Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

It appears to me as though the SFFD defined their service area as the City limits and surrounding properties who subscribed to their service.


Yes. And by extending that service to "surrounding properties who subscribed" they made it more than the "simple" situation you discribed.

Isn't that simple enough for you?
I was unaware I'd attempted slurs against the firefighters. Was this directed at me???


You made several references to the FD's responsibilities. That suggests you were pursuing some judgment of their responsibilities, and their adherence to them. Unless the FD just services whoever the heck they feel like then I'd say they were doing the job as mandated by the municipality. I'm not criticizing the FD. You were framing it in those terms.

The commitment to undertake subscription services is at the root of this issue. I expect that the municipality of South Fulton agreed to obligate their FD to do so. Perhaps I am mistaken. Maybe the firefighters just had too much free time on their hands and decided to pick up a little side work when they could.
 
South Fulton has a population of just 2500, so almost any increase in the area and number of buildings they serve will be significant. We're not talking about a "metropolis" of 50,000 here.

And the fine for a single fire could pay the cost they would charge every resident. If there are no fires, they aren't spending any resources on putting them out.
 
Obion County is pretty small and rural. I wonder how many other counties in the US have policies like this:

http://troy.troytn.com/Obion County...tation Presented to the County Commission.pdf

The same thing happened in Gilbert, AZ. Gilbert has about 220,000 people and it is a decent sized city, but there are few areas of Gilbert that refuse to be annexed, so they are in essence county islands. Well, the Gilbert Fire Department is only responsible for Gilbert residents of Gilbert and anyone who lives in Maricopa County and not in a city, they rely on Rural Metro or they had contracts with the Gilbert Fire Department. Rural Metro no longer has any fire stations in Gilbert, they only have amubulances. Anyway, as more areas of Maricopa County were annexed they obviously fell under the protection of the city, but the county islands that refused to be annexed had contracts with the Gilbert Fire Department. Well, contracts were not renewed, but the fire department still responded to structure fires and they put them out for a time, but there came a day when the Gilbert Fire Chief told the county they needed to renew the contracts and pay or Gilbert Fire was not going to put out anymore fires, but they would take action if there were lives in danger.

So, there came a day when a county resident's house caught on fire and the Gilbert Fire Department showed up, but they let the house burn. No lives were in danger and had there been the fire departmetn would have taken action. The bottom line was this: either pay taxes for police and fire or pay a contract fee. It isn't free and it should not be free.
 
The moral worth of an action is determined by its outcome, thus I believe that the leaders (mayor or fire chief) of the South Fulton Fire Department acted in an immoral way when they implemented a rule that allowed someone's home to burn down. The county is in their service area because they decided to offer fire-fighting services there. Whether or not the $75 was paid, the home shouldn't have been allowed to burn down.

I've been a volunteer firefighter my entire adult life and this sort of a thing is an anathema to every firefighter I've met over the years. We don't let politics get in the way of saving property (or lives). Doesn't matter if you in arrears paying your property taxes, are on welfare, abuse your spouse, have built your house on someone else's property, or are just passing through when your car/trailer catches fire. We'll respond and won't ever send a bill.

<snip>

I didn't join the fire service to be put in a situation where I was prevented from fighting a fire because someone didn't pay a fee.
(emphasis mine) It's nice to know that an actual firefighter feels this way. Thank you.

Oh gawd has this really spun wildly. Let me add my $.02 having been a volunteer firefighter and department treasurer in a small-town VFD in TX. While we apparently still don't know if the department in TN was paid, paid-on-call, volunteer, or mixed, that doesn't really matter.

My former department (I now live back where I grew up again in So. Cal.) is a non-profit private VFD contracted by the city it resides in and also covers the outlying county area and mutual aid to other neighboring departments. This has been the relationship for 70+ years. The city paid us $20k per year to cover the city (1998-2000 when I was treasurer.) Outside of the city limits, we mailed out subscription request envelopes asking for $35 per year to about 400-500 rural homes in our corner of the surrounding county. The city population was around 4,000. I can't remember exactly the number of subscriptions, but it was somewhere around 15-20% would subscribe.

What we explicitly stated on the subscription mailer is that we would always do our best to respond to any emergency and that if you did need our services and were not a subscriber, you would be billed for those services. We also informed them that anything we bill for should be submitted to one's insurance to reimburse for. We never shirked our responsibility as first responders because someone did not subscribe for service coverage.

If we had to, we ate the cost which is subsidized by our income (yeah- the other subscribers, the city residents and occasional fund raisers). That's part of life. That was a small price to pay in order to be members of the community supporting public safety where we live and to participate in our social obligation for the greater good (which seems to be disappearing really quick in this "you first after me" society.)

Had the department in question very publicly stated the fact of no subscription - no response, it guess it might be possible that they have some legal justification for not being liable (no, I'm not a lawyer), but I doubt it. In my opinion, I think that they bear some responsibility in the homeowner's loss for dereliction of duty at the scene of an emergency. Failure to act as an emergency response agency when there is no life safety consideration is pretty damning, in my opinion.

It would be no different for an ambulance crew (public or private) while not on another call or hospital run passing by the scene of an accident and not rendering aid. Even when on a call, such an ambulance crew should and would try to call for help. Believe me on that since I was rear-ended when I stopped for an LAFD rescue ambulance on a call and they radioed in for my accident.

I would expect a review with sanctions from the TN state agency that regulates and certifies emergency responders and agencies. I also figure that the homeowner, based on the failure to render aid by the responding department, would have grounds for a civil suit. Yeah, $75 is a small price to pay, but for the department in question to fail to act simply on the grounds that a county resident did not subscribe is horrible and, in my opinion, might be criminal. In my department, the subscription fee was used as a non-tax revenue source.

You can go round-and-round about the $75 being "insurance" (that's B.S.) and whether-or-not that the county in which this happened should have a county response system with tax funding (probably a great idea), the fact-of-the-matter is that the department was toned out for a structure fire, arrived on scene, determined that the owner had not paid the $75 subscription, and his property was left to burn. If there are other facts that might alter that timeline, I certainly have not read any.

This is not 100+ years ago where firefighting was a private protection racket! As first responders, based on what I have read, I figure that the duty to act was not fulfilled for a reason that did not involve life safety. Not good. That's what you get when it's all dollars and no sense and when people yell "no new taxes!". Believe me, I understand the responders' reluctance to help due to the cost of firefighting and possibly a ridiculous response protocol either self-imposed by the department or by the county, but come on! We did it on a shoestring budget in Bubbaville, but we still did our duty.

We ALL need to step up, pay up, close loopholes, stop whining about not having enough of my fair share, and remember that yes - we all have a social obligation, and part of that means paying for government (and essential quasi-government services) or this is what happens. I understand that a few years ago my former department and several surrounding dept.'s formed an Emergency Services District and passed a vote to legally tax everyone and spread the burden. That makes a big difference.

I feel that the need for a $75 subscription fee for an essential service is symptomatic of a larger problem in America. Here in CA it started with Proposition 13 and it's been all downhill since. Sorry for getting political, but it's an unfortunate fact. Anyway, the responding TN department, I feel, is going to find that the ice that it's standing on is cracking and that it will be legally underwater very soon.
(WildCat: I copied this for you with paragraphs added because you implied you hadn't read it. Highlighting mine for emphasis.) Another firefighter heard from! Thank you for believing in a "social obligation for the greater good."

Here's where your plan goes horribly wrong: The odds of any given house catching fire are 1000:1. Any potential fee would have to be in the tens of thousands of dollars to have a deterrent effect, in many cases this could esceed the cost of the house.
Why would the fees have to be so high? I live on a small fixed income, and the threat of a fee in the low thousands would make me pay the $75 pronto. I think you're way off in what you feel is needed to have a deterrent effect.

This guy had 2 hours to save his pets, he didn't lift a finger to do so. A real POS in my opinion.
Yes, unless the fire in the house immediately made it unsafe to enter, he should have rescued his pets. If he could have and didn't, he is indeed a POS. But even though in this case the loss of the pets may be the homeowners fault, the next time there may not be a two-hour window for pet rescue.
 
<snip>

The system is screwed here. Where the County Gov't should have acted to protect it's inhabitants, it willingly decided to refuse this service offered by SFFD. The hopeful outcome would be that the County Gov't would contract with all the local FDs to provide full coverage for the County while passing that cost on via a tax to the affected County residents (those who live outside City/Town limits).


That's been my position from the beginning of this conversation.
 
Here's more fuel for the fire . . . no pun intended.

Obion County has decided to expand their subscription-only fire service to more communities instead of adding a tax that would provide universal coverage.

http://thinkprogress.org/2010/10/05/after-firefighters-obion-expands/

There are two issues here in my opinion. First, the county set this up. Second, the people of the county voted the government in.
 
To further bolster your point, Obion County has a population of aprox 31,000.

So there is no way that the 2500 residents of South Fultion could bloc vote in a change in a county wide referendum to change this county policy
In such a referendum only the voters in the proposed area of increased coverage, whose property taxes would be affected, could vote on that issue. It certainly wouldn't be a county-wide vote.
 
You may as well ask, "Why would anyone pay taxes? Parking tickets? Speeding tickets? Assessed court costs?" and on and on.

As I said before, the punishment for failing to pay the $75 that would have secured fire fighting is to 1) pay the $75, 2) pay the costs incurred by having to write the ticket vs. paying the proper way, maybe another $100, then 3) some type of punitive fine to incentivize people to pay up front, maybe another $100.

A $275 fine would be more than enough to motivate people to pay ahead of time.

Penalties could also be placed for not paying on time, even before the fire hit, but I'm not that concerned with developing ways to make this horrific system run better. It would be easier to just deduct the fee as a tax.
You're a lawyer. Please explain how the town of South Fulton can fine people who don't live in South Fulton and cannot vote for any South Fulton officials, for refusing to buy services from South Fulton rendered outside of South Fulton.
 
And the fine for a single fire could pay the cost they would charge every resident. If there are no fires, they aren't spending any resources on putting them out.
:confused:

You think that once a fire breaks out the town buys fire trucks, recruits firemen, trains them, builds them a firehouse, and then rushes, sirens blaring, to the fire?

The vast majority of the costs incurred by a fire department are not the incremental costs of actually fighting fires, but in the vast infrastructure needed to do so.
 
Denial of service is absolutely not the only way. How do we get people to pay speeding tickets? How do we get people to pay property taxes?

Why they pay is denial of service. For instance, I'd pay a speeding ticket because I'd be denied a valid license if I didn't. Failure to pay property tax will deny me my land.
 
You're a lawyer. Please explain how the town of South Fulton can fine people who don't live in South Fulton and cannot vote for any South Fulton officials, for refusing to buy services from South Fulton rendered outside of South Fulton.

Oh my god, foiled!

Neither I, nor any person in the law before me, has every considered the problem of jurisdiction.

Or is it that once you leave city limits you enter a lawless commons akin to international waters?
 
The news video in the link said the same thing happend in 2008 and a council meeting was called to address the issue. There wasn't enough support from the community then to change the system to something better.
 
There may be some explanation about the discrepancy in the statements about the payment to be found here.

Apparently there was one from the husband Gene, and another one from his wife, who seems to be the owner of record.

South Fulton City manager Jeff Vowell confirmed the Cranicks had not paid the fee, which has been the department's policy since 1990. Cranick said her failure to pay was an oversight.
"I've paid it many, many times," Cranick said, "I just haven't gotten around to it (this year)." Cranick pointed out that the fire station is on the edge of town and "we don't go out that way every often."


So it doesn't seem to have been a matter of willfully disregarding the fee.

This comment of hers was also a bit interesting.

Even more puzzling to Cranick is why firefighters failed to respond to her home when, according to her, they had helped people in the past who hadn't paid.
"It doesn't make sense," she said. "Two or three years ago this house up here caught fire. My son lives there but they waived the fee." Cranick said South Fulton firefighters had also previously helped people but sternly reminded them to pay the fee the next day.
"I guess they have to let a house burn once in awhile to teach us a lesson," Cranick said.


Prophetic words. I wonder if she's been reading this thread.

So there may have been some cause for them to expect that they would get service. Like, a demonstrated history.
 
Why they pay is denial of service. For instance, I'd pay a speeding ticket because I'd be denied a valid license if I didn't. Failure to pay property tax will deny me my land.

Denial of land? Huh?

What happens if you get a jaywalking ticket? They deny you your legs?
 
(WildCat: I copied this for you with paragraphs added because you implied you hadn't read it. Highlighting mine for emphasis.) Another firefighter heard from! Thank you for believing in a "social obligation for the greater good."
I wonder if that firefighter works for free?

Why would the fees have to be so high? I live on a small fixed income, and the threat of a fee in the low thousands would make me pay the $75 pronto. I think you're way off in what you feel is needed to have a deterrent effect.
TraneWreck proposes a $100 fee. Would that compel you to pay the $75 every year? What if you were making $100,000/yr, maybe you'd roll the dice then for even a $10,000 fee since the odds of ever actually paying it are remote?

What if the person refuses to pay, and doesn't have the money to pay?
 
Oh my god, foiled!

Neither I, nor any person in the law before me, has every considered the problem of jurisdiction.

Or is it that once you leave city limits you enter a lawless commons akin to international waters?
Nice evasion counsel.

Explain how South Fulton can tax property outside of its jurisdiction, or require persons outside its jurisdiction to purchase a service for a fee if you want to play the fee/tax game. And fine any who don't comply.
 
What do you think happens if you don't pay your property taxes?

They can place a lien on your home, they can put you in prison, they can seize other assets and even possess the home.

"Denying land" is by far not the only remedy.

Interestingly, in areas where taxes finance fire departments, one thing they won't ever do is let someone's house burn to the ground.
 
Nice evasion counsel.

Explain how South Fulton can tax property outside of its jurisdiction, or require persons outside its jurisdiction to purchase a service for a fee if you want to play the fee/tax game. And fine any who don't comply.

They would obviously have to work out a deal with the jurisdiction collecting taxes on that property. This is not an unusual event, especially if one jurisdiction is providing services to another.

Seriously, why are we pretending that very basic concepts are unusual and mystifying?

You think the Kansas City, Kansas, police officers stop at the Missouri border when they're chasing a suspect? Or have the jurisdictions developed an arrangement?
 
They can place a lien on your home, they can put you in prison, they can seize other assets and even possess the home.

"Denying land" is by far not the only remedy.

Interestingly, in areas where taxes finance fire departments, one thing they won't ever do is let someone's house burn to the ground.

3 of your 4 could be considered methods of "denying land". At a minimum, possessing the home is specifically "denying land".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom