Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

I haven`t referred to it, but the statement made concerning the universe - that was a deliberate red herring. You certainly passed the test and satisfied my own curiosity. Thankyou..
What were you trying to test? The proposition that if you deliberately and prominantly included a piece of utter bollocks in your first post on the forum some people might not take you seriously?

Perhaps the fact that you admittedly started this thread with a post that was not in good faith tells us more about you than people's reactions to it tells you about "skeptics".
 
Hi Ladewig,

No, I`m not angry, just saddened by some of the rude responses of the forums contributors. Is there a need to trade insults?? That doesn`t strike me as a logical response?
I realise that my claims need to be properly analysed, but there has to be a measure of understanding of how I can best demonstrate it, and the suggestions I have detailed here ( seem to me), to best cover that. I don`t think them unreasonable and they can be tailored to suit some aspects of what has been proposed.
It seems perfectly fine to be rude and insulting by some of the sceptic contributors, but if I offer a robust defense, I am the one who is out of line. An example of your post - `more angry accusations snipped for length` Huh? Was I shouting and banging my fists?
Another observation of mine is that there is a tendency to place some contributors into pre-defined boxes by comparing me, for example, to other previous contributors rather than to accept that we as humans are all individually dfferent.
That is the fundamental flaw with some scientific doctrine. Rather than open minds to new arguments or views, it is easier to pre-categorise everything and everyone.

As I have said, I am only too happy to take part in a test but it has to be in an acceptable format to both parties.
I used this forum as a soundboard, and I am satisfied with what I have learnt. But as you and the others here won`t individually be testing me on the big day, any argument over the criteria laid down for evaluating my claims is as they say, quite academic.
The point of my challenge is not to give a two fingered salute to academic opinion, but to open up the possibility that there are other facets to our existence rather than a bland boring ideological view point that there isn`t.
I will say Ladewig that your opinions have generally been well balanced and impartial, but the comments of some others here have been insulting and exhibiting extreme prejudice. Anyway, I must move on and await what happens further on this proposition.


 
To Mojo.

I found this thread from another forum on existence. More enligtening than your response of `bollox`.

Ask yourself this question. Why does anything exist at all? Since we exist, was there ever a point where it didn’t exist? In other words, was there a point where nothing existed at all? If that is so, why and how did something ever come about? In other words if it is truly absolute nothingness, how could something ever come about? For something to come about there would seem to have to be some kind of burbling causation, a vortices or minimal 'something' that gave rise to further complexity, ultimately yielding the complex universe we have today. The question can be summed up as this:

How do we get something from nothing?

Part of the problem with the above thinking is that it implies the existence of time. Yet, we know that time, as least as we understand it is a function of space. According to the big bang/inflationary theory of the origin of our universe, both time and space were created simultaneously with the big bang. This of course always brings up the question, of what happened before the big bang? If time was created at the big bang, then there was no ‘time’ before the big bang. If that is the case, then what that implies is that the big bang is an extrusion out of an always existent, simultaneous, no-time (eternity) super-space. Or we could say that the big bang simply popped out of void. So did it either pop out of Void, or did it pop out of eternal everythingness? Either way, we are still caught in this ‘time’ thing. And that is the trap that we must transcend. So what are we left with? No time.

Therefore if the underlying meta-reality is that there is no time, then concepts like beginning and end have no meaning. Time is something that pops in and out of existence. Existence then is grounded in no time. Without time, what you are left with is something that has always existed and always will. It is the eternal now.

Now to our next topic – the laws of the universe. We again start with the same question. Why does anything exist at all? Since it does exist, why does it have the shape and form it does? Why not a different shape? We can of course say these shapes and forms are determined by physical law. But then the question becomes where did these physical laws come from? Why did our universe with all of its complexity come out of the big bang exactly as it did, and not some way else? When you examine in detail our physical laws, it quickly becomes apparent just how damn arbitrary it all is. For example, why is it that the electron to proton mass ratio is 1836, and not 1835, or 478? For one thing, if it weren’t exactly that ratio, matter as we know it would fly apart, and we would not have the periodic table of elements. No carbon, no humans. No humans, we don’t exist to even ask these questions. In other words, only those universes in which intelligent life can evolve, exist in the first place to even ask themselves how amazingly fine-tuned the constants are for them to exist! What this implies is that there billions, trillions of other universes where intelligence never evolves. Where the constants are arranged in such a way, that complexity can never emerge. This line of thinking is what is called The Anthropic Principle. I recommend reading up on it – it’s fascinating.

The opposite of this is that only those universes that evolve complex life exist? Why? Is there some greater intelligence guiding or designing it that way? Perhaps. But then where did that intelligence come from? Either way we are back to the utter arbitrariness of anything existing at all. So what we are left with, since we have ‘no time’ as a backdrop, is that everything already exists, has existed and will always exist.
 
Psychic Physicist
I don't know if you are genuine or not, but we should give you a fair go.
I do find unfortunately some skeptics are as dogmatic and close minded as any believer in superstition, Creationist, fundamentalists etc, etc.
 
I thought I did.This guy is an idiot.
This is the man that Corey refers too as an `idiot`.

This is exactly why Psychic Physicist went off in a huff. I don't blame him, I would do the same.

As soon as PsyP read this comment, then all other comments /debates appeared hostile.

I thought for one moment that we may have a thread that was unique from the normal sceptic arguing with sceptic.

We all have a right to an opinion and to voice that opinion. We do not have the right to insult someone just because their beliefs differ from ours - whatever we think of that belief.

I know that it was just one insult from one person but that's all it takes.

What happens to Jeff Corey? Anything or nothing? Is the forum policy to tolerate different beliefs or to tolerate the intolerant? I just want to know whether I should find somewhere else to hang out.

The proposition that if you deliberately and prominantly included a piece of utter bollocks in your first post on the forum some people might not take you seriously?

Mojo, you know as well as I that PsyP is upset. PsyP is just angry and reacting angrily. If he wasn't so angry he might have said something like "On second thoughts maybe I could have used a better example." Just read his reaction to the request to space out his paragraphs. The guy is just pissed.

I can't find the post, but someone once described the life cycle of these posts, going something like:
1. Person makes a vague claim of abilities
2. JREFrs try and condense this to a few simple testable sentences
3. Person leaves in a huff

Stewartp, this is not what happened. The guy was insulted and reacted like a person who had been insulted. And you know this!
He was called an idiot and had to suffer niggling comments like
for example, "I can only do it on Thursdays after having eaten a turkey sandwich" or something like that.
This is the reason for the short life cycle, perhaps the same happened on previous occasions.

He has been pissed off and he has pissed off.

Whatever my personal opinions, I was hoping to learn something from PsyP. Now I cannot.

So now what can I learn? Nothing.

Karl Quigley
 
Stewartp, this is not what happened. The guy was insulted and reacted like a person who had been insulted. And you know this!
He was called an idiot and had to suffer niggling comments like

This is the reason for the short life cycle, perhaps the same happened on previous occasions.

He has been pissed off and he has pissed off.

Whatever my personal opinions, I was hoping to learn something from PsyP. Now I cannot.

So now what can I learn? Nothing.

Karl Quigley
Karl, perhaps you are right. We went thru the same autopsy and analysis after the PinkLady thread. People would have liked to have had a longer and deeper dialogue to find out more about her beliefs and thoughts and processes. We went through much soul searching and chest beating about how we could have better responded. believe me, this thread has been positively ladies tea party in comparison.

Perhaps it is the insult that the cause, or perhaps it is the insult that is gratefully taken as an excuse to leave in high dudgeon when as the logical application of test protocals start to make it apparant that reality is drawing too close.

I too think it would be helpful if diologue was continued in a civilised, calm and respectful manner.

But I suspect we could get to the same conclusion, only it would take 200 posts instead of 30
 
But I suspect we could get to the same conclusion, only it would take 200 posts instead of 30

And in the 200 posts, we'd have the opportunity to get over the sound bytes and misleading frames.
In the case of this subject, ordinary human psycho-somatic effects that could use a lot more investigation are paranormalized or chalked up as mere delusion.
"Paranormal" is more sensational. "Delusional" is more sensational. People get excited with the frames. A Skeptic wants to know, "What's really going on here?"
 
Psychic Physicist, I think you should know that there are going to be changes in the acceptance of the applicants for the challenge. As I understand it (someone correct if I'm wrong) the applicants are going to be chosen based on their public profile. The more in the public eye the applicant is, the more chance of acceptance.
If I am right about this, you may find that you are not accepted for the challenge. Although, as you have applied before the changes have been announced, this might not apply.

My point in telling you this is that should your application not be accepted (or if you decide not to take the challenge after all), I would like you to keep a presence here for further discussions.

One other thing I thought about was, as you seem quite sceptical in other matters; had you thought about actually testing yourself? You seem clear as to the necessary procedures required to give a fair result. If you could find someone to act as placebo and found some volunteers who did not know you. It's just a thought, especially as you agree that there might be "conventional" reasons for your healing abilities. Should you find that your abilities are not actual healing powers you would save yourself the hardship and scrutiny (and listing in the "chamber of horrors"). If your self testing reaffirmed your belief in your healing abilities, you may find this beneficial to your confidence when facing the challenge (if accepted).

Kind regards

Karl Quigley
 
First off welcome to the forum!
Your on a wild world of discovery and great discussion here.



But remember science is constantly refining itself. It evolves as we evolve and discover new ways to measure and record more accurate and reliable data. You must remove thoughts that science is some evil big brother, arrogant and ignorant. Science is completely and utterly neutral. Its not something with feelings or morals, its a method to understand things. I dont like this sentence because most people who say it repeat this mantra because they dont understand and appreciate the real method behind science and how important the method is.



Its not so simple. There is evidence that suggests things started at a specific point. How that became to start with and how it progressed further is beyond my understanding, but that does not mean the information is non existant. What you dont know is what you dont know, not what no one else knows. I think I just confused myself.



Anecdotal yes, factual it is not. It's a bold claim that you posess an ability that will rewrite the science books. But im all eyes and ears.



This does suprise me. One of the appealing things I find with this line of work is to get to the facts. However I think your trying to appeal to authority to add weight to your arguement. Its going to hit a brick wall under scientific scrutiny. Check out what einstein himself said was his biggest blunder, and thats einstein - and he would have thanked science for showing him.



I dont like these grey lines people like to blur in order to make a claim sound more credible. Evidence not philosophy. Im completely open but after 60 years of research, im starting to wonder why people persist.



If I said you rubbing my knee made me feel some sort of sexual advance, would that be your healing power or some other weird power. This is completely vague evidence explainable is many mundane and unfortunately boring ways. I have seen elsewhere on here about tests using prayer etc and how a nice voice and soothing touch can make a big difference.



I have a proposal.

1) 20 volunteers. They are told and are believers in faith healing.
you and someone else - like me (I think its just emotion and a kind heart that is helping)

2) the 20 dont see each other but are told a faith healer will come in and help them with their various ailments.

3) We would take it in turns to approach the people. one at a time, no one repeated - so I would take 1, you 2, me the third, you the 4th etc, so we get 10 each, making sure none of the volunteers can give away anything about their suspicions by...using seperate rooms? They should not have any idea if its done properly and well out of sight, in a good test they will think you or I are the person they want to heal them.

4) We both use a same method - whatever that is - perhaps pretend to pray to god or whatever. A touch on the knee etc. Be sure its exactly the same.

5) Record results. Have a results grading sheet (level of healing felt), same for every person on test.

6) Now do the same for 20 more this time, you give them what they believe is a healing device. Lets say a simple iron rod. We will need 20 of these to ensure there is no mixing of 'powers' For each second person you get, you touch this device, the other time its left alone. Every person is told the iron rod has been touched by a healer.

7) Record results. Have a results grading sheet (level of healing felt), same for every person on test.

8) Another 20 people. Given an iron rod again, this time Neither of us touch it. They people are all told the rods are bestowed with magic healing powers.

9) Record results. Have a results grading sheet (level of healing felt), same for every person on test.

The only hassle is the amount of people :(

My thoughts
Cheers



Take 20 people and whack em in the knee with an iron rod, but tell them that the rod is a rod of god's power and they will be better for it in the end.


Now take 20 people and touch them on the knee and tell them that the warmth they feel is the breath of satan.


Who will walk away without a limp?
 
Just a final thought.. Try to get out more. You might find that the outside world is more challenging than you think.

condescend much?

arrogance and ignorance

are mached in perfect harmony

(ebony and ivory)
 
Take 20 people and whack em in the knee with an iron rod, but tell them that the rod is a rod of god's power and they will be better for it in the end.


Now take 20 people and touch them on the knee and tell them that the warmth they feel is the breath of satan.


Who will walk away without a limp?

condescend much?

arrogance and ignorance

are mached in perfect harmony

(ebony and ivory)

PsyP, you can see by the above quotes that unfortunately there are the few who hop from thread to thread, sprouting out inane comments in the belief that they are contributing. They believe that they can throw out one-liners all over the forum in the belief that we will gasp at their comprehension and deep knowledge in every subject. They believe we are in awe of their fast thinking meaningful abilities. They believe we do not think they are full of it.

...and these very same people will criticise your beliefs.

Mind you, anyone who does not take the time to read over what they have typed, or knows how to use a spell-checker, does not really deserve much attention. And that is exactly my advice, ignore the few and concentrate on those with intelligent input.

We feel the same way as you do about them.

Kind Regards

karl Quigley
 
Yes, Jeff, we are all human. Ask yourself this, though, and be honest: would the forum be better without Karl or without you?
 
Mojo, you know as well as I that PsyP is upset. PsyP is just angry and reacting angrily. If he wasn't so angry he might have said something like "On second thoughts maybe I could have used a better example." Just read his reaction to the request to space out his paragraphs. The guy is just pissed.
But what reason did he have to be pissed off with me? I have no control over what anyone else posts. Until he became actually hostile, all I did was to try to suggest ways he could present an acceptable challenge, based on what he had posted. When I realised I had misread what he had posted, I admitted this, and changed my suggestion accordingly. I assumed that he was sincere, and responded accordingly.

What else can you do?
 
Yes, Jeff, we are all human. Ask yourself this, though, and be honest: would the forum be better without Karl or without you?

I don't know, but anyone who fails to see the irony of making a mistake while criticizing others for making the same mistake is incredibily dense.
 
Last edited:
Absolutely true. But most people who see the irony do not feel the need to prove to themselves how smart they are by making an unproductive sarcastic comment.
 
I personally don`t feel I am an idiot, but like my healing claims, it all boils down to belief and opinion......

........To conclude, I really don`t give a toss what you think, I suggest that you show respect for others that don`t subscribe to your alleged empirical assertions of anything you really don't understand. That is made plainly obvious by the manner under which you feel these tests should be made.

So much for thoughtful debate. I`ve obviously arrived at the wrong forum!

PS: I haven`t referred to it, but the statement made concerning the universe - that was a deliberate red herring. You certainly passed the test and satisfied my own curiosity. Thankyou..
(Bolding mine)

Ok, Mr. Pommy, ex-Cop Psychic Healer bloke.

You come into a sceptics' forum, start off by telling us you're a psychic healer, make idiot statements about the universe, slag off all the "fraudulent psychics" and then expect to gain respect? I thought you were psychic! (joke, mate!)

Only one way to gain respect around here - take and pass the challenge. I'll leave it with JREF for now as you've already completed an application, but I have my doubts that it will ever be sent in. If it is, and you have trouble sorting out protocols, I'm sure we can overcome them, so let me know.

Meanwhile, my reading shows:


but I'll give you a fair go. Being a pom, you'd have heard the old expression about enough rope? I'll make damned sure you have plenty!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom