Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

I don't think the fact that someone made a bad choice is evidence of a difficult choice. There are too many bumbling idiots in this world to take that idea seriously.

Agreed, but not in the way that you think.

The Cranicks made a bad choice that was pretty easy to make the right one, they chose not to pay (or did not pay enough attention and forgot to pay) their $75 fee for fire protection services.

This led the SFFD to have to make a difficult choice. Either continue to provide free service to non-payers and risk not having enough funding in the furture to continue to provide service to anybody, or don't provide service to non-payers and let their house burn down.

The Cranick's choice was easy, assuming they wanted fire protection service, because one choice had no unfortunate consequences, and the other did. The SFFD's choice was difficult because regardless of which choice they made there would be unfortunate consequences.
 
I think we need to separate a possible good outcome from the quality of the underlying decision.

Well, the outcome of any decision is often the decider on whether it is good or bad but I can agree to this as long as people stop insisting that the outcome was bad.

I agree that it exposed dramatic flaws in their system and will serve as a fine example for dismissing libertarian arguments in the future, but it was still absurd to let the house burn for an unpaid $75 fee.

And yet, this isn't just a case with libertarian arguments/policies. Most policies, no matter the political ideology of the writers, have limits. I think the limits on this policy are pretty clear, even if the fire department has fought fires on the property of other unpaid people. That "everybody else does it" is not reason enough to throw out the limits.

Treat people as ends in themselves, not as means to an end...

When you put yourself into a position where people are allowed to treat you arbitrarily, you can hardly complain when they do.
 
The Cranicks made a bad choice that was pretty easy to make the right one, they chose not to pay (or did not pay enough attention and forgot to pay) their $75 fee for fire protection services.
It's not clear they made a deliberate choice. I'd be comfortable calling it a lapse.

This led the SFFD to have to make a difficult choice. Either continue to provide free service to non-payers and risk not having enough funding in the furture to continue to provide service to anybody, or don't provide service to non-payers and let their house burn down.
This is not a difficult choice.

Putting out the fire entails a risk of lowering subscription payments, creating an additional burden for taxpayers, and an inequitable payment scheme. This risk, which cannot exceed $60,000 (this is the target for the county's funding of the SFFD), is distributed among the town's ~1,100 households. That's an unfortunate and inequitable situation, but the worst case here is that they can't lower taxes below the levels they were at prior to extending the service to a swath of the county outside the town (correcting for general nationwide increases in the cost of firefighting). In the worst case, where nobody outside the city limits pays anything (not even the $500 charge), that's an additional $60 burden per household. I doubt South Fultonites have a lot of money to spread around, but that's manageable.

Letting the house burn creates an absurd situation where the cost of enforcement potentially exceeds funds raised. Yes, those costs are not born by the town. It's still absurd. It's also a hugely unjust arrangement where one household every couple of years is selected by reverse lottery to bear all of the costs of enforcement beyond administrative costs. It exposes the town to liability, creates significant tension in the community, puts people at risk, and makes South Fulton a national embarrassment.

The Cranick's choice was easy, assuming they wanted fire protection service, because one choice had no unfortunate consequences, and the other did. The SFFD's choice was difficult because regardless of which choice they made there would be unfortunate consequences.
This has been covered, over and over again. People are endorsing Stalinist tactics. Execute every tenth soldier to make an example of them. We have these ideas about fairness, justice, and proportionality in the 21st century. "Don't do the crime if you can't do the time" is not nearly enough to justify a punishment this severe. And if you have firefighters standing around, watching a house burn, telling the homeowner "It's too late," yes, you're punishing them.

Furthermore, if the Cranicks did choose to let their subscription lapse, it seems to me that they made the rational choice. The fire department seems to waive the subscription requirement much of the time, setting up an expectation that they will probably get away with it. Assume that they waive it four times out of five. Assume that Wildcat's 1/1,000 figure for fires in the US holds. That's a 1/5,000 chance that you'll be the unhappy winner of the lottery. How much would you be willing to pay to hedge against that risk? How much does your home have to be worth for $75 to make sense?

I mean, I'd pay it, when I remembered to. But not because I was looking out for #1.
 
Last edited:
It's not clear they made a deliberate choice. I'd be comfortable calling it a lapse.
Either way they made a choice that should have been easy, but chose wrong. Either they decided that paying the fee for fire protection was not important enough to make sure they pay on time, or they decided not to pay at all. either decision left them without fire protection services.


This is not a difficult choice.

Putting out the fire entails a risk of lowering subscription payments, creating an additional burden for taxpayers, and an inequitable payment scheme. This risk, which cannot exceed $60,000 (this is the target for the county's funding of the SFFD), is distributed among the town's ~1,100 households. That's an unfortunate and inequitable situation, but the worst case here is that they can't lower taxes below the levels they were at prior to extending the service to a swath of the county outside the town (correcting for general nationwide increases in the cost of firefighting). In the worst case, where nobody outside the city limits pays anything (not even the $500 charge), that's an additional $60 burden per household. I doubt South Fultonites have a lot of money to spread around, but that's manageable.
This has got the biggest load of crap I've read on this thread yet. Refusing to provide a service that was not paid for is unnacceptable, but passing that burden onto somebody else who is already paying for the service and now has to pay an additonal $60 for no additional service to cover the freeloaders is acceptable. Give me a freaking break.


Letting the house burn creates an absurd situation where the cost of enforcement potentially exceeds funds raised. Yes, those costs are not born by the town. It's still absurd. It's also a hugely unjust arrangement where one household every couple of years is selected by reverse lottery to bear all of the costs of enforcement beyond administrative costs. It exposes the town to liability, creates significant tension in the community, puts people at risk, and makes South Fulton a national embarrassment.
The only national embarrasment I see is the actions of those in unicorporated Fulton County, who refuse to pay for fire service through taxes and yet expect it to be provided by and paid for by those that live within the city limits.


This has been covered, over and over again. People are endorsing Stalinist tactics. Execute every tenth soldier to make an example of them. We have these ideas about fairness, justice, and proportionality in the 21st century. "Don't do the crime if you can't do the time" is not nearly enough to justify a punishment this severe. And if you have firefighters standing around, watching a house burn, telling the homeowner "It's too late," yes, you're punishing them.
Just don't build that strawman in unincorporated Obion county. It might catch fire and you won't have anybody to come and put it out. Declining to provide a service that has not been paid for is a completely proportionate response. I agree that it has very disproportinate consequences, which is why it was extremely silly for the Cranick's to allow that service to lapse (either by intent or neglect)

Furthermore, if the Cranicks did choose to let their subscription lapse, it seems to me that they made the rational choice. The fire department seems to waive the subscription requirement much of the time, setting up an expectation that they will probably get away with it. Assume that they waive it four times out of five. Assume that Wildcat's 1/1,000 figure for fires in the US holds. That's a 1/5,000 chance that you'll be the unhappy winner of the lottery. How much would you be willing to pay to hedge against that risk? How much does your home have to be worth for $75 to make sense?

I mean, I'd pay it, when I remembered to. But not because I was looking out for #1.
You do realize that this is the exact reasoning that I (and others) have been using to explain why providing service for non-payers is a really bad idea. Your solution of sticking it to the townies is appalling and a non-solution. The best solution is for Obion County to realize how messed up their current situation is and pass a measure to tax unincorporated residents and provide the service for everybody. However, as long as enough people have the attitude that it is immoral for the town to decline service to on-paying outlying areas, there will never be support for such a bill. 'Why buy the cow when you get the milk for free'.

The county is putting the town in a no-win situation. they either seem like cold-hearted bastards who watch a house burn down, or they let their fire department go broke as they are forced to expand services without expanded funding.

Finally somebody in the town had the balls to finally take a stand and not care about how bad it looked. I can assure that whoever that somebody is, he/she was elected by the residents of South Fultion, not Obion County and that is who they have responsibility to. I am glad that somebody finally decided that no matter how bad it would look to outsiders, he/she had the guts to make the right decision for those who elected him/her.
 
Last edited:
I've read a few articles and threads on this, I've got a few questions I'm hoping someone can give a source for. The system setup (unfortunate as it is) and fire department actions seem pretty well explained, but I haven't seen much on the situation of the fire itself.

- Did he lose 3 dogs and a cat in the fire? Most of the newer articles are saying he did, but I saw at least one assertion that they only mentioned that days after the fire was over and it didn't appear to be mentioned in the early articles I've seen.
- If he did lose animals... why didn't he take a moment during the several hours they were fighting the flames with garden hoses to open the door to his double wide and let them out? (assuming they were inside)
- Did the owner start the fire, or did a son/grandson?
- Latest articles mention him getting money from his insurance company... does homeowner's insurance normally cover fires that are started by the homeowner? It spreading was probably an accident but I don't know how an insurance company typically responds to "I was burning some trash and it got out of hand."
- Did he previously have a fire at his house? Several places have mentioned his son (grandson?) caused a fire in 2007, but I haven't seen it in any of the news articles.
- If he did then did he pay up after the fact?
- How many years has he paid the fee? I've seen both that he has usually done so and that he has not. Some quotes that they just "forgot" this year.
- I have seen references to other buildings burning down in the area (someone mentioned a barn full of horses), why has this gotten all this attention when I didn't hear anything about those (assuming they did in fact happen)?
 
I haven't been following this thread very diligently .. so excuse if this question has been answered.

Did the guy in this instance collect on his insurance?
 
I'd be surprised if he collected insurance. It's negligent to turn down/forget to pay for fire coverage.
 
I haven't been following this thread very diligently .. so excuse if this question has been answered.

Did the guy in this instance collect on his insurance?
He apparently has received some payment from his insurance company. IF he's going to get anymore or if they'll decide that he was at fault or not remains to be seen.
 
He apparently has received some payment from his insurance company. IF he's going to get anymore or if they'll decide that he was at fault or not remains to be seen.

I´m surprised he has insurance, and remembered to pay for it. Must have looked like a useless waste of money to him.
 
Well, the outcome of any decision is often the decider on whether it is good or bad but I can agree to this as long as people stop insisting that the outcome was bad.

I'm not sure you can credit a decision with the unintended consequences, whether good or bad, unless you can prove that they were reasonably forseeable. I strongly doubt that the people standing around watching that house burn thought, "Aha, this will expose the flaws inherent in the system!"

Perhaps a person who really likes to gamble would be thankful that we exterminated most Native Americans then forced them onto reservations, but that consequence hardly justifies the underlying cause.

It's easy to come up with endless similar situations.

And yet, this isn't just a case with libertarian arguments/policies. Most policies, no matter the political ideology of the writers, have limits. I think the limits on this policy are pretty clear, even if the fire department has fought fires on the property of other unpaid people. That "everybody else does it" is not reason enough to throw out the limits.

I didn't follow that.


When you put yourself into a position where people are allowed to treat you arbitrarily, you can hardly complain when they do.

I really disagree with that statement. We can simultaneously recognize irresponsible behavior on the part of a victim while acknowledging equally poor behavior on the part of other people.

Stupid victims don't justify wrongdoing. At risk of derailing this thread, raping a drunk girl is still a crime, even if she acted stupidly. Bilking people out of money because they fall for an obvious scam is still a crime. Stealing a radio from a car that was left unlocked is still wrong, even if only foolish people forget to lock their doors.

There's more than enough stupidity for everyone involved in this case.
 
<snip>

The only national embarrasment I see is the actions of those in unicorporated Fulton County, who refuse to pay for fire service through taxes and yet expect it to be provided by and paid for by those that live within the city limits.


I don't know why you're picking on Kentucky. They're all the way across the state line (or street). OTOH, maybe the Cranicks should have called them instead. It's probably less than a mile farther away, and maybe the Kentuckians wouldn't have been such ********.


<snip>

The county is putting the town in a no-win situation. they either seem like cold-hearted bastards who watch a house burn down, or they let their fire department go broke as they are forced to expand services without expanded funding.
"The county" didn't do anything to anybody. The town of South Fulton chose, for whatever reason, to extend the service of their fire department beyond the town limits. They didn't have to do that, and "the county" couldn't force them to, even if "the county" wanted to.

In fact, that's exactly what's happening in "the county" right now. I posted a link to the article about it.


Finally somebody in the town had the balls to finally take a stand and not care about how bad it looked. I can assure that whoever that somebody is, he/she was elected by the residents of South Fultion, not Obion County and that is who they have responsibility to. I am glad that somebody finally decided that no matter how bad it would look to outsiders, he/she had the guts to make the right decision for those who elected him/her.
I bet if he/she lived next door, and the wind had shifted that grass fire towards his/her house before it ate the Cranick's home they wouldn't be living in a camper right now.

I bet if the wind had jumped the fire to his/her house and it had gotten away from the firemen and burned it to the ground then he/she would be looking at different models for community fire protection. Less libertarian ones, I expect.

This is what happens when ideology runs up against reality. Reality wins, sooner or later. All the 'personal responsibility' mantra chanting in the world won't change the fact that the only right way to fight a fire is to put it out ... as soon as you can. Trying to pick and choose the politically appropriate time to put it out is only going to get somebody, well ... burned ... sooner or later.

It's only good luck that this boneheaded policy hasn't gotten someone hurt or killed so far, or worse yet caused a major conflagration. This time maybe more than most. Contrary to WildCat's preconceptions that part of the state is in a full blown drought, and the state Forestry Service is already issuing fire warnings.

How embarrassed do you think South Fulton would have been if they were trying to explain why their fire department was standing around watching the beginning of a fire that took out a corner of Tennessee and Kentucky, instead of explaining why they watched some guy's home burn down?

The time to deal with a danger is when the danger is there. There's plenty of time afterward to argue about who owes how much to whom. That's how communities work. That's why they are communities. The callous, muleheaded, and gleefully cruel inability to sort out the differences and prioritize them is what makes the right-wingnut libertarian Utopia such an ugly fantasy.
 
I think we need to separate a possible good outcome from the quality of the underlying decision.

I agree that it exposed dramatic flaws in their system and will serve as a fine example for dismissing libertarian arguments in the future, but it was still absurd to let the house burn for an unpaid $75 fee.

Treat people as ends in themselves, not as means to an end...

But you lose either way.

Wide focus, it makes sense to do it to ensure better protection for everyone down the road.

Narrow focus, the guy failed to take basic precautions, so the blame's on him.
 
Once again, proportionality. It is not reasonable, not defensible, not even remotely sane to punish the crime of failing to pay a $75 fee with total destuction of a home.

Sometimes people behave stupidly, sometimes irresponsibly, levying a fine against the homeowner would not "reward irresponsible behavior," and would be in proportion to the offense.

How does letting the house be destroyed for want of $75 make any sense at all?


"pour encourager les autres"
 
But you lose either way.

Wide focus, it makes sense to do it to ensure better protection for everyone down the road.

Narrow focus, the guy failed to take basic precautions, so the blame's on him.

It's amazing to me that people are expressing such a simple notion of fault.

THere's a car accident. Car A runs a red light and is slammed into by Car B, driven by someone under the influence who would have been able to stop if sober, who is at fault?

There's a reason every state that I'm aware of has adopted "comparative negligence" statutes.

If I fail to take basic precautions and leave my car unlocked overnight, is it my fault that I was robbed? Could the thief, if caught, go into court and argue, "Sure I took the stereo, but this guy was an idiot, he left his car open?"

Obviously not.

The dude should have paid $75. It was ABSURD to let a house burn to the ground for an unpaid $75 fee.

And as to the long view, given the current political climate and the congratulatory posts on this thread, I'm not certain the end result of this stupidity will be the cessation of such policies. That hasn't been decided yet. There are way too many who think it was a just act and a proper law.

I asked this earlier and no one answered, I'm curious to hear people's opinion:

People commiting crimes behave irresponsibly. In fact, it's often worse than that. Instead of merely being foolhardy, criminals often intentionally cause harm.

So my question is this: what sort of crime would one have to commit to justify the punishment of having their house burned down?

Theft? Burglary? Rape? Homicide?

How about shoplifting? Being in possession of alcohol under the age of 21?

People seem to be content to let this man's irresponsible behavior be punished with a destroyed home, what would someone have to do with malice to earn the same level of culpability punishment?
 
According to a news report I just watched, 85% of the fires municipal departments fight are out in th ecounty and they DO NOT GET PAID.

The only department with the subscription system is South Fulton but that system has just been expanded to cover the whole county because the tax based system was rejected.

I think the fire departments have gone above and beyond for a long time and cannot be blamed for saying "enough is enough."
 
The time to deal with a danger is when the danger is there. There's plenty of time afterward to argue about who owes how much to whom. That's how communities work. That's why they are communities. The callous, muleheaded, and gleefully cruel inability to sort out the differences and prioritize them is what makes the right-wingnut libertarian Utopia such an ugly fantasy.
It takes 2 people to argue. Apparently the freeloaders didn't think anything was wrong with the system as is. Only now do they want to talk!

And this has squat to do with libertarianism or any other political philosophy, someone could just as easily paint the Crainicks as liberals, demanding free services from the government and expecting to be bailed out from their own asshattery.

This is about South Fulton being fed up with the freeloaders in the unincorporated areas they serve.
 
Your response lacks any semblance of logic

"dans ce pays-ci, il est bon de tuer de temps en temps un amiral pour encourager les autres."

The justification for letting a house burn down for want of $75 is "to encourage others." Maybe you were saying it sarcastically, which is why I phrased my response to be read as enforcing your point if sarcastic and show the absurdity of it if it was serious.

Our legal system has previously been bound by a concept of proportionality--the consequences must be in proportion to the wrong.

If we're going to do away with that, might as well bring back the guillotine or chop off theives hands or start stoning again. If you just want to set an example, there are better ways than fines and prisons.
 
Last edited:
Okay, okay . . . someone answer me this:

Since when is asking the Lord to visit a curse on everyone involved in allowing the house to burn down, a threat? :dl:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom