Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

More information regarding the "refusal to pay" argument. Mr. Cranick's latest statements to the press indicate that he simply forgot to pay the service fee.

I'd tend to believe his statement he made before he had the chance to sit down and think it over.
 
I've been a volunteer firefighter my entire adult life and this sort of a thing is an anathema to every firefighter I've met over the years. We don't let politics get in the way of saving property (or lives). Doesn't matter if you in arrears paying your property taxes, are on welfare, abuse your spouse, have built your house on someone else's property, or are just passing through when your car/trailer catches fire. We'll respond and won't ever send a bill.

For years here in New England "Mutual Aid" was an accepted concept (Officially made legal by enabling legislation in Vermont in the mid 1960s). Our department automatically responds to a fire or emergency in the towns on either side of us without even being asked- They'll turn us back if they don't need us. The few residents who objected to seeing tax paid Town apparatus leaving for a neighboring town when this policy began were reminded that it was a two way street- When there was a fire in OUR town, particularly in the daytime when you might get only one or two local firefighters responding (sometimes none), it was nice to know two other departments were automatically responding with manpower and equipment.
Clearly this isn't the case in other areas. I remember reading about a house fire somewhere in California where the nearest, but wrong, fire department was called. The burning house was a hundred feet over the line in the next jurisdiction. The firefighters just sat and watched the house burn. And the neighbors were so incensed they threw rocks and bottles at the firetrucks doing significant damage.
I didn't join the fire service to be put in a situation where I was prevented from fighting a fire because someone didn't pay a fee.
 
It's not the man's decision that's at issue, it was obviously a foolish one. It's a question of we, as a nation, as a community, choose to behave towards one another.

Of course if you had your way it would have been a smart decision. As long as I can pass the buck to someone else it is genius.
 
We all know what happened, we all know why it happened. "It is what it is" is a worthless statement. We're discussing whether it was correct or justified or moral or proportional.

Whatever the laws said, whatever mistake that guy made, it was an absurd decision to let that house burn for lack of $75. You act like the behavior of the fire department was bound by a natural law beyond any criticism or scrutiny.

But who's decision was it? The home owners or the municipalities?

How many surrounding towns fire departments would you like to be taxed for?
 
The International Association of Fire Fighters issued a statement October 5, 2010, condemning the actions of the South Fulton fire department:
Washington, DC--International Association of Fire Fighters General President Harold Shaitberger today issued the following statement on the September 29 fire in Obion County, Tennessee:

"The decision by the South Fulton Fire Department to allow a family's home to burn to the ground was incredibly irresponsible. This tragic loss of property was completely avoidable. Because of South Fulton's pay-to-play policy, fire fighters were ordered to stand and watch a family lose its home.

"Everyone deserves fire protection because providing public safety is among a municipality's highest priorities.

"Instead, South Fulton wants to charge citizens outside the city for fire protection. We condemn South Fulton's ill-advised, unsafe policy. Professional, career fire fighters shouldn't be forced to check a list before running out the door to see which homeowners have paid up. They get in their trucks and go." iaff.org/comm/pdfs/southfulton.pdf
I was wondering what firefighters thought about all this. So at least I know what some of them think. I don't know who in this thread is a firefighter, so I don't know any other firefighter opinions outside Obion County.

According to Union City Fire Chief Kelly Edmison, also in Obion County, who does defend the firefighters in South Fulton,
<snip>
Obion County has entered into a letter of intent with all eight fire district municipalities, so all eight departments will soon respond to county residents through subscription service only. wpsdlocal6.com/news/local/More-fallout-following-house-fire-104113489.html
I'm not sure if this is a new thing or if it was already in place. If new, I guess the county didn't learn much from the incident, unless this is just a stopgap until a better solution is found.

I think the policy of the South Fulton Fire Department, whether or not it was handed down by the mayor, was wrong. It was too inflexible. Mr. Cranick offered to pay whatever it cost to put out the fire when tallking to 911. South Fulton could have charged him a large amount to cover their actual and amortized (is this the right word?) costs, plus a penalty for not paying up front. Have standard promissory note forms in all fire trucks. Let people know how much more they would be charged if they didn't pay their $75. How would a large payment be a disincentive for others to pay their $75? Or they could bill the county for their actual costs and the homeowner $75 (let the lawyers duke it out). There seem to be several options available besides letting people's homes burn and pets die.

I agree with TraneWreck that the "punishment" (especially if the owner really did "just forget to pay") is disproportionate. I also agree that there is an element of "good citizenship" in looking out for others, even if they are stupid.

I agree (maybe because I'm in Southern California) that you put out fires when you first spot them because you don't know the future, and fires can grow rapidly.
 
Who said anything about a proposed fee? Make the fee whatever you want. Not the cost required to put out the fire. Make it $5000 if need be. Whatever it takes so people have an option and the people performing the service can make a profit and have incentive to help.

Their salaries and the cost of running the dept is not based on these houses so them not getting the $75 is not going to put them out of business. But since they are not obligated to service those areas and do it for extra money, then they stand to make a lot more.

So you disagree with the principle that there is no such thing as a free lunch, clearly there is a lot of free lunches in the area.
 
Considering that I'm not served by their fire department, no.

So you are feeling very free spending other peoples money. But remarkably unwilling to put your money where your mouth is. How about this, if that was the case in your neighborhood would you pay $75 for each of your neighbors so they would be covered?
 
Oh gawd has this really spun wildly. Let me add my $.02 having been a volunteer firefighter and department treasurer in a small-town VFD in TX. While we apparently still don't know if the department in TN was paid, paid-on-call, volunteer, or mixed, that doesn't really matter. My former department (I now live back where I grew up again in So. Cal.) is a non-profit private VFD contracted by the city it resides in and also covers the outlying county area and mutual aid to other neighboring departments. This has been the relationship for 70+ years. The city paid us $20k per year to cover the city (1998-2000 when I was treasurer.) Outside of the city limits, we mailed out subscription request envelopes asking for $35 per year to about 400-500 rural homes in our corner of the surrounding county. The city population was around 4,000. I can't remember exactly the number of subscriptions, but it was somewhere around 15-20% would subscribe. What we explicitly stated on the subscription mailer is that we would always do our best to respond to any emergency and that if you did need our services and were not a subscriber, you would be billed for those services. We also informed them that anything we bill for should be submitted to one's insurance to reimburse for. We never shirked our responsibility as first responders because someone did not subscribe for service coverage. If we had to, we ate the cost which is subsidized by our income (yeah- the other subscribers, the city residents and occasional fund raisers). That's part of life. That was a small price to pay in order to be members of the community supporting public safety where we live and to participate in our social obligation for the greater good (which seems to be disappearing really quick in this "you first after me" society.) Had the department in question very publicly stated the fact of no subscription - no response, it guess it might be possible that they have some legal justification for not being liable (no, I'm not a lawyer), but I doubt it. In my opinion, I think that they bear some responsibility in the homeowner's loss for dereliction of duty at the scene of an emergency. Failure to act as an emergency response agency when there is no life safety consideration is pretty damning, in my opinion. It would be no different for an ambulance crew (public or private) while not on another call or hospital run passing by the scene of an accident and not rendering aid. Even when on a call, such an ambulance crew should and would try to call for help. Believe me on that since I was rear-ended when I stopped for an LAFD rescue ambulance on a call and they radioed in for my accident. I would expect a review with sanctions from the TN state agency that regulates and certifies emergency responders and agencies. I also figure that the homeowner, based on the failure to render aid by the responding department, would have grounds for a civil suit. Yeah, $75 is a small price to pay, but for the department in question to fail to act simply on the grounds that a county resident did not subscribe is horrible and, in my opinion, might be criminal. In my department, the subscription fee was used as a non-tax revenue source. You can go round-and-round about the $75 being "insurance" (that's B.S.) and whether-or-not that the county in which this happened should have a county response system with tax funding (probably a great idea), the fact-of-the-matter is that the department was toned out for a structure fire, arrived on scene, determined that the owner had not paid the $75 subscription, and his property was left to burn. If there are other facts that might alter that timeline, I certainly have not read any. This is not 100+ years ago where firefighting was a private protection racket! As first responders, based on what I have read, I figure that the duty to act was not fulfilled for a reason that did not involve life safety. Not good. That's what you get when it's all dollars and no sense and when people yell "no new taxes!". Believe me, I understand the responders' reluctance to help due to the cost of firefighting and possibly a ridiculous response protocol either self-imposed by the department or by the county, but come on! We did it on a shoestring budget in Bubbaville, but we still did our duty. We ALL need to step up, pay up, close loopholes, stop whining about not having enough of my fair share, and remember that yes - we all have a social obligation, and part of that means paying for government (and essential quasi-government services) or this is what happens. I understand that a few years ago my former department and several surrounding dept.'s formed an Emergency Services District and passed a vote to legally tax everyone and spread the burden. That makes a big difference. I feel that the need for a $75 subscription fee for an essential service is symptomatic of a larger problem in America. Here in CA it started with Proposition 13 and it's been all downhill since. Sorry for getting political, but it's an unfortunate fact. Anyway, the responding TN department, I feel, is going to find that the ice that it's standing on is cracking and that it will be legally underwater very soon.
 
So you are feeling very free spending other peoples money. But remarkably unwilling to put your money where your mouth is.
No, that's foolish: as I said, we're not discussing whether or not people outside the area the SFFD serves (subscription or not) should pay anything. You can't even frame your pathetic gotcha correctly.

How about this, if that was the case in your neighborhood would you pay $75 for each of your neighbors so they would be covered?
Considering that I live in New York, and that would come to ~$600,000,000, no. I don't have $600,000,000 to give.

But what is the point of this question? Where will you find a fire department relying on a tax base of one? What fundamental value are you trying to identify? I'm more than willing to pay into a system that covers an area that imperfectly overlaps with the taxed area. I'm forgiving of a little coloring outside the lines where it costs me nothing and brings security to my neighbors. I guess I'm pretty awesome that way? I'm sorry if it makes the baby Rand cry.
 
Once again, proportionality. It is not reasonable, not defensible, not even remotely sane to punish the crime of failing to pay a $75 fee with total destuction of a home.

Sometimes people behave stupidly, sometimes irresponsibly, levying a fine against the homeowner would not "reward irresponsible behavior," and would be in proportion to the offense.

How does letting the house be destroyed for want of $75 make any sense at all?



What are small town values then? Just letting someone suffer tremendously for the equivalent of a parking ticket?

This is ridiculous and absurd. Why don't we punish speeding by destroying someone's car? That would really teach people not to speed.

Shoplifters should have their hands cut off, people forgetting to pay parking tickets should have their pets killed, in a responsible society no one would do those things and we're just rewarding by behavior by allowing someone who rolled through a stop sign to get away with a $50 ticket.

There is a reason why proportionality exists in the law.
He's not being punished TraneWreck, he's being denied a service he refused to pay for.

By your logic the government should pay to rebuild houses which burned down for those who didn't buy fire insurance, or pay car repairs for someone who didn't buy the extended warranty or collision insurance.

And I think the lesson learned here is far, far more valuable than this asshat's house. You can be sure everyone in that area is paying their $75 now.
 
No, that's foolish: as I said, we're not discussing whether or not people outside the area the SFFD serves (subscription or not) should pay anything. You can't even frame your pathetic gotcha correctly.


Considering that I live in New York, and that would come to ~$600,000,000, no. I don't have $600,000,000 to give.

But what is the point of this question? Where will you find a fire department relying on a tax base of one? What fundamental value are you trying to identify? I'm more than willing to pay into a system that covers an area that imperfectly overlaps with the taxed area. I'm forgiving of a little coloring outside the lines where it costs me nothing and brings security to my neighbors. I guess I'm pretty awesome that way? I'm sorry if it makes the baby Rand cry.

Apparently, this particular homeowner lives outside the area SFFD serves...
 
No, that's foolish: as I said, we're not discussing whether or not people outside the area the SFFD serves (subscription or not) should pay anything. You can't even frame your pathetic gotcha correctly.

He is outside the area it serves. That is the problem there is no fire service for his area. They expanded their service area on a subscription basis.

Considering that I live in New York, and that would come to ~$600,000,000, no. I don't have $600,000,000 to give.

And if it were 30 people would you do it then? How much will you personally spend to cover deadbeats?
 
Oh gawd has this really spun wildly. Let me add my $.02 having been a volunteer firefighter and department treasurer in a small-town VFD in TX. While we apparently still don't know if the department in TN was paid, paid-on-call, volunteer, or mixed, that doesn't really matter. My former department (I now live back where I grew up again in So. Cal.) is a non-profit private VFD contracted by the city it resides in and also covers the outlying county area and mutual aid to other neighboring departments. This has been the relationship for 70+ years. The city paid us $20k per year to cover the city (1998-2000 when I was treasurer.) Outside of the city limits, we mailed out subscription request envelopes asking for $35 per year to about 400-500 rural homes in our corner of the surrounding county. The city population was around 4,000. I can't remember exactly the number of subscriptions, but it was somewhere around 15-20% would subscribe. What we explicitly stated on the subscription mailer is that we would always do our best to respond to any emergency and that if you did need our services and were not a subscriber, you would be billed for those services. We also informed them that anything we bill for should be submitted to one's insurance to reimburse for. We never shirked our responsibility as first responders because someone did not subscribe for service coverage. If we had to, we ate the cost which is subsidized by our income (yeah- the other subscribers, the city residents and occasional fund raisers). That's part of life. That was a small price to pay in order to be members of the community supporting public safety where we live and to participate in our social obligation for the greater good (which seems to be disappearing really quick in this "you first after me" society.) Had the department in question very publicly stated the fact of no subscription - no response, it guess it might be possible that they have some legal justification for not being liable (no, I'm not a lawyer), but I doubt it. In my opinion, I think that they bear some responsibility in the homeowner's loss for dereliction of duty at the scene of an emergency. Failure to act as an emergency response agency when there is no life safety consideration is pretty damning, in my opinion. It would be no different for an ambulance crew (public or private) while not on another call or hospital run passing by the scene of an accident and not rendering aid. Even when on a call, such an ambulance crew should and would try to call for help. Believe me on that since I was rear-ended when I stopped for an LAFD rescue ambulance on a call and they radioed in for my accident. I would expect a review with sanctions from the TN state agency that regulates and certifies emergency responders and agencies. I also figure that the homeowner, based on the failure to render aid by the responding department, would have grounds for a civil suit. Yeah, $75 is a small price to pay, but for the department in question to fail to act simply on the grounds that a county resident did not subscribe is horrible and, in my opinion, might be criminal. In my department, the subscription fee was used as a non-tax revenue source. You can go round-and-round about the $75 being "insurance" (that's B.S.) and whether-or-not that the county in which this happened should have a county response system with tax funding (probably a great idea), the fact-of-the-matter is that the department was toned out for a structure fire, arrived on scene, determined that the owner had not paid the $75 subscription, and his property was left to burn. If there are other facts that might alter that timeline, I certainly have not read any. This is not 100+ years ago where firefighting was a private protection racket! As first responders, based on what I have read, I figure that the duty to act was not fulfilled for a reason that did not involve life safety. Not good. That's what you get when it's all dollars and no sense and when people yell "no new taxes!". Believe me, I understand the responders' reluctance to help due to the cost of firefighting and possibly a ridiculous response protocol either self-imposed by the department or by the county, but come on! We did it on a shoestring budget in Bubbaville, but we still did our duty. We ALL need to step up, pay up, close loopholes, stop whining about not having enough of my fair share, and remember that yes - we all have a social obligation, and part of that means paying for government (and essential quasi-government services) or this is what happens. I understand that a few years ago my former department and several surrounding dept.'s formed an Emergency Services District and passed a vote to legally tax everyone and spread the burden. That makes a big difference. I feel that the need for a $75 subscription fee for an essential service is symptomatic of a larger problem in America. Here in CA it started with Proposition 13 and it's been all downhill since. Sorry for getting political, but it's an unfortunate fact. Anyway, the responding TN department, I feel, is going to find that the ice that it's standing on is cracking and that it will be legally underwater very soon.
I'm sorry, but I can't hear you through that wall of text.

See what happens when you hit the "enter" key once in a while while typing!
 
Maybe you can tell me the relevance of that?

Ok. I suppose I really need to spell this out for you in very simple terms:


1) The property in question is outside the service area
2) The SFFD has no responsibility to fight any fire outside their service area
3) Therefore, the SFFD had no responsibility to risk their lives (and let's not lie to ourselves, any fire fighting risks life/limb) to service the property in question.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom