Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

I'd tend to believe his statement he made before he had the chance to sit down and think it over.

That's a fair point but what I first read was...

"I thought they'd come out and put it out, even if you hadn't paid your $75, but I was wrong," said Gene Cranick.

...which allows for both refusal and forgetfullness. To paraphrase Aasimov, never attribute to defiance, what can adequately be explained by simple negligence. I agree, though, that it's immaterial to the question of whether or not he was legally entitled to the service.
 
He is outside the area it serves.
I was hoping to avoid this diversion with "(subscription or not)". He is inside the area served; if they didn't serve that area, we wouldn't be talking about it. They just charge for the service.

That is the problem there is no fire service for his area. They expanded their service area on a subscription basis.
This is like saying there's no cable service in my area because it's provided on a subscription basis. I.e., totally wrong.

And if it were 30 people would you do it then? How much will you personally spend to cover deadbeats?
I don't consider people who don't pay into a system where it would be impractical for them to do so deadbeats. I think of them as people who might as well get a service, because it doesn't cost me anything, and charging them is a headache. Similarly, I don't care if the people who use the public library pay any taxes. Whatevs.

This system is impractical. It demands that firefighters sit on their heels as homes burn to the ground. It has significant administrative costs. It's bound to incur liabilities. It gets you a huge amount of negative press every time you have to teach someone a lesson. I mean, does the phrase 'teach someone a lesson' even sound like something you want you civic leaders saying? It belongs in the mouth of a mob boss, not a councilman.

But I'll re-iterate here: this doesn't cost the taxpayers anything. They already pay for the fire department, and they charge off the marginal costs, $500 a pop. I can answer your question with "Zero dollars and zero cents," and I can still coherently argue that coverage ought to be extended. A more relevant question would be "How many people who can be served without incurring additional costs for the fire department would you be willing to deny service to save a few bucks?" Answer: zero.
 
I was hoping to avoid this diversion with "(subscription or not)". He is inside the area served; if they didn't serve that area, we wouldn't be talking about it. They just charge for the service.


This is like saying there's no cable service in my area because it's provided on a subscription basis. I.e., totally wrong.

Ok, would you be complaining if the cable guy sat outside your house while you were missing your football game because you chose not to pay for the cable service?
 
1) The property in question is outside the service area.
False. See above.

2) The SFFD has no responsibility to fight any fire outside their service area
True. We're relying on their humanity here.

3) Therefore, the SFFD had no responsibility to risk their lives (and let's not lie to ourselves, any fire fighting risks life/limb) to service the property in question.
We're relying on their humanity here, too.

I mean, we're talking about human beings. If I can help some people out without incurring any costs at all, why on Earth would I not be willing to do this?

The only reason I can muster is strictly ideological.
 
Ok, would you be complaining if the cable guy sat outside your house while you were missing your football game because you chose not to pay for the cable service?
No. Watching a football game is a trivial interest. Preferring that my house not burn down, my pets no die horribly, my irreplaceables not be lost, is not.
 
I mean, we're talking about human beings. If I can help some people out without incurring any costs at all, why on Earth would I not be willing to do this?
But you are incurring costs. It costs more to equip a fire department to serve 10,000 buildingss than it does to equip one for 1,000 buildings.

You cannot expand your coverage area wiithout incurring more costs.
 
It's impractical for everyone basically, because most people's homes don't catch fire and you have a very high chance of not paying and never regretting it.
 
I think the policy of the South Fulton Fire Department, whether or not it was handed down by the mayor, was wrong. It was too inflexible. Mr. Cranick offered to pay whatever it cost to put out the fire when tallking to 911. South Fulton could have charged him a large amount to cover their actual and amortized (is this the right word?) costs, plus a penalty for not paying up front. Have standard promissory note forms in all fire trucks. Let people know how much more they would be charged if they didn't pay their $75. How would a large payment be a disincentive for others to pay their $75? Or they could bill the county for their actual costs and the homeowner $75 (let the lawyers duke it out).
Here's where your plan goes horribly wrong: The odds of any given house catching fire are 1000:1. Any potential fee would have to be in the tens of thousands of dollars to have a deterrent effect, in many cases this could esceed the cost of the house.

There seem to be several options available besides letting people's homes burn and pets die.
This guy had 2 hours to save his pets, he didn't lift a finger to do so. A real POS in my opinion.
 
How was the $75 fee "impractical" in this case?
Because emergency dispatchers shouldn't have to figure out if you're a subscriber or not before responding to a call, incurring liabilities well in excess of the money collected if they get it wrong.

Also, because in order to make this system work, you have to let the odd house burn down.
 
Because emergency dispatchers shouldn't have to figure out if you're a subscriber or not before responding to a call, incurring liabilities well in excess of the money collected if they get it wrong.

Also, because in order to make this system work, you have to let the odd house burn down.

Then the county should fix the system. It is not the towns job to fix the system.

How about say Yonkers forgoes fire departments and the like and just sponges off NYC, you would be cool with that right?
 
Of course if you had your way it would have been a smart decision. As long as I can pass the buck to someone else it is genius.

But who's decision was it? The home owners or the municipalities?

How many surrounding towns fire departments would you like to be taxed for?

I don't remotely understand your arguments. He should have been fined. That would have taken care of it.

I enjoy how a number of people seem to think that letting the house burn was the only possible way to punish this guy for his poor choice.
 
But you are incurring costs. It costs more to equip a fire department to serve 10,000 buildingss than it does to equip one for 1,000 buildings.
Oh, no doubt. Would you care to specify the relevance to this situation, which does not remotely resemble that?

You cannot expand your coverage area wiithout incurring more costs.
Sure you can, if you have more capacity than you need, and there's not way to scale down that capacity without compromising service to the taxpayers.

It's not like you can have one guy with a helmet and a plastic bucket and a tricycle and call it a fire department.
 
To be fair, you don't go back into a burning house once you're out.
He never went in. The fire started outside some barrels where he was burning something and took 2 hours before it reached his house. His life wouldn't have been in any jeopardy whatsoever. He just didn't give a damn.
 
He never went in. The fire started outside some barrels where he was burning something and took 2 hours before it reached his house. His life wouldn't have been in any jeopardy whatsoever. He just didn't give a damn.

Oh. Article was sparse on details.
 
Oh, no doubt. Would you care to specify the relevance to this situation, which does not remotely resemble that?
This does resemble that. You're asking the fire dept. to expand its coverage to more homes while providing no money with which to do so.

Sure you can, if you have more capacity than you need, and there's not way to scale down that capacity without compromising service to the taxpayers.

It's not like you can have one guy with a helmet and a plastic bucket and a tricycle and call it a fire department.
What makes you think they had "more capacity than [they] needed"?
 
He's not being punished TraneWreck, he's being denied a service he refused to pay for.

People with fire hoses stood by and watched the house burn because he didn't pay $75. They easily could have stopped the fire then corrected the monetary issue after the fact.

By your logic the government should pay to rebuild houses which burned down for those who didn't buy fire insurance, or pay car repairs for someone who didn't buy the extended warranty or collision insurance.

Huh? Sometimes stuff happens. This was a situation where people were available to remedy a problem but did not do so because of a trivial sum.

Your other examples aren't remotely analogous.

And I think the lesson learned here is far, far more valuable than this asshat's house. You can be sure everyone in that area is paying their $75 now.

These are the callous, self-involved emotions that are the hallmark of glibertarianism. It's a good thing it's such a marginalized ideology, though it inexplicably has been gaining traction of late.
 
Then the county should fix the system. It is not the towns job to fix the system.
Absolutely. But until they do, it's the town's problem. They either don't help where they can, which is remarkably heartless, or they do help to the extent that they can do so without incurring additional costs.

Hopefully the in-towners will eventually wise up and just vote in a county-wide department.

How about say Yonkers forgoes fire departments and the like and just sponges off NYC, you would be cool with that right?
No, they have the population to sustain their own department, and New York taxpayers would incur additional costs.

It would be helpful if the analogies and hypotheticals bore any resemblance to the situation under discussion.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom