Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

People commiting crimes behave irresponsibly. In fact, it's often worse than that. Instead of merely being foolhardy, criminals often intentionally cause harm.

So my question is this: what sort of crime would one have to commit to justify the punishment of having their house burned down?

Theft? Burglary? Rape? Homicide?

How about shoplifting? Being in possession of alcohol under the age of 21?

People seem to be content to let this man's irresponsible behavior be punished with a destroyed home, what would someone have to do with malice to earn the same level of culpability?

The difference here is that this isn't a "punishment". No one set fire to his house because he didn't pay. But, houses burning down is a forseeable occurance. There is a preventative measure that can be taken- paying the $75. He chose to accept the forseeable risk of his house burning down because he didn't want to pay.

The equivilent scenario isn't "crime and punishment", it's someone sharing ditry needles and then whinging because the hospital won't treat his hepatitis for free.
 
Ok, let's recapitulate points made in this thread.

One family lost their house because:

1) county, town and fire station made a deal and do not give a **** about little guy. (as befits government, public authorities).

Personally I blame the state of California myself. Why bother limiting the blame to local municipalities that he was not a constituent of?
 
Why would "the vast majority are clearly going to choose the $75", or 6% of the proposed $1,250 fee, when the odds of actually having the house catch fire are far less than 1%?

I'd risk the $1,250, as would any rational person. If you disagree, stay away from the craps table. You'll be the guy tha's all over the sucker bets.

Who said anything about a proposed fee? Make the fee whatever you want. Not the cost required to put out the fire. Make it $5000 if need be. Whatever it takes so people have an option and the people performing the service can make a profit and have incentive to help.

Their salaries and the cost of running the dept is not based on these houses so them not getting the $75 is not going to put them out of business. But since they are not obligated to service those areas and do it for extra money, then they stand to make a lot more.

The current plan they get nothing.

The problem again is claiming that by them not getting their $75 that it's taking away from paying for the fire dept to exist. That's clearly not true. They are acting as a for hire service outside of the city. If they have to perform outside of the area that is paying taxes, then of course they should get compensated. Find a cost that acts like a fine that makes it more than worth it. Letting someone's house burn to the ground is beyond a reasonable consequence for simply forgetting to pay a $75 fee one time.

This is not craps.
 
Bad idea. Charging based on marginal costs creates a similar problem for first adopters. Essentially it penalizes people who look at the situation and say “this town needs a fire department” and rewards the ones who sit back and wait for others to get a fire department running and then ask to be part of it for lower marginal costs.
I don't think those groups closely correspond to political boundaries. It was apparently worthwhile for people in South Fulton to do this without consideration of outlying rural areas, and they presumably won't be willing to incur significant block costs (say, buying a new fire engine) to serve ever larger areas (there are still great swaths of the county not served by any fire department). It's a minor concession to practicality and introduces no perverse incentives worth worrying about. Sure, people in the semi-protected rural areas have an interest in the status quo, but the people in the population centers represent the great bulk of the population in the county. If they don't like it, there's nothing to stop them from voting for a new arrangement.
 
Last edited:
Congratulations, you just presumed 100% of the population is stupid and unable to recognise a good deal when they see one. Good job!

Naa, you just get a pool of people to donate to create a firefighter insurance pool. You save money and screw the firedepartment, a win win situation
 
Who said anything about a proposed fee? Make the fee whatever you want. Not the cost required to put out the fire. Make it $5000 if need be. Whatever it takes so people have an option and the people performing the service can make a profit and have incentive to help.

Their salaries and the cost of running the dept is not based on these houses so them not getting the $75 is not going to put them out of business. But since they are not obligated to service those areas and do it for extra money, then they stand to make a lot more.

The current plan they get nothing.

The problem again is claiming that by them not getting their $75 that it's taking away from paying for the fire dept to exist. That's clearly not true. They are acting as a for hire service outside of the city. If they have to perform outside of the area that is paying taxes, then of course they should get compensated. Find a cost that acts like a fine that makes it more than worth it. Letting someone's house burn to the ground is beyond a reasonable consequence for simply forgetting to pay a $75 fee one time.

This is not craps.

He didn't forget. He chose not to pay.
 
The system worked fine. Almost zero property damage to people buying into the system..

Banks must charge higher interest rates to cover their losses, insurance companies must charge higher insurance rates to cover their losses, taxpayers still needed to pay for a fire department to exist and be deployed, neighbours take a property value hit.
There was plenty of damage incurred to many other people.
If I have a false alarm at my house, the fire department comes and checks it out, and then on the drive back they see a real fire and put it out, I am still charged for the false alarm?.
You can be, yes.

The cost of the bankruptcy is paid regardless of whether you go bankrupt or not

You should parse this statement for sanity...

The value of the house is gone, when he declares bankruptcy this loss is passed onto the people he owes money to. This only happens if the house burns and he declares bankruptcy so it’s absurd to suggest “it’s paid for anyway”

YOu need to read the links. He is already being provided with insurance money.

Then he’s lucky and the loss is passed onto the insurance company instead. The loss of the house doesn’t vanish because there is insurance, it’s still gone and someone is still paying the bill.
 
You know what? I have No Freaking Idea.

All I know is that there are fire stations at convenient points, some (in the big cities) manned constantly by full-time crew, while others are served by locals who have other jobs, who are paid a retainer to train and be competent and to turn out PDQ whenever there is an incident.

I pay my taxes, but I never asked anyone which particular set of taxes funds that particular service. It's neither here nor there, because coverage is universal, country-wide.

(Though there was a big scandal last year when it turned out that every single retained firefighter in a particular town had gone off to the same football match many miles away - the town's team had got through to the final of a very prestigious tournament that should have been out of its league. As it happened, nothing happened. There was a lot of shuffling by fire service bosses saying that the team in the next town would have covered if necessary, honest mate.... Probably.)

Rolfe.

In towns like that it is entirely likely, mutual aid is very common. But this is a rather different situation as the county chose not to have some arrangement to provide fire coverage for the whole county. And parts of the county are not in a municipality that has coverage.

I am more familiar with the ambulance portion of it but then again the county I live in has a centralized dispatch system that all the towns are part of. And likely has little if any unincorporated areas.

Is this a screwed up situation? Sure, but it is the counties job to fix it, and honestly it might well take things like this to get the county to fix it.
 
Everyone is aware of the differences in fire danger in northwest Tennessee compared to California, Texas, and other more arid places, aren't you? And no, the area isn't in a drought.


If you think that fires only go out of control in geographically traditional locations then I believe you don't really understand the situation.

Oh, BTW. According to this U.S. Drought Map, as of Sept. 28, 2010, Obion County, TN was in a condition of moderate to severe drought.

So, yes, it is. Unless you have better data.

You do understand that drought isn't a condition which respects state lines and common preconceptions either, right?
 
What I can't understand why there wasn't some sort of fall-back plan for this situation already in place - an on-the-spot payment, a form for fees incurred, a huge fine. Perhaps there was at some point? A pay-as you go model that didn't work?

We’ve already seen the numbers. The fine would need to be large, quite possibly more then the house was worth to him.
 
Finally, some people getting idea I proposed. Ok, proposal's so far are:

1) Make the "fee" mandatory, aka part of tax, so no one can choose to do stupid thing and not pay.
or

Not going to happen. You will never get elected on a pledge of raising taxes in the county.
 
More information regarding the "refusal to pay" argument. Mr. Cranick's latest statements to the press indicate that he simply forgot to pay the service fee.

A man whose home burned down because he hadn't paid a $75 municipal fee said he had made a simple mistake and wasn't trying to take advantage of the system.

"I'm no freeloader, I've worked all my life for everything I've got," Gene Cranick of Obion County, Tennessee, told Keith Olbermann on MSNBC on Tuesday evening. "It happens to anybody, I don't care, you forget things and I did. I suffered the consequences for it." (MSNBC story)
 
I agree. The underlying issue would seem to be that the County refused to pay the City for firefighting while assuming the City would simply provide it's services in an emergency. The County bluffed, and the City called it.

Sucks to be the guy caught in the middle...but that's on him. It just as easily could have not been him, but someone else that refused to pay.


I'd like to learn more details. I feel like the city screwed up by trying to take half a loaf. They should have told the county that there wasn't going to be any service out of the city limits at all until it was a blanket coverage.

Again, if I were a betting man, I'd bet that there are more than a few city movers and shakers who live or own property in the county.
 
You're assuming every resident of the county is stupid. Most people realize it takes money to supply and man a fire station, and I bet most people would happily still voluntarily pay the $75 charge even if firefighters had to occasionally respond to a fire started by someone who hadn't bothered. Most people don't need to see somebody "taught a lesson" to understand how important it is to keep the fire dept. funded.

But the townies will pay for that. And how rural are you if you don't see the benefit in screwing over the townies?
 
That excuse doesn't fly with insurance companies either.

And neither does the old insurance company comparison. He isn't asking them to pay the cost of his home. He was asking them to simply put out the fire and he would pay them whatever they wanted.
 
You know what? I have No Freaking Idea.

All I know is that there are fire stations at convenient points, some (in the big cities) manned constantly by full-time crew, while others are served by locals who have other jobs, who are paid a retainer to train and be competent and to turn out PDQ whenever there is an incident.
<snip>

Rolfe.

And then there are those of us who do not receive a dime for our service. True, my department pays for any training I take, but I get no monetary compensation in the form of a pay check or even a tax break. I'm not complaining, mind you, I didn't volunteer for the pay. I volunteered so I could drive a firetruck. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom