Feet In Both Camps? Psychic Challenger

I'm sorry, but this is simply wrong. If I have a bacterial infection and am given antibiotics, it is them, not the body, that cures it. If I have a gangrenous finger amputated it is the surgeon who cured it (or at least stopped it spreading). Yes, the body is good at healing itself and some medicine simply helps it, or reduces the syptoms while it heals itself, but there is a lot of medicine that genuinely cures things, either in conjunction with the body, or without its help at all.

I am pleased to see you no longer pratice "energy healing", but it seems you still believe many of the things such practioners say to belittle real medicine.

Thank you for the qualifiers. I agree medicine does cure. Now, after the antibiotic and the amputation, the body still engages in a process called recovery that is its own work. I believe that TT is useful here in hastening the recovery process. And that it does as described by the OP reduce various symptoms.

"Energy Healing" is such a problematic term. I still from time to time do give Reiki or TT sessions. It's helpful and harmless provided people aren't decieved into thinking it's a substitute for medicine and medical treatments. It's not an alternative.

Is it medicine? Some will strongly insist it's not and others that it is, depending on presuppositions of what medicine is and how it works. I don't really care to get into that argument, but because of the subjective nature of the matter, I'd say it falls more towards the "Chicken Souo for The Soul" arena.
 
Last edited:
I believe that TT is useful here in hastening the recovery process. .

I have a question about Theraputic Touch. From what I've read about it, TT practicioners identify the area that needs healing and then "smooth the energy" across this area. How do the TT folks know that smoothing or balancing the energy improves the healing process more than redirecting more energy to the effected area? How do they know that removing excess energy from this area is better than adding energy to this area?
 
Stewart P - Thanks, I appreciate your comments upon my return.

Just another thought.. Whenever I have `treated` anyone with a medical condition, I always insist that they continue with any prescribed medication and report back to their GP if they no longer feel further medication is necessary. Sometimes my treatment of such cases is purely complimentary to the medication prescribed.

Many people I have worked with have come to me out of desperation when conventional treatment has failed them. I don`t think my techniques involve some form of hypnotherapy. I wish I could! I`d be down to the bank today withdrawing cash from a `hypno` influenced cashier, with no debit on my account.. Ahh, what a dream! :-)
 
Linda said:
But this claim is not based on anything unusual or unexpected. The sensation of "energy" or "warmth" or "electricity" flowing into and out of someone is common and does not depend upon an actual flow of energy. The sensation of being drained is common and not necessarily related to the type or kind of exertion. Pain and relief of pain are not necessarily indicative of pathology and subsequent reversal of that pathology. Subjective sensations are influenced and generated by processes which may have nothing to do with the actual functioning of the body. Subjective sensations provide no support one way or the other for a claim that defies the known laws of nature.

Yes, any demonstrable supernatural claim would have the power to revolutionize science. Which makes stating it here in this thread redundant.

Linda

PsychicPhysicist said:
Hi Linda,
Please could you validate the above comment based upon proven medical research and not say, someone elses opinion. What you appear to be saying is precisely that.

I think there is a good chance that you can demonstrate your claim. I cannot see why your claim requires a supernatural explanation, though. Can you specify what you want me to provide references for? I usually refer to research articles - will this be something that you will find useful?

If you consider that your gift is real, does it matter whether it is on the basis of something natural vs. supernatural?

Linda
 
Hi again Linda,

I think the real problem here is by what something is defined as `supernatural`.
Clearly, what I wish to demonstrate falls into two separate schools of opinion.
One, such as yourself, would argue that it isn`t `supernatural`, because you feel - and that`s all it is, an opinion that what I do is not.
Others would refute that I can do it, so in their minds any claim to perform such acts is allegedly, `supernatural` - meaning impossible or ridiculous.

Wikipedia defines Supernatural as thus:
The word supernatural is used for things that some people believe are real, but that are not part of nature. Because we cannot prove whether these things are real, people often disagree about these things.
Scientists say that we should talk about things without talking about the supernatural, because we cannot prove that supernatural things are real. Other people say that although we cannot prove supernatural things in a scientific way, they are real. Many ideas like religion, magic, miracles, spirits, ghosts, angels, devils, gods, and God are supernatural.


So there are many schools of opinion as to what supernatural means or represents.


Another ability that aligns itself to my healing is that I can `feel` where the seat of a person’s pain lies.
I cannot tell you how I know, but I sense it in some way that is not apparent to me. Is that `supernatural`? Or is it easily explained?
This area is problematical for me simply because on occasions, the seat of the pain is sometimes away from the point that the subject feels the pain.
It is only when I give my `treatment` or energy, that the subject feels where the heat actually goes, and that is normally where I first sensed it.
You can appreciate my dilemma.
I don’t believe that what I perform is truly `supernatural`, nor do I attribute it to the alleged mechanisms that you have described.
I believe that the human brain is capable of achieving feats outside of our understanding, and that in time these acts will be understood by medical science.
That’s my view, and I’m sure some will agree or beg to differ. Either way, it is not fully understood.
I am hoping that my demonstrations of this ability will actually be looked at in greater depth and not dismissed as hocus pokus, or here, the `Woo Woo`s`.
 
Psychic Physicist said:
I am only too happy to take part in a test but it has to be in an acceptable format to both parties.
After participating in an acceptible test, what would be your reaction if such a test indicated that you did not have the abilities you claim? Would you be willing to consider a more natural explaination for the events you have experienced?
 
I think the real problem here is by what something is defined as `supernatural`.

That's a good point. Some people use the word "supernatural" as equivalent to "not thoroughly explained" or "not demonstrated to exist". When I speak of supernatural, it is in contradistinction to the domain of science which assumes that the natural world is material, lawful, and scrutable. So supernatural refers to ideas or phenomena that would be immaterial, lawless or inscrutable. For the purposes of the Challenge, from the FAQ's, the definition given (from Webster's Online dictionary) is "of or relating to an order of existence beyond the visible observable universe; departing from what is usual or normal especially so as to appear to transcend the laws of nature; attributed to an invisible agent (as a ghost or spirit)"

Since you are talking about the Challenge, I have been using the word "supernatural" in that spirit.

Clearly, what I wish to demonstrate falls into two separate schools of opinion.
One, such as yourself, would argue that it isn`t `supernatural`, because you feel - and that`s all it is, an opinion that what I do is not.

I am simply informing you that your description does not transcend what is usual or normal in that it corresponds to what we have already observed and studied in medicine. It did not appear that you were aware of this. You may say this is just my opinion if you like.

Another ability that aligns itself to my healing is that I can `feel` where the seat of a person’s pain lies.
I cannot tell you how I know, but I sense it in some way that is not apparent to me. Is that `supernatural`? Or is it easily explained?
This area is problematical for me simply because on occasions, the seat of the pain is sometimes away from the point that the subject feels the pain.
It is only when I give my `treatment` or energy, that the subject feels where the heat actually goes, and that is normally where I first sensed it.
You can appreciate my dilemma.
I don’t believe that what I perform is truly `supernatural`, nor do I attribute it to the alleged mechanisms that you have described.
I believe that the human brain is capable of achieving feats outside of our understanding, and that in time these acts will be understood by medical science.
That’s my view, and I’m sure some will agree or beg to differ. Either way, it is not fully understood.
I am hoping that my demonstrations of this ability will actually be looked at in greater depth and not dismissed as hocus pokus, or here, the `Woo Woo`s`.

What we already understand in this area is vast and I did not mean for my brief listing to be exclusive or representative. I do not think pursuing the Challenge (even if you were accepted) will accomplish your stated goals.

Linda
 
I have a question about Theraputic Touch. From what I've read about it, TT practicioners identify the area that needs healing and then "smooth the energy" across this area. How do the TT folks know that smoothing or balancing the energy improves the healing process more than redirecting more energy to the effected area? How do they know that removing excess energy from this area is better than adding energy to this area?

Before I attempt to give an acceptable answer to that, there are a few loose ends to tie up.

1. I'm using TT or Therapeutic Touch for lack of a better term for a number of different so-called "energy work" therapies. Personally I might call this kind of thing Caring Touch, not to deny its therapuetic value, but to try to affiirm the value it has without the garbage that's usually attached to this activity.

2. I agree with Linda. This isn't about something supernatural, and is only paranormal in the sense that its an effect most people in our culture don't ordinarily notice and use, though how many millions of times have moms made an ouchy go away with a kiss, and lovers have eased pain and other sypmtoms with kisses. (Perhaps I should start a new modality: "Therapeutic Kissing." Then at least I could get some kisses for a change.) As I said before, I don't think it's really Challenge material and would like to see good research that doesn't get sidetracked by supernatural claims.

3. "Energy" in the context of TT, in my opinion isn't an energy in the physical sense, such as the four forces. It's just a discriptive term. People feel "energetic" effects. For example, an aquaintance was suffering eye fatigue and asked me to "run some energy" into her eyes. I focus on my palms and held them before her eyes. She told me that she felt a great deal of heat going into her eyes. Thinking that my hands must be way hot she touched one of them and found they weren't. So I explained to her where this heat energy was coming from. Two things: On in reponse to the focused attention on her eyes, more blood was flowing into them. Where there's more blood there's a slightly higher body temperature. Two, such a focusing of attention often brings heightened sensitivity. If you are good at holding attention, you can raise your body temperature at the place you put that attention upon. This is a simple example, but it shows that the so-called energy is not something PsyP could use to heat up an iron bar.
After a short time the aquaintance felt the heat flow away and her fatigue, not only in her eyes, but in general, was gone.

There are differences in electrical resistance as well as body temperature in areas TT would call "Congested." When I took my first class in Shiatsu, I was easily able to feel where the acupressure points were. These are the same points as used in Acupuncture and you can many of them with devices used to measure electrical conductivity and resistance on the skin. I think I simply was sensitive in that way. The more you use your tactile senses the more sensitive they become and the more your brain learns to process the information.
But what are these poits anyway? According to the Massage Therapy modality called Trager, they are simply places of stress and tension along a muscle.
Whe the muscle tone is good, they don't stand out, but when there's a tightening tension there, that spot is sore and tender and feels to the Shiatsu therapist as being "jitsu," or having an excessive charge. When the tone is weak and empty, the Shiatsu word is "kyo." with practice you can tell the difference by touch. Theraputic Touch practitioners can simply feel when an area is "Imblanced" and needs "smoothing out," I can feel when there is too much "energy" or too little.
Our culture mostly ignores the tactile senses and most people have little body awareness. I got into this when I begin meditating and was instructed to be alert to my senses. There were a number of different "energy" effects that arose in that process and I began to study what they were about and if they had any use.

I know this is still vague and strange. It makes more sense if you let yourself experince it or at least talk to some Massage Therapists about their touch sensitivity.
 
Therupetic Touch doesn't involve physical contact with the body.
Only the imaginary undetectable energy fields around it.
 
Last edited:
Another ability that aligns itself to my healing is that I can `feel` where the seat of a person’s pain lies.
I cannot tell you how I know, but I sense it in some way that is not apparent to me. Is that `supernatural`? Or is it easily explained?
This area is problematical for me simply because on occasions, the seat of the pain is sometimes away from the point that the subject feels the pain.
It is only when I give my `treatment` or energy, that the subject feels where the heat actually goes, and that is normally where I first sensed it.
You can appreciate my dilemma.

I used to believe I could do this too.
Until I learned about how I could (not conciously) read other people's body language in most instances. In other instances I believed the pain originated elsewhere and the other person, on having this suggested to them, would agree that the heat directed from me to them would indeed go to where I 'knew' the seat of the pain actually was.

It's placebo, body language and other minute signals being interpreted, and the power of suggestion all neatly combined.
 
Therupetic Touch doesn't involve physical contact with the body.
Only the imaginary undetectable energy fields around it.

Imaginary or not, skin contact or not, it's touch and in somecases can be more intimate in nature than an actual physical contact.
The recipiant's reaction to the contact is physical.

Now if you put up a screen, so that the individual doesn't know she's getting personal attention, then there won't be contact.
 
I used to believe I could do this too.
Until I learned about how I could (not conciously) read other people's body language in most instances. In other instances I believed the pain originated elsewhere and the other person, on having this suggested to them, would agree that the heat directed from me to them would indeed go to where I 'knew' the seat of the pain actually was.

It's placebo, body language and other minute signals being interpreted, and the power of suggestion all neatly combined.

Yes, and these things add up to an activity that in my experience is rather nice.
It's worth exploring and sharing. No need to throw it all out when we explain how it really works.
 
Yes, and these things add up to an activity that in my experience is rather nice.
It's worth exploring and sharing. No need to throw it all out when we explain how it really works.

Of course you need to throw it all out, when you realise you are conning people. You don't magically sense where their pain is - you can tell from how they move or hold a part of their body, or something else more subtle. If you can't tell it correctly, then you just claim that what you feel is really the actual source of the pain. They won't argue with you. You wave your hands about, hold their hands gently, whatever form your 'healing' takes, and they honestly believe that you are sending energy and heat into them. They will back up your claim about where the energy is going, and if they don't you just forget it, and remember the hits instead.
 
Hi Everyone,

If medical science has known about this for years, why is it nor available on the NHS? Further, why does so much `informed` medical opinion rail against it?

I have spoken in the past to a number of GP`s and their view was this was either utter rubbish, or a placebo effect.
I accept there must be others that do think otherwise.
I personally feel there is much more to this which has hitherto not been explained or examined properly. I accept I am talking about matters beyond some peoples experiences, and expect you to stand in your corner with your view point, and mine in my own.
I`ve just uploaded a photo which I would like your opinion on, but hey, where`s it gone?????
 
Imaginary or not, skin contact or not, it's touch and in somecases can be more intimate in nature than an actual physical contact.
The recipiant's reaction to the contact is physical.

Now if you put up a screen, so that the individual doesn't know she's getting personal attention, then there won't be contact.

But Therapeutic Touch, as still practiced in some places in the US, involves no contact whatsoever. We understand what TT is, and isn't. Most of us are familiar with Emily Rosa's study.
So what are you talking about?
 
Hi Everyone,

If medical science has known about this for years, why is it nor available on the NHS? Further, why does so much `informed` medical opinion rail against it?

I have spoken in the past to a number of GP`s and their view was this was either utter rubbish, or a placebo effect.
I accept there must be others that do think otherwise.
I personally feel there is much more to this which has hitherto not been explained or examined properly. I accept I am talking about matters beyond some peoples experiences, and expect you to stand in your corner with your view point, and mine in my own.
I`ve just uploaded a photo which I would like your opinion on, but hey, where`s it gone?????

As I pointed out in an earlier post there is more to it than the classical placebo effect but not the regularity of tested and appoved medications for various symptoms.
As to why this hasn't recieved the attention and study it deserves is in part the claims of healing of chronic illnesses that has been attached to it.
Whenever it's touted as a substitute, competitor, or alternative of established medical practices, the whole topic becomes an untouchable to anyone who cares about actaully helping people rather than taking their money for a dubious if not fraudulent service.

Also there is a place in the healthcare industry where caring touch is an established and recognized matter, and that is Massage Therapy.
It's in the Massage Therapy industry that you'll find it taken almost for granted.
 
But Therapeutic Touch, as still practiced in some places in the US, involves no contact whatsoever. We understand what TT is, and isn't. Most of us are familiar with Emily Rosa's study.
So what are you talking about?

Read my posts in this thread.
A personl contact needn't necessarily involve a physicak skin contact. I'm talking about personal contact. The term "Therapeutic Touch" was coined by its practitioners. They understand that touch is a bit more involved than just a skin to skin contact.
 
Last edited:
Read my posts in this thread.
A personl contact needn't necessarily involve a physicak skin contact. I'm talking about personal contact. The term "Therapeutic Touch" was coined by its practitioners. They understand that touch is a bit more involved than just a skin to skin contact.

Listen, I don't need to be told to read your posts. I did and I'm telling you that you are using the term Therapeutic Touch incorrectly, as the TT people don't actually touch other people.
 
Listen, I don't need to be told to read your posts. I did and I'm telling you that you are using the term Therapeutic Touch incorrectly, as the TT people don't actually touch other people.



You arre right. They don't physically touch other prople. They emotionally touch them. I will refrain from using the term in further posts. It's hard to find a term for this that isn't tainted by the usual "Energy" mythology. For the time being I'll use the term I cobbled up, "Caring Touch."

For the sake of some lost clarity here:

What is called "Therapeutic Touch" by its practitioners generally doesn't make skin contact. They say they are touching "energy fields." Reiki makes the same claim but does make physical contact with the body.
I'm looking to understand what is really going on with these modalities, since experiments like the one Jeff mentioned have shown no energy fields.
I was using "Therapeutic Touch" as a generic for the various modailties of "energy work." That was confusing.
And one thing I forgot to say when I was talking about Shiatsu's 'kyo' and 'jitsu' was that I didn't need to make physical contact with the points to access them. A quarter of an inch away I could tell. And yes I can do your ordinary Therapeutic "Touch" thing and sense a "congestion" at a greater distance. But I'm not claiming to feel a mysterious energy field.
 
Last edited:
Psychic Physicist and Hyparxis, I just to want to say Thanks. I've appreciated your taking the time to discuss dispassionately what you've experienced. Hyparxis - did you experience the same fatigue after sessions that PP did?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom