Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

Psychic Physicist

New Blood
Joined
Sep 28, 2006
Messages
15
Hi All,
Having for years admired the work of James Randi with his logical and well thought exposures of the varied shysters and fraudsters of the psychic world, I decided it was time that I joined this forum.
I am unfortunately standing with my feet in either camp on the question of the existence of real psychic phenomena. On one side I realise only too well that there are a lot of clever conmen and women who walk the psychic plank. I have had unfortunate dealings with some and know only too well the lengths that these individuals will go to in their quest for personal or financial gratification.
I hold no subscription of belief in any of the established or `new age` religions, and in fact view the majority as being created by the same type of individuals who now adorn many mystic mags and TV programs as `mystics` or `mediums`.
To me, religion is all about mind control, with the imposition of a minority viewpoint upon a gullible majority.
However I digress. On the other foot, I know that all life and our existence are not plainly and easily explainable with quick scientific fixes.
An easy illustration is the age old mind bender which asks, `Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist?
Not even a sceptic can answer that one.
Another problem I have to contend with rails firmly against sceptical opinion or indifference. That simply is the fact that I have a `gift` or ability that allows me to `heal` or improve peoples physical ailments by the action of simply touching their fingers on point of contact.
I have been aware of this ability for some considerable time and have much anecdotal evidence which I gathered over the years to satisfy my own scepticism.
I have to tell you that I am a retired cop with 28 years service in the British Police. A number of those service years were spent as a detective and later as a police crime analyst and researcher. That type of work involved intelligence scepticism until I could finalisemy investigations by producing hard facts which could be used in police operations against organised or local criminal activity. So there is the sceptic in me. Until I can satisfy any claim, I have to have hard facts.
That’s where Mr Randi`s challenge intrigues me.
I am not drawn by financial reward to his challenge, but am motivated simply by the fact that not all alleged psychic phenomena are false. To dismiss this entirely is not scepticism but ignorance.
A true sceptic keeps an open mind, and I have always endeavoured to adhere to that notion.
I first discovered this ability around 10 years ago when a partner complained of a re-occurring pain in her knee joint. On one occasion I placed my hand over the knee to rub it, and she reported that energy from my hand had travelled to the affected area and had warmed an area deep inside her knee which completely removed the pain.
I naturally thought it pure chance but decided to follow through by testing this ability on other people’s ailments. Within a year, I had managed to work with 10 people from work to friends who although at first sceptical stated that a warm energy had travelled through their bodies to soothe away muscular pains or swellings.
The strangest experience was a woman police officer with a badly swollen hand which literally disappeared after five minutes. That in a way shocked me as I (despite evidence to the contrary) still didn’t fully believe in my own ability!
Anyway, after satisfying my own curiosity, I didn’t return to healing until very recently when a guest speaker at a conference I was attending didn’t show.
I volunteered to talk about healing to a fifty plus adult audience to entertain them. I was approached by five volunteers, four women and a man.
The first was complaining of a long term pain in her swollen wrist and shoulder.
After literally a few seconds of finger contact she reported the same healing energy moving up her hands and into her shoulder. She claimed that the pain her gone. Also her wrist had returned to normal from its swollen state.
The second volunteer – the man had a sharp pain in his shoulder allegedly from an old motorcycle accident. On point of contact he exclaimed the pain had disappeared. I found that implausible from previous experience but not impossible.
The third had pain under her right arm which had persisted for some months. That too went after a few seconds. By the time I started on the 4th – a lady with a stomach ulcer, the others I had previously dealt with claimed that as I touched a new volunteer, they could feel the healing energy return as though I was touching them again. This was something very new to me. - This lady’s pain incidentally, went as quickly as the others. The last volunteer was a lady with short rasping breath who was emotionally upset and complained that diagnosed growths or `polyps` in her throat was impeding her breathing and that she awaited an operation to remove them. As I touched her, she exclaimed that the energy was in her throat having travelled up her arm from finger contact, and that she `felt` her throat being widened to a degree that she could now breath clearly. To date, I none have reported a relapse with the exception of the lady with the wrist injury who informed me that although her shoulder was fine, some pain had returned to her wrist – but not as painfully as before. She explained further that she had engaged in heavy work with her hands that involved bending her wrist whilst holding heavily weighted items. I am certain that had she allowed her hand to recuperate properly, the pain would have gone.
So to round things up, Where does this lead me? Am I deluded, are were they deluded? Was it as they say, a `placebo effect`, or is it genuinely possible that this healing is real, and more importantly, another natural aspect of the human process?
I can add that since I first started healing, my palms are permanently red, and they feel incredibly hot. When measured by a thermometer, they are registered at normal body temperature. As I type this open response they still feel very hot indeed.
So, should I take up the Randi challenge? If I did it would not be simply a quest for a million bucks, but an illustration that not all life on this planet is without some form of `spiritual` - call it what you will, experience.
Your thoughts please would be appreciated. I am quite willing to demonstrate this process. Whether I `win` or `lose`, is quite immaterial to me, but even if I could demonstrate this process I doubt whether I would succeed - after all, no one else has..
 
Last edited:
Your thoughts please would be appreciated. I am quite willing to demonstrate this process. Whether I `win` or `lose`, is quite immaterial to me, but even if I could demonstrate this process I doubt whether I would succeed - after all, no one else has.

PP, I assure you that if you can demonstrate this process, you will indeed succeed. Not only will you win a million dollars but you will help usher in an entirely new understanding of medicine and physics.

It is usually impractical to create a protocol where you actually heal people, however. Do you think that if you held your hand behind a screen, a friend of yours could determine whether your hand was there or not? If you are giving off energy, this might be possible. Then it would be simple to place you behind a screen, have it randomly determined whether you place your hand out or not, and then ask your friend if it is there or not. I am sure something along the lines of 9 right guesses out of 10 would be sufficient to guarantee you a million dollars.

Let's see what others think.
 
Hi Loss Leader,
Thanks for your response. If (by a miracle) I could succeed in a controlled demonstration, the money would be given to charity. I am more interested in opening awareness that some psychic ability is real. I know it works, but the public need to be assured that it is possible, and not ridiculed by the idle ramblings of lunatics and opportunists.
 
Last edited:
Steven Howard: is comments like yours that debase discussion. I had a chuckle also, but what purpose does your comment serve?

As regards the protocol: what if the ailment is actually a requisite to perceive the healing? It would appear to me that Loss Leader's proposed protocol would be inconclusive. Maybe 10 or possibly more patients touched at random by the claimant and a control person in a setting able to exclude other sensory clues (heath, sight etc.) would be more decisive. You can work out the statistics.
 
You should absolutely take up the Randi challenge. Read and learn about how the challenge works and how you can contact the JREF (Jeff Wagg apparently) and start discussions on a meeting and a challenge. You will likely be directed to one of the local British skeptic groups that works closely with the JREF for a preliminary challenge. (Which no one has ever passed).

Do you know a lot about how the challenge works? How the procedure of applying works? The rules for applying? If not then you should read up on it from the randi.org main page which links to info about the challenge including FAQ's and whatnot.
 
The presence or absence of pain can be highly subjective. Perhaps as ThinkTooMuch suggests, a protocol might be designed like a small scale "clinical trial". X number of subjects suffering from headache (or similar noncritical ailment) X number of controls, and a double blind methodology?
 
Though I may disagree with the assertion that the supernatural must exist because science cannot easily answer everything, I think you should take the challenge. As for the exact circumstances of the test, it would depend on if you need to physically touch people, but Loss Leader's idea is good, and you would be able to agree on the specifics of the challenge.
 
Something occurred but the question is did you actually heal anyone? To define this you would need to have a specific diagnosis and then specific proof they were actually healed. I think the majority of healers are like you who think they are doing something but once studied will be shown to not be doing anything other than making people feel better about themselves.
 
Though I may disagree with the assertion that the supernatural must exist because science cannot easily answer everything, I think you should take the challenge.

My sentiments exactly.

Follow the advice that previous posters have given and come up with a precise description of what you can and cannot do.
 
...An easy illustration is the age old mind bender which asks, `Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist?Not even a sceptic can answer that one...

Sure I can. When I read a load of gibberish like your post, I stop when it meets my bull manure threshold and say to myself, "This cretin knows nothing about logic or presenting an arguement."
 
Jeff, since when insulting is a knowledgeable way of presenting an argument? This appears to me as the pot calling the kettle black. Are all your >4000 posts of this quality?
 
... I know that all life and our existence are not plainly and easily explainable with quick scientific fixes....
Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist?

Hi and welcome to the forum Psychic Physicist.

Yes, many things are currently unexplained,
but this is not a reason to invent weird explanations, you see ...
I exist; and "We don need yer stinkin universe!"
Regardless of our comprehension or definition of the universe, we exist.

LossLeader proposes an excellent test.
What do you think about it PP?
Lets get focussed on that easy million.
 
First off welcome to the forum!
Your on a wild world of discovery and great discussion here.

However I digress. On the other foot, I know that all life and our existence are not plainly and easily explainable with quick scientific fixes.

But remember science is constantly refining itself. It evolves as we evolve and discover new ways to measure and record more accurate and reliable data. You must remove thoughts that science is some evil big brother, arrogant and ignorant. Science is completely and utterly neutral. Its not something with feelings or morals, its a method to understand things. I dont like this sentence because most people who say it repeat this mantra because they dont understand and appreciate the real method behind science and how important the method is.

An easy illustration is the age old mind bender which asks, `Where does the universe end or begin – in terms of size and distance?` Because logically, if there is no comprehendible end or beginning, how can we exist? Not even a sceptic can answer that one.

Its not so simple. There is evidence that suggests things started at a specific point. How that became to start with and how it progressed further is beyond my understanding, but that does not mean the information is non existant. What you dont know is what you dont know, not what no one else knows. I think I just confused myself.

Another problem I have to contend with rails firmly against sceptical opinion or indifference. That simply is the fact that I have a `gift` or ability that allows me to `heal` or improve peoples physical ailments by the action of simply touching their fingers on point of contact...have much anecdotal evidence...

Anecdotal yes, factual it is not. It's a bold claim that you posess an ability that will rewrite the science books. But im all eyes and ears.

I have to tell you that I am a retired cop with 28 years service in the British Police. A number of those service years were spent as a detective and later as a police crime analyst and researcher. That type of work involved intelligence scepticism until I could finalise my investigations by producing hard facts which could be used in police operations against organised or local criminal activity. So there is the sceptic in me. Until I can satisfy any claim, I have to have hard facts.

This does suprise me. One of the appealing things I find with this line of work is to get to the facts. However I think your trying to appeal to authority to add weight to your arguement. Its going to hit a brick wall under scientific scrutiny. Check out what einstein himself said was his biggest blunder, and thats einstein - and he would have thanked science for showing him.

...but am motivated simply by the fact that not all alleged psychic phenomena are false. To dismiss this entirely is not scepticism but ignorance. A true sceptic keeps an open mind, and I have always endeavoured to adhere to that notion...

I dont like these grey lines people like to blur in order to make a claim sound more credible. Evidence not philosophy. Im completely open but after 60 years of research, im starting to wonder why people persist.

I first discovered this ability around 10 years ago when a partner complained of a re-occurring pain in her knee joint. On one occasion I placed my hand over the knee to rub it, and she reported that energy from my hand had travelled to the affected area and had warmed an area deep inside her knee which completely removed the pain.

If I said you rubbing my knee made me feel some sort of sexual advance, would that be your healing power or some other weird power. This is completely vague evidence explainable is many mundane and unfortunately boring ways. I have seen elsewhere on here about tests using prayer etc and how a nice voice and soothing touch can make a big difference.

...<stories of healing>...So to round things up, Where does this lead me? Am I deluded, are were they deluded? Was it as they say, a `placebo effect`, or is it genuinely possible that this healing is real, and more importantly, another natural aspect of the human process?...So, should I take up the Randi challenge? If I did it would not be simply a quest for a million bucks, but an illustration that not all life on this planet is without some form of `spiritual` - call it what you will, experience...I am quite willing to demonstrate this process. Whether I `win` or `lose`, is quite immaterial to me, but even if I could demonstrate this process I doubt whether I would succeed - after all, no one else has..

I have a proposal.

1) 20 volunteers. They are told and are believers in faith healing.
you and someone else - like me (I think its just emotion and a kind heart that is helping)

2) the 20 dont see each other but are told a faith healer will come in and help them with their various ailments.

3) We would take it in turns to approach the people. one at a time, no one repeated - so I would take 1, you 2, me the third, you the 4th etc, so we get 10 each, making sure none of the volunteers can give away anything about their suspicions by...using seperate rooms? They should not have any idea if its done properly and well out of sight, in a good test they will think you or I are the person they want to heal them.

4) We both use a same method - whatever that is - perhaps pretend to pray to god or whatever. A touch on the knee etc. Be sure its exactly the same.

5) Record results. Have a results grading sheet (level of healing felt), same for every person on test.

6) Now do the same for 20 more this time, you give them what they believe is a healing device. Lets say a simple iron rod. We will need 20 of these to ensure there is no mixing of 'powers' For each second person you get, you touch this device, the other time its left alone. Every person is told the iron rod has been touched by a healer.

7) Record results. Have a results grading sheet (level of healing felt), same for every person on test.

8) Another 20 people. Given an iron rod again, this time Neither of us touch it. They people are all told the rods are bestowed with magic healing powers.

9) Record results. Have a results grading sheet (level of healing felt), same for every person on test.

The only hassle is the amount of people :(

My thoughts
Cheers
 
Hmmm I just thought of an easier way.
20 people all believers

Frist run of 20, you touch and heal. Second run of the same 20, given untouched iron rods, told that you enforced some powers of yours onto it during some amazing ritual. See if they feel your presence.

I know someone will think of a better way. Perhaps this thread should be in the million dollar challenge?

Compare results.
 
PsyP,

Your talent is in a difficult place for testing. A bit in the gray area due to the subjective elements of it. I lot of it is relational in nature, having to do with the interpersonal elements between you and the person you are touching.
Touch when given with confidence, care, and a nonjudgemental acceptance of the other, engages the parasympathetic nervous system to varying degrees. The nervous system opporates in two complementary fuctional areas: The Sympathetic and the Parasympathetic. The Sympathetic controls stress functions such as fight or flight in danger, and exertion. The Parasympathetic controls relaxation, sleep, digestion, intimacy, and the release of endorphins that block pain and some cases create feelings of euphoria.

This adds up to what I call a "heightened placebo effect." It's not merely that the individual believes you are helping him or her, but you have a charisma about you and your touch that relaxes, sooths, resolves painful tension. When the body isn't in fight or flight, it puts more attention on recovery.

As I said, it's touchy to test this, because we are dealing with individual emotional responses. Tests on this in regard to Theraputic Touch have shown merely that peole tend to react positively to nice personal contact. Beyond that results have been marginal.

This subject usually gets sidetracked by talk of mysterious "energies."
People do have feelings that they describe as electric like or heat like. These are subjective experiences. One person will describe the touch as electric, another as warm, another as a kind of pressure or movement. Some even go into more relaxed states and see or hear things. Never mind that sort of stuff for now. Testing for mysterious energies misses what's actually afoot.

What you are doing is great. Keep it up. Just understand that it's not actually something paranormal or supernatural.
 
Last edited:
PsyP,

Your talent is in a difficult place for testing. A bit in the gray area due to the subjective elements of it. I lot of it is relational in nature, having to do with the interpersonal elements between you and the person you are touching.
Touch when given with confidence, care, and a nonjudgemental acceptance of the other, engages the parasympathetic nervous system to varying degrees. The nervous system opporates in two complementary fuctional areas: The Sympathetic and the Parasympathetic. The Sympathetic controls stress functions such as fight or flight in danger, and exertion. The Parasympathetic controls relaxation, sleep, digestion, intimacy, and the release of endorphins that block pain and some cases creta feelings of euphoria.

This adds up to what I call a "hightened placebo effect." It's not merely that the individual believes you are helping him or her, but you have a charisma about you and your touch that relaxes, sooths, resolves painful tension. When the body isn't in fight or flight, it puts more attention on recovery.

As I said, it's touchy to test this, because we are dealing with individual emotional responses. Tests on this in regard to Theraputic Touch have shown merely that peole tend to react positively to nice personal contact. Beyond that results have been marginal.

This subject usually gets sidetracked by talk of mysterious "energies."
People do have feelings that they describe as electric like or heat like. These are subjective experiences. One person will describe the touch as electric, another as warm, another as a kind of pressure or movement. Some even go into more relaxed states and see or hear things. Never mind that sort of stuff for now. Testing for mysterious energies misses what's actually afoot.

What you are doing is great. Keep it up. Just understand that it's not actually something paranormal or supernatural.


I take back that its explained in mundane and boring ways!
Is this an evident nervous system effect?
 
I take back that its explained in mundane and boring ways!
Is this an evident nervous system effect?

Indeed mundane. It happens all the time between mothers and children, friends and lovers. Massage Therapists use this all the time. Some people inspire more confidence with their touch, and people who make it an intent touch others in a "healing" way have more stories and experiences to share. You could do this yourself. It's really not that special.
Just that our culture isn't touchy-feely.

NB I'm not talking about miracle healing here. This is common garden variety ease of aches and pains brought on by muscle tension and contraction, and other things the body does when it is in trama.

This is a simplification, but do a little online research about the parasympathetic nervous system and endorphins.
As I said, all this gets mystified. All we need here is some dimystification.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom