? Gotta subtract those costs.
 
Either way they made a choice that should have been easy, but chose wrong. Either they decided that paying the fee for fire protection was not important enough to make sure they pay on time, or they decided not to pay at all. either decision left them without fire protection services.
Sure, this is a common use of the word 'choose'. For example, in the following exchange:

"Oh no!"
"What is it, dear?"
"I chose not to send in the insurance check!"

This is a transparent attempt at redefinition to sweep under the rug the fact that you're willing to throw people to the wolves for their flaws.

Refusing to provide a service that was not paid for is unnacceptable, but passing that burden onto somebody else who is already paying for the service and now has to pay an additonal $60 for no additional service to cover the freeloaders is acceptable.
If the service is 'not letting your house burn down', absolutely. A $60 difference in taxes per household is trivial in comparison. Similarly, I don't really care if someone freeloads on the rest of us in using emergency room services. The consequences of the alternative are too severe.

Declining to provide a service that has not been paid for is a completely proportionate response.
This is an attempt to cloak the relevant facts by not considering the severity of the failure to act. Since it's not possible to determine proportionality without doing so, the quote above is nonsense.

I agree that it has very disproportinate consequences, which is why it was extremely silly for the Cranick's to allow that service to lapse (either by intent or neglect)
The same causal oversimplification we've seen for the past 15 pages.

You do realize that this is the exact reasoning that I (and others) have been using to explain why providing service for non-payers is a really bad idea.
Yes. Do you realize that I'm pointing out that if the county residents are economic robots, it's immaterial whether you let the house burn or not? The enforcement is too sporadic to pose a serious enough risk.

And they have what many rural areas do, subscription based fire coverage.
Yes. For example, the first hit I get from Google on 'subscription fire department' not related to this debacle is for a fire department in Oklahoma that charge a $48 subscription, and charges a $500 fee to non-subscribers. They won't let your house burn. Same with the second hit. The third is non-specific, but the text implies that the subscription functions as a glorified donation. I stopped checking there.

I think it's probably quite rare that a fire department will let your house burn for non-payment. Why? Because it's insane.
 
For example, the first hit I get from Google on 'subscription fire department' not related to this debacle is for a fire department in Oklahoma that charge a $48 subscription, and charges a $500 fee to non-subscribers. They won't let your house burn.

But that is not the arrangement that the county in question decided to enter into.

Look, there are consequences in this world, and sometimes they are harsh.

I can attest to that, because at one point my own choices left me without a home, with most of my stuff sold off, the rest of it in a buddy's basement, and crashing on a relative's sofa.

It would be great if the county had made such an agreement, but the reality is that they did not.

Maybe now they will.
 
You're wrong. There is a difference between public services offered to a community and private enterprise. The trades you're talking about are optional choices on the part of a homeowner. They choose when and who they will hire. Public services, on the other hand,
. . . tend to be those considered so essential to modern life that for moral reasons their universal provision should be guaranteed, and they may be associated with fundamental human rights (such as the right to water). An example of a service which is not generally considered an essential public service is hairdressing.The Volunteer Fire Dept. and Ambulance Corps. are institutions with the mission of servicing the community. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/public_services
Society usually decides that some services should be available to everyone. In the U.S., we usually consider police and fire departments as public services.

Get them to sign promissory notes.
Except in this case, the society of Obion County did in fact decide that Fire Protection was not a public service. If they had, they would have either supported their own county Fire Department or used tax revenues to contract with one or more of the cities to pay for everybody in the county.

They want to treat it as a private enterprise when it comes to paying, but as a public service when it comes to receiving.

We now all know the results of that mentality. The Cranick's know it far to well.
 
I think it's probably quite rare that a fire department will let your house burn for non-payment. Why? Because it's insane.

Stop blaming the fire department.

They're the ones caught in the middle here.

The county and the people who "opted out" are the ones creating the situation that eventually resulted in them having to watch a trailer burn.

These guys don't decide to become fire fighters because they want to watch property get destroyed.

Get real.
 
They want to treat it as a private enterprise when it comes to paying, but as a public service when it comes to receiving.

Yup. And this mentality is one of the biggest problems in our country today. Privatized gain, socialized risk.

When will we learn?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom