Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

Look, that's the contract the homeowner agreed to. The City offered it's services, the Homeowner thought he could get by without. He's the libertarian who's now crying foul, not I.

Just because I realize there are consequences for one's decisions does not make me a libertarian. Just a student of life ;)

We all know what happened, we all know why it happened. "It is what it is" is a worthless statement. We're discussing whether it was correct or justified or moral or proportional.

Whatever the laws said, whatever mistake that guy made, it was an absurd decision to let that house burn for lack of $75. You act like the behavior of the fire department was bound by a natural law beyond any criticism or scrutiny.
 
Last edited:
We all know what happened, we all know why it happened. "It is what it is" is a worthless statement. We're discussing whether it was correct or justified or moral or proportional.

Whatever the laws said, whatever mistake that guy made, it was an absurd decision to let that house burn for lack of $75. You act like the behavior of the fire department was bound by a natural law beyond any criticism or scrutiny.

Have I not already, many times, stated that I believe the system in that County is screwed up?

For ****s sake, man, read my posts.
 
I understand the system. If the fire dept. was expected to provide service for a larger area, they would need extra equipment and more full-time employees. The city budget may not have allowed for that. This system was the alternative. After a certain number of people pay the addition $75, additional equipment and employees are added. So far, so good.

What I can't understand why there wasn't some sort of fall-back plan for this situation already in place - an on-the-spot payment, a form for fees incurred, a huge fine. Perhaps there was at some point? A pay-as you go model that didn't work?
 
It's not the man's decision that's at issue, it was obviously a foolish one. It's a question of we, as a nation, as a community, choose to behave towards one another.
I choose not to reward irresponsible behavior, nor eliminate the consequences of such behavior, under the reasoning that that will just encourage more irresponsible behavior.

This was a trivial amount of money punished to an absurd extent. The means of saving the house were available, countless proportional punishments were available, yet people are actually defending this decision.
Because people don't like to reward irresponsible behavior. He's not a small child, he's a grown man with no mental health issues I'm aware of.

We are judged by how we treat the least among us. This fellow was clearly lacking in the smarts, that's his problem, but the people in that county showed themselves to be true villians. Are these those "small town values" I hear so much about? Those halcyon days of community where people looked out for one another? The Real Americans?
This has nothing to do with small town values, and everything to so with refusing to reward irresponsible behavior. Once again, this is not a child or mental incompetent we're talking about.

I prefer my urban nightmare where tax dollars pay for services that help out people who aren't necessarily me.
Which has nothing at all to do with this issue. Was someone arguing that only one person should get the services of the fire department?
 
Have I not already, many times, stated that I believe the system in that County is screwed up?

For ****s sake, man, read my posts.

Where does it imply that I think otherwise?

You're not agreeing with it, but you're behaving as though once the $75 fee was established as law, then the only available remedy was to allow non-payers to have their home consumed by fire.

This is absurd. There are many ways to deal with that minor problem that fall short of consigning a residence to the flames.
 
I understand the system. If the fire dept. was expected to provide service for a larger area, they would need extra equipment and more full-time employees. The city budget may not have allowed for that. This system was the alternative. After a certain number of people pay the addition $75, additional equipment and employees are added. So far, so good.

What I can't understand why there wasn't some sort of fall-back plan for this situation already in place - an on-the-spot payment, a form for fees incurred, a huge fine. Perhaps there was at some point? A pay-as you go model that didn't work?
If I had to guess, there's probably a turf war between the town and the county that is not obvious to an outsider. Since none of us here are locals, we cannot know what transpired to get them to that point, but I'm willing to bet a quarter that there's bad blood between the county and the town over this issue.
 
Having been part of my fair share of controlled burns, this is very true. We're also jeeped up on adrenaline and caffeine (as we generally start pretty early and no one goes to bed at a reasonable time the night before ;)) but we're also respectful of the fire.
Everyone is aware of the differences in fire danger in northwest Tennessee compared to California, Texas, and other more arid places, aren't you? And no, the area isn't in a drought.
 
Everyone is aware of the differences in fire danger in northwest Tennessee compared to California, Texas, and other more arid places, aren't you? And no, the area isn't in a drought.
Which may be why it took 2 hours to get to the trailer, rather than 2 minutes.

Speaking of which, once the fire got to the guy's trailer, it was a gonner. Those things go so fast, it's really amazing to watch.
 
I choose not to reward irresponsible behavior, nor eliminate the consequences of such behavior, under the reasoning that that will just encourage more irresponsible behavior.

Because people don't like to reward irresponsible behavior. He's not a small child, he's a grown man with no mental health issues I'm aware of.

Once again, proportionality. It is not reasonable, not defensible, not even remotely sane to punish the crime of failing to pay a $75 fee with total destuction of a home.

Sometimes people behave stupidly, sometimes irresponsibly, levying a fine against the homeowner would not "reward irresponsible behavior," and would be in proportion to the offense.

How does letting the house be destroyed for want of $75 make any sense at all?

This has nothing to do with small town values, and everything to so with refusing to reward irresponsible behavior. Once again, this is not a child or mental incompetent we're talking about.

What are small town values then? Just letting someone suffer tremendously for the equivalent of a parking ticket?

This is ridiculous and absurd. Why don't we punish speeding by destroying someone's car? That would really teach people not to speed.

Shoplifters should have their hands cut off, people forgetting to pay parking tickets should have their pets killed, in a responsible society no one would do those things and we're just rewarding by behavior by allowing someone who rolled through a stop sign to get away with a $50 ticket.

There is a reason why proportionality exists in the law.
 
If I had to guess, there's probably a turf war between the town and the county that is not obvious to an outsider. Since none of us here are locals, we cannot know what transpired to get them to that point, but I'm willing to bet a quarter that there's bad blood between the county and the town over this issue.

I agree. The underlying issue would seem to be that the County refused to pay the City for firefighting while assuming the City would simply provide it's services in an emergency. The County bluffed, and the City called it.

Sucks to be the guy caught in the middle...but that's on him. It just as easily could have not been him, but someone else that refused to pay.
 
Once again, proportionality. It is not reasonable, not defensible, not even remotely sane to punish the crime of failing to pay a $75 fee with total destuction of a home.

Sometimes people behave stupidly, sometimes irresponsibly, levying a fine against the homeowner would not "reward irresponsible behavior," and would be in proportion to the offense.

How does letting the house be destroyed for want of $75 make any sense at all?



What are small town values then? Just letting someone suffer tremendously for the equivalent of a parking ticket?

This is ridiculous and absurd. Why don't we punish speeding by destroying someone's car? That would really teach people not to speed.

Shoplifters should have their hands cut off, people forgetting to pay parking tickets should have their pets killed, in a responsible society no one would do those things and we're just rewarding by behavior by allowing someone who rolled through a stop sign to get away with a $50 ticket.

There is a reason why proportionality exists in the law.
Parking tickets are $75 in Chicago now? Glad I left then. I just got one here in Iowa and it's $7.50, that seems outrageous.
 
I choose not to reward irresponsible behavior, nor eliminate the consequences of such behavior, under the reasoning that that will just encourage more irresponsible behavior.
Letting someone's house burn to the ground is irresponsible behavior.

I choose not to reward it.
 
This is just not an accurate description of the law.

If your neighbor hires someone to paint his house and they paint yours by mistake, you can still be charged for the service, especially if you were aware they were working and didn't make them stop. This guys was watching his house burn and begging the firefighters to douse the flames.

This is just true under basic contract law. It's the concept of unjust enrichment. When dealing with government services, the legal history is even more firmly against your claim.

There would be no legal basis for this man to argue against any fee levied against him. The firefighters can quite easily argue that the fire needed to be extinguished to protect others in the area, and based on how the county pays for fire services, he should receive such a fine.

I didn't sign anything declaring that seat belt laws apply to me, but I can still receive a ticket.

But the problem is you are talking about utopian law. A law in which no one lies, and the facts are always obvious.

In the real world, people are very willing to ask for help, then deny they asked for help. Sure there is no legal basis for him to make the claim, but as a judge, do you know what was said at the time? If nothing is signed can you even prove that the man asked?

The problem is this guy could easily make a case that he didn't agree to the fee, and as we can see he is the type of person who will say anything ( i didn't know not paying a fee would result in no service.) to get out of consequences. It doesn't matter what he said, it matters what the fire department can prove, and in this case, they wouldn't have been able to prove jack.

And on top of that, there is the entire issue of the firefighters having to take time out of their day to be in court. So this is more time wasted on this guy that could have been spent , you know, fighting fires.

So the choices are

A) Put out the fire for the man who didn't pay without any proof that he asked. Or if a contract is somehow signed, him able to make a very good case for being under duress. This would lead to court time for the firefighters and all appropriate personal, not to mention a paying customer could be lacking attention due to them putting out this man's fire.

B) Make sure no one is dying/hurt and leave this man to the fate he chose ( from a financial standpoint). This leads to no taking time to go to court, and even if the man does attempt to sue, it is a very open and shut case. With the fact that he did not pay for a service as the key piece of evidence.

If we lived in a perfect world, i would say your right. But we live in a world full of people willing to say anything when it is their checkbook on the line. And to bring it back to this specific case, a man who has already shown when his actions cause him monetary damage, a tendency to flat out lie.

And this is all above and beyond another major issue with the " pay after the fire" line of logic.

Let's say the fire department charges him 400 grand. What choice does the man have? Would you want to see that bill in a month, not knowing it was coming? If this guy wasn't an a-hole, this raises all kinds of questions about the nature of fire service, and the simple fact that you cannot charge someone a fee for a service without consent prior to the service.

There is no way in which the " pay after the fire" setup works better than the current, pay or get marshmallows set up. In a perfect world, maybe, but not in the one we are currently living in.
 
People commiting crimes behave irresponsibly. In fact, it's often worse than that. Instead of merely being foolhardy, criminals often intentionally cause harm.

So my question is this: what sort of crime would one have to commit to justify the punishment of having their house burned down?

Theft? Burglary? Rape? Homicide?

How about shoplifting? Being in possession of alcohol under the age of 21?

People seem to be content to let this man's irresponsible behavior be punished with a destroyed home, what would someone have to do with malice to earn the same level of culpability?
 
If he had skipped the previous 9 years and just paid $75, his house would have been saved. Thus, for lack of $75 it was allowed to burn.

But interestingly, we're arriving at the problem that made the individual mandate necessary in health care reform: without punishment, there's no incentive to purchase the service before its needed. This leaves the service radically underfunded and unable to deal with emergencies.

This program is really stupid. Funding fire departments with tax dollars is a much wiser policy, but given the situation as presented, it was absurd to let that house burn for an unpaid $75.

The South Fulton fire department is funded with TaX Dollars. The guy in question's home is not in South Fulton. If you live in the county out side the city,,you have to pay 75 bucks because you are NOT taxed for support of the fire department. I agree it is a screwed up situation (looks as if the county is trying to get fire protection for free) but not quite as simple as you make it out to be. Instead you see to ignore the legal jusidicitonal problems involved.
 
If that's the case he's even more stupid than he first appeared.


I don't think that there has been much disagreement that under the circumstances of his situation he should have paid the money. I don't even think that many people in this thread would disagree with the characterization of "stupid". I certainly don't. The thing is, the whole incident was an inevitable consequence of the system which was put into place. There's a wealth of "stupid" out there. Half the people in the country are below average, and 'average' isn't all that special to begin with. It was only a matter of time before they ran into a "stupid" one.

I believe that the main controversy within this discussion is whether or not that system is an appropriate one. The entire arrangement reeks of political expediency and "gotcha" ideologues. The rather thinly veiled exultation in this thread that this guy 'got what he deserves' seems to be overwhelming some people's ability to contemplate the rational solutions to the basic problem. If you have a world view which rejects the idea that communities may occasionally need to work in concert for the common good, then you can find yourself in predicaments like this.

The idea of subscription services for fire protection is not a new one. It is also one that has been proven to be flawed ... over and over again. That's why it's so rare these days. Ultimately it doesn't work to the general benefit of the community.

The only real question is how much damage needs to be done before they figure that out. Maybe this time will be enough. Maybe it'll take a wind shift towards a county commissioner's house when the next stupid guy's house goes up.
 
Once again, proportionality. It is not reasonable, not defensible, not even remotely sane to punish the crime of failing to pay a $75 fee with total destuction of a home.

Sometimes people behave stupidly, sometimes irresponsibly, levying a fine against the homeowner would not "reward irresponsible behavior," and would be in proportion to the offense.

How does letting the house be destroyed for want of $75 make any sense at all?
People do it all the time with their insurance. They don't get it, don't get enough coverage, or let it lapse. They kiss a $30k car goodbye because they didn't want to pay the $100 monthly premium before wrecking it. The insurance company has the resources to handle their claim regardless of if they pay, but does that obligate the company to? Should the company pay the poor, sweet single mother's medical bills regardless of whether the uninsured driver that hit her forgot to pay his bill? After all, why should she bear the cost?

This is ridiculous and absurd. Why don't we punish speeding by destroying someone's car? That would really teach people not to speed.
Unless the fire department set the fire because he didn't pay, that isn't an equivlent situation.
 
I don't. Did you see the part where I said we should charge them for the marginal costs? That strongly implies that I think there are marginal costs.

Bad idea. Charging based on marginal costs creates a similar problem for first adopters. Essentially it penalizes people who look at the situation and say “this town needs a fire department” and rewards the ones who sit back and wait for others to get a fire department running and then ask to be part of it for lower marginal costs.
 
But the problem is you are talking about utopian law. A law in which no one lies, and the facts are always obvious.

[...]

There is no way in which the " pay after the fire" setup works better than the current, pay or get marshmallows set up. In a perfect world, maybe, but not in the one we are currently living in.

I would recommend spending a few hours in a municipal court. You use the phrase "real world" quite a few times, yet your post displayed one of the most fantastic, unrealistic understandings of a courtroom I've read.

Everything you said applies equally to traffic tickets. Yet someone they're dealt with. Must be magic.

Any responsible attorney would tell that man, "You're going to spend a miniumum of $500 paying me to try and get you out of a $250 fine. Waste of money."

He will go to court, have a few minutes to plead his case, someone from the fire department will be there with his report, the judge will spend .03sec considering the complaint and enter judgment, then tell him to leave so he can deal with the next case on the docket.

There will not be a dramatic Law and Order opening statements or witnesses called to the stand powerful confrontations. These are all figments of your imagination.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom