federal reserve conspiracy!!!

The market did not select fiat money. Fiat money was imposed by force, by government. The U.S. government made it a felony to refuse paper money, and eventually confiscated all the monetary gold.

And yet it is neither currently illegal to refuse the US dollar, nor is it illegal to own gold. Although, technically, the possession of "monetary gold" (in the technical sense of something redeemable for either x amount of money or y amount of gold) is illegal, gold is freely traded in the open market.

What are the current laws stopping you from holding 100% of your wealth in the form of gold, Ace? The Executive Order banning private gold ownership (except for small quantities as jewelry, etc.) has been dead for over 30 years.

You implore Alan to "learn history," but you seem to be missing a big chunk of history that deals with the gold standard in the US and the creation of the Reserve.
 
The Quantity Theory of Money, is the QToM. Regardless of who's behind it, the assumptions are the same.


Only if the Velocity of money is fixed. Do you even understand the equation?

This whole discussion is Sisyphean at best.

Yes Abby, I understand. It is George Reisman who gives a rigorous treatment of the Austrian QTM. He explains how it subsumes cost-push and demand-pull. Changes in velocity are symptoms of changes in money supply, or changes in consumer time preference. I could link you, but I don't think you care.

I am still waiting for you to give a coherent explanation of why fiat money does not equal theft, which is the subject of the thread.

Can you? Will You?
 
Fiat money = theft. I have to agree. You see, back in the mid-'70's, I owned a cute little sports car, a Fiat X 1/9. Dark green, with gold racing stripes, pop-up headlights, two-seater. When it ran, it was fun, but keeping it running was a headache! Since it was a mid-engine sports car, just changing the plugs meant having to practically pull the engine!
So, having spent tons of money to get almost no real enjoyment from it, I would call that theft.
Therefore, Fiat money = theft.
Also FIAT actually stands for Futile Italian Attempt at Transportation. Just thought I'd add that.
As far as the money stuff goes, my bet is that Ace is just as correct as he is about anything else. Not very.
 
Or "Fix It Again, Tony".


Still waiting for anyone to offer an argument for why fiat money is not theft.

Several people have already, Ace. Your ignoring them doesn't do much to help you make your case.

My latest - a few paragraphs down.

Your only sound case for fiat money = theft might be arguing that it steals wealth from everyone (via inflation) and gives it to no one, unless you're privvy to some secret of economics regarding monetary policy. Yet you've actually argued that it somehow "gives" wealth to the money creators. Never mind that the actual money creator is an abstract pseudo-government entity with salaried employees.

Not only that, but fiat money can be removed from circulation as well, generally decreasing inflation and increasing the value of each dollar on the market. That also counts as theft, Ace?
 
The monetary crises are a problem of fiat money and fractional reserve systems, not gold. Under gold, there is no exchange rate. An ounce of gold is an ounce of gold.

And yet it can STILL fluctuate.

Also, not enough gold for everybody.

Plenty of paper, though.

The market did not select fiat money. Fiat money was imposed by force, by government. The U.S. government made it a felony to refuse paper money, and eventually confiscated all the monetary gold.

Then why can I use a credit card ?
 
Don't expect Ace to answer this one.

Yeah... I'm kind of not.

I'm also not really expecting him to address my little history-based questions, because they don't happen to support his assumptions about the Reserve, fiat currency, or the gold standard.

What really galls me is what appears to be an implication on his part that non-backed currency is responsible for some unprecedented loss of real wealth on the part of the general populace.

Again, I maintain that Ace needs to read up on history a bit more if he honestly believes the general populace is worse off than ever before, economically speaking. The same holds true if he thinks simply bringing back the gold standard will fix all of our problems.
 
OK, here's the assertion you call an argument:

You claim that "fiat money = theft" is meaningless, because theft requires that someone take something from someone else. Although excessive production of currency can reduce overall wealth through excessive inflation, that is not necessarily the case. More to the point, that inflation wouldn't help anyone, it would hurt everyone who has a stake in the economy based on that currency, including the wealthy.

Wrong. The creation and spending of fiat money does help someone. It benefits the early receivers of the new money, especially it benefits the creators of the new money, as explained.

Here's another way for me to argue my same point. If it is OK for one entity to create new money out of thin air, why is everyone not allowed to do it? On the free market, there is no problem with people mining gold. The mining of gold will be limited by supply and demand, the same way supply and demand limit the production of everything.

So, Johnny, you have avoided the point. The creation of fiat money (which used to be known as counterfeiting, BTW), hurts some while benefiting others. Had you actually read my argument, you would have known this.

Can anyone actually explain any errors in the theoretical argument that fiat money = theft? I am still waiting.
 
Not only that, but fiat money can be removed from circulation as well, generally decreasing inflation and increasing the value of each dollar on the market. That also counts as theft, Ace?

This is why a 100% gold backed currency is not only the best protection against inflation, but also of deflation and depression as well. Under a gold standard, once money comes into existence, it stays in existence.
 
And yet it is neither currently illegal to refuse the US dollar, nor is it illegal to own gold. Although, technically, the possession of "monetary gold" (in the technical sense of something redeemable for either x amount of money or y amount of gold) is illegal, gold is freely traded in the open market.

What are the current laws stopping you from holding 100% of your wealth in the form of gold, Ace? The Executive Order banning private gold ownership (except for small quantities as jewelry, etc.) has been dead for over 30 years.

You implore Alan to "learn history," but you seem to be missing a big chunk of history that deals with the gold standard in the US and the creation of the Reserve.

The complete takeover and monopolization of the the dollar began in 1913, and was completed in 1971. In 1913 refusal to accept paper was made a felony. In 1933, ownership of gold was made a felony. Until 1971, foreign banks and governments could still redeem in gold. The last remnant of the gold standard was shredded when Nixon closed the "gold window". All monetary gold was out of circulation in safely in Fort Knox. The takeover was finished.

As far as I know, it is still illegal to refuse Federal Reserve Notes in payment of debt. "Legal tender for all debts, public and private".

It would take a long time for the gold standard to re-emerge on the market, but if allowed, it will. As the dollar becomes less and less valuable, gold-backed private currency will become more and more attractive. Unfortunately, I'm sure government will act to thwart private money, should it ever begin gaining any sort of foothold.
 
I'm glad I can goad you into eventually answering me, Ace. At least you don't have me on ignore. You've much better than 28th Kingdom was.

Wrong. The creation and spending of fiat money does help someone. It benefits the early receivers of the new money, especially it benefits the creators of the new money, as explained.

You have categorically not explained how the "early receivers" benefit in any way, Ace. When new money is created and circulated, it is distributed into the economy at large through the banking system, or held in reserve. Who is benefitting? You still haven't explained this in a concrete way.

Here's another way for me to argue my same point. If it is OK for one entity to create new money out of thin air, why is everyone not allowed to do it?

Because it would create rampant inflation and the currency would be worthless. That is why the protection of currency and prevention of counterfeit is a major priority for the Treasury department.

Fiat currency's value is preserved by controlling the supply of it, as gold's value is controlled because it is naturally scarce. The monopoly of production on fiat money you rail against is what helps to protect that currency from inflation.

This is one of the reasons the Fed was created as somewhat apart from the rest of the government, to preserve its neutrality. Additionally, the people behind the Fed's policy are all salaried employees chartered with working towards a stable, workable monetary policy. The Federal Reserve is not some free-wheeling entity, as you may believe. Similarly, it is not a mere puppet of the executive or legislative branch. The Fed is designed to objectively pursue a monetary policy that is most beneficial to the general economic health of this country.

On the free market, there is no problem with people mining gold. The mining of gold will be limited by supply and demand, the same way supply and demand limit the production of everything.

Gold is inherently limited by supply, being a scarce, non-renewable resource.

So, Johnny, you have avoided the point. The creation of fiat money (which used to be known as counterfeiting, BTW), hurts some while benefiting others. Had you actually read my argument, you would have known this.

You don't distinguish between counterfeiting and legal production of currency, which is silly.

Yes, the creation of additional currency does hurt some... but probably not in the way you think. Your argument about "new receivers" versus "old receivers" is actually obscuring the issue.

In reality, the creation of additional money tends to hurt lenders and help debtors, due to the devaluation of the currency the loans were originally made in. This has a lot to do with my historical question, if you plan on asnwering it.

Can anyone actually explain any errors in the theoretical argument that fiat money = theft? I am still waiting.

Your definition of "theft" is flawed and you still haven't established how these "first receivers" are benefitting from a fiat currency. Please provide concrete examples of your claims, it makes it much easier to evaluate them. How would this "theft" proceed, precisely?

This is why a 100% gold backed currency is not only the best protection against inflation, but also of deflation and depression as well. Under a gold standard, once money comes into existence, it stays in existence.

Unless, of course, someone removes it from the market. Or the economy expands too fast.

It's funny you mention deflation and depression. Would you like to discuss the return to the gold standard after WWI and the subsequent economic consequences?

The complete takeover and monopolization of the the dollar began in 1913, and was completed in 1971. In 1913 refusal to accept paper was made a felony. In 1933, ownership of gold was made a felony. Until 1971, foreign banks and governments could still redeem in gold. The last remnant of the gold standard was shredded when Nixon closed the "gold window". All monetary gold was out of circulation in safely in Fort Knox. The takeover was finished.

Actually, the issues with the gold standard began several years earlier, with President Wilson's commitment to attack the three things he saw as destructive the American people - one of which was the bankers.

In the middle of the first decade of the 1900's, Wilson began the actions that would lead to the creation of the Federal Reserve in 1913. The existence of the Fed, and the corresponding elasticity of the currency, allowed for the rapid economic expansion during the first World War. With the strict gold standard, reserves tended to concentrate in major private banks, preventing the currency market from quickly adjusting to a growing economy.

After WWI, there was a push to return to the old gold standard. Returning to the standard at pre-war price levels caused a massive deflation of the currency. This proved destructive to those already in debt (e.g. farmers, business owners), as they lacked sufficient currency to pay off their debts, especially those incurred during inflationary years. Deflation brought down both incomes and prices (and hence business profits), but the debt remained.

This immense debt burden was one of the central causes of the Great Depression.

The recovery from the GD is a story of both removing the gold standard and deficit spending, both of which helped provide the means to stimulate the economy.

As far as I know, it is still illegal to refuse Federal Reserve Notes in payment of debt. "Legal tender for all debts, public and private".

You don't read what I write, do you? Or read the links I post?

According to the US Treasury, it is not illegal to refuse Reserve notes. If you believe otherwise, please cite the current law to this effect. The US Treasury, that prints those notes and distributes them to the Fed, disagrees with you.

It would take a long time for the gold standard to re-emerge on the market, but if allowed, it will. As the dollar becomes less and less valuable, gold-backed private currency will become more and more attractive. Unfortunately, I'm sure government will act to thwart private money, should it ever begin gaining any sort of foothold.

What is stopping you from simply transferring all your wealth into gold now? The executive order was repealed three decades ago - you are free to buy and sell gold all you want. Why don't you just do this?

You're right, if the dollar became less valuable on the market it would be less attractive to investors.

Which is why it's so good that, in the US, private individuals are not prevented from buying commodities on the free market, or other currencies. We are free to invest in pretty much whatever we want, even gold, without the wrath of our government descending on us.

You also switch off between talking about a gold standard (i.e. a currency backed in gold with an exchange rate set and enforced by the government) and free market gold. We already have free market gold, and it seems odd that you would want the government not to control fiat money but are perfectly comfortable with them controlling and enforcing the gold standard.
 
OK, here's the assertion you call an argument:
Wrong. The creation and spending of fiat money does help someone. It benefits the early receivers of the new money, especially it benefits the creators of the new money, as explained.
If I understand correctly, you argue that early receivers have an advantage because the market is at first not fully adjusted to the new situation with an expanded money supply. The early receivers can buy things before the inflationary effect has been fully adjusted for.

It is true that people can gain an advantage when the market is not yet adjusted to a new situation. The extent a single person can use this depends of course on the actions he takes in such a situation. If prices are lower than would be the case on a perfect market, people who buy things are generally better of than the people who sell. In your example of counterfeit money, the guy who sold the condo is in theory on the losing side. If he had waited before the inflationary effect had kicked in, he could have sold the house for more.

So early receivers do not necessarily benefit. Only if they use this money to buy certain things, they will gain a (negligible) benefit. If the Fed buys all my government bonds and pays me with newly created money, I will be on the losing side if I just put this money on the bank. The market will adjust to the new situation and I will not benefit at all. My money will be worth less because of the inflationary effect.

In general (and again theoretically speaking because the effect is usually insignificant) people who buy win, people who sell or do nothing lose. This is not always the case. The people who buy government bonds (TIPS excluded) for example lose. Government bonds are less attractive when there is high inflation.

The FED expands the money supply mainly through Open Market Operations. It buys government bonds on the secondary market. The nominal value of these securities will remain the same so the FED is on the losing side.

Expanding the money supply could create a situation where the market is not yet fully adjusted. Arguing that the early receivers of the newly created money (who could be anyone who happens to be selling securities when the Fed has decided to buy) will benefit and all others will lose is nonsense. It doesn't matter if I buy a condo of the money I got from selling securities to the Fed or if I buy a condo of the money I got from selling the securities to a Mr. Smith.

The only possibility to foul play is when there is no transparency. People who know about the Fed's intentions might take better decisions than people who don't know. But the Fed is transparent about it's intentions and makes it's objectives for monetary policy public after each meeting.

Btw: the entire argument is imo irrelevant. Inflation is stable and highly predictable. The argument would be relevant in a situation where inflation would fluctuate heavily.
 
@Truthseeker1234

Learn history and learn theory. Originally, currencies were based on precious metals, notably gold and silver. The British "pound" was exactly that, 1 pound of silver. A certificate for one pound of silver will exchange for another certificate for one pound of silver, regardless of what names are printed on the certificates.

Newsflash: the world is a very different place today, different economies have different currencies, some are let to float free others are pegged. What you are trying to sell here is a global parity which is just nonsense, how do you expect that two different economies like the U.S.’s and Bangladesh’s will have a 1:1 exchange rate?

Perhaps you should worry about learning economics yourself before trying to worry about other people’s education.

But to think that there would be an exchange rate from one gold back currency to another gold backed currency misses the whole point.

And there you go again with the parity. Get this into your head: two different economies can’t have a 1:1 exchange rate, why? Because the weakest economy will have an overvalued currency … you do know hat happens in this situation, right? Or shall I explain it for you?

Rothbard clears up your confusion. Purchases are made in weights of gold. Paper money, or magnetic card digits, are simply a method to keep track of the weights being exchanged. 0.23 ounces for lobster dinner and a glass of wine.

So in your golden world an economy like Cuba’s will have a currency with the same value as the U.S.’s even when they are widely different economies. In time of crisis monetary authorities in Cuba won’t be able to make any effective monetary policy because of this fixed exchange rate regime.

Again, it’s a good thing that you are searching for the truth and not drafting monetary policy for any country.

On the market, money is not issued by governments. It is issued by anyone who wants to issue it.

And in your book this is somehow a good thing? Didn’t you say at the beginning of your post that you were “quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ”? What happened to your knowledge when you were writing that statement? it sure went out the window.

The monetary crises are a problem of fiat money and fractional reserve systems, not gold.

Apparently you know very little about the asian monetary crisis of 90’s. One of the main reasons of the capital flight was exactly what you are proposing: a virtual parity that caused these currencies to get overvalued.

But what you propose goes even further, you propose a fixed exchange rate and the use of commodity money which can lead (due to the finite nature of the commodity) to rising interest rates and overvaluing of the currency (exactly what led to the asian crisis) that in turn will cause a hike in the price levels. Wow, I wonder why no one will ever heed your advice.

Please get this straight. The gold standard is not a "fixed exchange rate", it is no exchange rate. An ounce of gold is an ounce of gold. Gold is money, the pieces of paper are simply receipts. They don't set values for anything.

Apparently you don’t know what you’ve been implying so far. If every country takes your advice (God help us) they will have a fixed exchange rate with the rest of the countries. Again, didn’t you say at the beginning of your post that you were “quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ”?

Changes in supply and demand move prices of individual goods up and down, of course. This is not a sustained, general change in price level.

I am talking about aggregated demand and supply, sport. I shouldn’t make this observation to someone who’s “very knowledgeable in undergrad econ”.

The current value of the dollar is less than 1/100 what it was in 1913.

Relative to what? And can you back that up with actual data?

To explain that change in overall price level in terms of reduced supply would require a greater reduction in economic output than occurred after the fall of the Roman Empire.

You do know that for demand can be higher that supply even when supply is growing? Just checking since your example seems to be forgetting this tiny, but obvious, bit.

The only explanation for this is that the money supply has expanded 100 times more than the production of goods and services.

Again, can you back that up with actual data?

Under sound money, the tendency is for prices to fall gradually, as production methods become more and more efficient. This serves to make money increase in value as it is held.

And do you think this is good? Do you really think it is profitable to start a business knowing that prices are going to be lower in the next periods? I’ll give you a small microeconomic example of what you propose. Let’s assume there’s a company named Kooks’r’us that has benefit function of the form: PQ-(CF+CV) they only use one input: labor. Fixed costs are 5000 and variable costs are 2000, current price for the good they produce is 500 and they produce 15 units of it. In this first period they have $500 in benefits. In the next period, according to your reasoning, the price of Kooks’r’us good goes down and keeps on going down for the next periods until it reaches $300 … solving the benefit function yields a negative amount of -2500.

Are you sure you are that knowledgeable on this subject?
On the market, the rate of profit tends to be equal for all businesses, including the production of money, and the lending of money. Anytime any activity becomes more profitable than average, it will attract more producers, thus increasing the supply, lowering prices and pushing profitability down towards the average. Anytime any activity becomes less profitable than average, it will repel some producers, thus decreasing the supply, increasing prices and pushing profitability up towards the average.

You didn’t reply to the fact I pointed out. I’ll repeat for you so you read it and actually address what I said:


So in your golden model if there's inflation because demand was higher than supply then your investors will "pull some assets out of gold" ... but this will have a negative effect, demand will still be higher than supply and now producers will have to pay more for the credit because of a rising interest rate due to less gold being mined and available to be lent. To pay their obligations producers will have to raise their prices and matters will get worse.

Still I would like to address something I saw in that ray of knowledge you just shared. How on earth are profits going to be equal for all businesses? Are you out of your mind? Not only are you claiming each firm has the same benefits function they also are producing at the same level and using the exact same number of inputs. I think you’ve never been close to an economics books, 10 yards top.

In your world Intel would have the same profits as the mom’n’pops next door.

The market did not select fiat money. Fiat money was imposed by force, by government. The U.S. government made it a felony to refuse paper money, and eventually confiscated all the monetary gold.

I already addressed that particular claim, you are free to hold as much gold as you want. Since your argument resides on the intrinsic value of gold you can melt all your coins into bullions and still have the same value.

Explained here.

No, you didn’t explain anything related to the contraction of legal reserves. I did however answer to that particular nonsense with this:

That could be the case in a scenario where the Central Bank is an active agent of the economy, where it has the ability to spend the money it creates. In the case of the Federal Reserve the “money creators” receive no transfer of wealth.

The bit about the “late receivers” and “early receivers” makes no sense in the context of a Central Bank that manages the growth of the money supply according to the changes in the demand. A stable and predictable rate of inflation does away with your argument about the transfer of wealth from the “late receivers” to the “early receivers”.
 
@Truthseeker1234

Newsflash: the world is a very different place today, different economies have different currencies, some are let to float free others are pegged. What you are trying to sell here is a global parity which is just nonsense, how do you expect that two different economies like the U.S.’s and Bangladesh’s will have a 1:1 exchange rate?

I realize that having lived your whole life under fiat money, it is difficult to re-conceptualize money. Under a gold standard, there is not a 1:1 exchange rate. There is not a 2:1 exchange rate. There is no exchange rate. Money is measured in weight. Ounces and pounds, grams and kilograms, not dollars and not marks. "Dollars" are simply receipts or titles to money.

If a region (like Bangladesh) is poor, it is because they do not produce very many goods and services per person. Playing around with "exchange rates" does not solve this problem. If it could solve the problem, you would be hard pressed to explain why there are any poor regions in world at all. The real problem with poor regions is tyrannical governments which disallow people from owning things.

And there you go again with the parity. Get this into your head: two different economies can’t have a 1:1 exchange rate, why? Because the weakest economy will have an overvalued currency … you do know hat happens in this situation, right? Or shall I explain it for you?

Stop with the strawman argument. The problems with over- and under-valued currencies are problems with fiat money, not gold. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. Gold is gold. An ounce is an ounce. There are no exchange rates in gold.

So in your golden world an economy like Cuba’s will have a currency with the same value as the U.S.’s even when they are widely different economies. In time of crisis monetary authorities in Cuba won’t be able to make any effective monetary policy because of this fixed exchange rate regime.

You are correct. Governments the world over would not have the power to enact "monetary policy". That is the whole point. "Monetary Policy" is theft. The idea is to put a stop to it. Correct.

Again, it’s a good thing that you are searching for the truth and not drafting monetary policy for any country.

That's like thanking me for not committing murder. You're welcome, I don't want to commit monetary policy, it is theft.


And in your book [privately issued money] is somehow a good thing? Didn’t you say at the beginning of your post that you were “quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ”? What happened to your knowledge when you were writing that statement? it sure went out the window.

Money originated on the market, privately. It was then forcibly taken over by governments. Yes, money should be privatized for the same reason that everything else should be privatized. Competing private firms have incentives to be efficient and to please customers, governments do not have those incentives.

Apparently you know very little about the asian monetary crisis of 90’s. One of the main reasons of the capital flight was exactly what you are proposing: a virtual parity that caused these currencies to get overvalued.

This is Orwellian. We live in a world of unbacked, fluctuating fiat currencies. How could you possibly blame the gold standard for that? Preposterous.

But what you propose goes even further, you propose a fixed exchange rate and the use of commodity money which can lead (due to the finite nature of the commodity) to rising interest rates and overvaluing of the currency (exactly what led to the asian crisis) that in turn will cause a hike in the price levels. Wow, I wonder why no one will ever heed your advice.

Historically, we know that during the worldwide gold standard, prices were gradually falling for a hundred years, during a time of unprecedented economic growth. Repeat, not a fixed exchange rate.

Apparently you don’t know what you’ve been implying so far. If every country takes your advice (God help us) they will have a fixed exchange rate with the rest of the countries. Again, didn’t you say at the beginning of your post that you were “quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ”?

Yes, and I'm also very knowledgeable about the Austrian school, which is far more important. I'm not denying that what you say is what is taught in mainstream econ. I'm arguing that it is wrong. Just as I could easily regurgitate the official story of 9/11, I could easily regurgitate Samuelson tripe. I have studied economists from Smith to Keynes, Marx to Malthus, Galbraith to Friedman, and many points in between. It is Mises and Rothbard who make sense, and who have debunked the others.

And do you think this is good? Do you really think it is profitable to start a business knowing that prices are going to be lower in the next periods? I’ll give you a small microeconomic example of what you propose. Let’s assume there’s a company named Kooks’r’us that has benefit function of the form: PQ-(CF+CV) they only use one input: labor. Fixed costs are 5000 and variable costs are 2000, current price for the good they produce is 500 and they produce 15 units of it. In this first period they have $500 in benefits. In the next period, according to your reasoning, the price of Kooks’r’us good goes down and keeps on going down for the next periods until it reaches $300 … solving the benefit function yields a negative amount of -2500.

Are you sure you are that knowledgeable on this subject?

The reason prices comes down in a free market is because innovation leads to a reduction in costs. Thus a firm can offer lower prices, and maintain profitability. Changing costs is not in your example.

You have done nothing to refute the theoretical proof that on the market, the rate of profit tends towards the same for all activities. If you think about it, it could not be any other way. Prices will direct resources to their most highly valued use.

You didn’t reply to the fact I pointed out. I’ll repeat for you so you read it and actually address what I said:


So in your golden model if there's inflation because demand was higher than supply then your investors will "pull some assets out of gold" ... but this will have a negative effect, demand will still be higher than supply and now producers will have to pay more for the credit because of a rising interest rate due to less gold being mined and available to be lent. To pay their obligations producers will have to raise their prices and matters will get worse.

You forgot to finish your analysis. In your example, investors will pull out of gold, and into the area of high demand. This increases production in the area of high demand, thus lowering prices, and pushing profitability back toward the average.

Without realizing it, you are about to stumble into the Austrian theory of the business cycle.

Increased consumer demand for present goods will cause them to save less. Lowered savings means less loanable funds, so the interest rate goes up. The higher interest rate causes investors to shift out of capital goods industries, and into consumer goods, because capital goods are more sensitive to the interest rate. And this is exactly the outcome we want. Consumers demand more in the present, and the price signals cause investors to respond correctly.

Decreased consumer demand for present goods will cause them to save more. Higher savings means more loanable funds, so the interest rate goes down. The lower interest rate causes investors to shift out of consumer goods, and into capital goods industries. Again, exactly the outcome we desire.

[/quote]

Still I would like to address something I saw in that ray of knowledge you just shared. How on earth are profits going to be equal for all businesses? Are you out of your mind? Not only are you claiming each firm has the same benefits function they also are producing at the same level and using the exact same number of inputs. I think you’ve never been close to an economics books, 10 yards top.

In your world Intel would have the same profits as the mom’n’pops next door.

[/quote]
The same rate of profit, yes.

On the market, the constant tendency is for the rate of profit to converge toward an average. It never gets there of course, but that is the driving tendency. With government intervention, there are all sorts of things which prevent the market from functioning correctly.








I already addressed that particular claim, you are free to hold as much gold as you want. Since your argument resides on the intrinsic value of gold you can melt all your coins into bullions and still have the same value.



No, you didn’t explain anything related to the contraction of legal reserves. I did however answer to that particular nonsense with this:

That could be the case in a scenario where the Central Bank is an active agent of the economy, where it has the ability to spend the money it creates. In the case of the Federal Reserve the “money creators” receive no transfer of wealth.

The bit about the “late receivers” and “early receivers” makes no sense in the context of a Central Bank that manages the growth of the money supply according to the changes in the demand. A stable and predictable rate of inflation does away with your argument about the transfer of wealth from the “late receivers” to the “early receivers”.[/quote]
 
What about wide recievers? Does the NFL devalue their contribution by paying them in Italian Automobile Money? What about AM/FM recievers? Would they cost less if I bought them with gold instead of IAM? And what about platinum? Or even uranium, especially U-235? They're both more scarce and valuable than gold. Even more useful. Especially moreso than IAM!
Maybe this is what God was saying to Moses. "IAM that IAM!" Jehovah is Italian Automobile Money! I figured it out! Now I have to make up a really ugly website, and trick you all to visiting it! Then you, too, can see the true value of IAM!
 
Again, I maintain that Ace needs to read up on history a bit more if he honestly believes the general populace is worse off than ever before, economically speaking. The same holds true if he thinks simply bringing back the gold standard will fix all of our problems.

I was under the impression that we were better off than ever before, even if soft drinks don't cost a dime, anymore.
 
Wrong. The creation and spending of fiat money does help someone. It benefits the early receivers of the new money, especially it benefits the creators of the new money, as explained.

Technically, only for their first purchase.

And who are those "first receivers" ?

Here's another way for me to argue my same point. If it is OK for one entity to create new money out of thin air, why is everyone not allowed to do it?

You really don't understand why we have governments, do you ?

Can anyone actually explain any errors in the theoretical argument that fiat money = theft? I am still waiting.

IT IS INCORRECT.

This is why a 100% gold backed currency is not only the best protection against inflation, but also of deflation and depression as well. Under a gold standard, once money comes into existence, it stays in existence.

"Comes into existence" ? How ? By finding more gold ?

Oh, Ace:

What is stopping you from simply transferring all your wealth into gold now?

I realize that having lived your whole life under fiat money, it is difficult to re-conceptualize money. Under a gold standard, there is not a 1:1 exchange rate. There is not a 2:1 exchange rate. There is no exchange rate. Money is measured in weight. Ounces and pounds, grams and kilograms, not dollars and not marks. "Dollars" are simply receipts or titles to money.

What happens to countries with no gold reserves ?

I don't want to commit monetary policy, it is theft.

So you keep claiming.

It was then forcibly taken over by governments.

I was under the impression that money throughout history was always controlled by the government. I distinctly remember Caesar's face on a coin, somewhere.

The reason prices comes down in a free market is because innovation leads to a reduction in costs. Thus a firm can offer lower prices, and maintain profitability.

They'll also have to LOWER wages, Ace.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom