Firefighters stand by as house burns to ground

.
Along with delivering mail with postage due.
It was returned to the sender.
The P.O. would open the mail if there was no stamp, typically a bill, and get the name of the person the bill was sent to, and send it back to them.
Yep it's the same here, no valid postage means no delivery. I remember 'postage due' stamps from collecting stamps as a child though.
 
Letting it burn was stupid. They could simply have fought the fire and then put a lien on the property for whatever it cost them.
Wouldn't that be rather dubious legally? If there's no valid contract for their services in place what claim would they have for payment?
 
Just out of curiosity...

[...]

And even if they do manage to sue, and the fire department does win the case (this is assuming the guy doesn't claim "duress" as others have suggested he might), what guarantee do they have that he'll pay and not just claim bankruptcy?

We're overstating the likely costs. The fine would really be no different than a speeding ticket. I'm assuming the highest costs possible--forcing the municipality to prove its case in court.

A lien wouldn't make much sense in this case, but if they won the case, they could garnish his wages, depending on the local laws.

Presumeably he's employed, and it's not like the fine will be that large. It will basically be the $75, the filing fee, usually $125-$150, some court costs, and a fine. In all, it should be less than $500. That could be garnished at some monthly cost.

If he's impoverished and forced to declare bankruptcy, then there's an existing house to foreclose on instead of a charred pile of rubble.

Remember, this is over failure to pay $75. I would argue that letting a house burn down because someone didn't pay $75 is cruel and unusual, it's radically disproportionate.
 
Last edited:
No. Their income is based on the tax payers in the city. This is an additional service they provide, not one that pays their salaries. And when faced between a simple 75$ year vs risking several thousands for a year, the vast majority are clearly going to choose the $75. The few that don't end up paying far more which equates far more people paying $75.

So it can be made so not only do they not lose money, but they make a profit for each fire outside the city line.
Why would "the vast majority are clearly going to choose the $75", or 6% of the proposed $1,250 fee, when the odds of actually having the house catch fire are far less than 1%?

I'd risk the $1,250, as would any rational person. If you disagree, stay away from the craps table. You'll be the guy tha's all over the sucker bets.
 
<snip>

The intent of letting it burn is not to make an example out of the guy, that is just a pleasant side effect.
<snip>


Of course the intent was to make an example out of him. It's disingenuous to pretend otherwise. You can bet that an awful lot of subscriptions have been caught up on since the incident.

The part I highlighted is something that bothers me even more. There has always been a sort of underlying glee towards the misfortune of others which is a root component of the libertarian perspective. They share this with many religious fundamentalists. It's probably no coincidence that I find both to be distasteful.

There will always be some people who suffer as a result of their own stupidity or inaction. The degree that we as a society find this tolerable, and the way we react says much about us, and what it says isn't always pretty, no matter how many ways it is presented otherwise. "I guess that 'll show 'im!" isn't a statement of practical self-interest, it's an expression of satisfaction.

It is patently obvious that the solution the county chose for fire protection service isn't the most effective one for the society overall, it is simply the most politically palatable (i.e.; convenient) one for the locale at the time. One of the reasons for this is the occasional dose of glee that some people derive from other people's tragedy. Protestations to the contrary are not convincing.
 
You're assuming every resident of the county is stupid. Most people realize it takes money to supply and man a fire station, and I bet most people would happily still voluntarily pay the $75 charge even if firefighters had to occasionally respond to a fire started by someone who hadn't bothered.
I'm guessing they won't pay, and I'd bet that's the reason they changed their policy in 1990 to not service the people who don't pay.
 
When I was growing up (from 1st grade to I'm not sure when), we didn't have fire protection. We lived in a geographically large county. The county seat, also the state capital, had a population of around 100,000 at the time. We lived about a mile outside the county seat. At the time the area was still quite rural--lots of farms, a few isolated houses and a few small subdivisions. We lived in one of the latter. Police protection wasn't a problem because the county sheriff's department was quite large. We didn't have fire protection though. The township (I believe it was the township) had the opportunity to vote to contract with the city for fire protection. I'm not sure if the cost would have been in the form of a fee or additional property taxes.

For years, people had voted against fire protection. My parents were vocally in favor of fire protection. You'd be surprised (or perhaps not) how angry some people were by the idea that we should have some means of extinguishing house fires. There was no option for individual households to pay for fire protection.

Then there was fire. I don't actually remember if the fire department showed up, though I think they did. Since no one had fire protection and the houses were close together, there was potential for a fairly huge disaster, so I think the city fire department may have done something to contain the fire. The house burned to the ground, though.

Well, not too long afterward, people did finally vote to get fire protection, though some folk were still agin' it. After all, our neighborhood had had a fire, and it wasn't their home. What were the chances that there would be another fire?
 
We're overstating the likely costs. The fine would really be no different than a speeding ticket. I'm assuming the highest costs possible--forcing the municipality to prove its case in court.

A lien wouldn't make much sense in this case, but if they won the case, they could garnish his wages, depending on the local laws.

Presumeably he's employed, and it's not like the fine will be that large. It will basically be the $75, the filing fee, usually $125-$150, some court costs, and a fine. In all, it should be less than $500. That could be garnished at some monthly cost.

If he's impoverished and forced to declare bankruptcy, then there's an existing house to foreclose on instead of a charred pile of rubble.

Remember, this is over failure to pay $75. I would argue that letting a house burn down because someone didn't pay $75 is cruel and unusual, it's radically disproportionate.

The problem with your calculation is that this policy has been in place for 10 years already. Mr. Cranich has already potentially saved $750.00 by not paying. Why on earth would anybody pay a $75 fee for something that has a 1% chance of happening, if the fine only comes out to $500.00. In order for things to approach balancing out, they would have to charge $7,500 fines, which would have Mr. Cranick equally up in arms about the unfairness of it all.
 
For the same reason anyone buys insurance of any sort. The insurance industry existed, last time I checked... Yep.
Last I checked, you can't buy fire insurance once the house is on fire. That's why people buy it in advance.

Sure you can. You just have to charge what it actually costs.
So, $75,000 for the one house fire a year?

Pennies on the dollar is more than zero, which is what they did in fact get for that house.
Revenue that may come in sometime in the distant future doesn't buy a fire truck today.
 
Well, not too long afterward, people did finally vote to get fire protection, though some folk were still agin' it. After all, our neighborhood had had a fire, and it wasn't their home. What were the chances that there would be another fire?

100% chance if it had been my home that burned down.
 
According to the story the fire took 2 hours to reach the house once it started. He couldn't have saved his pets in that 2 hour window? This makes me hate the guy even more.
.
Hate... such a strong word.
Olberman had him on last night.
I don't spend much time watching retards wrestling with difficult situations.
 
I used to work for insurance, including the claims department for household/building insurance for a while.

I´m pretty sure that, if the insurance knew about the arrangement of fire protection in the area, they´d make his paying the $75 fee a condition for providing cover.

And I am absolutely certain that the information about this arrangement is a fact relevant to the fire risk inherent in his property, meaning he has to provide it when he takes out the insurance - if he does not, the insurance can withhold coverage because he fraudulently withheld relevant information.

It's been a long time since I studied any of this but I believe the Principle of Utmost Good Faith would be relevant here as would Concealment and Misrepresentation.

Utmost Good Faith means that each party to a proposed insurance contract is legally obliged to reveal to the other all information and materials facts, which would influence the other’s decision to enter into the contract, whether such information is requested or not.

Concealment is the intentional failure to reveal a material fact, which would influence a prudent underwriter in deciding whether to accept or reject a risk and what rate to charge and what conditions to impose.

Misrepresentation is the giving of false or misleading information on the material fact.

Concealment and/or misrepresentation gives the aggrieved party the right to avoid the contract.
While we can't say what was in the policy, if the insured party failed to inform his insurer of the fire fighting arrangement and his non-subscription to those arrangements I'd say he hasn't the proverbial leg to stand on.
 
Yep it's the same here, no valid postage means no delivery. I remember 'postage due' stamps from collecting stamps as a child though.
Of course, if you put the intended recipients name in the return address area, and yours in the address area, it gets "returned" to its intended recipient.

Oh no, not that I would ever do that just to see if it would work... :whistling
 
Yep it's the same here, no valid postage means no delivery. I remember 'postage due' stamps from collecting stamps as a child though.
.
I got one back that had the proper stamp, but the address wasn't visible in the window in the envelope.
The Post Office opened the envelope, determined I had sent it.. it was a bill.. and -returned- it to me to re-send... with another stamp of course.
When I took it to the P.O., the postmaster said "You might be wondering why after opening it and finding the address, we didn't then handle it properly".
"Yes, that thought did cross my mind".
"We didn't do it that way".
 
It seems to me the county didn't buy into any system. That's the problem.


Sure they did, they bought into the system that said pay if you want fire protection don’t pay of you don’t. The problem is that system doesn’t work very well and we can see the results.
They are getting paid anyway.

Not necessarily.

The costs come with fighting the fire. One could say that, at most, it was the cost of the fuel in the truck the fire department is out.


The costs of fighting the fire are trivial in comparison to costs of maintaining a fire department, but most of them come from responding to the call and having people on scene. This may only be $1000 (what I’ve typically seen charged for false alarms) but it’s more then they would need to pay otherwise, and in this case they ended up fighting a fire anyway.


One can't sy this would have much of a negative impact on value but if it did, it would only be in the short term. One doesn't know what would happen after. Also, the neighbour might be able to purchase the land at a very good price which is an increase in value for them.

Burnt out houses decrease local property values until someone pays to clean up the mess. I have no idea why you are trying to dispute this.
That's already been paid. The bank calculates a certain bankruptcy rate into the price of everyone's morgage.


So? Do you think these numbers are pulled from a hat? They are based on real bankruptcy rates and costs, which are altered under system where people push their risk back to the bank as happened here. The house doesn’t suddenly become free simply because bank knows they will lose o some of their investments.

Why should the city taxpayers pay the cost of fighting a fire outside their taxation area when the person refused to pay the fee? Fighting this fire is what would have put the burden onto the taxpayer.


That’s a valid question, the correct answer is they should not. In this case they *did*need to and the person responsible is unlikely to pay the bill. You can’t ignore externalities like you seem to want to do. The homeowner didn’t just create expenses for himself he created expenses for many other people.
No, he is covered by insurance. We don't even know that he has a mortgage. Could be paid in full. In which case there would be no bankruptcy.


It’s doubtful he will collect on insurance if he was found to be negligent. Even if he does it’s an expense to the insurance company that needs to be passed along. Again, just because there is insurance doesn’t make things free.

There is nothing to pass on, they are all imagined costs.
The cost to the bank when he defaults on his loan is not imaginary. The cost to the insurance company is not imaginary, the cost the town is not imaginary, they cost to his neighbours is not imaginary. You can’t simply pretend externalities like this don’t exist.
 
Ok, I'm a taxpayer in South Fulton. The town pays, I dunno, $500,000 per year to fund the fire department.

The town says, hey, we have enough excess capacity to also cover this outlying area of the county. We'll charge anyone we assist out there, let's say, $500, to cover marginal costs (the extra gas it takes, extra wear and tear on the engine, whatever risk we can monetize, etc.).

Total cost to the town: $500,000.

It strikes me as remarkably stingy not to offer a service if it doesn't cost you anything to do so.

Why do you think it doesn't cost anything to do it?

If you are a taxpayer in South Fulton, whose taxes go to pay for all services, how are you going to feel when you find out that there are a large number of people living outside the area, who paid zero taxes but who receive all your services, in fact, you are paying for them?

It would be nice to increase the pool of 'paying customers', so that my individual share goes down a little, so that everyone is chipping in.

That's what was done.

But if they only way anyone can think of to do that is to occasionally watch someone's house burn to the ground, I'll go for the first option.

Appeal to emotion. I am perfectly fine with allowing someone's house to burn when they have chosen not to be a part of a fire protection system. That's the beauty of freedom of choice.
 
Last edited:
Part of the problem is constructing a system where the choice even exists.

What if the city fire department had simply refused to assume the responsibility of additional jurisdiction unless all the houses were part of their purview?

It was not needful for them to function on a subscription basis. They could have just said, "Okay, we've got the equipment and resources to assume this much more territory if you pony up this much money." and waited until that money was forthcoming. If it wasn't, then don't go there at all.

Sometimes communities need to function as communities, and not as aggregates of individuals. This is one of those situations. Pretending that it isn't and trying to implement band-aid solutions is just denial.
 
We're overstating the likely costs. The fine would really be no different than a speeding ticket. I'm assuming the highest costs possible--forcing the municipality to prove its case in court.
Most speeding tickets probably don't get challenged in court. But given the fact that lawyers typically charge hundreds of dollars per hour, trying to get him to pay by bringing him in front of a judge will rapidly increase the cost to the city, possibly throwing good money after bad. (And even if the municipal lawyers are not receiving hourly salaries, they are still probably quite highly paid.)

Presumeably he's employed, and it's not like the fine will be that large. It will basically be the $75, the filing fee, usually $125-$150, some court costs, and a fine. In all, it should be less than $500.
Pretty big assumptions. As I pointed out, the 'court costs' could be pretty substantial given the cost of lawyers. And it sounds like you're assuming he's only liable for $75. What if he hadn't paid the fees for the past 10 years? Shouldn't he pay $750? (At this point, we don't know if he just "forgot" to pay the past year, or if this is an ongoing situation with him.)

It also sounds like you're just assessing him for the cost of the "insurance", and he's not getting charged for the actual fire fighting costs. From the fire department's point of view, this is the worst of all situations... not getting the money up front (which could have implications on long term funding), plus not getting the 'true' cost of fighting the fire.

If he's impoverished and forced to declare bankruptcy, then there's an existing house to foreclose on instead of a charred pile of rubble.
Not sure how things are down in the U.S., but here in Canada, when you declare bankruptcy your principal residence is except from the proceedings. I suspect similar rules are in place in the U.S.
 
I'm guessing they won't pay, and I'd bet that's the reason they changed their policy in 1990 to not service the people who don't pay.
.
But in the 20 years following, no similar incident occurred?
Or this bozo was the only hold-out, "knowing" he'd get the service for free anyway.
Lots of people think that way.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom