Oh gawd has this really spun wildly. Let me add my $.02 having been a volunteer firefighter and department treasurer in a small-town VFD in TX. While we apparently still don't know if the department in TN was paid, paid-on-call, volunteer, or mixed, that doesn't really matter. My former department (I now live back where I grew up again in So. Cal.) is a non-profit private VFD contracted by the city it resides in and also covers the outlying county area and mutual aid to other neighboring departments. This has been the relationship for 70+ years. The city paid us $20k per year to cover the city (1998-2000 when I was treasurer.) Outside of the city limits, we mailed out subscription request envelopes asking for $35 per year to about 400-500 rural homes in our corner of the surrounding county. The city population was around 4,000. I can't remember exactly the number of subscriptions, but it was somewhere around 15-20% would subscribe. What we explicitly stated on the subscription mailer is that we would always do our best to respond to any emergency and that if you did need our services and were not a subscriber, you would be billed for those services. We also informed them that anything we bill for should be submitted to one's insurance to reimburse for. We never shirked our responsibility as first responders because someone did not subscribe for service coverage. If we had to, we ate the cost which is subsidized by our income (yeah- the other subscribers, the city residents and occasional fund raisers). That's part of life. That was a small price to pay in order to be members of the community supporting public safety where we live and to participate in our social obligation for the greater good (which seems to be disappearing really quick in this "you first after me" society.) Had the department in question very publicly stated the fact of no subscription - no response, it guess it might be possible that they have some legal justification for not being liable (no, I'm not a lawyer), but I doubt it. In my opinion, I think that they bear some responsibility in the homeowner's loss for dereliction of duty at the scene of an emergency. Failure to act as an emergency response agency when there is no life safety consideration is pretty damning, in my opinion. It would be no different for an ambulance crew (public or private) while not on another call or hospital run passing by the scene of an accident and not rendering aid. Even when on a call, such an ambulance crew should and would try to call for help. Believe me on that since I was rear-ended when I stopped for an LAFD rescue ambulance on a call and they radioed in for my accident. I would expect a review with sanctions from the TN state agency that regulates and certifies emergency responders and agencies. I also figure that the homeowner, based on the failure to render aid by the responding department, would have grounds for a civil suit. Yeah, $75 is a small price to pay, but for the department in question to fail to act simply on the grounds that a county resident did not subscribe is horrible and, in my opinion, might be criminal. In my department, the subscription fee was used as a non-tax revenue source. You can go round-and-round about the $75 being "insurance" (that's B.S.) and whether-or-not that the county in which this happened should have a county response system with tax funding (probably a great idea), the fact-of-the-matter is that the department was toned out for a structure fire, arrived on scene, determined that the owner had not paid the $75 subscription, and his property was left to burn. If there are other facts that might alter that timeline, I certainly have not read any. This is not 100+ years ago where firefighting was a private protection racket! As first responders, based on what I have read, I figure that the duty to act was not fulfilled for a reason that did not involve life safety. Not good. That's what you get when it's all dollars and no sense and when people yell "no new taxes!". Believe me, I understand the responders' reluctance to help due to the cost of firefighting and possibly a ridiculous response protocol either self-imposed by the department or by the county, but come on! We did it on a shoestring budget in Bubbaville, but we still did our duty. We ALL need to step up, pay up, close loopholes, stop whining about not having enough of my fair share, and remember that yes - we all have a social obligation, and part of that means paying for government (and essential quasi-government services) or this is what happens. I understand that a few years ago my former department and several surrounding dept.'s formed an Emergency Services District and passed a vote to legally tax everyone and spread the burden. That makes a big difference. I feel that the need for a $75 subscription fee for an essential service is symptomatic of a larger problem in America. Here in CA it started with Proposition 13 and it's been all downhill since. Sorry for getting political, but it's an unfortunate fact. Anyway, the responding TN department, I feel, is going to find that the ice that it's standing on is cracking and that it will be legally underwater very soon.