Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

They can place a lien on your home, they can put you in prison, they can seize other assets and even possess the home.

"Denying land" is by far not the only remedy.
Actually, what they do is have a tax sale where someone else pays the taxes, and that person then has a claim on the property. The owner is then expected to pay back the taxes paid, plus fees and interest, to the person who paid them. If they fail to do this after a set amount of time the property is sold at auction.

No, they don't put you in prison or seize other assets.

Interestingly, in areas where taxes finance fire departments, one thing they won't ever do is let someone's house burn to the ground.
Because the deadbeats don't have property to burn.
 
They would obviously have to work out a deal with the jurisdiction collecting taxes on that property. This is not an unusual event, especially if one jurisdiction is providing services to another.

Seriously, why are we pretending that very basic concepts are unusual and mystifying?

You think the Kansas City, Kansas, police officers stop at the Missouri border when they're chasing a suspect? Or have the jurisdictions developed an arrangement?

Why don't you call them and ask? I'd bet there's a jurisdictional agreement.
 
And things heat up a bit in South Fulton.

South Fulton’s fire chief was assaulted Wednesday in the aftermath of a fire where firefighters were unable to respond because the property owner had not paid a rural fire subscription fee.
South Fulton Fire Chief David Wilds was treated at an area hospital after being assaulted about 5:45 p.m. at the city’s fire station, located in the South Fulton Municipal Building.
Timothy A. Cranick, 44, a resident of Buddy Jones Road near South Fulton, was arrested and charged with felony aggravated assault, according to South Fulton Police Chief Andy Crocker.
Crocker said the assault stemmed from a fire that occurred earlier in the day and he identified Cranick as a family member of the person whose property burned.
He said Cranick allegedly came to the fire station looking for Wilds, according to witnesses. When the fire chief identified himself and asked if he could help him, Cranick allegedly struck Wilds.
“He just cold-cocked him,” Crocker said, based on witness statements.
Crocker said Wilds was knocked down, rendering him virtually defenseless. He said Cranick was pulled off the fire chief by other firefighters who restrained him until additional help arrived.
Cranick was taken to the Obion County Law Enforcement Complex and was later taken to the hospital in Union City for treatment of a hand injury sustained in the incident.
 
Every municipality is already charging rural residents for fire department services, at $500 a pop (apparently, even the ones that collect a subscription fee). Collection rates are 'less than 50%'. Which implies 'not very much less than 50%'.

Either half the people in the rural areas are idiots, or half of the people in the area recognize some duty to pay for emergency services irrespective of cynical self-interest.
 
They would obviously have to work out a deal with the jurisdiction collecting taxes on that property. This is not an unusual event, especially if one jurisdiction is providing services to another.

Seriously, why are we pretending that very basic concepts are unusual and mystifying?
Apparently they are mystifying you. The only legal method for getting those in the area the South Fulton Fire Dept. covers for a fee to pay for the service via property taxes is by referendum of the voters living in that area.

To date, those voters have rejected that remedy, or not even shown enough support to get such a referendum on the ballot.

South Fulton has no control at all over that process.
 
Last edited:
Actually, what they do is have a tax sale where someone else pays the taxes, and that person then has a claim on the property. The owner is then expected to pay back the taxes paid, plus fees and interest, to the person who paid them. If they fail to do this after a set amount of time the property is sold at auction.

No, they don't put you in prison or seize other assets.

It depends on the amount of taxes owed and the availability of liquid funds or other assets possessed by the homeowner. If they owed $5000 and had $10000 in the bank, they would chose garnishment over selling the home, for example.

Prison time is usually reserved for Federal tax evasion, property taxes are local, I still had Wesley Snipes on my mind, you are correct.


Because the deadbeats don't have property to burn.

You're assuming that all issues of owing real estate taxes result in taking the property. THose are the most extreme examples.
 
Last edited:
Apparently they are mystifying you. The only legal method for getting those in the area the South Fulton Fire Dept. covers for a fee is via referendum by the voters living in that area.

Nice scope shift. Are you asking me about what could be done, or are you asking about what these morons have chosen to do?

If the fire department put out the fire, they could have just left a bill with the owner. Likely whatever appeared on that bill would be upheld in court under the doctrine of unjust enrichment.

That's always available even if the morlocks in the area haven't figured out how to deal with the problem.
 
Last edited:
You're assuming that all issues of owing real estate taxes result in taking the property. THose are the most extreme examples.
I'm not aware of any other method used by governments wrt property taxes. At least not around here.
 
Nice scope shift. Are you asking me about what could be done, or are you asking about what these morons have chosen to do?
In unincorporated areas the only way to add services is via referendum. You seem to think there's some way for South Fulton or the county to impose a fire protection fee without the assent of the voters affected.
 
In unincorporated areas the only way to add services is via referendum. You seem to think there's some way for South Fulton or the county to impose a fire protection fee without the assent of the voters affected.

I described the most basic method in an above edit.

The fact that they didn't arrive at an enforcement mechanism highlights their absolute idiocy. Just letting people's homes burn is ridiculous.
 
See the Prisoners Dilemma. Just because it’s in everyone’s best interest to pay the $75 to properly maintain a fire department doesn’t mean it makes sense to do so.

When I was a child, we kept the volunteer fire department going as a charity; We had a HUGE annual fundraiser picnic (with bingo tables the cops looked the other way on) and raffles and etc. If you have people connected enough with their community you can make this work.
 
Cranick and his family lost all of their possessions in the Sept. 29 fire, along with three dogs and a cat.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/39535911/ns/us_news-life/
One of those times I wish someone was there with their cellphone, recording a bunch of dumb hicks who can't even think to open the door when their house is on fire to let their pets out. And their dumb hick firemen, standing around outside having a smoke while listening to the howling, burning animals...

I guess I'm being too judgmental but these kind of people are exactly what taxes were invented for.
 
And the fine for a single fire could pay the cost they would charge every resident. If there are no fires, they aren't spending any resources on putting them out.

As has been pointed out, they have expenses related to manpower and maintenance over and above the costs of going on calls. A regular subscriber base helps with that during a time of budget cuts.

Also, I doubt the FD has any authority to levy fines, and the city certainly would have no authority to levy fines on county residents.

Instead, they would have to trust the homeowner to pay up, and resort to litigation if he didn't.

I'm sure the most common feeling among the firefighters who were obligated to watch that house burn down was "Why does it have to come to this?"
 
The moral worth of an action is determined by its outcome, thus I believe that the leaders (mayor or fire chief) of the South Fulton Fire Department acted in an immoral way when they implemented a rule that allowed someone's home to burn down. The county is in their service area because they decided to offer fire-fighting services there. Whether or not the $75 was paid, the home shouldn't have been allowed to burn down.

Then you have to think of long-term outcomes, too, not just immediate ones.

And you know what, the homeowner also has to think of outcomes, and so does the County Commission. Both of them failed to do this, or believed they could bank on the FD taking the burden upon themselves when it was not theirs to bear.

The FD didn't set up the situation, nor did the Mayor, the CC did.

The FD was helping out to offer services for a modest annual fee.

And their service area was NOT the county, but only those residences who paid the fee.
 
You know, to everyone who's just horrified at the actions of the FD, I have to say, it's a cliche but it's true, life is full of hard and unpleasant choices.

Very few people want to kill dogs, for example, but some people have to do it to prevent even more dogs from starving to death, spreading disease, and attacking humans.

Serving in Iraq and Afghanistan is no picnic, either.

And the biggest reason we're in such a dangerous political and financial mess right now is precisely because so many politicians refuse to make hard choices.

Sure, the impulse is "Help those people!" But acting on that impulse is not necessarily the right thing to do, horrible as that may seem.
 
Then you have to think of long-term outcomes, too, not just immediate ones.
What long-term outcomes?

And you know what, the homeowner also has to think of outcomes, and so does the County Commission. Both of them failed to do this, or believed they could bank on the FD taking the burden upon themselves when it was not theirs to bear.
The the homeowner apparently had paid in the past and just forgot this time. When were payments due? How late were they? Were late notices sent?

The homeowner says homes had been saved before when the $75 wasn't paid. Doesn't this mean South Fulton had established an expectation in people's minds that service would be provided? Did they send notices that they had changed their policy? Did they inform the County Commission so it could warn its residents?

I agree that Obion County should set up a better system, but that doesn't change the fact that you don't let people's homes burn down when you are there and can prevent it.

The FD didn't set up the situation, nor did the Mayor, the CC did.

The FD was helping out to offer services for a modest annual fee.

And their service area was NOT the county, but only those residences who paid the fee.
By offering fire-fighting to part of the county, they made that their service area. They were there. They were fire-fighters. They should not have let the home burn.
 
The thing is that for two hours it was a yard fire not a house fire.

So long as it was a yard fire, there was a chance to put it out. Once the mobile home slit, it was all over. Those damned things may as well be made of tissue paper for all the fire immunity they have.
 
By offering fire-fighting to part of the county, they made that their service area. They were there. They were fire-fighters. They should not have let the home burn.

Idealism is nice when you can afford it.

Apparently, the FD had decided they could no longer afford it.

And I don't have the cites, but from what I've been hearing as this story evolves, we've been getting a changing story on whether or not this guy "forgot" or simply decided not to pay.

If I were the county, I wouldn't institute a system which relies on people having to remember to pay, and on the FD to keep up to date records, and such.

Institute a tax, cover the whole county, and be done with it.
 
They would obviously have to work out a deal with the jurisdiction collecting taxes on that property. This is not an unusual event, especially if one jurisdiction is providing services to another.

Seriously, why are we pretending that very basic concepts are unusual and mystifying?

I believe the issue here is that the county refused to enter into such an agreement and town was fed up with paying for other peoples fire protection.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom