federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Truthseeker i've replied to that ray of knowledge here and here

I'll quote the replies for you:

TruthSeeker1234 in your analogy you assume that the entity holding the monopoly power over money creation takes active part in the economy, that is: buys goods and services with the money being issued. In the real world economists advocate for an independent central bank (the Federal Reserve and Chile's Central Bank are good examples) with the very purpose of avoiding the analogy you are trying to make.

That could be the case in a scenario where the Central Bank is an active agent of the economy, where it has the ability to spend the money it creates. In the case of the Federal Reserve the “money creators” receive no transfer of wealth.

The bit about the “late receivers” and “early receivers” makes no sense in the context of a Central Bank that manages the growth of the money supply according to the changes in the demand. A stable and predictable rate of inflation does away with your argument about the transfer of wealth from the “late receivers” to the “early receivers”.
 
I haven't been following this thread closely, but I just popped in and it looks like Ace is still pushing the "fiat money = theft" angle.

Ace, I think you're talking about our paper currency, right? Does it not shake your theory just a little when you consider that the amount of paper currency is an insignificant pimple on the elephant's butt, when you compare it to the actual money supply?
 
Alan Greenspan said

TruthSeeker1234 in your analogy you assume that the entity holding the monopoly power over money creation takes active part in the economy, that is: buys goods and services with the money being issued. In the real world economists advocate for an independent central bank (the Federal Reserve and Chile's Central Bank are good examples) with the very purpose of avoiding the analogy you are trying to make.

This is ridiculous. You are saying that money is created, but not spent. Of course new money gets spent. The Treasury issues "bonds" which are "purchased" by the Fed with checkbook money. Presto. New money for the executive branch to spend.

I don't assume the money creators spend the money, it is a fact. What else can happen with new money, other than it gets spent? It makes no difference if you want to pretend that the Fed is separate from the government, they are still creating money out of thin air and giving it to the government to spend.

This diverts real resources away from where they would have been put to use, and places them in the hands of government. As early receivers of new money, government contractors can also benefit by re-spending the money quickly. Late-receivers are screwed, as prices have risen by the time they get their hands on the new money.

The net result is a transfer of real wealth away from some, and into the hands of others.
 
I was asked not long ago why we needed money. Here is what I answered.

Suppose we didn't have money. Instead, we all barter and trade. I have a skill at making chairs, and you have a skill at making windows. I make you a chair, and you make me a window. That's fair. Now, suppose I need a window, but you don't need a chair; you need a bed instead. Well, I'll make a chair for Joe, the bedmaker, and he can make you a bed, and you can make me a window. Everybody's even.

Now, suppose I need a window, but you don't need a chair right now. You might in the future, though. Well, you give me the window, and I'll write out a little note that says I owe you a chair. Anytime you decide you need the chair, bring the note back and I'll make it for you.

With lots of people making lots of things, there will be a lot of these IOU notes running around. We want to make sure no one cheats by creating fake ones, so we'll make them fancy with little drawings and security codes imprinted on them.

And we want to make sure that the person making the notes doesn't make a whole bunch for himself, so we'll create a special corporation whose only job is to print these notes for everyone, but they aren't allowed to use them themselves.

And then we'll call the notes "money".


By the way, the person I explained this to was my 8 year old daughter. She understood it. Why can't some adults?
 
Truthseeker1234, since your post includes so much nonsense let's try to debate what you are saying one thing a time. Let's start with this particularly funny bit:



I guess that by rate of profit you meant a profits/investment ratio, so what incentive would Intel have to go into the complicated business of computer hardware when they can just just put up a bead & breakfast inn and have the same rate of return on their investment?

In this golden model of yours there no incentive to invest in innovation or any high risk business since you would have the same return on your investment if you just invest in a grocery store. Wow, and this comes from someone who claims to be "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ".
oh great, your making sense. Now the stock market is crashing. Thanks Mr. Greenspan!
 
@Truthseeker1234

This is ridiculous. You are saying that money is created, but not spent. Of course new money gets spent. The Treasury issues "bonds" which are "purchased" by the Fed with checkbook money. Presto. New money for the executive branch to spend.

Yes, money is issued to be spent. The thing is that for your analogy to make any sense the Central Bank would need to be actively buying goods and services in the economy every time the money supply is expanded. Which is not the case.

Since you are talking about the executive branch and money readily available for them to spend ... can you backup your claim with actual data and tell us how much of the government expenditures are financed with monetary emission?

I don't assume the money creators spend the money, it is a fact.

Then i guess you have the data to prove what you are saying, right? Or shall we just take your word for it?

What else can happen with new money, other than it gets spent?

It is spent, just not by the ones you are claiming to be spending it.

It makes no difference if you want to pretend that the Fed is separate from the government, they are still creating money out of thin air and giving it to the government to spend.

So the Federal Reserve is expanding the money supply and "giving" the money to the government. Well, since the data is publicly available i guess the next step is for you to actually prove your claim by telling us how much of the government expenditures is currently being financed by monetary emission.

And by the way, the Federal Reserve does not "create money out of thin air", it is the U.S. Treasury who has the power to print and mint currency.

As early receivers of new money, government contractors can also benefit by re-spending the money quickly.

You first have to prove how much of the government expenditures are financed with monetary emission. So far we only have your word on this, and seeing how "knowledgeable in undergrad econ" you are: that's far from being enough.

The net result is a transfer of real wealth away from some, and into the hands of others.

What you describe was not a transfer of wealth at all. When the prices went up, the purchasing power of everyone in that particular economy was affected not just the purchasing power from the "late receivers".
 
Alan Greenspan is correct. I am also a knowledgable or used to be in economics. I graduated with that major from NYU. The Fed does not "spend" the money on goods and services.
 
Alan Greenspan is correct. I am also a knowledgable or used to be in economics. I graduated with that major from NYU. The Fed does not "spend" the money on goods and services.

Viewed correctly, the Federal Reserve and the Executive Branch of the US govmt. are partners. By issuing bonds, and having them purchased by the Fed, the govt gets money to spend.

The notion that money is created but not spent is absurd. Are you suggesting money is not created? Or that it is created but not spent? Or what?

Someone has to be the first spender of new money, and and whoever that someone is, benefits greatly.
 
What you describe was not a transfer of wealth at all. When the prices went up, the purchasing power of everyone in that particular economy was affected not just the purchasing power from the "late receivers".

You are ignoring time. New money is not shared by everyone all at once, it takes time for it to flow into the economy. Prices do not go up all at once, the price increases ripple through the economy over time.

Hence the importance of early receivers vs. late receivers.
 
I am not ignoring time, by the time prices do go up both the "late receivers" and the "early receivers" will see their purchasing power eroded. Let's assume an economy with 2 agents, the lateys and the earleys. To simplify things we'll just use two periods. In the first period the Central Bank expands the money supply and the earleys get all the money. By the end of the period they have spent all this money and prices went up until they reached twice the level at the beginning of the period. In the second period bot the earleys and the lateys see their current purchasing power decreased by half since in this period both of them are seeing the same price level.

So no, there is no transfer of wealth and no theft taking place in this example you are providing.

And tell me something little Von Mises, are you supplying the data to backup your assertions? Or are you just going to pretend you never claimed The Fed is "creating money out of thin air" and "giving" it to the U.S. government?
 
The notion that money is created but not spent is absurd. Are you suggesting money is not created? Or that it is created but not spent? Or what?

What is absurd is the thought of The Fed "creating" 1,000,000 US$ just to buy goods and services for itself, as your analogy implies.
 
You're almost there, Alan. All you have to do is complete your model and follow it around. I'll do it for you.


In the beginning, Mr. Early and Mr. Latey each have 10 loaves of bread, and each has $10. They each like to keep a cash balance on hand of $10. The government has no money and no bread. The current market price of bread is $1 per loaf.

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 6 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

Govt. now has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $16, and 4 loaves.
Latey still has $10, and 10 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $2 per loaf.

Early buys 6 loaves of bread from Mr. Latey for $2 per loaf.

Govt. still has $4, and 6 loaves.
Early now has $4 and 10 loaves.
Latey now has $22 and 4 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $4 per loaf.

Latey buys 3 loaves from the government at $4 per.

Govt. now has $16, and 3 loaves.
Early still has $4 and 10 loaves.
Latey now has $10 and 7 loaves.

This chases the price of bread up to $6 per loaf.

The government buys 1 loaf of bread from Early for $6.

Final score:

Govt. has $10 and 4 loaves.
Early has $10 and 9 loaves.
Latey has $10 and 7 loaves.


Play with the numbers all you want. You could make it so that Latey ends up with the same amount of bread, but way less money. Anyway you slice it, the late receivers get screwed under the creation of fiat money. Whoever is given the power to create money can and must siphon real wealth away from others.
 
The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 6 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.
Can you show the line in the US balance sheet that lists the revenue the government receives from simply printing money? :rolleyes:

And btw Ace, the Fed doesn't print any money at all. The Treasury Dept. prints money.
 
wow why is this thread still going. i already explained on the first page that our dollars will never be less valuable than a piece of paper. That means it does have a protected value. Our dollars can not become worthless.


I think the actual problem we face as a society is that the dollars that are being printed are not finding its way into american hands. Theres much more dollars in existance today, compared to 20 years ago, yet the amount of dollars that average 50 hours a week working american has compared to 20 years ago has not increased at anywhere near the same percentage. however you would also have to add in population growth, cost of living, price increases and decreases, and a few other factors into that equation to see a good estimate of the problem...

i havn't done the equation, but still i think if someone did do the equation they would find that theres extra dollars that were printed that the american people never saw... who knows where it went (it may have gone to an american business but i don't consider that the american people).


UGH MY POINT IS THIS. we live in a technological age today where every man, as long as he works 50 hours a week, should be able to support himself and his family and 3-4 kids. Something is wrong. I know raising the minimum wage to a living wage is a bad idea, but SOMETHING ELSE IS WRONG here.

If I work 50 hours a week at mcdonalds, i should be able to make enough money to support a family and 3-4 kids and buy a house. This should occur naturally in a free economy without the government even needing to mandate a minimum living wage. With technological advances that we have today that should be possible. The elite must have somehow engineered society to prevent that from happening, because if one man could so easily support his family and 4 children, you would see the population of a technologically advanced society nearly double every 4 generations. So the elite must have seen that problem a long time ago (before the easy access to technology) and manipulated the money and economic system to prevent that from happening today. Now its at the point where some people are in the situation to go to college and find a job to support a family, and some people end up working a bad job / single / near poverty / unable to support a family. they still have kids, but the state takes the kids or they die young anyway so the population growth stays pretty much the same so it works out.


meh whatever i need to think about this more. nice train of thought i got goin' here


its sort of like the book 1984 where it explains that in order to keep down the standard of living even with an increase in technology, you have to wage the wars so resources could be used elsewhere so the average population never see's the increase in living standards. we sort of got the same thing going here but instead of resources it's just dollars that we never see (and without dollars we cant buy the resources) so the elite are getting most of the dollars letting them buy the resources.

I agree that our standard of living has increased. but there are still a lot of people in poverty and poor or working crapy jobs, and their standard of living should be as high as mine too and it should be easy to accomplish that in a technologically advanced society.
 
Last edited:
@Truthseeker1234

You're almost there, Alan. All you have to do is complete your model and follow it around. I'll do it for you.

The model was complete, at the end of your model the exact same thing happened: both the "late receivers" and the "early receivers" were seeing the same price level.

The fed prints up a brand new $10 dollars, and gives it to the government. The government buys 6 loaves from Mr. Early for $1 each.

First of all, The Fed does not print any money. The U.S. treasury does through the bureau of printing and engraving and the U.S. mint. Since your whole model is based on this flawed premise there is no need to even answer to the rest of it.

Whoever is given the power to create money can and must siphon real wealth away from others.

In your example no wealth was stolen from the "late receivers" in order to give it to the "early receivers", when the hike in prices eroded the purchasing power of the late receivers it also eroded the purchasing power of the "early receivers" in the exact same proportion. So even if your model does not make any sense (The Fed does not print money and "give" it to the gov.) it doesn't prove your point, it actually shows your point to be incorrect.

And i guess you'll never fetch the data to backup your claim about The Fed "creating money out of thin air" and "giving" it to the government. Next time you make an assertion be sure you can actually prove it.

"Fiat money = theft" ... lol.

But you know what's funnier? The fact that the same reasoning you are trying to apply here, can also be applied when using commodity money. Just substitute the unit of account you are using in your model, and instead of incorrectly saying "The Fed prints money" change it for "A mine owner produces more gold" and you'll see the exact same thing happening: that is, prices going up because of an imbalance in the monetary sector with all agents seeing the same new price levels. Still no theft or transfer of wealth from the "late receivers" to the "early receivers".
 
Last edited:
oahuoahu: so because you don't understand some basic economic principles there must be an elite conspiring to control the population through the use of minimum wage. Wow.

Seems like this elite didn't learn a thing from countries like China or India. The good thing is, they just exist in your imagination.
 
If I work 50 hours a week at mcdonalds, i should be able to make enough money to support a family and 3-4 kids and buy a house.
Why? I'm a computer programmer, and I can't afford that.

I agree that our standard of living has increased. but there are still a lot of people in poverty and poor or working crapy jobs, and their standard of living should be as high as mine too and it should be easy to accomplish that in a technologically advanced society.
Again, why? Also how?

Okay, if you mean "should" as in "it would be nice if", then that's fine, and something we can work towards through continuing technological and economic growth. But we aren't there yet.
 
UGH MY POINT IS THIS. we live in a technological age today where every man, as long as he works 50 hours a week, should be able to support himself and his family and 3-4 kids.


OK. For the sake of being sociable, I'll ignore the inherent sexism of your statement and agree with you that it would be nice if this is the way the world worked.


I know raising the minimum wage to a living wage is a bad idea, but SOMETHING ELSE IS WRONG here.


Why? I mean how do you "know" this? Maybe it's true, but why is it certainly true?


If I work 50 hours a week at mcdonalds, i should be able to make enough money to support a family and 3-4 kids and buy a house.


So, what place does our economy have for marginal workers? If a full-time job at McDonalds paid that well, what does our economy do with the teenage workers, the mentally disabled and the elderly who cannot or do not want to work full time at a skilled position?

I agree that McDonalds and other corporations take advantage of our marginal labor force, but I don't see why we need to destroy marginal labor as a concept.


This should occur naturally in a free economy without the government even needing to mandate a minimum living wage.


I would think the very existence of marginal laborers would cause the economy to shape itself naturally away from what you are claiming.


The elite must have somehow engineered society to prevent that from happening, because if one man could so easily support his family and 4 children, you would see the population of a technologically advanced society nearly double every 4 generations. So the elite must have seen that problem a long time ago (before the easy access to technology) and manipulated the money and economic system to prevent that from happening today.


Whoa! That's quite a leap.

Why does the fact that the economy exists in its present form mean that some "elites" designed it to exist in its present form? It seems like the same argument as inferring the existence of God because the human hand is so complex. Why does one necessarily imply the other?

Do you have any evidence for your statements? Do you have any idea how such design could have been accomplished? Do you have any sort of list of whom these "elites" might be?

Do you have, in short, any reason other than your own sense of justice as to why any of this should be true?
 
@Truthseeker1234



The model was complete, at the end of your model the exact same thing happened: both the "late receivers" and the "early receivers" were seeing the same price level.

At the end of my model, each at the same cash balance, but the loaves of bread had been resdistributed. Didn't you notice this? The government started with nothing, and ended up with cash and loaves? Did this escape you?

First of all, The Fed does not print any money. The U.S. treasury does through the bureau of printing and engraving and the U.S. mint. Since your whole model is based on this flawed premise there is no need to even answer to the rest of it.

Fiat money is created through the issuance of new debt. The treasury prints a piece of paper called a "bond" and the Fed prints a piece of paper called a "check". They swap paper. That is, the Fed "buys" the "bond" with "checkbook money". This increases the "balance" in the "bank account" of the "government". The "government" then writes "checks" to buy what it wants. These government contractors deposit those checks into their "accounts" at their "bank". The "Bank" counts this as an increase in "reserves". This allows them to issue new debt of their own, "pyramiding" on top of their new reserves in some ratio, say 6:1. The Fed sets this ratio.

If this sounds absurd, that's because it is absurd. It's perfectly correct and true, and it is absurd. Our current money system is entirely built on debt, and is backed by nothing of value.


In your example no wealth was stolen from the "late receivers" in order to give it to the "early receivers", when the hike in prices eroded the purchasing power of the late receivers it also eroded the purchasing power of the "early receivers" in the exact same proportion. So even if your model does not make any sense (The Fed does not print money and "give" it to the gov.) it doesn't prove your point, it actually shows your point to be incorrect.

Wrong on both counts. The partnership of the Fed and the Treasury absolutely do create money out of this air, and inject it into the banking system in the form of new loanable funds. The government gets money to spend that it never collected in taxes. The methodology is complex, but for analysis, it is completely correct to just imagine that their is a printing press where The Fed and The treasury simply print money for themselves at will.

You have again put words in my mouth, stop it. I didn't say that one person's dollars were worth more than another person's at any point in time. Yes, purchasing power erodes.

The point is that real wealth is redistributed in the process.

Fiat money = theft. That's the whole reason they set the system up that way, silly. Did you really think it was to "manage the economy"? LOL.

And i guess you'll never fetch the data to backup your claim about The Fed "creating money out of thin air" and "giving" it to the government. Next time you make an assertion be sure you can actually prove it.

I've just explained it again in this post. Treasury prints bonds, Fed prints checks, they swap. Presto, new money.

"Fiat money = theft" ... lol.

I'd be laughing too if I was AlanGreenspan.

But you know what's funnier? The fact that the same reasoning you are trying to apply here, can also be applied when using commodity money. Just substitute the unit of account you are using in your model, and instead of incorrectly saying "The Fed prints money" change it for "A mine owner produces more gold" and you'll see the exact same thing happening: that is, prices going up because of an imbalance in the monetary sector with all agents seeing the same new price levels. Still no theft or transfer of wealth from the "late receivers" to the "early receivers".


No, not true, already explained.

Mining gold is hard work. It has a cost associated with it. Every ounce of gold requires labor and equipment. Gold had market value separate and apart from it's value in exchange. Thus is constitutes wealth.

Fiat money is essentially costless to produce. It costs no more to produce $10,000 bills than $1 bills. Checks can be written for any amount. Fiat money has no value, other than as a medium of exchange. Therefore it does not constitute wealth.

Heres a test for you:

Anything which actually benefits society, we want people to do. On the market, there is no problem with having many gold mines. If another producer wants to start a new gold mine, great. Now think about printing up unbacked paper money. Ever wonder why the government monopolized it? If it is good for society, why not let others do it also?

Answer that question, and you have understood why fiat money is evil.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom