federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Fiat money is created through the issuance of new debt. The treasury prints a piece of paper called a "bond" and the Fed prints a piece of paper called a "check". They swap paper. That is, the Fed "buys" the "bond" with "checkbook money". This increases the "balance" in the "bank account" of the "government". The "government" then writes "checks" to buy what it wants.
You keep claiming this. I asked you once to show where in US revenue (publicly available information) this money is accounted for. You haven't done so. Put up or shut up Ace.
 
Mining gold is hard work. It has a cost associated with it. Every ounce of gold requires labor and equipment. Gold had market value separate and apart from it's value in exchange. Thus is constitutes wealth.
Pure nonsense. The market value of any product has nothing to do with the cost to produce said products. If it did, the gem-quality synthetic diamond market would be thriving. It isn't, because it costs far more to make them than people are willing to pay for them. Gold has no inherent value of its own - if people stopped wanting it the gold market would collapse.

Fiat money is essentially costless to produce. It costs no more to produce $10,000 bills than $1 bills. Checks can be written for any amount. Fiat money has no value, other than as a medium of exchange. Therefore it does not constitute wealth.
You are confused about how money is created. The Treasury doesn't simply print money. In fact, the notes in circulation is a percentage of the money in existence. The Treasury prints paper notes, they don't create money. There is a difference.
 
I did not mean to imply that cost had anything to do with value. This would be the labor theory of value, ala Smith and Marx, and is wrong.

1. Gold is costly to produce, this is one limiting factor on its production. This has nothing to do with its market value.
2. Gold has a market demand separate from the demand for its use as money. That it is a tangible commodity with market demand is why it counts as real wealth.

I hope that clears it up.
 
2. Gold has a market demand separate from the demand for its use as money. That it is a tangible commodity with market demand is why it counts as real wealth.
Its market demand is because people like pretty shiny things. If people stop liking pretty shiny things or prefer pretty shiny things other than gold, the price will plummet. Why you would want to base an economy on something as fickle as the price of gold is beyond me. Theoretically, the price of gold could fall to such an extent that there would not be enough gold in the entire world to buy a new car. What then Ace? This is why fiat money is superior - it has a value independent of fickle commodity prices.
 
At the end of my model, each at the same cash balance, but the loaves of bread had been resdistributed. Didn't you notice this? The government started with nothing, and ended up with cash and loaves? Did this escape you?

Of course i did notice this, but you were not talking about an inflation tax you instead you were talking about an imaginary theft committed by the "early receivers". Inflation tax is just another form for the government to get more revenues, the negative effect on the economy will obviously depend on how much of the government expenditures is financed in this way.

About the redistribution: seeing this is a two goods model with no producers and and initial allocation of goods, this redistribution took part because of the utility function of the agents, that is: they chose this absurdity to take place. This is basic microeconomics that someone who claims to be "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ" should be able to understand. In this particular model you can replace the goods with "A" and "B" and you will have the same outcome.

Fiat money is created through the issuance of new debt. The treasury prints a piece of paper called a "bond" and the Fed prints a piece of paper called a "check". They swap paper. That is, the Fed "buys" the "bond" with "checkbook money".

Now i get it, you are not only clueless on basic economic theory but you also have no idea about how the monetary system works in the United States. What you said is just incorrect. The U.S. treasury through the bureau of printing and engraving prints the federal reserve notes, issuing bonds is another completely different thing.

This increases the "balance" in the "bank account" of the "government".

You are confusing federal notes with treasury bonds, when the government want to finance its expenditures by taking a loan (from anyone) the treasury department issues the Treasury Bonds. When The Fed buys these treasury bonds it is monetizing government debt. It is buying a debt owed by the government, not just "printing money out of thin air and giving it to the government" ... by the way, you have not produced the data to backup this particular claim. Could it be that you were talking out of your ass, eh little Hayek?

These government contractors deposit those checks into their "accounts" at their "bank". The "Bank" counts this as an increase in "reserves". This allows them to issue new debt of their own, "pyramiding" on top of their new reserves in some ratio, say 6:1. The Fed sets this ratio.

And this is the part that takes the cake, seriously you have a lot to read on this subject. When the banks receive a deposit the are not allowed to lend this money on a 6:1 ratio, in fact by law banks are required to keep in their reserves what in some countries is called "legal reserves". This is the main concept behind fractional reserve banking, and since you seem to ignoring it is not a surprise that you make the silly claims you've been making this far.

Read up on fractional reserve banking and you'll realize the absurdity you just claimed. I hope you are responsible enough to come back an admit how wrong you've been in this subject ... somehow, i doubt you are that responsible.

Our current money system is entirely built on debt, and is backed by nothing of value.

No, it is actually built on purchasing power rather than intrinsic value.

The partnership of the Fed and the Treasury absolutely do create money out of this air, and inject it into the banking system in the form of new loanable funds. The government gets money to spend that it never collected in taxes.

You keep claiming that, yet when asked for the data (which is publicly available) to backup your claim you just ignore the request and go back to repeating the same claim. Shall we just take your word for it? The words from someone who just claimed that banks could lend 6 times the money they have in their reserves?

I've just explained it again in this post. Treasury prints bonds, Fed prints checks, they swap. Presto, new money.

The treasury prints federal notes, not bonds. When the government wants to borrow, the treasury issues treasury bonds which are not the same as federal notes.

Mining gold is hard work. It has a cost associated with it. Every ounce of gold requires labor and equipment. Gold had market value separate and apart from it's value in exchange. Thus is constitutes wealth.

Still, an increase in the supply of gold (without an increase in the demand) will cause an imbalance in the monetary sector which will have the same effect on your (flawed) model.

Ever wonder why the government monopolized it? If it is good for society, why not let others do it also?

Really? I mean, are you really asking this in a serious tone?
 
Victory is mine. Alan Greenspan has admitted that inflation is just like a tax. I.e. that it transfers real wealth away from some and into the hands of others.

Thank you for your (belated) intellectual honesty.
 
Fiat money is created through the issuance of new debt. The treasury prints a piece of paper called a "bond" ...
Tell me more about this piece of paper called a "bond". Does any sort of benefit accrue to its possessor?

Only I'm aware that some pieces of paper can be quite valuable. Share certificates, for example. Or title deeds. Or contracts. Or government bonds, whoops, my mask of ingenuousness just slipped off, my bad.
 
@Truthseeker1234

Victory is mine. Alan Greenspan has admitted that inflation is just like a tax. I.e. that it transfers real wealth away from some and into the hands of others.

Thank you for your (belated) intellectual honesty.

Er, weren't you talking about "fiat money = theft" ... when did you change it to "inflation tax = theft". LOL, seeing you backtracking was fun but what you are trying to do now is even funnier.

In case you didn't know, an inflation tax is not particular to the use of fiat money. In fact the term seigniorage came from a feudal practice involving gold coins. Get some formal education in the subject little Hayek, you have a lot to read.

Another thing, i didn't "admit that inflation is just like a tax" ... no no, you missed my point entirely. Lookup what an inflation tax is and then you'll understand what i meant. Or if you want i can give you a brief explanation ... but wait, how come someone who claims to be "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ" would misunderstand what an inflation tax is like you just did? Perhaps you and i have very different definition of what "Very knowledgeable" is.

Inflation is just the rate of change of an index, Hayek. Nothing more, nothing else. An inflation tax happens when the government finances its expenditures with monetary emission which leads to higher inflation rates. It is called an inflation tax because even if the government is not receiving revenues through taxation, it causes an increase in the price levels which erodes the purchasing power for all agents in the economy. Still not a theft.
 
Last edited:
No, inflation is called a tax because it transfers real wealth into the hands of government, just as taxation does.

Answer this for me. If I counterfeit $1,000,000 and use the money to buy a condo at the beach, who have I hurt?

Please answer this question.
 
Fiat money has no value, other than as a medium of exchange. Therefore it does not constitute wealth.
...

Answer that question, and you have understood why fiat money is evil.

As a moral, upstanding human being, it would be remiss of me to let you continue your evil ways. I am willing to take one for the team and relieve you of your evil burden. Please send me all your fiat money immediately, so that you may resume your life of ease, free from the influences of evil.
 
Why? I'm a computer programmer, and I can't afford that.

you, as a computer programmer, should make enough money to support 15 children and buy 4 houses.


80 years ago, people working in the food business could flip burgers their entire life and if he saved his money properly he could make enough money to buy a house and send his kids to college.


I would think the very existence of marginal laborers would cause the economy to shape itself naturally away from what you are claiming.

sure some jobs would pay more money. but the lowest jobs on that scale would still be good jobs. someone flipping burgers would make enough income to support 4 kids and buy a house, someone programming computers would make 3 times that income.

today we live in a economy where there aren't enough good jobs to go around. people who go to college or get lucky or work their way up get those good jobs, and the rest of people with the bad jobs have to somehow deal with it (the best way i've seen is you got 1 house with 12 people in it, and all 12 of those people work a bad job to make enough income to work things out between them and they are trying to get through the system to find good jobs while doing this) or they just become homeless or who knows what happens to them. then the people who actually have good jobs feel all high and mighty look at the homeless people on the street and laugh at them and say "go get a job!!". since both my parents make pretty good income im going to college i will probably get a good job, but i wont look at homeless people and laugh at them i will realize its not their fault for most of them.

well im only 19 years old. maybe i will get drafted into the military. whatever happens i dont care.

anyway i wasn't debating with u guys on the existance of the elite. I was just talking to the other CT'ers out there that know the elite exists and I was telling them how our dollars are not the problem its something else thats the problem. i just dont know what it is yet.
 
you, as a computer programmer, should make enough money to support 15 children and buy 4 houses.
Why? Is computer programming a rare skill demanding high pay?


80 years ago, people working in the food business could flip burgers their entire life and if he saved his money properly he could make enough money to buy a house and send his kids to college.
No, they couldn't. You might want to check and see how many people actually went to college 80 years ago, and the percentage of people who owned their own homes. I guarantee you the percentages of both are far higher today.

sure some jobs would pay more money. but the lowest jobs on that scale would still be good jobs. someone flipping burgers would make enough income to support 4 kids and buy a house, someone programming computers would make 3 times that income.
Why? What special skill is required to flip burgers? But I bet programmers make at least 3 times the wage of a burger flipper.

today we live in a economy where there aren't enough good jobs to go around. people who go to college or get lucky or work their way up get those good jobs, and the rest of people with the bad jobs have to somehow deal with it (the best way i've seen is you got 1 house with 12 people in it, and all 12 of those people work a bad job to make enough income to work things out between them and they are trying to get through the system to find good jobs while doing this) or they just become homeless or who knows what happens to them. then the people who actually have good jobs feel all high and mighty look at the homeless people on the street and laugh at them and say "go get a job!!".
Things must be pretty rough in Hawaii! Perhaps you should move to the mainland, nothing like that going on here.

since both my parents make pretty good income im going to college i will probably get a good job, but i wont look at homeless people and laugh at them i will realize its not their fault for most of them.
I suggest you take a few economics classes when you go to college.

well im only 19 years old. maybe i will get drafted into the military. whatever happens i dont care.
No, you won't get drafted. There is not a draft, nor will there be one.

anyway i wasn't debating with u guys on the existance of the elite. I was just talking to the other CT'ers out there that know the elite exists and I was telling them how our dollars are not the problem its something else thats the problem. i just dont know what it is yet.
The problem is your longing for "the good old days" that never really existed. Where burger flippers raised families with one wage earner and owned their own homes!
 
well im only 19 years old. maybe i will get drafted into the military.
Are you an American? Because if you are, the chances of you being drafted into the military are zero right now. That's because there is no draft law on the books, so the U.S. military is an all-volunteer organization.

For you to be drafted, a draft law would have to be passed in Congress and signed by the President. Given the enormous political wrangling that would occur around any bill proposing a draft or other mandatory military service, and given the fact that no such legislation has been put forth or even seriously suggested, you are quite safe from being drafted into the U.S. military.
 
i guess i just foolishly believe that today with technology advances things should be a lot better.

meh i dont care doesn't matter if i'm right or wrong doesn't really effect anything that happens to my future haha. im just talking and stuff
 
The problem is your longing for "the good old days" that never really existed.
In this regard I highly recommend a television series from Britain entitled The Worst Jobs in History. It's been played a couple of times now on History Television (Canadian version of the History Channel).

The program examined, in a fun and interesting way, some of the most thoroughly unpleasant and difficult jobs in history, starting with the Roman period and working forwards. Fascinating stuff, and involving a lot of things I'm sure most folks today have never thought of or heard of before.
 
@Truthseeker1234

Inflation is just the rate of change of an index, Hayek. Nothing more, nothing else.

No, AlanGreenspan. Here you betray your evident amorality. Inflation is a real effect in the real world, with real consequences for real people. Innocent people. If you will not admit that inflation is has real consequences then I am done with you.

On the free market, the overwhelming tendency is for the prices on consumer items to come down. The cause of price inflation is the creation of money, beyond the creation of new goods and services. This is why the Austrians define inflation the way they do - it has greater explanatory power.
 
In this regard I highly recommend a television series from Britain entitled The Worst Jobs in History. It's been played a couple of times now on History Television (Canadian version of the History Channel).

The program examined, in a fun and interesting way, some of the most thoroughly unpleasant and difficult jobs in history, starting with the Roman period and working forwards. Fascinating stuff, and involving a lot of things I'm sure most folks today have never thought of or heard of before.
I've seen it, the worst in my opinion was the job of "fuller". A fuller made wool cloth nice and soft by removing the lanolin. Why was that such a bad job you say? Because it required you to march in place all day in a vat of human urine and wool cloth. And everyone whose last name is Fuller probably had an ancestor doing this job.

Ah, here it is.
 
Also, Wildcat, all valuation is subjective. Economic value is a purely subjective human emotion.


Except for gold which has some sort of objective value that for some reason makes it the world's best form of money, I think you meant to say.


sure some jobs would pay more money. but the lowest jobs on that scale would still be good jobs. someone flipping burgers would make enough income to support 4 kids and buy a house, someone programming computers would make 3 times that income.


First of all, why four kids?

Second of all, you're still ignoring the marginal labor force. There are plenty of people out there who neither want nor need jobs that pay the kind of money you're talking about. What the hell does the Downs Syndrom guy at McDonalds who sweeps up need with fifty thousand dollars a year? If you raise the price of unskilled labor, then skilled people are going to take those jobs. Then the guy who lives in a group home doesn't have a job anymore. The high school student doesn't have a job. The retiree doesn't have a job.

Never mind, I see your buzz wore off and you admitted you don't know what you're talking about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom