Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

I guess I better go rewrite all the statutes that include the phrase "acts and omissions."
Show me "all the statutes" that show I'm wrong.

I was asking a philosophical question, but that's interesting. Fire departments aren't bound by Constitutional provisions?
No. The Constitution creates and binds the Federal government, not city fire departments.

If you think I'm wrong, show me which "provisions" are the ones that "bind" them.
 
Courts aren't the only institutions that impose penalties, as this latest financial crisis has taught many people.

The fire department penalized that man for failure to pay $75. The method they chose was unduly harsh.

You seem to have a problem with consequences vs penalties. They did not penalize him, they just did not offer him their services.
 
It's the Free-Market, the freely contracted exchange of goods/services for currency. The proportionality is no payment: no service.
The legal system is only involved if one of the parties fails to meet the contracted exchange. In this case there was no agreement.

It is better than that, it is Democracy. See they voted down paying for county wide fire coverage and so they don't have it. Simple.
 
I would love to have you explain where the free market ends and the legal system begins.

No it is democracy in action. People don't want to pay for service X and so people don't have service X. Simple and direct, the way government is supposed to work.
 
Do you have any evidence, or even any reason to support that? Do you know for certain that the town of South Fulton began to provide service beyond their city limits solely at the request of Obion County? Do you even have any reason to think that the county ever asked for anything at all?

The fact that the county is currently involved in a effort to arrive at such an understanding with its various municipalities leads me to suspect not.

The fact that it was a nearly identical episode involving South Fulton two years ago which seems to have prompted that effort makes me suspect not.

The fact that South Fulton, out of all of those various municipalities, has elected not to participate, but rather to stick with the responsibilities they had chosen to assume in the past instead makes me suspect the same.

Check out the link in post 492 by ponderingturtle. It is the Union City Fire Department (another FD in the county that provides subscription service). official stance on this issue.

Some interesting quotes from it.
The first point that needs to be noted is that Obion County Tennessee does not have a county fire department. Secondly, no county tax revenues are even ear marked for county fire protection.

The county is made up of 8 municipalities which do provide fire protection to its city residents, through city property taxes, which fund their respective fire departments.

Three of theses cities, South Fulton; Kenton and Union City allow their departments to respond outside the city limits by way of a Subscription Service which charges a $75 yearly fee to receive fire protection. After they respond to a “members” fire, the member is billed $500 for the response.
hmm three cities all having the same deal with the county, seems more like a county plan than just SFFD

The remaining 5 city fire departments have for years responded into the county without a subscription service, banking on collecting fees for their services, “after the fact.” The problem has been, that once those people have been provided the service; they often seem to choose not to reimburse. Attempting to charge on a per call basis does not generate the needed funds nor does it give county residents an incentive to support the cities, if they can wait until they actually have a fire to pay anything.
cities that used to provide service to county residents on a pay after the fire scheme found that it they were not getting paid and could not legally force reimbursement so no longer offer any service outside those cities.

Based on the tone of that article, I have a sneaking suspicion that if the county does not find a way to tax the unincorporated residents for fire service, the cities may stop providing even the subscription based service.
 
Show me "all the statutes" that show I'm wrong.

Really? No, I'm not going to "show you" the endless statutes containing that phrase. I presume you have access to google.

Here's a brief wiki describing the concept in criminal law.

In the criminal law, an omission, or failure to act, will constitute an actus reus (Latin for "guilty act") and give rise to liability only when the law imposes a duty to act and the defendant is in breach of that duty.
Nevertheless, such failures might be morally indefensible and so both legislatures and the courts have imposed liability when the failure to act is sufficiently blameworthy to justify criminalisation. Some statutes therefore explicitly state that the actus reus consists of any relevant "act or omission", or use a word that may include both.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omission_(criminal_law)

Now, obviously the firefighters had no legal duty to act, which is why they aren't in prison.

I am saying that their omission was a miserable, morally bankrupt choice. Such things need not always be criminal, but your claim:

Letting something bad happen to someone because they do something stupid (especially if you specifically told them what could happen) is never going to be the same thing as intentionally causing something bad to happen to someone because they do something you don't like, no matter how much you continue to insist.

Is not strictly true in the laws of our land.

No. The Constitution creates and binds the Federal government, not city fire departments.

If you think I'm wrong, show me which "provisions" are the ones that "bind" them.

Hmm, I seem to remember this thing called the 14th amendment...
 
I just wanted to toss in a bit of vinegar to cut the uncut glurge in that post.


Sorry about that, Champ. I've never been a firefighter, so I can only imagine what it must have been like to be in their shoes. Maybe that's the "glurge" that was bothering you so much.

I have been a lifeguard, so I "glurged" that by way of comparison. I "glurged" how I'd feel if I was sitting in a lifeguard chair, swim trunks on, pole and float by my side, and watched someone drown because I wasn't allowed to rescue anyone who didn't have a subscription.

It didn't feel good.

Just wearing a funny yellow coat and riding a big red truck doesn't make anybody any better than anyone else.


No, it doesn't. Is that all you think the job entails?

Do you think soldiers just dress up in silly uniforms and march down the street on holidays?

Do you think that sailors just wear cravats and drink martinis, or batten down hatches and hoist up landlubbers. :p

You know, there really are jobs which ask a bit more than most people are willing to offer, and even ones which demand a little bit more than many people are able to give.

Some of those jobs might even involve a hero or two.
 
In Tranewreck's world, by not paying off my house Bill Gates is "punishing" me for not being rich.

Surely you can do better than that.

Once again, this house was allowed to burn for want of $75 when easy legal remedies were available. If you were capable of paying off your house but Bill Gates figured out a way to screw you on a technicality, I would view him with equal distaste.
 
Sorry about that, Champ. I've never been a firefighter, so I can only imagine what it must have been like to be in their shoes. Maybe that's the "glurge" that was bothering you so much.

I have been a lifeguard, so I "glurged" that by way of comparison. I "glurged" how I'd feel if I was sitting in a lifeguard chair, swim trunks on, pole and float by my side, and watched someone drown because I wasn't allowed to rescue anyone who didn't have a subscription.

It didn't feel good.

Nice strawman there, what is his name?

If there was a person at risk they would have acted irregardless of payment and the like. This is entirely a property issue.
 
They keep trying that and it gets voted down. The people of this county voted for this system, I don't see why people feel that they should tell them how to run their county.

I dunno. Maybe because it's ******* stupid?

But yeah, people have the right to be dumb in a free society.

In any case, nobody is going to tell them how to run their county because no one has the power to do so. They're gonna do what they're gonna do.

But maybe, now that they've seen some real consequences, they'll start changing their tune.

What really burns my cheese, tho, is that I keep hearing sound-byte stories on the news about "firemen watch house burn down" when the real story is "county has head up ***".
 
Hmm, I seem to remember this thing called the 14th amendment...

Tough sell.

I'd have to wonder though, if a lawyer were representing a client who was in danger of losing their home through no fault of their own, and the lawyer didn't receive their fee, would the lawyer continue to defend the client?
 
My father. If possible, he would avoid paying for any kind of insurance.

There's millions of people like that, I suspect.

When I worked in a telco, the municipalities would set up 911 service and the telco would itemize it as a charge on the bill. "Municipal E911 Service" - about 14c/mo in Greater Victoria but 11c/mo in most other municipalities in BC.

Every day, about a thousand customers would call in asking to 'opt out' of this service to save a few cents. It was mandated by law, so customers didn't actually have a choice, and some customers solved the problem by cancelling their phones in protest.

This relates to the thesis of Thomas Frank's "What's The Matter with Kansas" where he provide examples of people who crossed the picketline to destroy their union and were shortly unemployed as their jobs were sent to Mexico. But they'd rather be homeless than unionized as a matter of principle and aggressively defend their decision.
 
Tough sell.

I'd have to wonder though, if a lawyer were representing a client who was in danger of losing their home through no fault of their own, and the lawyer didn't receive their fee, would the lawyer continue to defend the client?

We're allowed to withdraw for failure to pay fees, but that has to be given to court in a motion. There are a number of reasons why a judge might disallow withdrawal. The ability of the client to obtain a fair and just outcome is often weighed.

There have been times when judges ordered lawyers to keep representing a client that fired them.

In some rural areas, where there aren't public defenders, courts will just assign a client to a lawyer and force them to do the work for free. This has been challenged in the Supreme Court of a number of states, most recently Kansas, I believe, but I may be wrong about that.
 
Last edited:
Check out the link in post 492 by ponderingturtle. It is the Union City Fire Department (another FD in the county that provides subscription service). official stance on this issue.

<snip>


I did. Check out my response. Post #513

Were you able to unearth any discussion of voting in your perusal of that article?

Now that you mention it, there's even another ramification which that brings up.

Nearly half of the population of the county lives in the three largest towns in that county. I wonder if they vote in both the city and the county elections. I wonder how the ones who already have fire protection services vote when the city and county pols start talking about raising funds for the rest of the county?

Pretty neat deal, huh? You can fund your fire departments by selling subscriptions to the ones you won't let have fire departments by making sure there isn't enough funding.

Good catch, cwalner. Thanks.
 
We're allowed to withdraw for failure to pay fees, but that has to be given to court in a motion. There are a number of reasons why a judge might disallow withdrawal. The ability of the client to obtain a fair and just outcome is often weighed.

There have been times when judges ordered lawyers to keep representing a client that fired them.

Cool, thanks. Do you feel that a lawyer is under a moral obligation not to opt to drop a client for non-payment?
 
Really? No, I'm not going to "show you" the endless statutes containing that phrase. I presume you have access to google.

Here's a brief wiki describing the concept in criminal law.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omission_(criminal_law)

Now, obviously the firefighters had no legal duty to act, which is why they aren't in prison.

I am saying that their omission was a miserable, morally bankrupt choice.
Right. You're trying to pretend your moral feelings are legal realities.

Is not strictly true in the laws of our land.
Yes, it is- that's why there are the separate and distict legal terms "comission" and "omission".

Hmm, I seem to remember this thing called the 14th amendment...
Sell it.
 
Cool, thanks. Do you feel that a lawyer is under a moral obligation not to opt to drop a client for non-payment?

It's situational. If they have time to secure other counsel, no. If it's a civil matter, especially one in which I represent the petitioner, then there's less of an obligation than when one defends someone in a criminal matter.

If I was in an immediate position to stop a great harm, like the firefighters, I would consider it my obligation to intervene even if I wouldn't get paid. M choice in such matters would depend on some sliding scale involving the nature of the problem, my ability to help, and the level of burden placed on me.

In this case with customary effort the firefighters could have stopped the fire and recovered the economic loss very easily.
 
Right. You're trying to pretend your moral feelings are legal realities.

You say that like I've argued differently. Find the part where I argued the firefighters were legally bound to act.

Yes, it is- that's why there are the separate and distict legal terms "comission" and "omission".

It depends on the statute. Negligence actions generally don't make that distinction. Duty-breach-causation-damages. The breach can be either an act or omission.


I don't know what that means, but the 14th amendment applied the Bill of Rights to the states.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom