Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

I am totally confused:

"And a final thought regarding the "pommy" saga - I use the exact same term with both andyandy and brodski, and they are both people whose opinions I am on record as respecting.

"... frauds ...! Respect - no."

WTF?

Well ...when you start putting up a million, you'll be able to belittle...

Even more confusing. Are you putting up a million?

..., honey,...

I sure hope you are female and good looking... your place or mine?
 
P.S.
I have looked at the web page. Your organisation does put up a million. No mention of where the money is though. And in any case, you are not really worried that anybody could take it, so what is the justification of your "risking money entitles me to belittle" statement?

My apologies to all other readers, my love for logic has got the best of me. I will try to restrain myself.
 
P.S.
I have looked at the web page. Your organisation does put up a million. No mention of where the money is though. And in any case, you are not really worried that anybody could take it, so what is the justification of your "risking money entitles me to belittle" statement?
We run a different system to JREF, mainly because nobody's given us a mio to play with, so we have an arrangement with a consortium of bookmakers at odds ranging between 1,000:1 and 10,000:1. That's why I suggested earlier making the JREF challenge $10M instead of the measly $1M.

Actually, I don't need any reason to get stuck into frauds, but I thought it sounded like a good excuse! :) (My other name is Arrogant_B_Stard, but they won't let me use it in here) But hey, I did offer him a crack, do I need to patronise him as well?

My apologies to all other readers, my love for logic has got the best of me. I will try to restrain myself.
Nah, don't do that, derailing threads is excellent, especially when they're as dead as this one appears to be.
 
The Atheist: this is great idea!

We run a different system to JREF, mainly because nobody's given us a mio to play with, so we have an arrangement with a consortium of bookmakers at odds ranging between 1,000:1 and 10,000:1. That's why I suggested earlier making the JREF challenge $10M instead of the measly $1M.

If 100 JREF members put up $100 each with 100 bookmakers at 10,000 to 1 odds we would have $100 million to play with! I have heard a (Oz?) saying that "if the price of eggs is high enough even the roosters will start laying"... we might get some real scientists (yes, some do believe in supernatural things) doing real research of the type advocated by Hyparxis here to sort the sheep from the goats (just keeping the Oz/NZ flavour...) in the hope to get it. It would be all a different ball game, possibly in line with the "watch this space" changes afoot, and cut across many of the excuses for refusing to play.

We have to be honest with ourselves though. Is this what we want or is exposing small time charlatans just too much fun to give up?
 
The Atheist: this is great idea!

We run a different system to JREF, mainly because nobody's given us a mio to play with, so we have an arrangement with a consortium of bookmakers at odds ranging between 1,000:1 and 10,000:1. That's why I suggested earlier making the JREF challenge $10M instead of the measly $1M.

If 100 JREF members put up $100 each with 100 bookmakers at 10,000 to 1 odds we would have $100 million to play with! I have heard a (Oz?) saying that "if the price of eggs is high enough even the roosters will start laying"... we might get some real scientists (yes, some do believe in supernatural things) doing real research of the type advocated by Hyparxis here to sort the sheep from the goats (just keeping the Oz/NZ flavour...) in the hope to get it. It would be all a different ball game, possibly in line with the "watch this space" changes afoot, and cut across many of the excuses for refusing to play.

We have to be honest with ourselves though. Is this what we want or is exposing small time charlatans just too much fun to give up?
 
A red flag goes up when anyone claims to be a "Healer." And this red flag attracts some bullish responses. Even when I was active in Reiki, TT, Shiatsu, etc., I refused to call myself any kind of healer, not because of potential bull horn gorings, but because it's just wrong. Healing is something the body does, not someting done to it. Doctors proper only facilitate a recovery from an injury or disease.

A former boss of mine was getting sessions from an "energy/psychic healer." He marketed himself as such. He told her her breast cancer was in complete remission and she believed him. That cost her her life. I don't mind at all belittling and more, frauds like that.

Unfortunately its hard to keep this word "healing" out of a discussion about Therapeutic Touch, because there is a claim that these modalities facilitate, and hasten recovery and healing. And then most practitioners, especially those who want to make some kind of career of it, use the word in the worst possible way.

Because I have personal experience helping people using the so-called "energy" modalities, I listen first before dismissing them as frauds.
Had the OP come on board claiming to be able to cure and heal chronic diseases and marketing his healing services, I'd have kept my mouth shut and let the bulls gore him. But it seemed he was someone open to learning and the examples he gave a pretty much the same kinds of effects I've seen myself.

It is my opinion that these modalities assist and hasten recovery from illness to some extent. Not to the extent claimed by the majority of the people who sell them (especially Reiki which lends itself so well to racketeering). But enough to encourage it as a helpful, harmless supplement to healthcare under the benificialilty of Massage Therapy.
research in this area has yielded mixed results so far, partailly because of focus on the detection of supposed "energies" rather than on the physiology of
nervous system, immune system, and hormonal responses to caring touch.

Here are a couple of links for anyone intersted in the pros and cons.
http://www.phact.org/e/tt/
http://www.intelihealth.com/IH/ihtIH/WSS/8513/34968/358873.html?d=dmtContent
 
The Atheist: this is great idea!

If 100 JREF members put up $100 each with 100 bookmakers at 10,000 to 1 odds we would have $100 million to play with! I have heard a (Oz?) saying that "if the price of eggs is high enough even the roosters will start laying"... we might get some real scientists (yes, some do believe in supernatural things) doing real research of the type advocated by Hyparxis here to sort the sheep from the goats (just keeping the Oz/NZ flavour...)
Just a quick correction - for Oz, that would be, "sorting the sheep from the women":D
in the hope to get it. It would be all a different ball game, possibly in line with the "watch this space" changes afoot, and cut across many of the excuses for refusing to play.

We have to be honest with ourselves though. Is this what we want or is exposing small time charlatans just too much fun to give up?
No question that this is possible, although I think $100M might be pushing it a little - remember that bookies assess risk and offer odds accordingly. At that kind of risk, they're going to offer average odds of far less that 10k:1. I'd suggest that the average would be around 1000:1(and maybe less that that, 100M is a lot of risk), so 100M prize would need to be funded by 100k. And that money is gone forever each time someone reaches the actual challenge stage, so it would become quite an expensive exercise at that level. Also, the UK and international bookies who take this kind of bet on isn't large in numbers and any bookie is going to get queasy about exposure to large losses as they aren't sceptics or scientists who can be confident that a claimant isn't going to win it. I'd suggest there is a danger if that kind of level is offered, JREF would be open to smart people with an agenda figuring ways of getting past the initial stages in an effort to bankrupt JREF by making challenges, even though they would know that those challenges are bound to fail.

Far better to use $10M - which is still a huge amount. At that level, the risk can be spread nicely - say 20 bookies at 500k exposure each, an amount they handle daily and will be very confortable with. One thing I found setting up EA's $1M is that some bookies think it's great fun and are keen to be in, while others are a little scared and only take the risk at all because they don't want to be seen as complete wimps. We're lucky that we have a lead bookie who's happy to take 500k at 10k:1 - pretty easy to accept a $50 loss if someone makes the challenge stage.

Another option would be for JREF to consult its members and members of this forum as to whether they'd put their money where their mouths are and offer to underwrite the risk themselves to at least some of the new amount required. After all, there are plenty of people here who are happy to jump all over psychics, faith healers, dowsers etc., but would they be willing to put up actual money of thier own at risk? I have no idea what the average net worth of forum members is, but I'd be picking quite a high number. The beauty of self-funding is that it could be done in conjunction with 10M cover by bookies, arriving at a much higher figure.

On the other hand, a lot of people are great at talking the talk, but not so flash at action. In fact, as I'm writing this, I have an idea for a thread - so I'll start one on that very subject!
 
Last edited:
No. Because you claim a power that, if true, would start a scientific revolution as far-reaching as Copernicus's or Einstein's, we ask for evidence.

I am an infrequent poster, but I just wanted to add my two bits as a physician. I do not see anything paranormal about this claim. Certainly the demonstration of his claim would not represent a scientific revolution of the type described. We already know that touch, massage, relaxation, etc. can have a significant effect on how someone feels. I think you were sidetracked because he used the word "healing" when what he was referring to was "symptom relief". We also already know that swelling can be reduced with pressure. Even if he demonstrated an effect better than a "placebo" person, it wouldn't be paranormal, as we already know that some people are more persuasive or charismatic than others.

It is reasonable to believe that he can do as he claims, but there is nothing about the nature of the claim that suggests one must jump to a supernatural explanation.

Linda
 
I think you were sidetracked because he used the word "healing" when what he was referring to was "symptom relief".
Linda - I think you're on the money here.

It explains why many flakey folk refer to themselves as "healers". It is also releated to what these healers perceive as being the "disease" in the first place.

If the healer thinks I suffer from blocked chi, and manipulates my energies via Remote Touch, and I feel that I have benefitted from the treatment, then a healing will have said to have taken place. Are there protocols to test this?

. . .

No, because there is nothing to test.

But, it has been pointed out before that skeptics and woos are talking two different languages. In many cases, both groups are sincere in their desire to help their fellow man, but neither group can understand the viewpoints and rationales of the other. I read an excellent report of a mystic and healer that had realised that her beliefs were not founded on rationality. Having been brought up, and educated, and trained and worked in the "alternate medicine" culture she could see how there were two different worldviews that failed to communicate.
I can't remember if I read that here at JREF or elsewhere.
 
Ladewig said:
Because you claim a power that, if true, would start a scientific revolution as far-reaching as Copernicus's or Einstein's, we ask for evidence.

I am an infrequent poster, but I just wanted to add my two bits as a physician. I do not see anything paranormal about this claim. Certainly the demonstration of his claim would not represent a scientific revolution of the type described. We already know that touch, massage, relaxation, etc. can have a significant effect on how someone feels. I think you were sidetracked because he used the word "healing" when what he was referring to was "symptom relief". We also already know that swelling can be reduced with pressure. Even if he demonstrated an effect better than a "placebo" person, it wouldn't be paranormal, as we already know that some people are more persuasive or charismatic than others.

It is reasonable to believe that he can do as he claims, but there is nothing about the nature of the claim that suggests one must jump to a supernatural explanation.

Linda

Yes, swelling can be reduced with pressure, but PP's accounts of the events do not involve applying pressure and his accounts also involve changes far, far quicker than any physical application of pressure could produce.

The first was complaining of a long term pain in her swollen wrist and shoulder.
After literally a few seconds of finger contact she reported the same healing energy moving up her hands and into her shoulder. She claimed that the pain her gone. Also her wrist had returned to normal from its swollen state.

If he touched her fingers and the swelling in the wrist disappeared within seconds, then what PP is doing is much more than touch, massage, or relaxation. Furthermore PP, himself, doesn't describe his technique as being any of those things. PP claims that energy is actually flowing from his body into the other person's body. I see no reason to believe he is speaking metaphorically in that he describes himself as feeling the energy flow out of him (to the point of being unable to continue the healing) and the recipients describe the energy as flowing into them (some actually describing the energy flowing up the arm to the location of the illness or disorder). If his claim of energy transfer is true, then he is indeed stepping beyond the borders of science into an unknown area. While it might be possible that this newly discovered energy could eventually be described and understood by science, right now such an energy transfer is outside the scientific realm.
 
A red flag goes up when anyone claims to be a "Healer." And this red flag attracts some bullish responses. Even when I was active in Reiki, TT, Shiatsu, etc., I refused to call myself any kind of healer, ...

Just a small compliment - great posts Hyparxis.
 
A red flag goes up when anyone claims to be a "Healer." And this red flag attracts some bullish responses. Even when I was active in Reiki, TT, Shiatsu, etc., I refused to call myself any kind of healer, not because of potential bull horn gorings, but because it's just wrong. Healing is something the body does, not someting done to it. Doctors proper only facilitate a recovery from an injury or disease.

I'm sorry, but this is simply wrong. If I have a bacterial infection and am given antibiotics, it is them, not the body, that cures it. If I have a gangrenous finger amputated it is the surgeon who cured it (or at least stopped it spreading). Yes, the body is good at healing itself and some medicine simply helps it, or reduces the syptoms while it heals itself, but there is a lot of medicine that genuinely cures things, either in conjunction with the body, or without its help at all.

I am pleased to see you no longer pratice "energy healing", but it seems you still believe many of the things such practioners say to belittle real medicine.
 
Just a quick correction - for Oz, that would be, "sorting the sheep from the women":D
Re-correction. NZ or Wales.

Sideline, heard an American comedian in Scotland with the following opener.
"I've heard about you Scotsmen and sheep!".

[audience response]

"That's Wales".

[comedian]

"Whales?! I am impressed!"
 
... I`d rather not continue with this debate as my application is pending. But I`ll be there for other discussions and probably taking your viewpoints - but with an open mind in view of my experiences.
See you all later, I have enjoyed this discussion.
If you need a volunteer for a preliminary test and you're based near London - PM me.

Does an effective "cure" hinge on me being a believer?

And when you say "cure", we're talking pain and swelling gone - that sort of thing?
 
I decided to leave this thread for a couple of days mainly because of the heated comments from some posters. My thanks to those that stood their ground and tried to add some balance and neutrality to the arguments.

I am prepared to continue, but if this thread reverts once more to a lion pit, I will stop altogether.
All I am trying to share with you is something that I consider as a gift - call it what you like, and it works on certain types of ailments.

Let me explain exactly what I do again, and what I can’t perform.

If I make finger tip contact with another`s I feel a hot energy leave my hands and travel into the body of a person receiving this energy. All people receiving this treatment feel tingling initially, followed by transference of energy along their arms to the parts or part of their body where the injury is. They always report that the energy of warmth remains in the affected area for some time before it fades away, and leaves the subject without anymore pain, or reduces the amount of pain they were suffering with. In the case of swellings to the body, this energy or if you prefer, "energy" will reduce or remove it.

Okay, when I first witnessed this phenomena for myself, it shocked me. It really shocked me. I find it just as staggering to believe as you do, but it actually works.
It has been suggested that the healing process is somatic in the sense that I am psychologically enforcing a belief that the patient will feel better, and as a result the recipient’s natural healing process takes over making them feel relieved of the pain.
If that were true, why does it not work with people say, suffering from a common cold?

It was earlier suggested on this post that as part of a test, I could energise a metal rod for evaluation. That is beyond my capabilities. The heat transfer works on organic flesh, not metal or some inanimate article.

I don’t claim to be a "miracle healer", I cannot cure cancer, I cannot cure virus infections, and I cannot make broken bones heal themselves.

Another point covering my limitations. Say is someone has a long term injury where the subject is suffering from multiple injuries caused from a road accident or such like. I can relieve the pain for a maximum of three months - no more, without further treatment.

How do I feel when using this energy? As I already explained, it drains me, and makes me very tired.

Since I have been away, I have been reviewing a number of `Faith Healers` videos on YouTube. That is not what I do, there is no religious base context to my way of working, and I treat these individuals with the same scepticism that you do of me.
I could go on here forever, but to get to the point.

I have a challenge for any of you sceptics that live in the home counties of England, preferably Essex, London, Herts, or Suffolk.
I am prepared to demonstrate my abilities on any person that you know who is suffering from swellings or pain discomfort. It matters not whether they believe or disbelieve, I will be more than willing to show you.
Anyone willing to take me on?
 
Last edited:
Yes, swelling can be reduced with pressure, but PP's accounts of the events do not involve applying pressure and his accounts also involve changes far, far quicker than any physical application of pressure could produce. If he touched her fingers and the swelling in the wrist disappeared within seconds, then what PP is doing is much more than touch, massage, or relaxation.

To elaborate on this point....swelling is arguably the only component of what he claimed that could be objectively observed. And even the observation of swelling can be influenced by subjective perceptions. Plus it is a dynamic process where one can expect variation even in the absence of any "treatment". And his description reflects his explanation of what he thinks is happening. We do not know whether an observer that is knowledgeable would see (and describe) the process differently, but we do know that that (a knowledgeable observer) commonly eliminates the allegedly inexplicable.

Furthermore PP, himself, doesn't describe his technique as being any of those things. PP claims that energy is actually flowing from his body into the other person's body. I see no reason to believe he is speaking metaphorically in that he describes himself as feeling the energy flow out of him (to the point of being unable to continue the healing) and the recipients describe the energy as flowing into them (some actually describing the energy flowing up the arm to the location of the illness or disorder). If his claim of energy transfer is true, then he is indeed stepping beyond the borders of science into an unknown area. While it might be possible that this newly discovered energy could eventually be described and understood by science, right now such an energy transfer is outside the scientific realm.

But this claim is not based on anything unusual or unexpected. The sensation of "energy" or "warmth" or "electricity" flowing into and out of someone is common and does not depend upon an actual flow of energy. The sensation of being drained is common and not necessarily related to the type or kind of exertion. Pain and relief of pain are not necessarily indicative of pathology and subsequent reversal of that pathology. Subjective sensations are influenced and generated by processes which may have nothing to do with the actual functioning of the body. Subjective sensations provide no support one way or the other for a claim that defies the known laws of nature.

Yes, any demonstrable supernatural claim would have the power to revolutionize science. Which makes stating it here in this thread redundant.

Linda
 
[/quote]
But this claim is not based on anything unusual or unexpected. The sensation of "energy" or "warmth" or "electricity" flowing into and out of someone is common and does not depend upon an actual flow of energy. The sensation of being drained is common and not necessarily related to the type or kind of exertion. Pain and relief of pain are not necessarily indicative of pathology and subsequent reversal of that pathology. Subjective sensations are influenced and generated by processes which may have nothing to do with the actual functioning of the body. Subjective sensations provide no support one way or the other for a claim that defies the known laws of nature.

Yes, any demonstrable supernatural claim would have the power to revolutionize science. Which makes stating it here in this thread redundant.

Linda[/quote]

Hi Linda,
Please could you validate the above comment based upon proven medical research and not say, someone elses opinion. What you appear to be saying is precisely that.

To EH Hocking.

You are offering yourself as a volunteer? I will PM you today. Just one more detail. Whoever I demonstrate this ability on has to have. a) A noticeable medical condition such as swelling, or..
b) Some medical record to validate that they are indeed ill with the condition I am asked demonstrate on.
That request is simply there to prevent someone claiming they have a condition which is not visually obvious with the intent to claim I am a fraud.
I am not suggesting for one moment that is anyones intent. But I need to ensure fairness.
 
Last edited:
Psychic Physicist.

I had predicted earlier in the thread that you would disappear, indignant, in the face of suggested protocols to test your abilities.

I was wrong. You're still here and still arguing your corner and trying to communicate.

Good on you mate. I'd love to see something thrashed out and get a result.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom