This is just not an accurate description of the law.
If your neighbor hires someone to paint his house and they paint yours by mistake, you can still be charged for the service, especially if you were aware they were working and didn't make them stop. This guys was watching his house burn and begging the firefighters to douse the flames.
This is just true under basic contract law. It's the concept of unjust enrichment. When dealing with government services, the legal history is even more firmly against your claim.
There would be no legal basis for this man to argue against any fee levied against him. The firefighters can quite easily argue that the fire needed to be extinguished to protect others in the area, and based on how the county pays for fire services, he should receive such a fine.
I didn't sign anything declaring that seat belt laws apply to me, but I can still receive a ticket.
But the problem is you are talking about utopian law. A law in which no one lies, and the facts are always obvious.
In the real world, people are very willing to ask for help, then deny they asked for help. Sure there is no legal basis for him to make the claim, but as a judge, do you know what was said at the time? If nothing is signed can you even prove that the man asked?
The problem is this guy could easily make a case that he didn't agree to the fee, and as we can see he is the type of person who will say anything ( i didn't know not paying a fee would result in no service.) to get out of consequences. It doesn't matter what he said, it matters what the fire department can prove, and in this case, they wouldn't have been able to prove jack.
And on top of that, there is the entire issue of the firefighters having to take time out of their day to be in court. So this is more time wasted on this guy that could have been spent , you know, fighting fires.
So the choices are
A) Put out the fire for the man who didn't pay without any proof that he asked. Or if a contract is somehow signed, him able to make a very good case for being under duress. This would lead to court time for the firefighters and all appropriate personal, not to mention a paying customer could be lacking attention due to them putting out this man's fire.
B) Make sure no one is dying/hurt and leave this man to the fate he chose ( from a financial standpoint). This leads to no taking time to go to court, and even if the man does attempt to sue, it is a very open and shut case. With the fact that he did not pay for a service as the key piece of evidence.
If we lived in a perfect world, i would say your right. But we live in a world full of people willing to say anything when it is their checkbook on the line. And to bring it back to this specific case, a man who has already shown when his actions cause him monetary damage, a tendency to flat out lie.
And this is all above and beyond another major issue with the " pay after the fire" line of logic.
Let's say the fire department charges him 400 grand. What choice does the man have? Would you want to see that bill in a month, not knowing it was coming? If this guy wasn't an a-hole, this raises all kinds of questions about the nature of fire service, and the simple fact that you cannot charge someone a fee for a service without consent prior to the service.
There is no way in which the " pay after the fire" setup works better than the current, pay or get marshmallows set up. In a perfect world, maybe, but not in the one we are currently living in.