Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

That is exactly what is being done here. The simple answer is cut off all of them from fire coverage. Then it is simple and basic and not a problem anymore right?
No, the simple answer is just to cover those areas you can cover without incurring significant costs, charging off marginal costs at $500 a pop.

The ******* answer is to do nothing.
 
Last edited:
South Fulton had 1199 households (a more relevant measure) in 2008.

The total number of households not in a town is 4612. There's also one town, Woodland Mills, which doesn't appear to have a fire department. 122 households, assuming they don't contract with one of the other towns.

Considering that there are eight other fire department serving the county, one of them in a city four times larger than South Fulton (which presumably has more rural households surrounding it than other towns), I think we can safely assume that the additional number of households covered is relatively small.

You seem to be making some strange assumptions. Why would the larger city have to cover so much more of the county outside of it?

So it is only a 50% increase or so, and given the situation probably more than 50% of wear and tear and such on equipment. FDNY covering all of Westchester is a much smaller percentage of increase. But as that would effect you, you clearly hold that to different standards.
 
South Fulton had 1199 households (a more relevant measure) in 2008.

The total number of households not in a town is 4612. There's also one town, Woodland Mills, which doesn't appear to have a fire department. 122 households, assuming they don't contract with one of the other towns.

Considering that there are eight other fire department serving the county, one of them in a city four times larger than South Fulton (which presumably has more rural households surrounding it than other towns), I think we can safely assume that the additional number of households covered is relatively small.
Why are you assuming the larger town serves more out-of-towners than South Fulton, or that it is proportionate?

Geography will likely have a big say, more than population alone, in which towns serve which areas.
 
Because it will not be sufficient to actually get them to do something or you will be whining about how a $10000 fine is disproportionate.

Haha, what?

If they paid $75, they get fire service. The fire would be fought for that cost. The fine doesn't need to be any more than a speeding ticket.

And yes, $10,000 for failure to pay a $75 fee is insane.
 
No, the simple answer is just to cover those areas you can cover with incurring significant costs, charging off marginal costs at $500 a pop.

The problem is that there is no clear boundary on what that area is. It will always be "why isn't the boundary another 1000' down the road that will not add more costs"
The ******* answer is to do nothing.

Hey you are the one advocating that in the case of FDNY and westchester.
 
Haha, what?

If they paid $75, they get fire service. The fire would be fought for that cost. The fine doesn't need to be any more than a speeding ticket.

And yes, $10,000 for failure to pay a $75 fee is insane.

So how many years is failure to pay a million dollars worth? Talk to Kent Hovind, Westly Snipes and H. Beatty Chadwick.

Free them all right?

Denial of service is the only tool the town has to get people to pay. It can not throw them in jail or take their house like would be the case in a more sensible system.
 
Last edited:
Why are you assuming the larger town serves more out-of-towners than South Fulton, or that it is proportionate?
Because they will (and do) have greater capacity for a similar tax rate, and because population tends to taper off as you move away from urban centers.
 
It would be "simple" if the SFFD declined to respond to any calls outside of the municipality of South Fulton, which would presumably be, absent any other understandings, the limit of their service area. Once they undertook to service some areas outside that limit it became less simple.
It appears to me as though the SFFD defined their service area as the City limits and surrounding properties who subscribed to their service.



But I thought we had mostly agreed that the FD was behaving as it had been mandated to, and we were discussing those mandates. Let's not try and sneak slurs against the firemen back into the discussion, just to rebuild a straw man.

I was unaware I'd attempted slurs against the firefighters. Was this directed at me???
 
The problem is that there is no clear boundary on what that area is. It will always be "why isn't the boundary another 1000' down the road that will not add more costs"
There is a clear boundary, it's just not geographical. Once the fire department gets to the point where they would need to buy a new engine, hire new personnel, etc. to provide the same level of service to their tax base, that's as far as they can go.

Hey you are the one advocating that in the case of FDNY and westchester.
I think I've already refuted this nonsense once.
 
This does resemble that. You're asking the fire dept. to expand its coverage to more homes while providing no money with which to do so.


Is that a fair representation? It seems to me that the town elected to expand its coverage, and developed a questionable method to defray any potential additional cost.

What makes you think they had "more capacity than [they] needed"?


Apparently the town thought they did, otherwise it would have been rather foolish to agree to provide the service.
 
Haha, what?

If they paid $75, they get fire service. The fire would be fought for that cost. The fine doesn't need to be any more than a speeding ticket.

And yes, $10,000 for failure to pay a $75 fee is insane.
So the penalty for not paying the $75 fine is "the cost of a speeding ticket" - $100 or so?

And the only way you can incur this penalty is if your house catches fire?

And you are guaranteed fire protection?

Why would anyone pay the $75?
 
Is that a fair representation? It seems to me that the town elected to expand its coverage,
And likely an expanded budget.

and developed a questionable method to defray any potential additional cost.
What's questionable about it? What else could they do?

Apparently the town thought they did, otherwise it would have been rather foolish to agree to provide the service.
Or they boosted the budget of the fire dept. by the amount of revenue expected from the new area, in order to adequately serve it.
 
There is a clear boundary, it's just not geographical. Once the fire department gets to the point where they would need to buy a new engine, hire new personnel, etc. to provide the same level of service to their tax base, that's as far as they can go.

No the boundary is always fuzzy, and a little more can always be added with out any of that.

I think I've already refuted this nonsense once.

Not on any level that creates a principle.
 
South Fulton has a population of just 2500, so almost any increase in the area and number of buildings they serve will be significant. We're not talking about a "metropolis" of 50,000 here.

To further bolster your point, Obion County has a population of aprox 31,000.

So there is no way that the 2500 residents of South Fultion could bloc vote in a change in a county wide referendum to change this county policy
 
So the penalty for not paying the $75 fine is "the cost of a speeding ticket" - $100 or so?

And the only way you can incur this penalty is if your house catches fire?

And you are guaranteed fire protection?

Why would anyone pay the $75?

You may as well ask, "Why would anyone pay taxes? Parking tickets? Speeding tickets? Assessed court costs?" and on and on.

As I said before, the punishment for failing to pay the $75 that would have secured fire fighting is to 1) pay the $75, 2) pay the costs incurred by having to write the ticket vs. paying the proper way, maybe another $100, then 3) some type of punitive fine to incentivize people to pay up front, maybe another $100.

A $275 fine would be more than enough to motivate people to pay ahead of time.

Penalties could also be placed for not paying on time, even before the fire hit, but I'm not that concerned with developing ways to make this horrific system run better. It would be easier to just deduct the fee as a tax.
 
Last edited:
Is that a fair representation? It seems to me that the town elected to expand its coverage, and developed a questionable method to defray any potential additional cost.




Apparently the town thought they did, otherwise it would have been rather foolish to agree to provide the service.

Perhaps the town felt that they should be better citizens toward those living just outside the town limits and thus offered to assist those willing to defray the costs of such assistance.

But that's how a social contract works - I should not expect my Gov't, at any level, to assist me if I'm not willing to pay my fair share. I greatly enjoy all the socialist benefits found in our society - and I pay my share to ensure they can continue.

If the homeowners do not wish to accept the offer to be a part of the SF community (and accept the fees associated therewith), it cannot be expected for the SF community to respond merely out of the goodness of their hearts.


The system is screwed here. Where the County Gov't should have acted to protect it's inhabitants, it willingly decided to refuse this service offered by SFFD. The hopeful outcome would be that the County Gov't would contract with all the local FDs to provide full coverage for the County while passing that cost on via a tax to the affected County residents (those who live outside City/Town limits).
 
No the boundary is always fuzzy, and a little more can always be added with out any of that.
Fuzziness doesn't imply that bright lines can't be defended.

Not on any level that creates a principle.
Yonkers has a fire department. Obion county doesn't. Yonkers is an incorporated municipality perfectly capable of raising its own funds. The rural areas of Obion county aren't. The NYPD can't cover Yonkers without incurring significant costs (I mean, do you have any sense of the traffic? They'd at least have to build a number of fire departments in Yonkers). The SFFD can cover a swath of the rural area of the county without incurring costs, charging back marginal costs on a per-call basis.

This allows me to articulate a useful principle: where you can help people avoid significant loss without incurring any costs and where no one else is available to help them, you ought to do so.

I also think that's a pretty easy principle to defend.
 
Last edited:
So how many years is failure to pay a million dollars worth? Talk to Kent Hovind, Westly Snipes and H. Beatty Chadwick.

Free them all right?

Denial of service is the only tool the town has to get people to pay. It can not throw them in jail or take their house like would be the case in a more sensible system.

Haha, tax evasion is an actual crime, failure to pay a fee is not.

Perhaps if that were added to the penal code, you might have something to work with, but that's just not the case.

Denial of service is absolutely not the only way. How do we get people to pay speeding tickets? How do we get people to pay property taxes?

Why does everyone act like this is an unusual situation? It's the most quotidian of circumstances made singular by the insane decision to let the house burn. A fine could EASILY be levied and enforced.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom