Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

It's amazing to me that people are expressing such a simple notion of fault.

THere's a car accident. Car A runs a red light and is slammed into by Car B, driven by someone under the influence who would have been able to stop if sober, who is at fault?

There's a reason every state that I'm aware of has adopted "comparative negligence" statutes.

If I fail to take basic precautions and leave my car unlocked overnight, is it my fault that I was robbed? Could the thief, if caught, go into court and argue, "Sure I took the stereo, but this guy was an idiot, he left his car open?"

Obviously not.

The dude should have paid $75. It was ABSURD to let a house burn to the ground for an unpaid $75 fee.
You do understand there's a difference between criminal activity and the laws thereof and a fee-for-service contract and the laws governing those?

You are acting as if some court ordered his house burnt down as sentence for not paying his fire service fee.

It's absurd.
 
You do understand there's a difference between criminal activity and the laws thereof and a fee-for-service contract and the laws governing those?

You are acting as if some court ordered his house burnt down as sentence for not paying his fire service fee.

It's absurd.

Courts aren't the only institutions that impose penalties, as this latest financial crisis has taught many people.

The fire department penalized that man for failure to pay $75. The method they chose was unduly harsh.
 
The way I see it, you're only paying for the service if your house burns down. Otherwise, you're giving the city a gift.

Another way to look at it is taxes. If I live in the county and hadn't paid my taxes, I could still call the police if someone broke into my house, my kids could still attend the schools, I could still drive on the roads, etc. The consequences are NOT that I go unprotected and am trapped on my property, unable to go on roads I haven't paid for. The consequences are that I pay a penalty, a huge fine, or possibly go to prison for not paying my taxes - but I still get all the services.

So in this case, they should have had an exorbitant fee, which while being exorbitant, would still be less than starting all over with nothing. For example, pay in advance and it's $75. Pay after the fact, and it's $2,000, regardless of the size of fire, and $100 per hour, or something like that. It still highly encourages people to pay, and still has a penalty if they don't, but that penalty isn't loss of everything.
 
It's amazing to me that people are expressing such a simple notion of fault.

THere's a car accident. Car A runs a red light and is slammed into by Car B, driven by someone under the influence who would have been able to stop if sober, who is at fault?

There's a reason every state that I'm aware of has adopted "comparative negligence" statutes.

If I fail to take basic precautions and leave my car unlocked overnight, is it my fault that I was robbed?
Partly, yes. It's that "comparative negligence" thing you mentioned. And I'd tell you that you deserved it, too.
 
The justification for letting a house burn down for want of $75 is "to encourage others."

Our legal system has previously been bound by a concept of proportionality--the consequences must be in proportion to the wrong.

There was no wrong and no punishment. Your comprehension seems to be lacking. The owner had every right to not pay the subscription fee. The firefighters were not punishing the owner for not paying the fee, they were simply following the subscription fee policy.

According to another fire chief, as soon as his city decides that there is a problem, for whatever reason, with his department fighting fires in the county, they will no longer fight fires in the county. That service will end as fast as you can snap your fingers and there has already been discussions about ending it within the city.

This is a county issue. The cities have so far been doing their best but they are done with the BS.
 
The way I see it, you're only paying for the service if your house burns down. Otherwise, you're giving the city a gift.

Another way to look at it is taxes. If I live in the county and hadn't paid my taxes, I could still call the police if someone broke into my house, my kids could still attend the schools, I could still drive on the roads, etc. The consequences are NOT that I go unprotected and am trapped on my property, unable to go on roads I haven't paid for. The consequences are that I pay a penalty, a huge fine, or possibly go to prison for not paying my taxes - but I still get all the services.

So in this case, they should have had an exorbitant fee, which while being exorbitant, would still be less than starting all over with nothing. For example, pay in advance and it's $75. Pay after the fact, and it's $2,000, regardless of the size of fire, and $100 per hour, or something like that. It still highly encourages people to pay, and still has a penalty if they don't, but that penalty isn't loss of everything.

And putting out the fire would bind the recipient of their service whether they agreed to it or not through the doctrine of unjust enrichment.

They very easily could have put out the fire and handed the guy a bill for $_____. As long as there was some reasonable justification for the bill (hours worked, amount of water used, gas burned...etc.), the courts would enforce it.
 
- Latest articles mention him getting money from his insurance company... does homeowner's insurance normally cover fires that are started by the homeowner?
Yes, all the time. Those decorative candles that were so in vogue recently are a huge culprit. So are barbeques, and those "whole-turkey fryers".

Now, if he did so with the extreme carelessness it appears he (or whoever) did, it might affect his ability to get insurance on the next house, but it's very likely a covered loss.

ETA: Assuming he wasn't to cheap to pay the insurance company, as well.

It spreading was probably an accident but I don't know how an insurance company typically responds to "I was burning some trash and it got out of hand."
The same way they do when a spark jumps out a fireplace.
 
Last edited:
I'm starting to stew over this travesty. That's not a good thing

The ramifications go well beyond the black-hearted, petty, vindictive sort of microcephalic mind that would self-righteously advocate such a policy at the expense of a family's home.

I feel sorry for the firefighters. They did what they were told. They did ... in a twisted and evil fashion ... their job.

I'd hate to be in their heads right now.

Not only did they have to stand aside and watch someone's home destroyed, but they probably knew those people. That town is only a few families bigger than microscopic. There are high schools bigger than that.

Every time they go to the grocery store, or the gas station, or their church there's a good chance they will have to look in the eyes of that family or their relatives. It doesn't even matter if those relatives don't blame them for doing what they were told to do. They know what they should have done.

They've got to be hating the position they were put in by some frothing-at-the-mouth neocon who thinks that mean-spirited ideology is a virtue. They used to be heroes. Selfless, courageous volunteers who put their lives at risk doing a dirty, dangerous job no one else wanted for other people's welfare.

Now they are tools. Schmucks. Maybe no one will say so to their face. Maybe most other people understand, and even maybe forgive. But they know. And they know the magic is gone. They know that no one will ever quite believe in them the same way again. Never look at them with quite the same sort of gratitude and appreciation. Never with quite the same respect.

They know that somewhere in the back of people's minds there will always be that question, "Would he stand by his equipment and watch my home burn down if the Mayor told him to?"

They know that every time they go into that little town there may be the eyes of a family they did just that too ... watching them.

They'll feel the weight of those eyes even when the eyes aren't there. Because there is a sacred trust between fire fighters and the people they protect. One they assumed without being asked to, or without it being demanded. And for whatever reason, they broke it.

-------------------------------------------------------

Pissing and moaning about where the stinking dollars are going to come from when it is really small change that's being talked about is bad enough. Letting someone's home burn to the ground when it can be easily stopped is worse, but the human cost of this sort of pointless statutory cruelty is impossible to measure. It travels out in waves, like a rock thrown in a pool.

(Sorry. End of rant.)
 
The individual and the relevant polity are both ********** up. Tennessee: where civilization goes to die.

This city/county/whatever has a ********** up system. It's especially evil if any animal inhabitants died choking on thick brown, smoke. Watching a house burn is absurdly punitive, inefficient. It's also, as I mentioned earlier, irreversible. Rumsfeld was unfairly criticized for mentioning "known unknowns and unknown unknowns." We never access to full information, so our disposition, particularly in emergency circumstances, should be to save rather than let burn. There's also the intuitive moral principle mumblethrax mentions -- if we can avert significant harms at a trivial cost, then we should do so. This applies to everyone, even if you did not personally start the fire. Finally, if the city arbitrarily enforced the subscription, then the guy was not so irrational (at least in an aspergery, homo economicus way).

We could draw a page from behavioral economics: why not, at the very least, make the subscription opt-out instead of opt-in? Impose it on everyone and then rugged individualists must take the initiative to deactivate. Also, you still do not allow perfectly good homes to burn down. The city should be able to put a lien on the property. (Did someone above mention that he lives in a double-wide trailer? If so, I wonder if there's class discrimination involved. Did the fire department put out other house fires because they involved "real" houses?)

But, this guy has to take personal responsibility. Did he really start the fire by burning trash? What a big brain. Did he really fiddle while the yard fire took hours to become a home fire, which went on to consume the animals inside?

I'm also surprised he managed to pay for fire insurance, and even more surprised if they made any sort of payout (it must have been a trivial sum, and done to avoid the bad publicity of kicking a guy while his house burnt down).
 
You may as well ask, "Why would anyone pay taxes? Parking tickets? Speeding tickets? Assessed court costs?" and on and on.

As I said before, the punishment for failing to pay the $75 that would have secured fire fighting is to 1) pay the $75, 2) pay the costs incurred by having to write the ticket vs. paying the proper way, maybe another $100, then 3) some type of punitive fine to incentivize people to pay up front, maybe another $100.

A $275 fine would be more than enough to motivate people to pay ahead of time.

Why would that be a fine? The rule is simple it is $75 a year to have fire coverage and $500 if you have a call see the departments website.

http://ucfdtn.com/

The residents of the county repeatedly voted down fire coverage. They did not want fire coverage, or at least to pay for it and so they created this issue.

Really it is the perfect county for this man, he is a dead beat in a county of deadbeats.

And he didn't even learn his lesson the first time his progeny tried to burn down his house, and he had to beg the fire department to make an exception for him. Or rather he learned the lesson that you can forgo paying for fire coverage and still get the fire department to respond.

It would be nice if divorce lawyers had to provide advice and help with out regards to the ability or willingness of their clients to pay.
 
They used to be heroes. Selfless, courageous volunteers who put their lives at risk doing a dirty, dangerous job no one else wanted for other people's welfare.

...And they know the magic is gone. They know that no one will ever quite believe in them the same way again.
Good. Because they are just people. "Heros" are dumb guys in tights in the comic books.
 
The system is screwed here. Where the County Gov't should have acted to protect it's inhabitants, it willingly decided to refuse this service offered by SFFD. The hopeful outcome would be that the County Gov't would contract with all the local FDs to provide full coverage for the County while passing that cost on via a tax to the affected County residents (those who live outside City/Town limits).
But it keeps getting voted down. So no new taxes no county fire department.
 
Fuzziness doesn't imply that bright lines can't be defended.


Yonkers has a fire department. Obion county doesn't. Yonkers is an incorporated municipality perfectly capable of raising its own funds. The rural areas of Obion county aren't. The NYPD can't cover Yonkers without incurring significant costs (I mean, do you have any sense of the traffic? They'd at least have to build a number of fire departments in Yonkers). The SFFD can cover a swath of the rural area of the county without incurring costs, charging back marginal costs on a per-call basis.

And they have what many rural areas do, subscription based fire coverage.
 
"dans ce pays-ci, il est bon de tuer de temps en temps un amiral pour encourager les autres."

The justification for letting a house burn down for want of $75 is "to encourage others." Maybe you were saying it sarcastically, which is why I phrased my response to be read as enforcing your point if sarcastic and show the absurdity of it if it was serious.

Our legal system has previously been bound by a concept of proportionality--the consequences must be in proportion to the wrong.

If we're going to do away with that, might as well bring back the guillotine or chop off theives hands or start stoning again. If you just want to set an example, there are better ways than fines and prisons.

In the words of Homer "It's funny because it's true"
(But your response lacked relevance because the guilloitine lacked relevance to the quote)

You seem to think this situation is part of the legal system. It's not.

It's the Free-Market, the freely contracted exchange of goods/services for currency. The proportionality is no payment: no service.
The legal system is only involved if one of the parties fails to meet the contracted exchange. In this case there was no agreement.
 
Why would that be a fine? The rule is simple it is $75 a year to have fire coverage and $500 if you have a call see the departments website.

http://ucfdtn.com/

The residents of the county repeatedly voted down fire coverage. They did not want fire coverage, or at least to pay for it and so they created this issue.

Really it is the perfect county for this man, he is a dead beat in a county of deadbeats.

And he didn't even learn his lesson the first time his progeny tried to burn down his house, and he had to beg the fire department to make an exception for him. Or rather he learned the lesson that you can forgo paying for fire coverage and still get the fire department to respond.

It would be nice if divorce lawyers had to provide advice and help with out regards to the ability or willingness of their clients to pay.

So, this wasn't the first time the family hadn't paid their fee...nor was it the first time they'd called the FD and had to beg for assistance.

Gee, it's almost like what a couple people have been saying about "doing it for free and then billing afterward encourages people to not pay until they need the service"
 
Haha, tax evasion is an actual crime, failure to pay a fee is not.

And he didn't get the coverage the fee would have paid for. See no crime and the law works exactly as intended. Everyone wins.
Denial of service is absolutely not the only way. How do we get people to pay speeding tickets? How do we get people to pay property taxes?

Confiscate their house when they don't.

I suggest you look into this thread on this. It includes many people from rural areas who have exactly this issue.
Why does everyone act like this is an unusual situation? It's the most quotidian of circumstances made singular by the insane decision to let the house burn. A fine could EASILY be levied and enforced.
Sure you put a lean on the house and maybe get the money in 20 years. Of course you need to make it a much more substantial fine that you would consider reasonable to even begin to make it worth while.
 
There was no wrong and no punishment. Your comprehension seems to be lacking. The owner had every right to not pay the subscription fee. The firefighters were not punishing the owner for not paying the fee, they were simply following the subscription fee policy.

According to another fire chief, as soon as his city decides that there is a problem, for whatever reason, with his department fighting fires in the county, they will no longer fight fires in the county. That service will end as fast as you can snap your fingers and there has already been discussions about ending it within the city.

This is a county issue. The cities have so far been doing their best but they are done with the BS.

The firefighters were standing there with hoses watching vigilantly to see if it would spread to a paying person's land. They were present and able to put out the fire, but refused to do so because they hadn't been paid $75. They were the lone fire department covering that area.

As I have said many times, there were plenty of methods available, plenty of legal and financial remedies, for them putting out the fire, and the worst case scenario is that they were screwed out of $75.

There is no justification for standing idly by, and the only justification anyone can give for such callous behavior is that it taught other people a lesson. What do you call it when you intentional put someone though or allow someone to be put through pain in order to teach them and others a lesson? If you don't like the word "punishment" I'll gladly accept another that describes the situation.
 
<snip>

This is a county issue. The cities have so far been doing their best but they are done with the BS.


Do you have any evidence, or even any reason to support that? Do you know for certain that the town of South Fulton began to provide service beyond their city limits solely at the request of Obion County? Do you even have any reason to think that the county ever asked for anything at all?

The fact that the county is currently involved in a effort to arrive at such an understanding with its various municipalities leads me to suspect not.

The fact that it was a nearly identical episode involving South Fulton two years ago which seems to have prompted that effort makes me suspect not.

The fact that South Fulton, out of all of those various municipalities, has elected not to participate, but rather to stick with the responsibilities they had chosen to assume in the past instead makes me suspect the same.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom