Ummm... first of all, if you look at my original post, you'll see that I've already addressed the issue of private lawyers when I pointed out that municipal lawyers are probably still highly paid.
[...]
Of course, you're also assuming that the case would be handled by regular salaried lawyers. Here in Ottawa the city still occasionally hires outside law firms despite having its own legal department. (Probably wouldn't happen in that case, but it can't be totally discounted.)
Those attorneys will be paid the same amount whether that case is litigated or not, thus the cost to the municipality is zero. It might be a cost to the attorneys, working more hours for the same amount of pay, but the taxpayers won't suffer.
The case, were it argued, is no different (and probably simpler) than endless DUIs, batteries, MIPs, Speeding Tickets, and other nonsense that gets dealt with on a regular basis. It's also highly unlikely that any attorney would actually take this guy's case as the amount it would cost to hire a lawyer would be greater than the amount in controversy. He might show up at court, say he shouldn't pay (like people do when they run a stop sign), the judge would say, "Sorry, you owe $200." End of story.
I think you guys watch too many lawyer dramas, or something, you have a bizarrely unrealistic understanding of the day to day affairs of a municipal court.
I can see 2 reasons to administer a fine:
1) as a form of deterrence
2) to pay for actual physical damages (e.g. salaries, public property, etc.)
You seem to be suggesting the fines would be extremely low (since you are suggesting the total would be under $500). This does very little for either of those purposes.
No, I'm suggesting that being delinquent on a $75 fee is not sufficient cause to allow someone's house to burn down. As incentive to get people to pay ahead of time, a fine attached to after-the-fact firefighting would be adequate. If it goes to court, the minor court costs and administrative fees should be added on.
After doing some research, there are federal laws allowing an exemption of roughly $20,000 on a principal residence, plus and additional ~$10,000 on furniture and other possessions. And I did find other states that higher exemptions. (Oklahoma for one.) So, its certainly not unreasonable to assume the individual who has his house saved can still live in his place even after declaring bankruptcy.
Oh crap, that means if they had controlled the fire, there is an insanely remote chance that this guy could declare bankruptcy and avoid paying a $200 ticket. This is definitely a reason to let his house burn down.
Perfectly proportional.
Nope. We recognize that:
1) Hitting the person with a "low fine" would be worthless. In fact, it might be detrimental, since it might encourage others to likewise stop paying their fees with the expectation that they can just pay "when needed"
2) Hitting a person with a fine closer to the true cost of fighting the fire might result in the individual declaring bankruptcy, and thus causing the city to loose out on the cost of fighting the fire
If you're trying to figure out a way to salvage this retarded system, then yes, you're going to have problems. Just make it like licensing a vehicle and the problem is solved. Obviously taxes are the easiest, but paying $6 a month to the Gubmit is clearly out of the question.
You can dance all you want, but these idiots allowed a man's house to burn down, his pets to die, irreplaceable items to be destroyed, for $75. I'm honestly surprised anyone is really trying to defend it.