Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

I have known about Shiatsu for 30+ years (useful to recover from judo training - I can still fix a stiff neck with it) but had no idea that it was "energy" therapy. I have a book (Tokujiro Namikoshi, Shiatsu, Japan Publications Inc. Tokio 1969) where the author, self-proclaimed number 1 of Japanese shiatsu teaching, claims its ability to improve a lot of bodily functions but attributes its effectiveness to the pressure of muscles enabling the dispersion of lactic acid. No mention at all of acupunture points.

Was this just pandering to western ideas to make money out of the gaijin?
Is this explanation scientifically sound?
 
Psychic Physicist and Hyparxis, I just to want to say Thanks. I've appreciated your taking the time to discuss dispassionately what you've experienced. Hyparxis - did you experience the same fatigue after sessions that PP did?

At times, but mostly not. After most sessions I'd feel invigorated myself.
I don't know enough about PsyP's practice to understand why he would feel drained most of the time. There are a number of factors in this. One is becomming too emotionally identified with the client. Most Massage Practioners will tell you that have to maintain emotional boundaries, so as not to get drawn into a client's "stuff." Also the intensity of it seems to require one be in a good state of health and hormonal balance. Speaking figurativly one shouldn't be draining their own "energy," but resourcing it from the cosmos. That kind of talk doesn't coresspond to any objectively existing forces , but I do find that using my imagination that way helps give me an attitude that doesn't leave me whacked out. Another absurd but useful exercise is to imagine a grounding cord that draws off the so-called "negative energy."
This works for me as well. But again understand I'm not talking science here. I'm talking about emotional interactions and the imaginative metaphors that are used in connection with them. All this enhealing energy talk is a contextual language not a discription of physical realities. It requires no more surrender to woo-woo than reading Harry Potter.
 
I have known about Shiatsu for 30+ years (useful to recover from judo training - I can still fix a stiff neck with it) but had no idea that it was "energy" therapy. I have a book (Tokujiro Namikoshi, Shiatsu, Japan Publications Inc. Tokio 1969) where the author, self-proclaimed number 1 of Japanese shiatsu teaching, claims its ability to improve a lot of bodily functions but attributes its effectiveness to the pressure of muscles enabling the dispersion of lactic acid. No mention at all of acupunture points.

Was this just pandering to western ideas to make money out of the gaijin?
Is this explanation scientifically sound?

It soumds like he's looking for a way to distance himself from the traditional Chinese framwork about Acupuncture, Acupressure, and Shiatsu that it works with points of qi flow on meridians. I can well understand his desire to abandon the Qi stuff.

I was taught Shiatsu Qi and all including the Five Elements Theory.
It's all rather occult with its system of associations. In the end it's another kind of emotional code. These are all, in my opinon, somatic therapies having to do with the relationships between emotions and the body. They do influence each other back and forth, sometimes to remarkable degrees.
The immune system is very sensitive to emotional attitude. However, when there's a bad bug around, a happy face won't necessarily keep you from getting it. There is enough medical research now that verifies emotions do influnence rate of recovery. Also people with chronic depression do tend to be more suspectible to physical pathologies. But of course, we've known about psycho-somatics for over a hundred years.

Our emotional lives make languages of their own for purposes other than Physics. It's one of the reasons we have poetry, music, and art.
 
To EH Hocking.

You are offering yourself as a volunteer? I will PM you today. Just one more detail. Whoever I demonstrate this ability on has to have. a) A noticeable medical condition such as swelling, or..
b) Some medical record to validate that they are indeed ill with the condition I am asked demonstrate on.
That request is simply there to prevent someone claiming they have a condition which is not visually obvious with the intent to claim I am a fraud.
I am not suggesting for one moment that is anyones intent. But I need to ensure fairness.
Just a quick response to the thread. Psychic Physicist and I have been exchanging PMs to see if we can tee up a demonstration. I've suggested that an independent observer would be handy to cover just the sort of qualms he's mentioned above.

Without pre-empting any further correspondence between us, is there anyone out there in London area that would be willing to observe?

I think it would be better that it was someone from the forum that neither of us know - and I'd like to discuss the nature of the demonstration in public too, since a number of people here have been involved with Challenge protocol discussions.

Note - this is only a "private" demonstration for my own curiosity, unrelated to PP's Challenge application. On that score, I'd hope that any discussion on "protocol" is approached "in good faith" and we go for a simple demonstration of what he proposes he can do.

I have further questions on just what we might be able to test/demonstrate but want to straighten that out in PMs with PP first, so as not to misrepresent his case, in my enthusiasm.

So - first - anyone available for "impartial observer"?
 
If medical science has known about this for years, why is it nor available on the NHS? Further, why does so much `informed` medical opinion rail against it?

I don't know if you are referring to what I said, but I'm going to assume you are (at least in part). Why pass up an opportunity? <grin>

In a way, the NHS does offer the same treatment that you describe. The placebo effect is part of every therapeutic relationship regardless of whether the therapy also has a specific physiologic effect.

I think that what is being railed against is claims that do not have evidence to support them. The claim that you have a therapeutic effect on your clients is not so much under dispute. The claim that this is through an unrecognized mechanism is disputable. And it's not that exploring the possibility of an unrecognized mechanism is not legitimate - these possibilities are constantly explored in medicine and it's how we make progress. It's that we know to our chagrin that if this is not done in a systematic manner, we can and will fool ourselves. We have all had to go through the experience of believing that we were doing something useful and then discovering that, with more and better evidence, we were wrong.

Also, while it is reasonable to question information given to you, even that coming from someone whose knowledge and experience gives them expertise, simply putting quotes around the word "informed" does not suffice to invalidate the information.

I have spoken in the past to a number of GP`s and their view was this was either utter rubbish, or a placebo effect.

It is a placebo effect, though. Everything that we do has at least some placebo effect. In fact, that which falls under the umbrella of "placebo effect" forms a large chunk of the therapeutic effect. The question is not whether your therapy depends upon the placebo effect - it does - but rather whether there is any effect left over after the placebo effect is taken into account.

What falls under the umbrella of "placebo effect" is actually a number of different things, some of which I can already tell are taking place just from your description. The first is regression to the mean. You always have to ask yourself "what happens in the absence of any treatment?" Chronic pain varies. If you ask someone at random times to rate their level of pain, it will vary around the mean - sometimes it will be higher than average, sometimes lower. This will vary over minutes, hours, days and weeks. If on one occasion, the rating falls at the extreme of the range (high or low), it is very likely that the next time you ask for a rating it will be closer to the mean just by chance. That is what is meant by regression to the mean. Someone who on one occasion complains of severe pain, is likely to complain of moderate pain the next time you ask them *regardless of any therapeutic intervention*. Going the other direction, someone who has no pain on one occasion is likely to complain of mild or moderate pain the next time you ask.

The problem is that most of the time this is not what we do - systematically figure out the mean and variance. What is usually done is just what you describe - ask for a rating at one point in time, provide a treatment, and then ask for a rating after the treatment. If you are choosing when to offer the treatment on a random basis, the results may still be valid. Just by chance, the first rating is likely to be reasonably close to the true (and unknown) mean. So that your post-treatment rating, which is also likely to be reasonably close to the true mean by chance, should only differ significantly from the first if there is a specific treatment effect.

However, you are not choosing people to treat at a random time. People who have failed conventional treatment, who present themselves for healing at a seminar, who are complaining about their pain, etc. are all more likely to be experiencing a time when they fall above average or even at the extreme high end of the range. Even if your therapy had no effect, most of them would complain of less pain when asked a day, week or month later.

The second component is the influence over subjective findings rather than objective findings. The placebo effect consistently shows the greatest effect on those symptoms where subjective perception can vary greatly depending upon the mental state of the patient. It is difficult to demonstrate that the placebo effect makes any difference to objective findings. And you specifically state that you have an effect on pain but not on things like the common cold and cancer. We already have a lot of research documenting that pain perception (especially in chronic pain) can vary (greatly) depending upon the mental state of the patient. In addition, the sensation of fatigue is also highly influenced by mental state. And while you stated several times that these people were non-believers, actions speak louder than words. As a group, people that are willing to try to be healed through touch are more likely to be suggestible, regardless of what they say. Even if this wasn't backed by research, I have experienced over and over again the statement "I am a skeptic, but....." followed by an explicit demonstration that the speaker is not a skeptic - this thread included.

Third, the stress response can have a detrimental physiologic effect on healing. Those methods which reduce stress - reassurance, meditation, bio-feedback, etc. - can help with healing by removing the suppressive effects of stress. I don't doubt that you provide reassurance to those you have helped.

Those three components explain the bulk (if not all) of the placebo effect. We know that these effects are operating in your treatment. What has to be demonstrated is what effect is left over after you take all of that into consideration.

Which brings us back to my initial point. Even if, after all that, you demonstrate an effect that does not seem to be explained by any recognized mechanism, there is no reason to think that that unrecognized mechanism is supernatural in nature. We've encountered new mechanisms in medicine before and likely will continue to do so. While your description suggests that there may be an unrecognized mechanism at work, it does not suggest features that would place that mechanism outside the range of natural. Since the purpose of the Challenge is to demonstrate something that would revolutionize our scientific understanding - something that seems like it couldn't be due to a natural explanation - I would advise that Randi not accept your challenge. It is not what he is looking for. Also, the process of the Challenge is not the kind of process that you would follow if you were seeking to truly understand what it is that you can do. The Challenge is designed to help sort phenomena into "explainable through natural methods" and "not explainable through natural methods". It is not designed to "fully elucidate a natural process" which rather falls under scientific inquiry.

I accept there must be others that do think otherwise.
I personally feel there is much more to this which has hitherto not been explained or examined properly. I accept I am talking about matters beyond some peoples experiences, and expect you to stand in your corner with your view point, and mine in my own.

This is not a matter of differing viewpoints. It is a matter of recognizing that we are heavily influenced by cognitive biases - confirmation, attribution, selection, recollection, etc. And that scientific progress has only come about because we were willing to admit to those biases and take steps to eliminate them. The bulk of our scientific knowledge represents that which we did not want to believe and that which is counter-intuitive. Which makes "I believe this" and "this is intuitively obvious" unreliable criteria for assessing whether or not something is real or true. It is not sufficient to say, "it is my viewpoint that this is not the case." It is always the case. Which is why a major part of the design and write-up of a research project involves explicitly stating any possible biases and the steps taken to eliminate or reduce them.

Linda
 
I'm looking to understand what is really going on with these modalities,
It's the same reason guys will drop hundreds of dollars for lap dances in a topless bar. There's no touching there, either; just mechanics of inter-personal contact.

People need attention. So much so, they'll pay for it.

What else do we need to learn about this modality?
 
I cannot tell you how I know, but I sense it in some way that is not apparent to me. Is that `supernatural`? Or is it easily explained?
It's easily explained. When it's the product of long experience, it's called "intuition." In your case, it's called "guessing."

I believe that the human brain is capable of achieving feats outside of our understanding, and that in time these acts will be understood by medical science.
On the one hand, this is a trivial statement: we don't understand grammar processing, for example, and yet the brain clearly achieves it.

On the other hand, it is a statement of sheer faith, backed up nothing more than wishfuly thinking. Claiming that the brain can violate the laws of physics that constrain all other objects is just the same old "soul" in a different bottle, the same tired religoius infantile screed: "But... we're SPECIAL!"

We're not special, the brain is a material object, the mind is a production of brain, there is no privilged position for your personal sense of self.

I am hoping that my demonstrations of this ability will actually be looked at in greater depth and not dismissed as hocus pokus, or here, the `Woo Woo`s`.
Since your entire epistimology rests on the standard woo-woo rejection of self-evident reality, your hopes seem rather unfounded. But hey... pass the Challenge, and we will definitely take you seriously.
 
...
I have spoken in the past to a number of GP`s and their view was this was either utter rubbish, or a placebo effect.
I accept there must be others that do think otherwise.
I personally feel there is much more to this which has hitherto not been explained or examined properly. I accept I am talking about matters beyond some peoples experiences, and expect you to stand in your corner with your view point, and mine in my own.
...
Why would you doubt the experts?
Do you know more about it than them?

Did you take the time to read up on placebo and self delusion WRT to TT as previously suggested in this thread? (You ARE serious about this aren't you?)

In an earlier post, you talked about treating medical conditions.
Seems you do not have any medical qualifications, so this may be dangerous and fraudulent.
Do you get your car fixed by the local piano tuner?

No offence PP, but you are kidding yourself if you think this is not quackery.
 
(the mind is a production of brain,)

is also "a statement of sheer faith, backed up [by] nothing more than wishful thinking."

It seems that the mind as separate from the body has consistently been the obvious assumption throughout human history. And it is only in very recent history that serious consideration has been given to the idea that materialism can apply to the mind. Wishful thinking on this idea has been almost exclusively in one direction - i.e. almost every person, if asked, feels that their mind/thoughts direct their actions.

It can be said that the idea that we can explain all of the natural world through materialism is wishful thinking. And I agree even though that happens to be the direction of my wishful thinking. But then why single out the human mind?

See the thread about free will.

I will admit that I didn't read that whole thread, but I have had lots of "free will" discussions and they always seem to centre around the same few issues, so I hope I am not missing something critical in my reply here.

How do other people handle this? I usually skim the forum looking for topics that catch my eye. And I often come across posts (at the start of the thread) that I want to reply to, but don't have time to read the entire 261 posts that followed. And I don't feel like I should jump in with both feet without knowing whether what I want to say has already been said. So I end up saying nothing and remain strangely unsatisfied.

Linda
 
How do other people handle this? I usually skim the forum looking for topics that catch my eye. And I often come across posts (at the start of the thread) that I want to reply to, but don't have time to read the entire 261 posts that followed. And I don't feel like I should jump in with both feet without knowing whether what I want to say has already been said. So I end up saying nothing and remain strangely unsatisfied.

Linda

I find generally in the science and skepticism forums you are fine just jumping straight in. These forums tend to stay on topic, or at least try to, so even if they have drifted off you won't be attacked for bringing it back. If your point has been covered people will usually just refer you to the relevant post. Just don't try this in the politics forums. I think I'm scarred for life. :D
 
PsyP said

I have spoken in the past to a number of GP`s and their view was this was either utter rubbish, or a placebo effect.
I accept there must be others that do think otherwise.
I personally feel there is much more to this which has hitherto not been explained or examined properly. I accept I am talking about matters beyond some peoples experiences, and expect you to stand in your corner with your view point, and mine in my own.

I go with the placebo interpretation, but not the "rubbish" apraisal. Linda's post pointed out that the placebo effect includes the benifits of reduced stress. In my opinon that is heightened by engaging the individual's parasypathetic nervous system. It's not just a patient believes therefore placebo, therefore no value. Yes it is psycho-somatic and very subjective, which is why it can't be an alternative or substitute for tested and apporved medical tratments. However, these effects are still valued in Massage Therapy and warrant more research.

We are not just "meat machines." Our thoughts and feelings and feelings are major players in being healthy persons.
My personal opinion (and opinion it is, because there is no way to prove or disprove it using Science) is that we have no supernatural selves and metaphysical free wills. In the Buddhist understanding self has no inherent existance. What you see is what you get. We function with the fiction of an ego decider. That fiction isn't a representation of some metaphysical soul beyond the realm of experience. Of course in Buddhism there is nothing behind the apprerances of experience, so we creatively make do with our fictional egos, and that is part of being a healthy person. We neither cling to our egos nor deny their conventional sort of existance.

One of the main reasons people turn to so-called alternatives is that their HBO regards them as merely part of the profit making machinery and their hospital regards them as merely muscles, bones, and internal organs.
Something gets dropped, and so-called healers pick it ip and abuse it in their own way.

We don't need to dismiss the benifits of caring touch and attention because the frauds abuse them. But if we don't understand and can't explain to people why Reiki, TT, or whatever was able to help them within limitations, then they will again and again be struck with the wonder of their subjective experiences and be all the more vulnerable to people who tell them they don't need established medicine.
 
is also "a statement of sheer faith, backed up [by] nothing more than wishful thinking."
So you're saying that empirical data has no value?

Or are you saying the wishful thinking of a thousand years is worth more than one scientific expierement?

We know, as well as we know anything, that mind is a product of brain. This is self-evident to anyone who has ever observed a mind being altered by changes in the brain. Against these commonplace observation, what evidence do you assert?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom