Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

There has always been a sort of underlying glee towards the misfortune of others which is a root component of the libertarian perspective. They share this with many religious fundamentalists. It's probably no coincidence that I find both to be distasteful.
The word for that is schadenfreude, and one doesn't have to be a libertarian or fundy to have it.

Need I remind people that this asshat left his dog and 3 cats in the house for 2 hours while the fire slowly made its way to the house? And that they died because he couldn't be bothered to rescue them in this 2 hour window? He's a despicable human being.
 
The problem with your calculation is that this policy has been in place for 10 years already. Mr. Cranich has already potentially saved $750.00 by not paying. Why on earth would anybody pay a $75 fee for something that has a 1% chance of happening, if the fine only comes out to $500.00. In order for things to approach balancing out, they would have to charge $7,500 fines, which would have Mr. Cranick equally up in arms about the unfairness of it all.

If he had skipped the previous 9 years and just paid $75, his house would have been saved. Thus, for lack of $75 it was allowed to burn.

But interestingly, we're arriving at the problem that made the individual mandate necessary in health care reform: without punishment, there's no incentive to purchase the service before its needed. This leaves the service radically underfunded and unable to deal with emergencies.

This program is really stupid. Funding fire departments with tax dollars is a much wiser policy, but given the situation as presented, it was absurd to let that house burn for an unpaid $75.
 
The word for that is schadenfreude, and one doesn't have to be a libertarian or fundy to have it.

<snip>


Thank you for the pointless and unnecessary tutorial in German loaner words. Apparently I didn't need to use other languages for my meaning to be clear to you, though. I'm glad to see that you agree we are discussing people who find "pleasure derived from the misfortunes of others."

Where did I say that it was limited to those groups? I just happen to feel that it is one of their more prominent characteristics.

I have no problem including you.
 
Yeah, i am sure fire fighters have no idea how to tell if a fire is spreading. It is not like they have any clue how fire works.

That is why they showed up, to make sure there was no risk to other property. The argument you make would be valid, if , they didn't show up, but that is not the policy they have.

People keep painting the picture as the fire department showing up there with a stage and dice clay to make jokes about the guy. While i have no doubt there was some smug smiles as it happened, they were there to make sure that they did their jobs, and that the fire was contained on the idiot's property.
I haven't been painting a bad picture of the firefighters. The firefighters were doing what they were ordered to do. What I don't like is a policy that puts responsible people at risk of losing their property. If the firefighters were under orders to not respond to the Cranick fire, and the fire was allowed to get big enough that it crossed over to the neighbor's property (which it did, luckily they were able to contain it) that's bad policy. It makes more sense to put the fire out immediately, when it's still small, rather than wait for it to spread. It's safer for the property owners and the firefighters. Fires can grow unexpectedly fast, and even an experienced fire crew can have a very hard, life threatening time putting one out. It's best to stop a fire before it has a chance to spread, and based on what I've read, they may well have had that chance if they were allowed to put the Cranick fire out immediately. If the county policy is to not intervene unless the fire gets big enough to jump to other property owners' land, it's irresponsible not only to the property owners, but to the safety of the firefighters.
 
Most speeding tickets probably don't get challenged in court. But given the fact that lawyers typically charge hundreds of dollars per hour, trying to get him to pay by bringing him in front of a judge will rapidly increase the cost to the city, possibly throwing good money after bad. (And even if the municipal lawyers are not receiving hourly salaries, they are still probably quite highly paid.)

Speaking as a lawyer, this is 100% ********. The city isn't going to hire a private attorney, they'll use their salaried counsel. It's a simple, straightforward case and little if any time would be wated.

You guys are hilariously creating imaginary legal systems to try and make a fine seem impossibly difficult. There's already a structure in place to deal with such things and it could be administered with ease.

Pretty big assumptions. As I pointed out, the 'court costs' could be pretty substantial given the cost of lawyers. And it sounds like you're assuming he's only liable for $75. What if he hadn't paid the fees for the past 10 years? Shouldn't he pay $750? (At this point, we don't know if he just "forgot" to pay the past year, or if this is an ongoing situation with him.)

Why would he be liable for back payments? If he had paid $75 this year, would they have let the house burn?

It also sounds like you're just assessing him for the cost of the "insurance", and he's not getting charged for the actual fire fighting costs. From the fire department's point of view, this is the worst of all situations... not getting the money up front (which could have implications on long term funding), plus not getting the 'true' cost of fighting the fire.

Why would he be charged for the fire fighting costs? If he paid $75 he wouldn't have been.

And yes, this is a stupid, foolish way to finance a fire-department, but punishing one man with the total destuction of his home for lack of a $75 fee is just absurd.


Not sure how things are down in the U.S., but here in Canada, when you declare bankruptcy your principal residence is except from the proceedings. I suspect similar rules are in place in the U.S.

Depends on the state. The only one I know of with that policy is Florida, which is why a lot of Wall Street folks invest in property down there...
 
Why do you think it doesn't cost anything to do it?
I don't. Did you see the part where I said we should charge them for the marginal costs? That strongly implies that I think there are marginal costs.

If you are a taxpayer in South Fulton, whose taxes go to pay for all services, how are you going to feel when you find out that there are a large number of people living outside the area, who paid zero taxes but who receive all your services, in fact, you are paying for them?
I'd say, hey, that seems unfair. We should probably unify the various municipal fire departments to cover the whole county. Failing that, let's try to find some way to charge for it. Oh, you can't find a way a way to charge for it that doesn't involve denying service to people in the area we cover? Ok, let's just inform those people that they receive emergency services from us and solicit donations, hoping for the best. Our taxes might not be lowered as much as we like, but at least we're not letting people's houses burn down, watching their pets die, and putting the whole area at risk.

That's what was done.
This separating of paragraphs has a tendency to destroy context.

Appeal to emotion. I am perfectly fine with allowing someone's house to burn when they have chosen not to be a part of a fire protection system. That's the beauty of freedom of choice.
I really wish people on these forums would learn what 'appeal to emotion' means.

Anyway, if this is the beauty of freedom of choice, I'd hate to see what the ugly of freedom of choice looks like.
 
Thank you for the pointless and unnecessary tutorial in German loaner words. Apparently I didn't need to use other languages for my meaning to be clear to you, though. I'm glad to see that you agree we are discussing people who find "pleasure derived from the misfortunes of others."

Where did I say that it was limited to those groups? I just happen to feel that it is one of their more prominent characteristics.

I have no problem including you.
.
I watch "Stupid Daredevil Tricks" and "Stupid Criminals" on Trutv. Lots of laughs there.
 
Sure they did, they bought into the system that said pay if you want fire protection don’t pay of you don’t. The problem is that system doesn’t work very well and we can see the results.

The system worked fine. Almost zero property damage to people buying into the system.

Not necessarily.

Well, I didn't see anywhere that this was a volunteer fire department.

The costs of fighting the fire are trivial in comparison to costs of maintaining a fire department, but most of them come from responding to the call and having people on scene. This may only be $1000 (what I’ve typically seen charged for false alarms) but it’s more then they would need to pay otherwise. . .

Try run a business like this. You have to cover actual costs which are wages, equipment use, vehicle use and wear, insurance and WBC costs, etc. With say 8 firefighters putting in 4 hours for this fire, that's more than a thousand dollars.

. . . and in this case they ended up fighting a fire anyway.

If I have a false alarm at my house, the fire department comes and checks it out, and then on the drive back they see a real fire and put it out, I am still charged for the false alarm?

The fact that they had to fight a fire anyway is completely beside the point.


Burnt out houses decrease local property values until someone pays to clean up the mess. I have no idea why you are trying to dispute this.

I dispute the decrease because of the circumstances, this is not an area where houses are crammed wall to wall. You assume that the burned house can even be seen from another property.

So? Do you think these numbers are pulled from a hat? They are based on real bankruptcy rates and costs, which are altered under system where people push their risk back to the bank as happened here. The house doesn’t suddenly become free simply because bank knows they will lose o some of their investments.

The cost of the bankruptcy is paid regardless of whether you go bankrupt or not. And you are arguing against your own point in regard to this incident. The cost of fighting this fire gets pushed onto the people who paid their fees and were entitled to the service.

Look at all the people who say they are going to make a huge contribution to search and rescue when their sorry butt is saved from their own stupidity. Want to bet on how many do? Very few.

That’s a valid question, the correct answer is they should not. In this case they *did*need to and the person responsible is unlikely to pay the bill. You can’t ignore externalities like you seem to want to do. The homeowner didn’t just create expenses for himself he created expenses for many other people.

No they didn't "need" to and they didn't. The fire they fought was on the property of someone who paid the fee. There is very little expense to the taxpayers and they had already agreed to that expense with the way the system is set up. This is an "everybody lost who should have lost" scenario.

It’s doubtful he will collect on insurance if he was found to be negligent. Even if he does it’s an expense to the insurance company that needs to be passed along. Again, just because there is insurance doesn’t make things free.

YOu need to read the links. He is already being provided with insurance money. Perhaps you should see if his insurance company wants to foot the bill for everyone outside the fire department's taxation area. I know what they're going to tell you. :D

The cost to the bank when he defaults on his loan is not imaginary. The cost to the insurance company is not imaginary. . .

Already covered.

. . . the cost the town is not imaginary . . .

No cost to the town, their fire department didn't fight the fire.

. . . they cost to his neighbours is not imaginary.

Definitely unknown though. You can't claim this is a negative for them because no one knows and there are very foreseeable ways in which it could be a positive.

You can’t simply pretend externalities like this don’t exist.

I don't. I just don't buy into the whole "everything is a negative" idea. In my opinion, there is very little negative except to the family who chose not to pay a fee. That was a gamble they freely entered into and they lost. I am sure that if he had not paid the fees for 20 years and not had a fire, he would be bragging to his neighbours about how smart he was to save all that money and how stupid they were for being duped into paying for somehting they didn't need.

Now he, and you, want him to have free coverage and the bragging rights. Sorry but I can't agree to that.
 
I haven't been painting a bad picture of the firefighters. The firefighters were doing what they were ordered to do. What I don't like is a policy that puts responsible people at risk of losing their property. If the firefighters were under orders to not respond to the Cranick fire, and the fire was allowed to get big enough that it crossed over to the neighbor's property (which it did, luckily they were able to contain it) that's bad policy. It makes more sense to put the fire out immediately, when it's still small, rather than wait for it to spread. It's safer for the property owners and the firefighters. Fires can grow unexpectedly fast, and even an experienced fire crew can have a very hard, life threatening time putting one out. It's best to stop a fire before it has a chance to spread, and based on what I've read, they may well have had that chance if they were allowed to put the Cranick fire out immediately. If the county policy is to not intervene unless the fire gets big enough to jump to other property owners' land, it's irresponsible not only to the property owners, but to the safety of the firefighters.
.
Yeah, it's like immunizations of school children.
Fighting a fire early prevents its spread.
We're having a debate out here as to similar foot dragging by the Division of Forestry relative to fighting a small fire which subsequently went for about 50 miles and lasted for several weeks, because of negligent response at first.
 
.
I watch "Stupid Daredevil Tricks" and "Stupid Criminals" on Trutv. Lots of laughs there.


Apparently so, for some people. Quite a few judging from the shows' popularity.

I don't share their amusement. I've been around too many people hurt, whether through actions of their own or not. It isn't amusing or pleasing when you are there. I've never understood why it should suddenly become that way just because you aren't.
 
Fighting a fire early prevents its spread.
We're having a debate out here as to similar foot dragging by the Division of Forestry relative to fighting a small fire which subsequently went for about 50 miles and lasted for several weeks, because of negligent response at first.

Well, except that none of this happened in the case under discussion here.

Never let the facts get in the way of your argument. :D
 
It's been a long time since I studied any of this but I believe the Principle of Utmost Good Faith would be relevant here as would Concealment and Misrepresentation.

That´s it, exactly. I am only intimately familiar with the German legalese, so the English terms escaped me.

While we can't say what was in the policy, if the insured party failed to inform his insurer of the fire fighting arrangement and his non-subscription to those arrangements I'd say he hasn't the proverbial leg to stand on.

Indeed.
 
Speaking as a lawyer, this is 100% ********. The city isn't going to hire a private attorney, they'll use their salaried counsel. It's a simple, straightforward case and little if any time would be wated.
And as an attorney you also know that getting a judgement is not the same thing as getting payment.
 
.
Yeah, it's like immunizations of school children.
Fighting a fire early prevents its spread.
We're having a debate out here as to similar foot dragging by the Division of Forestry relative to fighting a small fire which subsequently went for about 50 miles and lasted for several weeks, because of negligent response at first.

Which brings us back to the root cause of this problem. The asenine system this county has set up for fire protection.

However, to expand on this, I am curious how this system came to be. I am not sure how county government works in TN, so cannot answer this. Was the county offered a plan to cover everybody and pass it along in taxes? Was this turned down? Was this plan and/or rejection of other plans decided through full county referrendums or just votes of county supervisors? If it was full referrendums, how did Mr. Cranick vote on them?

The problem with blaming 'the county' is that it eventually falls back onto the people who live there. people like Mr. Cranick and his neighbors.

Ultimately, this is not the fault of the South Fulton FD, but of the people of the unicorporated areas of the county who either voted for this asenine system or elected the people who then voted for it.
 
And as an attorney you also know that getting a judgement is not the same thing as getting payment.

Of course, and this is true with every fine levied against every citizen for any reason, anywhere. Once again, if he's employed they could garnish his wages, meaning that fine is withheld before he even gets his check. It would be collected like payroll taxes. Easy.

It's just amusing that everyone is pretending like hitting this guy with a couple hundred dollar fine would be so onerous that it justifies letting his house burn down:

"Sure, I realize his pets died and he lost irreplaceable items, but do you realize we'd have to fill out paperwork? **** that, let it burn."

But I guess this our new social contract: we're just gigantic ******** to one another. Awesome.

Maybe we should go all the way. Let the fire fighters negotiate their fees as the house is burning. I bet they could really maximize their profit that way.
 
Last edited:
Well, except that none of this happened in the case under discussion here.
Never let the facts get in the way of your argument. :D


What difference does that make? Most of the condemnation of this guy is about his failure to pay insurance. That is all about precautions for the potential of an occurrence. There was every potential for this particular fire to get out of control, even if it didn't in this particular instance.

If it had gotten out of control there would be good reason to argue that the firemen had failed in their obligation to the subscribers in the area, by not extinguishing the first fire before it became too much for them.

Imagine that case in a courtroom. There is a fire prevention professional on the stand, and he is asked exactly what point in time should the firefighters on the scene have decided that the first fire became a risk to others.

What do you suppose he is going to say? My guess is, "When they saw the first fire."
 
What difference does that make? Most of the condemnation of this guy is about his failure to pay insurance. That is all about precautions for the potential of an occurrence. There was every potential for this particular fire to get out of control, even if it didn't in this particular instance.

If it had gotten out of control there would be good reason to argue that the firemen had failed in their obligation to the subscribers in the area, by not extinguishing the first fire before it became too much for them.

Imagine that case in a courtroom. There is a fire prevention professional on the stand, and he is asked exactly what point in time should the firefighters on the scene have decided that the first fire became a risk to others.

What do you suppose he is going to say? My guess is, "When they saw the first fire."



What about doctors, then? Are they obligated to treat every ailment for free, no matter how minor? Because that cough might be a symptom of cancer. Why didn't you check for that, doctor, before letting it spread and the patient die?!
 
Which brings us back to the root cause of this problem. The asenine system this county has set up for fire protection.

However, to expand on this, I am curious how this system came to be. I am not sure how county government works in TN, so cannot answer this. Was the county offered a plan to cover everybody and pass it along in taxes? Was this turned down? Was this plan and/or rejection of other plans decided through full county referrendums or just votes of county supervisors? If it was full referrendums, how did Mr. Cranick vote on them?

The problem with blaming 'the county' is that it eventually falls back onto the people who live there. people like Mr. Cranick and his neighbors.

Ultimately, this is not the fault of the South Fulton FD, but of the people of the unicorporated areas of the county who either voted for this asenine system or elected the people who then voted for it.


If I was a betting man I'd bet that the phrase "No New Taxes." was probably involved.

Maybe "mantra" would be a better word.
 
If I was a betting man I'd bet that the phrase "No New Taxes." was probably involved.

Maybe "mantra" would be a better word.

I definitely have suspicions in that direction, but lacking any actual facts or evidence to support such in this particular case, I will withhold judgement.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom