He is outside the area it serves.
I was hoping to avoid this diversion with "(subscription or not)". He
is inside the area served; if they didn't serve that area, we wouldn't be talking about it. They just
charge for the service.
That is the problem there is no fire service for his area. They expanded their service area on a subscription basis.
This is like saying there's no cable service in my area because it's provided on a subscription basis. I.e., totally wrong.
And if it were 30 people would you do it then? How much will you personally spend to cover deadbeats?
I don't consider people who don't pay into a system where it would be
impractical for them to do so deadbeats. I think of them as people who might as well get a service, because it doesn't cost me anything, and charging them is a headache. Similarly, I don't care if the people who use the public library pay any taxes.
Whatevs.
This system is impractical. It demands that firefighters sit on their heels as homes burn to the ground. It has significant administrative costs. It's bound to incur liabilities. It gets you a huge amount of negative press every time you have to teach someone a lesson. I mean, does the phrase 'teach someone a lesson' even sound like something you want you civic leaders saying? It belongs in the mouth of a mob boss, not a councilman.
But I'll re-iterate here: this doesn't cost the taxpayers
anything. They
already pay for the fire department, and they charge off the marginal costs, $500 a pop. I can answer your question with "Zero dollars and zero cents," and I can
still coherently argue that coverage ought to be extended. A more relevant question would be "How many people who can be served without incurring additional costs for the fire department would you be willing to
deny service to
save a few bucks?" Answer: zero.