Good dog, I'm not going anywhere near a "free will" thread. They are cesspools of minutae and straw.I will admit that I didn't read that whole thread, but I have had lots of "free will" discussions
Good dog, I'm not going anywhere near a "free will" thread. They are cesspools of minutae and straw.I will admit that I didn't read that whole thread, but I have had lots of "free will" discussions
You want proof?I'm not saying he is not, only that he can not prove it. Plenty of highly qualified posters seem to concur.
Good dog, I'm not going anywhere near a "free will" thread. They are cesspools of minutae and straw.
![]()
If we don't know mind is caused by brain, then we don't know disease is caused by germs, or rain is caused by condensation, or winning the Superbowl is caused by scoring more points.
On the other hand, can you name a single experiment that would indicated mind is not a function of brain? Can you produce a brainless mind to interact with?
One of these things is not like the others....
(You know the tune)
Linda
If we don't know mind is caused by brain, then we don't know disease is caused by germs, or rain is caused by condensation, or winning the Superbowl is caused by scoring more points.
One of these things is not like the others....
(You know the tune)
Well, disease is not always caused by germs. Is that the one you meant?
See, the problem is, I don't know jack about sports, but I wanted to use a sports metaphor to make me look "normal."One of them is a tautology, rather than inductive.
Au contraire! Rather, we have interacted with many mindless brains....I am sure we both have interacted with plenty of "brainless minds" .![]()
It's not a source of possible enlightenment. And if the messenger is yelling 'Fire!" in a crowded theater, doesn't he deserve to be shot?Anyway, don't shoot the messenger. I just pointed you to a source of possible enligthenment and you have refused it. Suit yourself.
Could you give an example of this?...
Another ability that aligns itself to my healing is that I can `feel` where the seat of a person’s pain lies.
This area is problematical for me simply because on occasions, the seat of the pain is sometimes away from the point that the subject feels the pain.
It is only when I give my `treatment` or energy, that the subject feels where the heat actually goes, and that is normally where I first sensed it.
You can appreciate my dilemma.
I don't want an apology. I want substantive debate.My humble apologies,
That was not the point.On the other, you say that my referring you to another part of the forum is akin to a fire hoax in a theatre
I have to agree with Hannity on this: if someone can't explain what they mean in simple terms, then either they are a) lying or b) confused themselves.inability to make you understand what I had to say
If I ask you to review a thread about what 2+2 equals, would the fact that you know basic math mean your "mind" was closed to the arguments contained?Now we know that they can't because your "mind" is closed to them.
It's a little better. But it is somewhat off-topic.I hope you rate this as conversation!![]()
Anyway, given that you listened to me, I apologise again for my inability to make you understand what I had to say, that is that I humbly admit my inadequacy to enlighten you on the subject but I can offer information on where I found a lively debate of greater "minds" than mine who possibly could. Now we know that they can't because your "mind" is closed to them. I placed the wrong product with my meaningless babble.
I concur with your assessment: you are confused. Perhaps you should back up to the point where you still understand the issue, and try again.Yahzi: given that there is nothing here to lie about I must be confused, because I can not explain myself in simple terms.
See, the assumption in the above paragraph is that I don't already know the answer. You assumed I was as confused about the issue as you were. This assumption produced, as you put it, the proverbial result.You assume (with the proverbial results) that I was trying to teach you something about free will. I was only telling you that I am trying to learn something about it and thought you might want also.
See, the assumption in the above paragraph is that I don't already know the answer. You assumed I was as confused about the issue as you were. This assumption produced, as you put it, the proverbial result.