Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

What difference does that make? Most of the condemnation of this guy is about his failure to pay insurance. That is all about precautions for the potential of an occurrence. There was every potential for this particular fire to get out of control, even if it didn't in this particular instance.

No, there is no condemnation on that point, afterall, he was free to make a choice. Some people think he was stupid to risk his house by choosing not to paying $75 though.

The only condemnation I hear is for the firefighters and department that followed the established policy, the one the homeowner was fully aware of.

If it had gotten out of control there would be good reason to argue that the firemen had failed in their obligation to the subscribers in the area, by not extinguishing the first fire before it became too much for them.

Firefighters were standing by to make sure that didn't happen and, in fact, were required to respond promptly and did when the fire crossed onto someone else's property. Fires are often left to burn if they are naturally contained.

Imagine that case in a courtroom. There is a fire prevention professional on the stand, and he is asked exactly what point in time should the firefighters on the scene have decided that the first fire became a risk to others.

Why would there be a trial, there was no negligence involved?

What do you suppose he is going to say? My guess is, "When they saw the first fire."

My guess is he would easily be able to say, "As soon as the neighbours property was threatened."

This guy has no basis for any lawsuit. He will lose and have to pay legal costs but maybe that's what it will take to get the county to address their problem.
 
Ultimately, this is not the fault of the South Fulton FD, but of the people of the unicorporated areas of the county who either voted for this asenine system or elected the people who then voted for it.

It's going . . . going . . . . . . . going . . . . . . . . . HOME RUN!
 
What about doctors, then? Are they obligated to treat every ailment for free, no matter how minor? Because that cough might be a symptom of cancer. Why didn't you check for that, doctor, before letting it spread and the patient die?!


What about doctors? Go ahead and explain how you think there is an analogy.

If an ambulance responds to a two-car accident and one of the victims is just passing through town, do you think they should only treat the locals?

How's that for a doctor analogy?
 
given the fact that lawyers typically charge hundreds of dollars per hour, trying to get him to pay by bringing him in front of a judge will rapidly increase the cost to the city, possibly throwing good money after bad. (And even if the municipal lawyers are not receiving hourly salaries, they are still probably quite highly paid.)
Speaking as a lawyer, this is 100% ********. The city isn't going to hire a private attorney, they'll use their salaried counsel. It's a simple, straightforward case and little if any time would be wated.
Ummm... first of all, if you look at my original post, you'll see that I've already addressed the issue of private lawyers when I pointed out that municipal lawyers are probably still highly paid.

Not sure what the salaries are down there, but here in Canada government lawyers earn around $60-100k/year (plus benefits). So, even if they spent half a day on the case, they'd still be adding around $200-300 to the total bill. (given the number of work days in the year, etc.) And that's assuming the individual did nothing to challenge the fine. If he did, they'd probably need multiple days in court, plus they'd have to bring in firemen to testify, etc.

Of course, you're also assuming that the case would be handled by regular salaried lawyers. Here in Ottawa the city still occasionally hires outside law firms despite having its own legal department. (Probably wouldn't happen in that case, but it can't be totally discounted.)

You guys are hilariously creating imaginary legal systems to try and make a fine seem impossibly difficult. There's already a structure in place to deal with such things and it could be administered with ease.
I can see 2 reasons to administer a fine:
1) as a form of deterrence
2) to pay for actual physical damages (e.g. salaries, public property, etc.)
You seem to be suggesting the fines would be extremely low (since you are suggesting the total would be under $500). This does very little for either of those purposes.

And yes, this is a stupid, foolish way to finance a fire-department, but punishing one man with the total destuction of his home for lack of a $75 fee is just absurd.

Not sure how things are down in the U.S., but here in Canada, when you declare bankruptcy your principal residence is except from the proceedings. I suspect similar rules are in place in the U.S.
Depends on the state. The only one I know of with that policy is Florida, which is why a lot of Wall Street folks invest in property down there...
After doing some research, there are federal laws allowing an exemption of roughly $20,000 on a principal residence, plus and additional ~$10,000 on furniture and other possessions. And I did find other states that higher exemptions. (Oklahoma for one.) So, its certainly not unreasonable to assume the individual who has his house saved can still live in his place even after declaring bankruptcy.

It's just amusing that everyone is pretending like hitting this guy with a couple hundred dollar fine would be so onerous that it justifies letting his house burn down:
Nope. We recognize that:
1) Hitting the person with a "low fine" would be worthless. In fact, it might be detrimental, since it might encourage others to likewise stop paying their fees with the expectation that they can just pay "when needed"
2) Hitting a person with a fine closer to the true cost of fighting the fire might result in the individual declaring bankruptcy, and thus causing the city to loose out on the cost of fighting the fire
 
No, there is no condemnation on that point, afterall, he was free to make a choice. Some people think he was stupid to risk his house by choosing not to paying $75 though.

The only condemnation I hear is for the firefighters and department that followed the established policy, the one the homeowner was fully aware of.


Either you've been reading an entirely different thread than I have, or you have some strangely selective visual impairment which only permits you to see what you want to see, or you are prevaricating.

I'm guessing the latter, since saying, "Some people think he was stupid to risk his house by choosing not to paying $75..." is exactly the same thing.

I've read very few comments condemning the firefighters themselves. Mostly acknowledgments that they were doing what they were told. There has been condemnation that they were told to behave that way. Perhaps the distinction is confusing you.

Firefighters were standing by to make sure that didn't happen and, in fact, were required to respond promptly and did when the fire crossed onto someone else's property. Fires are often left to burn if they are naturally contained.



Why would there be a trial, there was no negligence involved?


If a subscriber's house had caught fire I guarantee you someone would have been looking for negligence.

My guess is he would easily be able to say, "As soon as the neighbours property was threatened."


Are you pretending to be ignorant of basic elements of risk assessment, or are you really that clueless.

Fires can get out of control. That is, in fact, the meaning of "out of control". When "controlled burns" are employed, for whatever reason, no one is more nervous than the firefighters.

When there is no reason to actually encourage a burn, the safest time to extinguish it is as soon as you see it. Everything past that point increases risk.

Do you really think that a professional would testify under oath, "Oh, they were fine watching it burn until the wind suddenly shifted and started gusting at 25 knots. That wasn't their fault."

Is that what you'd think if the house that was suddenly downwind was yours?

This guy has no basis for any lawsuit. He will lose and have to pay legal costs but maybe that's what it will take to get the county to address their problem.


I wasn't talking about a lawsuit from "this guy". Maybe you should be posting in whatever thread you're reading, instead of this one.
 
Ummm... first of all, if you look at my original post, you'll see that I've already addressed the issue of private lawyers when I pointed out that municipal lawyers are probably still highly paid.

[...]

Of course, you're also assuming that the case would be handled by regular salaried lawyers. Here in Ottawa the city still occasionally hires outside law firms despite having its own legal department. (Probably wouldn't happen in that case, but it can't be totally discounted.)

Those attorneys will be paid the same amount whether that case is litigated or not, thus the cost to the municipality is zero. It might be a cost to the attorneys, working more hours for the same amount of pay, but the taxpayers won't suffer.

The case, were it argued, is no different (and probably simpler) than endless DUIs, batteries, MIPs, Speeding Tickets, and other nonsense that gets dealt with on a regular basis. It's also highly unlikely that any attorney would actually take this guy's case as the amount it would cost to hire a lawyer would be greater than the amount in controversy. He might show up at court, say he shouldn't pay (like people do when they run a stop sign), the judge would say, "Sorry, you owe $200." End of story.

I think you guys watch too many lawyer dramas, or something, you have a bizarrely unrealistic understanding of the day to day affairs of a municipal court.


I can see 2 reasons to administer a fine:
1) as a form of deterrence
2) to pay for actual physical damages (e.g. salaries, public property, etc.)
You seem to be suggesting the fines would be extremely low (since you are suggesting the total would be under $500). This does very little for either of those purposes.

No, I'm suggesting that being delinquent on a $75 fee is not sufficient cause to allow someone's house to burn down. As incentive to get people to pay ahead of time, a fine attached to after-the-fact firefighting would be adequate. If it goes to court, the minor court costs and administrative fees should be added on.

After doing some research, there are federal laws allowing an exemption of roughly $20,000 on a principal residence, plus and additional ~$10,000 on furniture and other possessions. And I did find other states that higher exemptions. (Oklahoma for one.) So, its certainly not unreasonable to assume the individual who has his house saved can still live in his place even after declaring bankruptcy.

Oh crap, that means if they had controlled the fire, there is an insanely remote chance that this guy could declare bankruptcy and avoid paying a $200 ticket. This is definitely a reason to let his house burn down.

Perfectly proportional.

Nope. We recognize that:
1) Hitting the person with a "low fine" would be worthless. In fact, it might be detrimental, since it might encourage others to likewise stop paying their fees with the expectation that they can just pay "when needed"
2) Hitting a person with a fine closer to the true cost of fighting the fire might result in the individual declaring bankruptcy, and thus causing the city to loose out on the cost of fighting the fire

If you're trying to figure out a way to salvage this retarded system, then yes, you're going to have problems. Just make it like licensing a vehicle and the problem is solved. Obviously taxes are the easiest, but paying $6 a month to the Gubmit is clearly out of the question.

You can dance all you want, but these idiots allowed a man's house to burn down, his pets to die, irreplaceable items to be destroyed, for $75. I'm honestly surprised anyone is really trying to defend it.
 
...snip...
You can dance all you want, but these idiots allowed a man's house to burn down, his pets to die, irreplaceable items to be destroyed, for $75. I'm honestly surprised anyone is really trying to defend it.

Let me fix that for you:


"You can dance all you want, but this idiot allowed his house to burn down, his pets to die, irreplaceable items to be destroyed, for $75. I'm honestly surprised anyone is really trying to defend it."
 
Let me fix that for you:


"You can dance all you want, but this idiot allowed his house to burn down, his pets to die, irreplaceable items to be destroyed, for $75. I'm honestly surprised anyone is really trying to defend it."

If by "fix" you meant "substitute sensible position with glibertarian nonsense," then yes, you fixed it.

Good thing we have stern people like you in the world, willing to give someone such a harsh lesson for a $75 mistake. Screw it, let's get back to cutting off people's hands for stealing. THat'd really teach those thieves.
 
Last edited:
He might show up at court, say he shouldn't pay (like people do when they run a stop sign), the judge would say, "Sorry, you owe $200." End of story.

My brother is a landlord and frequently takes non-paying former tenants to small claims court. He says the average case takes about 15 seconds. The Judge asks the defendant if he owes the money, the defendant says "Yeah, but ...", the judge cuts him off and renders a verdict in an emotionless monotone then moves on to the next case. Contrast that with TV court shows, where they spend ten minutes on a case like that.
 
If by "fix" you meant "substitute sensible position with glibertarian nonsense," then yes, you fixed it.

Good thing we have stern people like you in the world, willing to give someone such a harsh lesson for a $75 mistake. Screw it, let's get back to cutting off people's hands for stealing. THat'd really teach those thieves.

How is that nonsense?


And I'm glad you've taken to addressing your rhetoric towards me instead of the Fire Dept :rolleyes:

Look, if I don't pay for life insurance - should I expect my family would receive any benefits? This fool and his elected County leaders are idiots - but pointing that out somehow makes me the bad guy?

If the homeowner wanted fire protection, he should have paid for it. Black and white, plain and simple. That he didn't is not the fault of the City, nor the Fire Chief, nor the Firefighters.

You may not like the system - hell, I don't like the system - but it is the system that the homeowner agreed to. That's how the world works.
 
<snip>

You may not like the system - hell, I don't like the system - but it is the system that the homeowner agreed to.


How do you know he agreed to it? The fact that he didn't pay the fee is some evidence that he didn't. He could have campaigned fervently for a county-wide tax assessment, and refused the fee in protest. We really don't know.

Nor is it germane to a discussion about the relative merits of such a system.

That's how the world works.


This could be used as a justification for a lot of things. I suspect you would be less blasé about its application to many of them.
 
How is that nonsense?

Because in the United States of America, in the 21st century, you're arguing that failure to pay a $75 fee should be punished by allowing someone's house to burn to the ground.

Let's consider what sort of behavior results in a $75 penalty: rolling through a stop-sign (higher in most areas), driving 10mph over the speed limit (likely result in more than $75), parking tickets...

This is a minor, minor issue punished with barbarism. There's a basic rule of proportionality that guides the legal system and civil society in general. This is ridiculously out of proportion.

But that'll learn him some personal responsibility...


Look, if I don't pay for life insurance - should I expect my family would receive any benefits? This fool and his elected County leaders are idiots - but pointing that out somehow makes me the bad guy?

The fee isn't insurance, he had insurance, it's covering the damage. The fee is to get the firemen to provide a service. It operates somewhat like insurance, in so far as it requires a number of people to pay into a general fund for a service that they may not need, but they're funding the fire department with that money.

If someone was wheeled into an emergency room and the doctors allowed him/her to expire for lack of insurance, I, along with the most of the civilized world, would be horrified.

Costs can be dealt with later, but failing to pay a trivial fee should not receive a punishment far in excess of anything below a felony.

If the homeowner wanted fire protection, he should have paid for it. Black and white, plain and simple. That he didn't is not the fault of the City, nor the Fire Chief, nor the Firefighters.

Well, now you've taught him a lesson. It's of course impossible to have him pay the $75 plus some fine after you've stopped his house from burning down.

You may not like the system - hell, I don't like the system - but it is the system that the homeowner agreed to. That's how the world works.

Right, this is libertarian *********. What a perverse social contract. Uh oh, you made a bad decision, now we're allowed to ignore any sense of common decency and humanity and let your house burn for want of $75.

Hey man, that's just the system, what could we do? Please.
 
Last edited:
that is **** ed up

Blame reality, which is the one who set things up such that, if people don't do something, bad things can happen.


Humanity has learned the hard way that forcing others to serve you...doesn't work out so well.


That so-and-so failed to plan means he's now reliant on the generosity of others. If that fire department can't survive on people making "spot payments", then it's in their, and everyone's interest to see the occasional building burn.
 
How do you know he agreed to it? The fact that he didn't pay the fee is some evidence that he didn't. He could have campaigned fervently for a county-wide tax assessment, and refused the fee in protest. We really don't know.

Nor is it germane to a discussion about the relative merits of such a system.
I don't see anyone here actually defending the system. I most certainly am not (as I've posted a number of times now). I do not, however, fault the City nor the Fire Chief nor the Firefighters.


We know, from the homeowner's own words, that his failure to pay was not a form of protest, but rather because "he thought he would be protected anyway." That, sir, makes this incident his own fault. Protection was offered by the City when it wasn't required to be - that the homeowner refused that protection until it was necessary is not the fault of the City/Fire Chief/Firefighters. It's like me taking my car to the shop where I'm informed that I need new brakes. I opt to save my $75 (good god, I wish my brakes only cost $75... :D) then claim the shop is somehow responsible when I'm in an accident because I couldn't stop. Granted, the analogy fails where the firefighters could have done something during the fire while the shop couldn't have done anything while I was attempting to stop. Point remains the same, however. A service was offered, the homeowner refused the service. How is it anything but the homeowner's fault that the service was not provided?


This could be used as a justification for a lot of things. I suspect you would be less blasé about its application to many of them.
:D Fair enough.
 
How do you know he agreed to it? The fact that he didn't pay the fee is some evidence that he didn't. He could have campaigned fervently for a county-wide tax assessment, and refused the fee in protest. We really don't know.
If that's the case he's even more stupid than he first appeared.
 
Because in the United States of America, in the 21st century, you're arguing that failure to pay a $75 fee should be punished by allowing someone's house to burn to the ground.
Yes, in America people are allowed to make stupid decisions all the time.

Most other places too.

So what?

eta: and I really don't think you've thought through your desire for a society where consequences are eliminated for making irresponsible decisions.
 
Last edited:
Because in the United States of America, in the 21st century, you're arguing that failure to pay a $75 fee should be punished by allowing someone's house to burn to the ground.

Let's consider what sort of behavior results in a $75 penalty: rolling through a stop-sign (higher in most areas), driving 10mph over the speed limit (likely result in more than $75), parking tickets...

This is a minor, minor issue punished with barbarism. There's a basic rule of proportionality that guides the legal system and civil society in general. This is ridiculously out of proportion.

But that'll learn him some personal responsibility...




The fee isn't insurance, he had insurance, it's covering the damage. The fee is to get the firemen to provide a service. It operates somewhat like insurance, in so far as it requires a number of people to pay into a general fund for a service that they may not need, but they're funding the fire department with that money.

If someone was wheeled into an emergency room and the doctors allowed him/her to expire for lack of insurance, I, along with the most of the civilized world, would be horrified.

Costs can be dealt with later, but failing to pay a trivial fee should not receive a punishment far in excess of anything below a felony.



Well, now you've taught him a lesson. It's of course impossible to have him pay the $75 plus some fine after you've stopped his house from burning down.



Right, this is libertarian *********. What a perverse social contract. Uh oh, you made a bad decision, now we're allowed to ignore any sense of common decency and humanity and let your house burn for want of $75.

Hey man, that's just the system, what could we do? Please.

Look, that's the contract the homeowner agreed to. The City offered it's services, the Homeowner thought he could get by without. He's the libertarian who's now crying foul, not I.

Just because I realize there are consequences for one's decisions does not make me a libertarian. Just a student of life ;)
 
Yes, in America people are allowed to make stupid decisions all the time.

Most other places too.

So what?

It's not the man's decision that's at issue, it was obviously a foolish one. It's a question of we, as a nation, as a community, choose to behave towards one another.

This was a trivial amount of money punished to an absurd extent. The means of saving the house were available, countless proportional punishments were available, yet people are actually defending this decision.

We are judged by how we treat the least among us. This fellow was clearly lacking in the smarts, that's his problem, but the people in that county showed themselves to be true villians. Are these those "small town values" I hear so much about? Those halcyon days of community where people looked out for one another? The Real Americans?

I prefer my urban nightmare where tax dollars pay for services that help out people who aren't necessarily me.
 
Fires can get out of control. That is, in fact, the meaning of "out of control". When "controlled burns" are employed, for whatever reason, no one is more nervous than the firefighters.
Having been part of my fair share of controlled burns, this is very true. We're also jeeped up on adrenaline and caffeine (as we generally start pretty early and no one goes to bed at a reasonable time the night before ;)) but we're also respectful of the fire.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom