Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

I will admit that I didn't read that whole thread, but I have had lots of "free will" discussions
Good dog, I'm not going anywhere near a "free will" thread. They are cesspools of minutae and straw.

:D
 
I'm not saying he is not, only that he can not prove it. Plenty of highly qualified posters seem to concur.
You want proof?

Take a pill. Huff some paint. Drink a beer. There are thousands of ways to mess up your brain chemistry and observe a change in behaviour, thought, feeling, and affect.

On the other hand, can you name a single experiment that would indicated mind is not a function of brain? Can you produce a brainless mind to interact with?

Given that there is readily available evidence on one side, and none on the other; given that one side corresponds to everything we know about physics and the world at large, and the other side violates all of those laws; how can we say we don't know?

If we don't know mind is caused by brain, then we don't know disease is caused by germs, or rain is caused by condensation, or winning the Superbowl is caused by scoring more points.
 
If we don't know mind is caused by brain, then we don't know disease is caused by germs, or rain is caused by condensation, or winning the Superbowl is caused by scoring more points.

One of these things is not like the others....
(You know the tune)

Linda
 
On the other hand, can you name a single experiment that would indicated mind is not a function of brain? Can you produce a brainless mind to interact with?

I am sure we both have interacted with plenty of "brainless minds" .:D
Anyway, don't shoot the messenger. I just pointed you to a source of possible enligthenment and you have refused it. Suit yourself.
 
Why the extended debate here? Just apply and see what they suggest for a protocol. It won't cost you anything but a bit of time, and if you can't come to an agreement over a protocol you can leave it at that. But if you DO, I'm sure everyone here would be interested in the results, so please do apply......
 
If we don't know mind is caused by brain, then we don't know disease is caused by germs, or rain is caused by condensation, or winning the Superbowl is caused by scoring more points.

One of these things is not like the others....
(You know the tune)

Well, disease is not always caused by germs. Is that the one you meant?

One of them is a tautology, rather than inductive.

Linda
 
One of them is a tautology, rather than inductive.
See, the problem is, I don't know jack about sports, but I wanted to use a sports metaphor to make me look "normal."

An exercise in futility, indeed. :D
 
I am sure we both have interacted with plenty of "brainless minds" .:D
Au contraire! Rather, we have interacted with many mindless brains....

:D :D :D

Anyway, don't shoot the messenger. I just pointed you to a source of possible enligthenment and you have refused it. Suit yourself.
It's not a source of possible enlightenment. And if the messenger is yelling 'Fire!" in a crowded theater, doesn't he deserve to be shot?

I did you the courtesy of actually listening. Doesn't that imply you owe me the courtesy of actually having something to say? I realize that in this advertisment-infested age, the line between "conversation" and "meaningless babble intended to sell something" becomes blurred, but by golly, it's time to take a stand! No more product placement without it being integral to the plot!

:)
 
My humble apologies, I did not realise you were in two minds :D :D about your participation to this forum. On one hand, (pardon, mind) you do me and the others in this thread the courtesy of listening, which to me means that you have an expectation of getting something out of the forum. On the other, you say that my referring you to another part of the forum is akin to a fire hoax in a theatre, ie. misleading and therefore punishable with shooting, because (that part of) the forum is "not a source of possible enlightenment". My apologies again, but if I were able to read your "minds" and know what you do and don't pay the courtesy to listen to, I would claim the million!

Anyway, given that you listened to me, I apologise again for my inability to make you understand what I had to say, that is that I humbly admit my inadequacy to enlighten you on the subject but I can offer information on where I found a lively debate of greater "minds" than mine who possibly could. Now we know that they can't because your "mind" is closed to them. I placed the wrong product with my meaningless babble.

I hope you rate this as conversation! :rolleyes:
 
My humble apologies, I did not realise you were in two minds :D :D about your participation to this forum. On one hand, (pardon, mind) you do me and the others in this thread the courtesy of listening, which to me means that you have an expectation of getting something out of the forum. On the other, you say that my referring you to another part of the forum is akin to a fire hoax in a theatre, ie. misleading and therefore punishable with shooting, because (that part of) the forum is "not a source of possible enlightenment". My apologies again, but if I were able to read your "minds" and know what you do and don't pay the courtesy to listen to, I would claim the million!

Anyway, given that you listened to me, I apologise again for my inability to make you understand what I had to say, that is that I humbly admit my inadequacy to enlighten you on the subject but I can offer information on where I found a lively debate of greater "minds" than mine who possibly could. Now we know that they can't because your "mind" is closed to them. I placed the wrong product with my meaningless babble.

I hope you rate this as conversation! :rolleyes:
 
...
Another ability that aligns itself to my healing is that I can `feel` where the seat of a person’s pain lies.

This area is problematical for me simply because on occasions, the seat of the pain is sometimes away from the point that the subject feels the pain.
It is only when I give my `treatment` or energy, that the subject feels where the heat actually goes, and that is normally where I first sensed it.
You can appreciate my dilemma.
Could you give an example of this?

For example if we were to test you on this ability and the subject has, say, a migraine, but you saiy the seat of the pain is in a foot, how would we be able to determine a "hit" in an experiment or the Challenge?

You'd say the seat of your pain is in your foot, the subject would say, "my head hurts".

How would you prove that the "seat" of the pain is elsewhere from where the subject feels the pain.

Are there injuries/problems that do NOT have this complication?
 
My humble apologies,
I don't want an apology. I want substantive debate.

On the other, you say that my referring you to another part of the forum is akin to a fire hoax in a theatre
That was not the point.

You said, "don't shoot the messenger." I explained that this was not a blanket defense: sometimes, the messenger is as much a part of the problem as anything else.

I did not mean to refer to the other thread as "not a source of enlightenment;" I meant to refer to the entire topic. Speculating on the phenomona described by "free will" is unlikely to tell us much about the real world, being, as it is, rather specific to the human-constructed world of culture.

It's like talking about Gandalf when you're trying to build a bridge.

inability to make you understand what I had to say
I have to agree with Hannity on this: if someone can't explain what they mean in simple terms, then either they are a) lying or b) confused themselves.

Just tell us, in the simplest terms, what your point is.

I suspect it is this: "free will implies minds violate the laws of physics."

If that is indeed your argument, then we are back where we started: we've all already heard this argument a thousand times, it's been soundly destroyed, so please either breath new life into it or say something new. But don't expect us to take the mere repetition of this argument seriously.

Now we know that they can't because your "mind" is closed to them.
If I ask you to review a thread about what 2+2 equals, would the fact that you know basic math mean your "mind" was closed to the arguments contained?

I hope you rate this as conversation! :rolleyes:
It's a little better. But it is somewhat off-topic.
 
Anyway, given that you listened to me, I apologise again for my inability to make you understand what I had to say, that is that I humbly admit my inadequacy to enlighten you on the subject but I can offer information on where I found a lively debate of greater "minds" than mine who possibly could. Now we know that they can't because your "mind" is closed to them. I placed the wrong product with my meaningless babble.

I see this frequently offered as a response and I fail to understand it. How does knowledge and an ability to evaluate information objectively preclude an open mind?

Linda
 
Ok fls, I take your point. Just say that my IQ is not sufficient to spot these subleties quickly enough to avoid them while hurriedly trying to communicate in simple language. I am quite aware that there are more than 60 million people on this earth smarter than I.

Yahzi: given that there is nothing here to lie about I must be confused, because I can not explain myself in simple terms.

What part of
"I humbly admit my inadequacy to enlighten you on the subject but I can offer information on where I found a lively debate of greater "minds" than mine who possibly could"

don't you understand?

You assume (with the proverbial results) that I was trying to teach you something about free will. I was only telling you that I am trying to learn something about it and thought you might want also. End of story.
 
Yahzi: given that there is nothing here to lie about I must be confused, because I can not explain myself in simple terms.
I concur with your assessment: you are confused. Perhaps you should back up to the point where you still understand the issue, and try again.

For instance: what, specifically, could free will possibly teach us about the nature of reality?

You assume (with the proverbial results) that I was trying to teach you something about free will. I was only telling you that I am trying to learn something about it and thought you might want also.
See, the assumption in the above paragraph is that I don't already know the answer. You assumed I was as confused about the issue as you were. This assumption produced, as you put it, the proverbial result.

There is no philosophical conumdrum in free will. Although it is true that many philosophers argue about it and write books about it, that is no more signficant than the fact that many people argue about God and write books about God. All it tells you is there are a lot of confused people out there.

Free will is no more metaphysically interesting than temperature. Both are qualities that do not exist in the micro-atomic world, no matter how much their apparent behavior matters in the macro world. Both are short-hand descriptions of complex interactions. Both are necessary, as well: imagine trying to survive in this world without understanding or believing in temperature: but the mere fact that a complex interaction must be condensed to a short-hand hueristic so we can function on a daily basis tells us nothing about the innate nature of the material universe.
 
An interesting study would be "How people convince themselves they have magical powers when they clearly do not."
 
See, the assumption in the above paragraph is that I don't already know the answer. You assumed I was as confused about the issue as you were. This assumption produced, as you put it, the proverbial result.

We are agreed, then: we are both asses.

I am amazed at the time you spend talking about something you denied so vehemently wanting to be involved with, to somebody who told you clearly is too ignorant to presume arguing about it. It reminds me of an ancient proverb: the tongue keeps touching the sore tooth. Try an aspirin.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom