federal reserve conspiracy!!!

I was under the impression that money throughout history was always controlled by the government. I distinctly remember Caesar's face on a coin, somewhere.


That's only true for coined money. The rise of paper money was an uncontrolled mess. Basically, any bank that wanted to could start issuing certificates based on its gold reserves.

In the early days of paper money, before the civil war, a region could have ten or twenty different currencies floating around - each one with a different value. Then, traveling to a different area of the country often meant that noone in your new state recognized the bank that was holding your money. So they wouldn't honor the bills. If you wanted to travel from New York to, say, Georgia, you needed to slowly work your way down the coast exchanging your paper bank notes at the far south of their influence for bank notes at the far north of their influence. You might have to exchange your currency five different times on a thousand mile trip.

As you can imagine, the lack of standardization caused terrible inefficiency. Did the bank really have the gold? Was this bill a forgery? What was the gold to dollar ratio for this bank compared to another one? And, as you can imagine, since a bank's certificates had to be backed up fully by gold deposits, it was very difficult for banks to lend out their gold capital to collect interest on the theory that everyone wouldn't cash their money in on the same day. Without the ability to borrow on credit, individuals could not invest in new enterprises and the economy could not grow nearly as rapidly as today.

The Civil War was the beginning of the end for private money. By taking control of the paper money supply, the US government standardized money so that it was accepted anywhere. This freed laborers and entrepreneurs to to travel to wherever their services were usefull. It also allowed banks to lend more than they actually had. This spurred a humoungous growth in infrastructure including railroads, canals, factories and more.

The private money experiment was over and for good reason - it didn't work.

Source: Greenback: The Almighty Dollar and the Invention of America
 
Last edited:
A few years ago, I read the book The History of Money, which is a pretty good explanation for the layman of how money as a social concept developed. He's an anthropologist, so the parts discussing the social aspects of money are especially good, but some of his more modern details are a little off.
 
But can I understand that most money in Earth's history was government-backed ?


Yeah ... welll ... um ... sort of.

Take the rise of paper money as a good example. Paper money began in Europe with the immensely rich and far-flung Medici family. Say it's 1630 and you want to move from Florence to Paris. You need money for your trip but you don't want to take all your gold and silver pieces with you because a) they're heavy and b) you will get robbed at some point on the road. So you could go to the Medici family in Florence and give them all of your money in exchange for a certificate of deposit. Then, when you got to Paris, you could present the Medici family there with your Florentine certificate and they would give you metal coins in exchange (less a small commission).

The question is whether this was private money or government money. The answer is: um ... both ... sort of. The Medicis were a private family but they were so damn rich they more or less were the Government. In 1630, a Medici was the Queen of France. Being rich and being the government were basically the same thing.

In general, coined money was a government enterprise. Paper money was a mix of private and government.

You can still to this day get private paper money. They're called bonds. They're often freely transferable and untraceable, just like cash. If you don't believe me, ask this guy.

Yipee-kay-yay m[rule8]er[rule8]er!
 
Truthseeker1234, since your post includes so much nonsense let's try to debate what you are saying one thing a time. Let's start with this particularly funny bit:

In your world Intel would have the same profits as the mom’n’pops next door.
The same rate of profit, yes.

I guess that by rate of profit you meant a profits/investment ratio, so what incentive would Intel have to go into the complicated business of computer hardware when they can just just put up a bead & breakfast inn and have the same rate of return on their investment?

In this golden model of yours there no incentive to invest in innovation or any high risk business since you would have the same return on your investment if you just invest in a grocery store. Wow, and this comes from someone who claims to be "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ".
 
Please take the time to understand the reasoning behind this, the tendency for the rate of profit to equilibrate is a well-established economic principle. It is not original with me.

First, this has to do with a free market. In our non-free market real world, rates of profit are all over the place.

The rate of profit is never exactly equal for all economic actors, but market forces relentlessly pull the rate of profit toward the average. Investors do not seek average profits, of course. They seek maximum profits.

If Intel dropped out of the chip-making business, and went into the food business, here's what would happen.


1. Supply of computer chips goes down, price of computer chips goes up.
2. Supply of food goes up, price of food goes down.
3. High prices on computer chips send signals to investors of new high-profit opportunity.
4. Low prices on food causes losses, some producers go bankrupt.
5. Investment shifts from bankrupt food companies to high-profit computer chip opportunity.
6. Supply of food goes back down, prices go back up.
7. Supply of computer chips goes back up, prices go back down.

Rates of profits are pushed toward the average. Relentlessly.

In fact, this theory is so sound, it can be used as a very reliable "government interference detector". Show me any situation where rates of profit are persistently higher or lower than average, and I will show you heavy government involvement in the situation.
 
Please take the time to understand the reasoning behind this, the tendency for the rate of profit to equilibrate is a well-established economic principle. It is not original with me.

I do understand what you are trying to state here. But we don't live in a perfect competitive world where all profits tend to 0. We live in a world that in the best case scenario resembles a Cournot equilibrium.

The rate of profit is never exactly equal for all economic actors, but market forces relentlessly pull the rate of profit toward the average. Investors do not seek average profits, of course. They seek maximum profits.

No no, i asked you if Intel would share the same rate of profits with the mom'n'pops next door and you said yes. Don't backtrack on me sport.

If Intel dropped out of the chip-making business, and went into the food business, here's what would happen.


1. Supply of computer chips goes down, price of computer chips goes up.
2. Supply of food goes up, price of food goes down.
3. High prices on computer chips send signals to investors of new high-profit opportunity.
4. Low prices on food causes losses, some producers go bankrupt.
5. Investment shifts from bankrupt food companies to high-profit computer chip opportunity.
6. Supply of food goes back down, prices go back up.
7. Supply of computer chips goes back up, prices go back down.

Wait a minute there little Hayek. Remember that earlier you said that a goldllar would be worth the same in the whole world and if this miracle currency is cure of all evil, then every country would be using it so there won't be any incentive to put money into chips production when you can live by the beach with the same return on your investment. Chips will effectively disappear. But there will be plenty of goldllars available.

On the other hand, i believe you are starting to contradict yourself. First you claimed that the rate of profits would be the same for everyone, but now you claim it has a relative fluctuation.

And guess what? what you describe is exactly what happens when you use fiat money.

In fact, this theory is so sound, it can be used as a very reliable "government interference detector". Show me any situation where rates of profit are persistently higher or lower than average, and I will show you heavy government involvement in the situation.

And do you somehow think that government intervention can only happen when using fiat money? What holds a government from imposing price controls in your golden market?
 
No no, i asked you if Intel would share the same rate of profits with the mom'n'pops next door and you said yes. Don't backtrack on me sport.

I said, on the market, the rate of profit tends to be the same for all activities. This is a relentless tendency. It is relevant to this thread, because the same would apply to gold mining and the private production of money. It was in answer to the fear that gold mines would be unfairly rewarded, or something.

If you're going to argue about rates of profit on a free market, then do so. You haven't made an argument yet, and frankly, I'm more interested in what you think is wrong with my contention that fiat money = theft.


Wait a minute there little Hayek. Remember that earlier you said that a goldllar would be worth the same in the whole world and if this miracle currency is cure of all evil, then every country would be using it so there won't be any incentive to put money into chips production when you can live by the beach with the same return on your investment. Chips will effectively disappear. But there will be plenty of goldllars available.
I never said anything remotely like what you're claiming. When you resort to such obvious fabrications, you betray the vacuous nature of your position.

On the other hand, i believe you are starting to contradict yourself. First you claimed that the rate of profits would be the same for everyone, but now you claim it has a relative fluctuation.

And guess what? what you describe is exactly what happens when you use fiat money.
The rate of profit tends toward the average. This is well-established theory. The relevance to the thread is that this would apply to the production of gold, and gold backed money, the same as it applies to everything else.

And do you somehow think that government intervention can only happen when using fiat money? What holds a government from imposing price controls in your golden market?

I never said that. Governments have been imposing price controls on all sorts of things for thousands of years, always with the same disastrous results. If prices are held below market, result is a shortage, if prices are held above market, result is a surplus.

If you are done fabricating statements for me, perhaps you could spend some time addressing the subject of the thread.

Fiat money = theft, says me. Argue otherwise, or admit I'm right.
 
Now that's a lot of backtracking. I thought the profits nonsense was somehow important to your point. Just so we're on the same page: the behavior of profits under a competitive market is the same no matter the currency used. What you said about rate of profits being the same for Intel and the mom'n'pops next door was not only absurd, it would cause no good for anyone. You ended up contradicting yourself.

All this coming from someone who is "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ".

Fiat money = theft, says me. Argue otherwise, or admit I'm right.

You are absolutely wrong. The arguments you have proposed as basis for this are as flawed as your reasoning behind the rate of profits for firms in different industries.
 
I never said anything remotely like what you're claiming. When you resort to such obvious fabrications, you betray the vacuous nature of your position.

I believe your exact words were "there is no exchange rate" ... i am not fabricating anything here. Still, you can keep trying to give that impression it's quite fun watching you do that.
 
AlanGreenspan, Nice try at the switcheroo. Your strawman was about government intervention under fiat money.

If two (or more) "countries" are both on a 100% gold standard, there is no exchange rate between them. An ounce of gold is an ounce of gold.

No one has offered any argument as to why fiat money is not theft.
 
Er, you were the one who brought up government intervention. You said that in any situation where the rate profits are higher than average there must be some heavy government intervention, you also said that under a gold standard the rate of profits is the same for everyone. Those are your own words sport, and it seems like you are trying to say that government intervention is particular to the use of fiat money.

No one has offered any argument as to why fiat money is not theft.

That is because you have not offered any arguments yourself to support what you're saying. All you've put forth is some flawed reasoning (and now some backtracking) loosely based on basic economic theory, like the nonsense about the rate of profits being the same for everyone.
 
can someone apply these arguments to the UK situation?

the goverment has no monopoly to print money in the UK so how is it different in the US?

just wondering, i am enjoying this post even though it has squat to do with much IMO
 
I have offered a clear theoretical explanation for why the creation of fiat money must redistribute wealth.

It is here.

Stop with strawmanning and flamebaiting, and get with the logical argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom