Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

If I were the county, I wouldn't institute a system which relies on people having to remember to pay, and on the FD to keep up to date records, and such.

Institute a tax, cover the whole county, and be done with it.

That is exactly what should happen but you always get the people who think that infringes on their freedom.
 
I believe the issue here is that the county refused to enter into such an agreement and town was fed up with paying for other peoples fire protection.
I keep trying to explain, there isn't anything the county or the town can do about it. Only the people living in the affected area can vote to have fire protection from the town tacked onto their property taxes. The people in the town don't get to vote in that referendum, nor do county residents outside the affected area. If those people wanted city fire protection for everyone via taxes, it would have been done. They chose the opt-in system instead, warts and all.

eta: counties generally don't have fire departments. There's no such thing as the Cook County Fire Dept., for example. Maybe out west it's common, but not in the east where wildfires aren't so much a concern.
 
Last edited:
I keep trying to explain, there isn't anything the county or the town can do about it. Only the people living in the affected area can vote to have fire protection from the town tacked onto their property taxes. The people in the town don't get to vote in that referendum, nor do county residents outside the affected area. If those people wanted city fire protection for everyone via taxes, it would have been done. They chose the opt-in system instead, warts and all.

eta: counties generally don't have fire departments. There's no such thing as the Cook County Fire Dept., for example. Maybe out west it's common, but not in the east where wildfires aren't so much a concern.

I could easily be mistaken, but I think the county is still the legal entity that the agreement would need to be formed with.
 
I believe the issue here is that the county refused to enter into such an agreement and town was fed up


I'm not sure that's what happened. I'd love to hear some local gossip.

South Fulton is on the extreme north border of Obion County. So extreme that the other part of Fulton is in Kentucky, on the other side of State Line St., aka State Line Rd., aka St. Rt. 129.

It is small by most standards. At ~2500 people it is one quarter the size of the largest town in the county, Union City. Somehow I doubt that there was ever any expectation that South Fulton would become the fire fighting provider for Obion County.

In an article I cited up-thread the mayor spoke of "the city’s designated rural coverage area." This doesn't sound like the town being "fed up with paying for other peoples fire protection." This sounds more like someone who worked in town wanting to get some town services where they lived, out of town, and had the juice to get a convenient policy pushed through.

I like the sound of "designated rural coverage area." It makes it seem so charitable. And distant. But contemplate what a town of 2,500 in a county whose biggest town is 10,000 would consider "rural".

Most of us would think of the town as verging on rural. The only reason I don't is because I grew up in the Appalachians and have an extreme interpretation of the word. Most Americans shop at malls with higher populations than that on a regular basis.

The Cranick home was somewhere on Buddy Jones Rd. I couldn't find an address, but according to Google Earth the farthest end of Buddy Jones Rd. is something less than three miles from the heart of the teeming metropolis of South Fulton.

We're talking Andy Griffith's "Mayberry" here, and a family which has been around for at least some years, that lived within easy walking distance of ... well, I guess it would be 'downtown'. So visions of lonely fire engines careening down through empty countryside into the vast wilderness just isn't appropriate.

There is more going on than meets the eye, and those folks aren't airing all their dirty laundry to outsiders.

BTW. If you are interested in the developments concerning the county's plans for the future, there is a piece here.

Some excerpts.

An interlocal agreement for county-wide fire pro-tection that has been two years in the making is being sent to the Obion County Commission for a vote.
The Obion County Bud-get Committee voted at its session Monday morning at the Obion County Court-house to send the Interlocal Agreement for County Wide Fire Protection to the full commission for a vote when it convenes Oct. 18.


The agreement would be among the communities of Hornbeak, Kenton, Obion, Rives, Samburg, Troy and Union City, as well as the Obion County Emergency Communications District (E-911) as the fire dispatch agency for all municipalities in the agreement and Obion County.


According to the pro-posed agreement, South Fulton intends to provide rural fire service outside its city limits as directed by its city commission in a designated fire service area and would not be a party to the interlocal agreement.


It should be noted that it was apparently an incident two years ago very similar to this one involving the South Fulton FD and someone else without a subscription in the SFFD "designated fire service area" which prompted this county wide effort to begin with.
 
Last edited:
counties generally don't have fire departments.

They do down here.

My water, power, law enforcement, and fire protection are all provided by the county, for example.

In the South, the tensions between counties and municipalities are an ongoing source of aggravation, and occasionally amusement.

There are two nearby municipalities in my county, and their police, fire departments, water/sewer departments, and utility companies do not service my area. Hell, I got a buddy in one of those towns, and I can't even get the same cable provider as he does (if I cared to have cable). My brother lives in the other one, and his Internet provider (the city utility) doesn't service this area.

It's a whole nother world down here, my friend.
 
I keep trying to explain, there isn't anything the county or the town can do about it. Only the people living in the affected area can vote to have fire protection from the town tacked onto their property taxes. The people in the town don't get to vote in that referendum, nor do county residents outside the affected area. If those people wanted city fire protection for everyone via taxes, it would have been done. They chose the opt-in system instead, warts and all.


In this particular case I wonder if they ever chose anything in the first place. I expect it was a side benefit of living as close to town as some of South Fulton's fat cats who happened to reside just outside the city limits and couldn't come up with a plausible excuse to limit service to only their own houses.

eta: counties generally don't have fire departments. There's no such thing as the Cook County Fire Dept., for example. Maybe out west it's common, but not in the east where wildfires aren't so much a concern.


Where do you get ideas like this? Maybe you need to get out more.

Try Googling "*+county+fire+department" and see what you get. Just for starters. And that's just the ones with their own web pages.

Wildfires generally start off as a Forestry Service issue anyway, and it isn't just out west where they worry about 'em. (Try Googling "Fire Tower Rd.", just for fun.) Until they start getting close to where people live. Then they get to be everyone's problem.

Well in some cases I suppose it might require a subscription.
 
Last edited:
The Cranick home was somewhere on Buddy Jones Rd.

That's a sign right there.

I live in the unincorporated county outside of a town with a population of less than 500 people, and an area of less than one square mile. Lots of the roads around here still bear the names of the folks who lived on them generations ago.

The road I live off of is named for the family of the farmers on either side of me, who have been here since before the county existed.

In fact, you encounter clusters of similar road names, with only the first name varying.

If you want to get a picture of where I live (literally) go watch the movie Zombieland -- the rural scenes were filmed all around my house.

There are over 150 counties in my state because of an old law stipulating that county lines may not be more than 1 day's wagon ride from the county seat.

That gives a whole different spin to the truism that "all politics are local".
 
TraneWreck proposes a $100 fee. Would that compel you to pay the $75 every year? What if you were making $100,000/yr, maybe you'd roll the dice then for even a $10,000 fee since the odds of ever actually paying it are remote?

Knowing the odds, a $10,000 fee would not be enough for me. $25,000 and I'd consider it.
 
This is pretty much why I didn't donate to any 9/11 victims charities. Those people would have collected on the life insurance. And if they chose not to buy life insurance, well, too bad.

What percentage of Americans can afford, say, an extra $50 to $100 per month for life insurance?

This reminds me of how some of those charities around 9/11 were giving people that had lost wealthy loved ones more than those that had lost poorer loved ones....

...as for the OP, the county did not have fire protection, they were lucky that a near by town was even offering help at such a reasonable price.

Some rural areas are so rural that a fire department literally wouldn't be able to respond in time, even if they wanted to.
 
I could easily be mistaken, but I think the county is still the legal entity that the agreement would need to be formed with.
Well, I don't know for certan how it works there but here's how it works around here:
About 856 households in unincorporated Elmhurst and Bensenville will continue to receive their contracted fire protection service at a capped property tax rate after nearly 87 percent of voters rejected a referendum last week.

If approved, residents in the area of York Road and Grand Avenue would have been taxed 40 cents per $100 of equalized assessed value of property, bypassing a state law capping property tax at 27 cents per $100 of EAV, which is determined by using the consumer price index.

Paul DeMichele, secretary of Bensenville Fire Protection District 1, a “paper fire department” that covers the unincorporated area through contracts with both Bensenville Fire Protection District 2 and the city of Elmhurst, said contracts have been extended until Oct. 31, and fire service will not change.

“There is no change in their fire protection and at no time will (unincorporated residents) go without fire protection,” he said. “There’s no burning issue at the moment.”
http://www.mysuburbanlife.com/elmhu...sts-same-for-now-for-unincorporated-taxpayers

In this instance, the voters in the unincorporated area had already approved a referendum for fire service, and apparently the amount they pay is no longer enough to fully cover their share, and the towns are trying to get more money. But note that only voters in those 856 households get to vote on this, the people in the town and rest of the fire protection district (Illinois has more taxing units of government than any other state btw, even much larger California) don't get to vote on the issue.

It will be interesting to see what happens if they continue to reject property tax increases to pay for fire service.
 
Woman doesn't blame firefighters


Paulette Cranik said they had paid the fee in the past, although sometimes late, but it slipped their mind this year.

Lance Cranik said "this is something I've got to live with the rest of my life."

Holy crap! The dementia of personal responsibility.

Is there a government program to help re-educate people with this mental disorder?
 
It is small by most standards. At ~2500 people it is one quarter the size of the largest town in the county, Union City. Somehow I doubt that there was ever any expectation that South Fulton would become the fire fighting provider for Obion County.

I agree, but if there were an agreement in place for that coverage area that agreement would still be between the county and town. It absolutely makes sense for the town to provide fire service to nearby rural areas but the best way to do that is for the county the pay for the service from tax revenue. Failing that the current system of optional coverage is a poor second choice, and this isn’t going to work if the service is provided whether the people pay or not.
Well, I don't know for certan how it works there but here's how it works around here:

http://www.mysuburbanlife.com/elmhu...sts-same-for-now-for-unincorporated-taxpayers

In this instance, the voters in the unincorporated area had already approved a referendum for fire service, and apparently the amount they pay is no longer enough to fully cover their share, and the towns are trying to get more money. But note that only voters in those 856 households get to vote on this, the people in the town and rest of the fire protection district (Illinois has more taxing units of government than any other state btw, even much larger California) don't get to vote on the issue.

It will be interesting to see what happens if they continue to reject property tax increases to pay for fire service.
I’m guessing what you are seeing is the county holding a referendum for the coverage area, and if they vote yes implementing the tax in that coverage area. AFAIK an ad-hoc coverage area wouldn’t have any taxation powers nor any legal standing to form agreements on behalf of all the residents in that area. These powers would still rest with the county even if the agreement only covered a limited area. I’m certainly not a lawyer though, so there are likely better people then me to comment on this.
 
I believe the issue here is that the county refused to enter into such an agreement and town was fed up with paying for other peoples fire protection.

Sure, that's the problem. Letting the house burn wasn't the solution.
 
Sure, that's the problem. Letting the house burn wasn't the solution.

We don't know yet. We do know that no one was talking about this before the fire, we wouldn't have heard about it if the fire department had fought the fire, and now it is one of the hotest topics on the internet.

Maybe letting the house burn was the solution on several different levels.
 
You know, to everyone who's just horrified at the actions of the FD, I have to say, it's a cliche but it's true, life is full of hard and unpleasant choices.
Sure.

I don't think this is one of them.
 
Sure, that's the problem. Letting the house burn wasn't the solution.

Jury's still out on that. The destruction of this one trailer may end up breaking an impasse and resulting in a better system for everybody.

Then again, they could all get their backs up and end up worse off than before.

Gotta wait and see.
 
I don't think this is one of them.

I'll bet if you asked the city and FD leaders they'd say different. I doubt any of them wanted to come to the point where they knew they had to decide "No more, we've gotta let the next one burn".
 
We don't know yet. We do know that no one was talking about this before the fire, we wouldn't have heard about it if the fire department had fought the fire, and now it is one of the hotest topics on the internet.

Maybe letting the house burn was the solution on several different levels.

Jury's still out on that. The destruction of this one trailer may end up breaking an impasse and resulting in a better system for everybody.

Then again, they could all get their backs up and end up worse off than before.

Gotta wait and see.

I think we need to separate a possible good outcome from the quality of the underlying decision.

I agree that it exposed dramatic flaws in their system and will serve as a fine example for dismissing libertarian arguments in the future, but it was still absurd to let the house burn for an unpaid $75 fee.

Treat people as ends in themselves, not as means to an end...
 
I'll bet if you asked the city and FD leaders they'd say different. I doubt any of them wanted to come to the point where they knew they had to decide "No more, we've gotta let the next one burn".
I don't think the fact that someone made a bad choice is evidence of a difficult choice. There are too many bumbling idiots in this world to take that idea seriously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom