Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

So, this wasn't the first time the family hadn't paid their fee...nor was it the first time they'd called the FD and had to beg for assistance.

Gee, it's almost like what a couple people have been saying about "doing it for free and then billing afterward encourages people to not pay until they need the service"

Which is why the after-the-fact billing should be more expensive.

Of course, it would make more sense to just jettison this idiotic system altogether.
 
And the fine for a single fire could pay the cost they would charge every resident. If there are no fires, they aren't spending any resources on putting them out.

You really have little concept of overhead like quarter of a million dollar fire trucks and several thousand dollar suits of turn out gear.

Of course you could also not go take a shower when you are burning garbage as well.
 
In the words of Homer "It's funny because it's true"
(But your response lacked relevance because the guilloitine lacked relevance to the quote)

It was an example of a dramatic, disproportionate form of punishment. Seems relevant to me.


You seem to think this situation is part of the legal system. It's not.

It's the Free-Market, the freely contracted exchange of goods/services for currency. The proportionality is no payment: no service.
The legal system is only involved if one of the parties fails to meet the contracted exchange. In this case there was no agreement.

I would love to have you explain where the free market ends and the legal system begins.

If it's just free market behavior, what would stop the fire department from just extorting payments as a house was burning?

"How much will you pay us to put out that fire?" I bet that would maximize their profits. Or is there something stopping them from doing that? Constraining the free market?

The legal system is directly involved because it easily would have offered remedies other than allowing the house to burn.
 
They can place a lien on your home, they can put you in prison, they can seize other assets and even possess the home.

"Denying land" is by far not the only remedy.

Interestingly, in areas where taxes finance fire departments, one thing they won't ever do is let someone's house burn to the ground.

Sure they will. This is not that uncommon it just is that this story got picked up by the news.
 
There is no justification for standing idly by, and the only justification anyone can give for such callous behavior is that it taught other people a lesson. What do you call it when you intentional put someone though or allow someone to be put through pain in order to teach them and others a lesson? If you don't like the word "punishment" I'll gladly accept another that describes the situation.

Some people need to learn the hard way.
 
It was an example of a dramatic, disproportionate form of punishment. Seems relevant to me.

Well there's your problem. For most people the example of a dramatic, disproportionate form of punishment is "Kill it with fire"
 
Idealism is nice when you can afford it.

Apparently, the FD had decided they could no longer afford it.

And I don't have the cites, but from what I've been hearing as this story evolves, we've been getting a changing story on whether or not this guy "forgot" or simply decided not to pay.

If I were the county, I wouldn't institute a system which relies on people having to remember to pay, and on the FD to keep up to date records, and such.

Institute a tax, cover the whole county, and be done with it.

They keep trying that and it gets voted down. The people of this county voted for this system, I don't see why people feel that they should tell them how to run their county.
 
Why would that be a fine? The rule is simple it is $75 a year to have fire coverage and $500 if you have a call see the departments website.

http://ucfdtn.com/

The residents of the county repeatedly voted down fire coverage. They did not want fire coverage, or at least to pay for it and so they created this issue.

Really it is the perfect county for this man, he is a dead beat in a county of deadbeats.

<snip>


Interesting article. The topic of voting about anything doesn't seem to be included. Did you just contribute that part?

Aside from the parts you want to add there doesn't seem to be any substance which we haven't already discussed in depth. Which parts were unique to you.

The towns got into the mess by expanding their service area beyond their tax jurisdiction. It's really as simple as that. Once you haul those firetrucks past the town limits, sooner or later this was going to happen. If they don't like the bad press they need to stay home.

They were trying to boost their funds by soliciting premiums is what this looks like. Fire departments shouldn't be in the insurance racket, and that is what a subscription plan is. Fire departments should be in the business of putting out fires.

Anything else and their mission gets lost in the politics.
 
So why don't we chop off thieves hands? Or do you think it would be a good idea to go back to that sort of punishment?

How do you interpret our Constitutional protections?

Which amendment does this fall under?
 
I keep trying to explain, there isn't anything the county or the town can do about it. Only the people living in the affected area can vote to have fire protection from the town tacked onto their property taxes. The people in the town don't get to vote in that referendum, nor do county residents outside the affected area. If those people wanted city fire protection for everyone via taxes, it would have been done. They chose the opt-in system instead, warts and all.

eta: counties generally don't have fire departments. There's no such thing as the Cook County Fire Dept., for example. Maybe out west it's common, but not in the east where wildfires aren't so much a concern.

I don't know, my brother is a Lieutenant in the Horry County fire department in Horry County SC.

I am not familiar with having unincorporated areas in the north east so that removes my other main point of reference.
 
So why don't we chop off thieves hands? Or do you think it would be a good idea to go back to that sort of punishment?
Letting something bad happen to someone because they do something stupid (especially if you specifically told them what could happen) is never going to be the same thing as intentionally causing something bad to happen to someone because they do something you don't like, no matter how much you continue to insist.

How do you interpret our Constitutional protections?
"Not having anything to do with fire service".
 
Good. Because they are just people. "Heros" are dumb guys in tights in the comic books.


There are real heroes. There are more of them than you seem to suspect. If you believe that they are only comic book figures in costumes then you lead a sad life.

The real heroes don't get much press time. An occasional filler maybe, when Britney and Lindsay are both between arrests, but that's about it. Little heroes and big ones. People who run into burning buildings when they don't have to certainly fill the bill for me. Whether they wear tights or not.
 
Last edited:
Letting something bad happen to someone because they do something stupid (especially if you specifically told them what could happen) is never going to be the same thing as intentionally causing something bad to happen to someone because they do something you don't like, no matter how much you continue to insist.

I guess I better go rewrite all the statutes that include the phrase "acts and omissions."

"Not having anything to do with fire service".

I was asking a philosophical question, but that's interesting. Fire departments aren't bound by Constitutional provisions?
 
There are real heroes. There are more of them than you seem to suspect. If you believe that they are only comic book figures in costumes then you lead a sad life.

The real heroes don't get much press time. An occasional filler maybe, when Britney or Lindsay are between arrests, but that's about it. Little heroes and big ones. People who run into burning buildings when they don't have to certainly fill the bill for me. Whether they wear tights or not.
I just wanted to toss in a bit of vinegar to cut the uncut glurge in that post.

Just wearing a funny yellow coat and riding a big red truck doesn't make anybody any better than anyone else.
 
Courts aren't the only institutions that impose penalties, as this latest financial crisis has taught many people.

The fire department penalized that man for failure to pay $75. The method they chose was unduly harsh.

So sue the plumber who refused to fix your broken pipes for free because you didn't pay them last time? It can destroy a house quite effectively after all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom