The Cranicks made a bad choice that was pretty easy to make the right one, they chose not to pay (or did not pay enough attention and forgot to pay) their $75 fee for fire protection services.
It's not clear they made a deliberate choice. I'd be comfortable calling it a lapse.
This led the SFFD to have to make a difficult choice. Either continue to provide free service to non-payers and risk not having enough funding in the furture to continue to provide service to anybody, or don't provide service to non-payers and let their house burn down.
This is not a difficult choice.
Putting out the fire entails a risk of lowering subscription payments, creating an additional burden for taxpayers, and an inequitable payment scheme. This risk, which cannot exceed $60,000 (this is the target for the county's funding of the SFFD), is distributed among the town's ~1,100 households. That's an unfortunate and inequitable situation, but the worst case here is that they can't lower taxes
below the levels they were at prior to extending the service to a swath of the county outside the town (correcting for general nationwide increases in the cost of firefighting). In the worst case, where nobody outside the city limits pays
anything (not even the $500 charge), that's an additional $60 burden per household. I doubt South Fultonites have a
lot of money to spread around, but that's manageable.
Letting the house burn creates an absurd situation where the cost of enforcement potentially exceeds funds raised. Yes, those costs are not born by the town. It's
still absurd. It's also a
hugely unjust arrangement where
one household every couple of years is selected by reverse lottery to bear
all of the costs of enforcement beyond administrative costs. It exposes the town to liability, creates significant tension in the community, puts people at risk, and makes South Fulton a national embarrassment.
The Cranick's choice was easy, assuming they wanted fire protection service, because one choice had no unfortunate consequences, and the other did. The SFFD's choice was difficult because regardless of which choice they made there would be unfortunate consequences.
This has been covered, over and over again. People are endorsing Stalinist tactics. Execute every tenth soldier to make an example of them. We have these ideas about fairness, justice, and proportionality in the 21st century. "Don't do the crime if you can't do the time" is not
nearly enough to justify a punishment this severe. And if you have firefighters standing around, watching a house burn, telling the homeowner "It's too late," yes, you're punishing them.
Furthermore, if the Cranicks did choose to let their subscription lapse, it seems to me that they made the
rational choice. The fire department seems to waive the subscription requirement much of the time, setting up an expectation that they will
probably get away with it. Assume that they waive it four times out of five. Assume that Wildcat's 1/1,000 figure for fires in the US holds. That's a 1/5,000 chance that you'll be the unhappy winner of the lottery. How much would you be willing to pay to hedge against that risk? How much does your home have to be worth for $75 to make sense?
I mean, I'd pay it, when I remembered to. But not because I was looking out for #1.