Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

It's not about "punishment". You're a lawyer, you should understand about assumption of risk.

If not, get your insurance agent to explain it to you.

It's absolutely about punishment. It's about "lesson teaching," as so many on this thread have made clear. If were just about making sure the fees were paid, a simple ticket or fine would suffice.

He made a bad decision. He should pay. Allowing the house to burn was insanely disproportionate.
 
Last edited:
Ok. I suppose I really need to spell this out for you in very simple terms:


1) The property in question is outside the service area
2) The SFFD has no responsibility to fight any fire outside their service area
3) Therefore, the SFFD had no responsibility to risk their lives (and let's not lie to ourselves, any fire fighting risks life/limb) to service the property in question.


It would be "simple" if the SFFD declined to respond to any calls outside of the municipality of South Fulton, which would presumably be, absent any other understandings, the limit of their service area. Once they undertook to service some areas outside that limit it became less simple.

But I thought we had mostly agreed that the FD was behaving as it had been mandated to, and we were discussing those mandates. Let's not try and sneak slurs against the firemen back into the discussion, just to rebuild a straw man.
 
People do it all the time with their insurance. They don't get it, don't get enough coverage, or let it lapse. They kiss a $30k car goodbye because they didn't want to pay the $100 monthly premium before wrecking it. The insurance company has the resources to handle their claim regardless of if they pay, but does that obligate the company to? Should the company pay the poor, sweet single mother's medical bills regardless of whether the uninsured driver that hit her forgot to pay his bill? After all, why should she bear the cost?

If the car insurance company was able to stop the crash, but chose not to because the person hadn't paid, I would have the same opinion of them.

This is not a pure insurance system. We have a party capable of dealing with a problem that consciously chose to allow great harm to occur over a trivial sum of money.

There were ample remedies available to correct the person's failure to pay.

Unless the fire department set the fire because he didn't pay, that isn't an equivlent situation.

There's a reason why the phrase "acts and/or omissions" appears so consistently in statutes.
 
[delurk]

I find TraneWreck's arguments persuasive. And my opinion of lawyers just went up quite considerably.

And as an aside, I see we have a poster here from Torrance. Cool! Did you ever meet Buffy?

[relurk]

Rolfe.
 
Absolutely. But until they do, it's the town's problem. They either don't help where they can, which is remarkably helpless, or they do help to the extent that they can do so without incurring additional costs.
There you go again, claiming a fire department can expand its coverage, both in area and number of homes served, without incurring increased costs. It doesn't work that way.

Hopefully the in-towners will eventually wise up and just vote in a county-wide department.
The in-towners can't do a damn thing about it. Only the out-of-towners who wish to be served by the town fire department can. And the only way that can happen is via referendum. In the meantime, I see no reason in-towners should have to pay for the people who live out of town.
 
This does resemble that. You're asking the fire dept. to expand its coverage to more homes while providing no money with which to do so.
Yes, but not ten times as many homes--not anywhere near it. I do take into consideration relevant circumstances.

What makes you think they had "more capacity than [they] needed"?
Because it's very unlikely that they have exactly as much as they need. There are significant block costs involved in scaling up or down. It's not like you can buy 0.31 fire engines.

And if we're talking about one extra fire per year, I think they can handle it.
 
I don't remotely understand your arguments. He should have been fined. That would have taken care of it.

I enjoy how a number of people seem to think that letting the house burn was the only possible way to punish this guy for his poor choice.

You are right there is nothing that can be done about deadbeats why even try?
 
There you go again, claiming a fire department can expand its coverage, both in area and number of homes served, without incurring increased costs. It doesn't work that way.
I'm not claiming that. I'm saying that it's practical to charge off any marginal costs on a per-call basis.

The in-towners can't do a damn thing about it.
Erm, yes they can. They can call a referendum, vote for the right politicians, whatever, and they'll easily win. They have significantly greater numbers than the out-of-towners.

And the out-of-towners can't place obligations on the towns in any case. This is all strictly voluntary. It's just the kind of voluntary where if you don't do it, you're an *******.
 
Yes, but not ten times as many homes--not anywhere near it. I do take into consideration relevant circumstances.

Because it's very unlikely that they have exactly as much as they need. There are significant block costs involved in scaling up or down. It's not like you can buy 0.31 fire engines.

And if we're talking about one extra fire per year, I think they can handle it.
South Fulton has a population of just 2500, so almost any increase in the area and number of buildings they serve will be significant. We're not talking about a "metropolis" of 50,000 here.
 
Absolutely. But until they do, it's the town's problem. They either don't help where they can, which is remarkably heartless, or they do help to the extent that they can do so without incurring additional costs.

So it is always the towns problem as the county has no need to fix it as they have no problem.
No, they have the population to sustain their own department, and New York taxpayers would incur additional costs.

You seemed not to care about forcing additional costs onto this town. Why do you seem to take an issue when it might be you?
 
And the out-of-towners can't place obligations on the towns in any case. This is all strictly voluntary. It's just the kind of voluntary where if you don't do it, you're an *******.

That is exactly what is being done here. The simple answer is cut off all of them from fire coverage. Then it is simple and basic and not a problem anymore right?
 
South Fulton has a population of just 2500, so almost any increase in the area and number of buildings they serve will be significant. We're not talking about a "metropolis" of 50,000 here.
South Fulton had 1199 households (a more relevant measure) in 2008.

The total number of households not in a town is 4612. There's also one town, Woodland Mills, which doesn't appear to have a fire department. 122 households, assuming they don't contract with one of the other towns.

Considering that there are eight other fire department serving the county, one of them in a city four times larger than South Fulton (which presumably has more rural households surrounding it than other towns), I think we can safely assume that the additional number of households covered is relatively small.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom