federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Victory is mine. Alan Greenspan has admitted that inflation is just like a tax. I.e. that it transfers real wealth away from some and into the hands of others.

No, inflation is called a tax because it transfers real wealth into the hands of government

If the government so much as spends this money, it gets handled by everybody else, eventually, and nobody wins or loses.

Your theory is thereby proven wrong.

Thank you.
 
you, as a computer programmer, should make enough money to support 15 children and buy 4 houses.

Not with my salary, we can't.

80 years ago, people working in the food business could flip burgers their entire life and if he saved his money properly he could make enough money to buy a house and send his kids to college.

But then he had nothing left to eat.

but the lowest jobs on that scale would still be good jobs.

Not to send your kids to college it won't.

someone flipping burgers would make enough income to support 4 kids and buy a house, someone programming computers would make 3 times that income.

Before tax, that is.
 
No, AlanGreenspan. Here you betray your evident amorality. Inflation is a real effect in the real world, with real consequences for real people. Innocent people.

You say "innocent people" as though the 'government' was made up of "evil" people.

You do realise that inflation is actually not a bad thing, right ? You DO want your salary to increase, don't you ?

Oh, perhaps you want to go back to the early 1900s and the coal mines ?
 
Oh, perhaps you want to go back to the early 1900s and the coal mines ?


Actually, he'd probably love it. Because you know what those late-19th century coal mining towns had? Their own private money.

Issued by the company, redeemable only at the company stores, free from inflation or government manipulation - private money freed those coal miners to ... die of black lung. It was a golden age.
 
No, inflation is called a tax because it transfers real wealth into the hands of government, just as taxation does.

Your ignorance on this subject is quite overwhelming, to say the least. When the Central Bank publishes an annual rate of inflation ... is it publishing a level of revenues the government got by an alternative tax? No, it is publishing the rate of change in the consumer's price index.

When the government decides to finance its expenditures with monetary emission is not through inflation that it gets the revenues, inflation is a product of this measure not the measure itself. This is the only case where the term "inflation tax" is used, since not every time there is a change in the price levels is because the government financed its expenditures with monetary emission. If you ever saw the Hicks-Hansen model you would know that inflation can result from a change in fiscal or monetary policy that transfers no wealth into the hands of the government.

Get some formal education on this subject Truthseeker1234, or at least don't claim to be "very knowledgeable" in it when you are that ignorant.

Answer this for me. If I counterfeit $1,000,000 and use the money to buy a condo at the beach, who have I hurt?

The whole economy.
 
No, AlanGreenspan. Here you betray your evident amorality. Inflation is a real effect in the real world, with real consequences for real people. Innocent people. If you will not admit that inflation is has real consequences then I am done with you.

When did i say it was an imaginary phenomenon? What part of "it is the rate of change of an index" got you so confused? You do know what a rate of change is, right?

On the free market, the overwhelming tendency is for the prices on consumer items to come down.

I already addressed this absurdity. What incentive would there be to invest in a given market knowing that in the next period prices will be lower? How will labor intensive goods be produced if eventually all firms will go bankrupt? You said the price comes down because of a technological advance, but since it is a labor intensive firm a change in technology will only make the workers more productive, and since factors of production are paid according to their productivity salaries will have to be raised too so the overall effect in the cost structure will be null.

So no, there is no such tendency because such tendency is just absurd. Quit making stuff up and get some education in the subject.
 
The whole economy[is hurt if i counterfeit $1,000,000 and buy a condo at the beach].

The "whole economy"isn't a person. Which people get hurt? Whose rights are violated? Everybody's? Including me, the hypothetical counterfeiter?

Really? I get hurt too, even though I know have a new condo at the beach that i never had before?

Let me try again, this time be honest.

If I counterfeit $1,000,000 and buy myself a condo at the beach, who is hurt?

Answer this question (honestly) and you will be on the road to understanding the subject of the thread.
 
The "whole economy"isn't a person. Which people get hurt?
Every single person and institution in the world.
Whose rights are violated?
Every single institution and person in the world.
Everybody's?
Yes.
Including me, the hypothetical counterfeiter?
Yes
Yes.
I get hurt too, even though I know have a new condo at the beach that i never had before?
Yes, you get hurt in two ways. First, all of your real money is worth less because you've added money to the economy without adding anything of equal value, so that causes inflation.

Second, you've now transformed yourself from a law-abiding citizen to a criminal. You've exposed yourself to the justice system and to punishment from the state. You now face the possibility of incarceration which you did not face before. That's a real risk and it's a real negative on your balance sheet.

You can't ignore the fact that you are now living under the threat of ten years of incarceration. That has a value which (if the system is working right) more than offsets your new condo.

If I counterfeit $1,000,000 and buy myself a condo at the beach, who is hurt?
Every person and institution in the world.
 
Yes, the whole economy.Yes, even the hypothetical counterfeiter.

I fail to see what is the relation between counterfeiting and monetary policy using fiat money ... but after reading the absurdities and nonsense you've written in this thread i would not be surprised if you make one up.
 
Yes, the whole economy.Yes, even the hypothetical counterfeiter.

I fail to see what is the relation between counterfeiting and monetary policy using fiat money ... but after reading the absurdities and nonsense you've written in this thread i would not be surprised if you make one up.


I would guess that he wants you to admit that the counterfeiter is not hurt so that he can draw a parallel between the counterfeiter as the "first" receiver of money and the rest of us as "late" receivers. This would make sense except that the counterfeiter doesn't create anything of value to offset the money he creates. The US Gov't does create something of value when it the Fed issues bonds that are bought with new money.

[Well, technically new value is not "created," instead future tax revenues are transformed from a future expectation into their present value. We borrow from the future. So long as our economy expands, this is a great deal. The value we borrow from te future is able to cause us to increase our productivity today so that the future gets even more benefit out of its investment. It is almost exactly the same as going back in time, starting a small catalogue company, jumping forward in time and having it be Sears.]
 
So the counterfeiter would be the creator and "first receiver" of the new money? I wonder when was the last time the Federal Reserve bought a condo with notes they just received from the treasury.
 
So the counterfeiter would be the creator and "first receiver" of the new money? I wonder when was the last time the Federal Reserve bought a condo with notes they just received from the treasury.


Who cares? When was the last time a conterfeitor guaranteed his counterfeit bills with future tax revenues?
 
For the sake of argument, let's assume the counterfeiter will not be caught.

Ignoring that the counterfeiter might get caught, do you all admit that the counterfeiter makes himself financially better off, at the expense of others?

Also, are you able to see that all others are not necessarily harmed equally?

Let's expand my example a little. Let's say the market value of the condo is only $800,000, but the counterfeiter agrees to pay $1,000,000 for it anyway. The guy who sold the condo is happy too. He's got an extra $200,000. That's more than enough to make up for the erosion of his purchasing power.

Are you guys honest enough to admit that counterfeiting will benefit the counterfeiter and also possibly the early receivers, while harming the late receivers of the new money?
 
You say "innocent people" as though the 'government' was made up of "evil" people.

You do realise that inflation is actually not a bad thing, right ? You DO want your salary to increase, don't you ?

Oh, perhaps you want to go back to the early 1900s and the coal mines ?

Increases in the standard of living are caused by increases in productivity and technological advances. Salaries in money terms are completely relative. $1,000,000/year is poverty if bread costs $10,000/loaf. $20,000 is affluent if bread costs $.01/loaf.

Inflation does not cause the standard of living to rise. Period. Inflation does greatly benefit some individuals, and greatly harms others. That is the subject of this thread.
 
For the sake of argument, let's assume the counterfeiter will not be caught.


"For the sake of argument, let's assume that there are no negative consequences to the counterfeiter. Do you all agree that there are only positive consequences to the counterfeiter?"

TS1234, that's not a concession I'm willing to make "for the sake of argument." When the US government (I'm conflating the Fed and the Treasury for a moment) prints new money, it also creates a negative so that both sides of the equation are even. It issues a bond indebting itself in the exact amount of the new money.

When the counterfeiter makes himself money, he enters a negative against himself as well. That negative is the chance of being caught and going to jail.

It doesn't even matter whether the counterfeiter gets caught. The moment he prints his first bill, he creates a possibility of going to jail. He creates a danger to himself that did not exist before. It's a negative outcome of his action and it equals or (if the system works right) exceeds the positive.

You cannot assume away half an equation.


Are you guys honest enough to admit that counterfeiting will benefit the counterfeiter and also possibly the early receivers, while harming the late receivers of the new money?


Are you honest enough to admit that by assuming away the negative consequence to the counterfeiter, you destroy any possible argument you think you had?
 
TruthSeeker1234: do you have a point with this counterfeiting example? I hope you are not really trying to relate an expansion of the money supply with printing money in your backyard ... that would be too ignorant, even for you. No wait, that's exactly what we should expect from you given the other thing's you've said.

Increases in the standard of living are caused by increases in productivity and technological advances.

An increase in the productivity of labor leads to raise of salaries/wages. A raise in the salaries leads to an increase in prices, that is: inflation. This is basic microeconomic theory TruthSeeker1234, something someone who claims to be "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ" shouldn't be forgetting.
 
And how many currencies were there before the federal reserve? Wasn't it over 30,0000? And that was when? 1913? Imagine that today. There would probably be millions of em and all based on different standards. Gold, silver, bonds, etc. Hell imagine going to the bank and not having any guarantee you could get your money...
 
[LossLeader Logic mode]

Although some points in history are full of redoubtable inferences, the conspicuous servitude inherent in all forms of societal modality are nontheless blatantly obsequious, fully granting their own value between further deviations not realized until some point in the future. Are you fully willing to admit Truthseeker, that despite the nonsequitors wrapped in false premises that permeate the landscape of linguistic verbosity, all taxation is fully repudiated upon nothing more and nothing less than the abstract flotation bubble bursting behind blending piano bench firecrackers in the wind? Yes or No? Of course you do not understand, because the answer is so obvious as to allude to the breath of fresh sausage now swirling scientifically amidst the angry colony of labor-theory dendrites masquerading as a catecholamine. Or words to that effect.

[/Loss Leader]

Go practice "law".
 
And how many currencies were there before the federal reserve? Wasn't it over 30,0000? And that was when? 1913? Imagine that today. There would probably be millions of em and all based on different standards. Gold, silver, bonds, etc. Hell imagine going to the bank and not having any guarantee you could get your money...

Eventually, jonny, there was 1.

Imagine. A worldwide gold standard, that occurred spontaneously.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom