@Truthseeker1234
Newsflash: the world is a very different place today, different economies have different currencies, some are let to float free others are pegged. What you are trying to sell here is a global parity which is just nonsense, how do you expect that two different economies like the U.S.’s and Bangladesh’s will have a 1:1 exchange rate?
I realize that having lived your whole life under fiat money, it is difficult to re-conceptualize money. Under a gold standard, there is not a 1:1 exchange rate. There is not a 2:1 exchange rate. There is no exchange rate. Money is measured in weight. Ounces and pounds, grams and kilograms, not dollars and not marks. "Dollars" are simply receipts or titles to money.
If a region (like Bangladesh) is poor, it is because they do not produce very many goods and services per person. Playing around with "exchange rates" does not solve this problem. If it could solve the problem, you would be hard pressed to explain why there are any poor regions in world at all. The real problem with poor regions is tyrannical governments which disallow people from owning things.
And there you go again with the parity. Get this into your head: two different economies can’t have a 1:1 exchange rate, why? Because the weakest economy will have an overvalued currency … you do know hat happens in this situation, right? Or shall I explain it for you?
Stop with the strawman argument. The problems with over- and under-valued currencies are problems with fiat money, not gold. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. Gold is gold. An ounce is an ounce. There are no exchange rates in gold.
So in your golden world an economy like Cuba’s will have a currency with the same value as the U.S.’s even when they are widely different economies. In time of crisis monetary authorities in Cuba won’t be able to make any effective monetary policy because of this fixed exchange rate regime.
You are correct. Governments the world over would not have the power to enact "monetary policy". That is the whole point. "Monetary Policy" is theft. The idea is to put a stop to it. Correct.
Again, it’s a good thing that you are searching for the truth and not drafting monetary policy for any country.
That's like thanking me for not committing murder. You're welcome, I don't want to commit monetary policy, it is theft.
And in your book [privately issued money] is somehow a good thing? Didn’t you say at the beginning of your post that you were “quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ”? What happened to your knowledge when you were writing that statement? it sure went out the window.
Money originated on the market, privately. It was then forcibly taken over by governments. Yes, money should be privatized for the same reason that everything else should be privatized. Competing private firms have incentives to be efficient and to please customers, governments do not have those incentives.
Apparently you know very little about the asian monetary crisis of 90’s. One of the main reasons of the capital flight was exactly what you are proposing: a virtual parity that caused these currencies to get overvalued.
This is Orwellian. We live in a world of unbacked, fluctuating fiat currencies. How could you possibly blame the gold standard for that? Preposterous.
But what you propose goes even further, you propose a fixed exchange rate and the use of commodity money which can lead (due to the finite nature of the commodity) to rising interest rates and overvaluing of the currency (exactly what led to the asian crisis) that in turn will cause a hike in the price levels. Wow, I wonder why no one will ever heed your advice.
Historically, we know that during the worldwide gold standard, prices were gradually falling for a hundred years, during a time of unprecedented economic growth. Repeat, not a fixed exchange rate.
Apparently you don’t know what you’ve been implying so far. If every country takes your advice (God help us) they will have a fixed exchange rate with the rest of the countries. Again, didn’t you say at the beginning of your post that you were “quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ”?
Yes, and I'm also very knowledgeable about the Austrian school, which is far more important. I'm not denying that what you say is what is taught in mainstream econ. I'm arguing that it is wrong. Just as I could easily regurgitate the official story of 9/11, I could easily regurgitate Samuelson tripe. I have studied economists from Smith to Keynes, Marx to Malthus, Galbraith to Friedman, and many points in between. It is Mises and Rothbard who make sense, and who have debunked the others.
And do you think this is good? Do you really think it is profitable to start a business knowing that prices are going to be lower in the next periods? I’ll give you a small microeconomic example of what you propose. Let’s assume there’s a company named Kooks’r’us that has benefit function of the form: PQ-(CF+CV) they only use one input: labor. Fixed costs are 5000 and variable costs are 2000, current price for the good they produce is 500 and they produce 15 units of it. In this first period they have $500 in benefits. In the next period, according to your reasoning, the price of Kooks’r’us good goes down and keeps on going down for the next periods until it reaches $300 … solving the benefit function yields a negative amount of -2500.
Are you sure you are that knowledgeable on this subject?
The reason prices comes down in a free market is because innovation leads to a reduction in costs. Thus a firm can offer lower prices, and maintain profitability. Changing costs is not in your example.
You have done nothing to refute the theoretical proof that on the market, the rate of profit tends towards the same for all activities. If you think about it, it could not be any other way. Prices will direct resources to their most highly valued use.
You didn’t reply to the fact I pointed out. I’ll repeat for you so you read it and actually address what I said:
So in your golden model if there's inflation because demand was higher than supply then your investors will "pull some assets out of gold" ... but this will have a negative effect, demand will still be higher than supply and now producers will have to pay more for the credit because of a rising interest rate due to less gold being mined and available to be lent. To pay their obligations producers will have to raise their prices and matters will get worse.
You forgot to finish your analysis. In your example, investors will pull out of gold, and into the area of high demand. This increases production in the area of high demand, thus lowering prices, and pushing profitability back toward the average.
Without realizing it, you are about to stumble into the Austrian theory of the business cycle.
Increased consumer demand for present goods will cause them to save less. Lowered savings means less loanable funds, so the interest rate goes up. The higher interest rate causes investors to shift out of capital goods industries, and into consumer goods, because capital goods are more sensitive to the interest rate. And this is exactly the outcome we want. Consumers demand more in the present, and the price signals cause investors to respond correctly.
Decreased consumer demand for present goods will cause them to save more. Higher savings means more loanable funds, so the interest rate goes down. The lower interest rate causes investors to shift out of consumer goods, and into capital goods industries. Again, exactly the outcome we desire.
[/quote]
Still I would like to address something I saw in that ray of knowledge you just shared. How on earth are profits going to be equal for all businesses? Are you out of your mind? Not only are you claiming each firm has the same benefits function they also are producing at the same level and using the exact same number of inputs. I think you’ve never been close to an economics books, 10 yards top.
In your world Intel would have the same profits as the mom’n’pops next door.
[/quote]
The same
rate of profit, yes.
On the market, the constant tendency is for the rate of profit to converge toward an average. It never gets there of course, but that is the driving tendency. With government intervention, there are all sorts of things which prevent the market from functioning correctly.
I already addressed that particular claim, you are free to hold as much gold as you want. Since your argument resides on the intrinsic value of gold you can melt all your coins into bullions and still have the same value.
No, you didn’t explain anything related to the contraction of legal reserves. I did however answer to that particular nonsense with this:
That could be the case in a scenario where the Central Bank is an active agent of the economy, where it has the ability to spend the money it creates. In the case of the Federal Reserve the “money creators” receive no transfer of wealth.
The bit about the “late receivers” and “early receivers” makes no sense in the context of a Central Bank that manages the growth of the money supply according to the changes in the demand. A stable and predictable rate of inflation does away with your argument about the transfer of wealth from the “late receivers” to the “early receivers”.[/quote]