Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Sorry about that, Champ. I've never been a firefighter, so I can only imagine what it must have been like to be in their shoes. Maybe that's the "glurge" that was bothering you so much.

I have been a lifeguard, so I "glurged" that by way of comparison. I "glurged" how I'd feel if I was sitting in a lifeguard chair, swim trunks on, pole and float by my side, and watched someone drown because I wasn't allowed to rescue anyone who didn't have a subscription.

It didn't feel good.
Which is why appeal to emotion isn't a good way to run a service.

No, it doesn't. Is that all you think the job entails?
For some of them, yes.

You know, there really are jobs which ask a bit more than most people are willing to offer, and even ones which demand a little bit more than many people are able to give.
The same goes for sewage treatment tecnician and migrant workers. Are they "heroes"?

Why do you get to use hyperbole, and not me?

Some of those jobs might even involve a hero or two.
Now brush away a tear while you say that. And have a big American flag billowing behind you.
 
It's situational. If they have time to secure other counsel, no. If it's a civil matter, especially one in which I represent the petitioner, then there's less of an obligation than when one defends someone in a criminal matter.

If I was in an immediate position to stop a great harm, like the firefighters, I would consider it my obligation to intervene even if I wouldn't get paid. M choice in such matters would depend on some sliding scale involving the nature of the problem, my ability to help, and the level of burden placed on me.

In this case with customary effort the firefighters could have stopped the fire and recovered the economic loss very easily.

Thanks again. Perhaps other lawyers feel the same way.
 
Nice strawman there, what is his name?

If there was a person at risk they would have acted irregardless of payment and the like. This is entirely a property issue.


There is no strawman. I was explaining where my feeling of empathy for those fire fighters came from.

I have no doubt I could craft an analogy which would fit even your meticulous standards, but an analogy was not my intent.

Sorry for confusing you. Hope you can find some medication for the knee you have that keeps jerking like that. I bet it gets painful after a while.
 
You say that like I've argued differently. Find the part where I argued the firefighters were legally bound to act.
Yet you are pretending what they did was a "punishment" just the same as a court sentence.

It depends on the statute. Negligence actions generally don't make that distinction. Duty-breach-causation-damages. The breach can be either an act or omission.
Then why do they have to specify each?

I don't know what that means, but the 14th amendment applied the Bill of Rights to the states.
I mean show me how that aplies to a city fire department.

In this case... the firefighters could have... recovered the economic loss very easily.
That's the part where you are making a huge unsubstantiated assumption.
 
Yet you are pretending what they did was a "punishment" just the same as a court sentence.

I'm definitely making the analogy. I am not, however, arguing that the firefighters were bound to behave differently by the law.

Then why do they have to specify each?

Because we in the legal profession like to understand what the laws mean.

I mean show me how that aplies to a city fire department.

Show what applies? The proportionality of punishment?

I'm confused. I'm making an analogy between the legal system that demands a proportionality of punishment-->crime and this current situation.

Letting a house burn down for want of $75 is about like cutting someone's hand off for shoplifting. It's insane. The fee could be incentivized with much easier methods through existing institutions.

If you think I'm arguing that the fire department was legally bound to behave differently than they did, then I will apologize for not expressing my stance clearly.

Many people on this thread have argued that the insanely extreme consequence of total destruction of one's home for failure to pay $75 is a valuable heuristic. If such Draconian tactics were used in the legal system, it would immediately be ruled unconstitutional based on the 8th amendment. I think that's a good thing. I think the principle of proportionality is a good one and should be extended to issues beyond just the law.

That's the part where you are making a huge unsubstantiated assumption.

No, I'm really not. Please research "unjust enrichment." Setting aside all other means of securing payment, if they had put out the fire and left a bill, courts would enforce that amount.

Given that $75 would have turned the hoses on, this is a much more reasonable course of behavior than letting the house burn to the ground.
 
It's situational. If they have time to secure other counsel, no. If it's a civil matter, especially one in which I represent the petitioner, then there's less of an obligation than when one defends someone in a criminal matter.

If I was in an immediate position to stop a great harm, like the firefighters, I would consider it my obligation to intervene even if I wouldn't get paid. M choice in such matters would depend on some sliding scale involving the nature of the problem, my ability to help, and the level of burden placed on me.

In this case with customary effort the firefighters could have stopped the fire and recovered the economic loss very easily.

I just wanted to add I understand where you're coming from, and I don't think it's unreasonable; clearly some people in the county outside of the fire coverage provided by the city are taking advantage, but taking care of that after putting out a fire is more important than sending the message that if you don't work you don't eat. But on the other hand, it's not morally right either for those people to continue to take advantage of the city and I think that unless the tax changes there was little else to be done. Something had to break.
 
<snip>

Now brush away a tear while you say that. And have a big American flag billowing behind you.


Wow. That's really original. And probably one of the most mis-aimed platitudes you've ever dragged out. I'm almost proud to watch it go by. I don't get mistaken for a flag waver very often. It takes a rare and singular sort of tunnel vision which hardly ever occurs in nature.

Tell me what your opinion is. How do you think those firemen felt while they watched that home burn down?
 
Last edited:
There is no strawman.

So you are simply lying? If someones life was at risk they would have acted anyway. You don't seem to recognize the difference here. I am thinking you would think heroes nobly sacrifice their own life to save a bunch of houses.
 
I did. Check out my response. Post #513

Were you able to unearth any discussion of voting in your perusal of that article?

Now that you mention it, there's even another ramification which that brings up.

Nearly half of the population of the county lives in the three largest towns in that county. I wonder if they vote in both the city and the county elections. I wonder how the ones who already have fire protection services vote when the city and county pols start talking about raising funds for the rest of the county?

Pretty neat deal, huh? You can fund your fire departments by selling subscriptions to the ones you won't let have fire departments by making sure there isn't enough funding.

Good catch, cwalner. Thanks.

That makes no sense whatsoever.

Yes lets keep a subscription service that only half (or whatever the percent is, its less than 100) the unincorporated county residents pay, rather than passing a tax that forces them all to pay it and fully fund our FD.

Also see Wildcat's several posts that likely only unincorporated residents would be able to vote on such a tax since it would only apply to them.

Passing such a tax would likely reduce costs for city residents, because they would no longer have to foot the bill for any freeloaders in the unincorporated areas.

I also did read a post on another forum that such a tax was in a referendum in 2002 and was defeated. Unfortunately it was not sourced and my googel-fu was not strong enough to confirm. ( I could not find any web sites showing what the 2002 Obion county measures or election results were).
 
There are real heroes. There are more of them than you seem to suspect. If you believe that they are only comic book figures in costumes then you lead a sad life.

The real heroes don't get much press time. An occasional filler maybe, when Britney and Lindsay are both between arrests, but that's about it. Little heroes and big ones. People who run into burning buildings when they don't have to certainly fill the bill for me. Whether they wear tights or not.
I just wanted to toss in a bit of vinegar to cut the uncut glurge in that post.

Just wearing a funny yellow coat and riding a big red truck doesn't make anybody any better than anyone else.
It's not the coat and the truck that make firefighters heroes, it's the fact that they are willing to risk their lives for others, for the greater good, just like members of the armed forces. I consider them all worthy of respect and esteem for that willingness.

I think your posts need a vinegar check because they are sounding very sour, malicious, and full of jerkishness.

<snip>
I feel sorry for the firefighters. They did what they were told. They did ... in a twisted and evil fashion ... their job.

I'd hate to be in their heads right now.

Not only did they have to stand aside and watch someone's home destroyed, but they probably knew those people. That town is only a few families bigger than microscopic. There are high schools bigger than that.

Every time they go to the grocery store, or the gas station, or their church there's a good chance they will have to look in the eyes of that family or their relatives. It doesn't even matter if those relatives don't blame them for doing what they were told to do. They know what they should have done.<snip>
Because there is a sacred trust between fire fighters and the people they protect. One they assumed without being asked to, or without it being demanded. And for whatever reason, they broke it.<snip>
I originally agreed with quadraginta about how hard this must be on the firefighters. But I'm starting to think this is a case of "why didn't they refuse to carry out an immoral order?" These were their neighbors, people they probably knew. How could they just stand by? Why is this different than disobeying any order that is wrong? I think they did break a trust with the community, and they should be sorry. And they should be blamed.

<snip>
No. The Constitution creates and binds the Federal government, not city fire departments.

If you think I'm wrong, show me which "provisions" are the ones that "bind" them.
See below.
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
I believe the Constitution applies to all Americans. The Preamble embodies its purpose.

You seem to have a problem with consequences vs penalties. They did not penalize him, they just did not offer him their services.
Bushwa. They punished them. Punishment: Any ill suffered in consequence of wrongdoing. They punished the family when they stood by and watched the home burn (under orders that were morally wrong) because someone forgot to pay a paltry $75. This in spite of the fact that the family offered to pay whatever was asked when they called 911.

I don't understand you and those others who are saying tough luck and they deserved it. Can't you realize that standing by was an unacceptable action on any American's part? That your posts are disgusting?

What kind of a country are we turning into? Are all of you callous posters representative of Americans today? Is this what the future holds? A nation where no one else matters and where there is no concept of neighborliness, kindness, mercy, or charity. I certainly hope you are only a small, nasty minority.

How can a people pull together under adversity if they cannot trust each other? What happened to the idea of a common good?
 
Bushwa. They punished them. Punishment: Any ill suffered in consequence of wrongdoing. They punished the family when they stood by and watched the home burn (under orders that were morally wrong) because someone forgot to pay a paltry $75. This in spite of the fact that the family offered to pay whatever was asked when they called 911.

Then we need to make more service trades mandatory with out regard for payment. There are all kinds of ones that can be needed or you will lose or have massive damage to your house.
How can a people pull together under adversity if they cannot trust each other? What happened to the idea of a common good?
The county voted it down.
 
Bushwa. They punished them. Punishment: Any ill suffered in consequence of wrongdoing. They punished the family when they stood by and watched the home burn (under orders that were morally wrong) because someone forgot to pay a paltry $75. This in spite of the fact that the family offered to pay whatever was asked when they called 911.

I don't understand you and those others who are saying tough luck and they deserved it. Can't you realize that standing by was an unacceptable action on any American's part? That your posts are disgusting?

What kind of a country are we turning into? Are all of you callous posters representative of Americans today? Is this what the future holds? A nation where no one else matters and where there is no concept of neighborliness, kindness, mercy, or charity. I certainly hope you are only a small, nasty minority.

How can a people pull together under adversity if they cannot trust each other? What happened to the idea of a common good?

Would it make a difference if the guy intentionally didn't pay instead of forgot?
 
Then we need to make more service trades mandatory with out regard for payment. There are all kinds of ones that can be needed or you will lose or have massive damage to your house.
If you are referring to trades such as plumbers and electricians, that is a different category than public services. You're comparing peaches and peanuts.
The county voted it down.
South Fulton was offering firefighting services in the county. And the commonality doesn't recognize political boundaries.

Sue him if he ignores it. And why would he? The family offered to pay when they called 911.
 
Last edited:
Bushwa. They punished them. Punishment: Any ill suffered in consequence of wrongdoing. They punished the family when they stood by and watched the home burn (under orders that were morally wrong) because someone forgot to pay a paltry $75. This in spite of the fact that the family offered to pay whatever was asked when they called 911.

Except according to the chief of another FD in the same county:
The problem has been, that once those people have been provided the service; they often seem to choose not to reimburse. Attempting to charge on a per call basis does not generate the needed funds nor does it give county residents an incentive to support the cities, if they can wait until they actually have a fire to pay anything.

Also that's a very interesting definition of punishment. Is a homeowner who shoots an intruder punishing him or protecting his family?

What if because of the situation none of the municipal FD offered subscription service and the guy's house burned down because no fire trucks were available to answer the call? would that have been punishment?

If I live in an area where I vote to lower my taxes by cutting the PD budget to 1/10 of its previous amount, then get mugged because of an increase in crime due to lower PD presence, did the PD punish me by not having officers available to protect me?

The point is that often wrongdoing carries inherent risk of ill being suffered as a consequence without need for any active agency to step in and mete out punishment.

If you don't want your house to burn down to the ground, make certain that you have fire protection services available to you. If such requires that you pay $75 a year, pay it. Not paying it, then complaining that somebody was being cruel for not providing you the service anyway just makes one sound like a 3 year old.
 
Bushwa. They punished them. Punishment: Any ill suffered in consequence of wrongdoing.

If, as you say, the fire department was the punisher and they were punishing the owner for wrongdoing . . . what was the wrong that the owner done?
 
And then he ignores it

Exactly, which is why this whole "charge him on the spot" or "bill him for it" business is a nightmare waiting to happen.

It means the FD would then have to turn intself into a collections agency.
 
Once again, proportionality. It is not reasonable, not defensible, not even remotely sane to punish the crime of failing to pay a $75 fee with total destuction of a home.

Sometimes people behave stupidly, sometimes irresponsibly, levying a fine against the homeowner would not "reward irresponsible behavior," and would be in proportion to the offense.

How does letting the house be destroyed for want of $75 make any sense at all?
because they did not pay the fee, they are outside the nominal area covered by taxes.

It is liek asking why they don't fix potholes in another town.

Sorry, the US is a nation of hard heads.
What are small town values then? Just letting someone suffer tremendously for the equivalent of a parking ticket?
Nope, he may not have paid the fee for ten years.

You don't buy car insurance and you crash your car what happens?

It is cold hearted, but that is why most people belong to volunteer districts. (In similar situations, but guess what there is usually a tax levy.)
This is ridiculous and absurd. Why don't we punish speeding by destroying someone's car? That would really teach people not to speed.
Why would an insurance company cover you if you didn't pay the premium?
Shoplifters should have their hands cut off, people forgetting to pay parking tickets should have their pets killed, in a responsible society no one would do those things and we're just rewarding by behavior by allowing someone who rolled through a stop sign to get away with a $50 ticket.

There is a reason why proportionality exists in the law.

Um, sorry this is a contract case, he did not meet the terms of the contract, and had knowledge of the rules.

I do not support the decision, but I do understand it.
 
Exactly, which is why this whole "charge him on the spot" or "bill him for it" business is a nightmare waiting to happen.

It means the FD would then have to turn intself into a collections agency.

And other fire departments in the same county have said they do not have an agreement so all the fires they fight in the county are done for free. Not an efficient way to maintain such an important service for the people who actually pay you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom