federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Well John, I contend the moon is made of gold. It's obvious it's not made of cheese or it would be blatantly unfair. Us of us born now would have to put up with a terrific stench. As late comers to the Earth that is completely unacceptable.

Furthermore you cannot just declare the moon to be cheese by your personal fiat, you need the solid backing of evidence! To support this I point you to a respected professionals opinion. The Economist in a 1991 article clearly states the moon is made of of gold (google it!).

Now as I've seen no one counter these arguments, I assume we can all agree that cheese is evil.
 
And you continue to refuse to address the way that the devaluation helps the trade balance. (Of which the US is in a negative one. Look up the BP curve.)

I addressed this. I'll do it again. Pay attention.

When any two parties agree to trade, both expect to benefit. This is true whether the trading partners are across the street or across the ocean. It makes no difference. All voluntary trade is beneficial. Every single trade.

All other things being equal, an increase in exports is good, because more trades have taken place. All other things being equal, an increase in imports is good, because more trades have taken place.

Attempting to use government force to "balance" imports and exports is a terrible idea, because it necessarily restricts trade. Trade is good. Preventing trade is bad. Economics does not see borders. They are economically irrelevant. If China were to become the 51st state, our trade imbalance with them would magically disappear. But nothing would be any different. Imagine China is the 51st state. Feel better?

I run a trade deficit with my grocery store. They never buy anything from me. Is this a problem to be dealt with by monetary policy? No.

Can anyone address the argument that fiat money = theft?

Thank You.
 
False. The Quantity Theory of Money is based on this equation: V=(nominal GDP/money supply). It is dependent on Velocity being fixed.

Don't believe me? http://www.investopedia.com/articles/05/010705.asp

or here: http://www.economyprofessor.com/economictheories/quantity-theory-of-money.php

Or just google the thing and take a look at the equation and necessary assumptions.


Your links are a to a mainstream economics take on QTM, and correctly points out that the assumption of a constant velocity is "criticized". This is where Friedman and the monetarists go wrong.

The Austrians most certainly do not say velocity is constant. As I said before, time preference is central to Austrian theory. Velocity, wage-push, demand-pull are not ignored in Austrian theory. Rather, since rising prices must be a result of increasing quantity of money, these are treated as symptoms, not causes.

Thus, rather than getting stuck in pedantic naming exercises, we actually have causative explanations for macro-phenomena, something curiously lacking in mainstream econ, if you hadn't noticed.
 
In your calculations of "late-receivers", you are ignoring the time it takes for the money supply to grow from an injection. This is one hundred percent dependent on the money multiplier. Something you've acknowledged you don't know of or understand.


Abby, I understand the money multiplier, and more importantly, I understand central banking. In the real world, the time it takes for the money supply to grow from the injection of new debt is not "dependent" on the money multiplier. It is dependent on how long it takes banks to make loans based on their newly increased reserves. The money multiplier is an abstract mathematical attempt to quantify the total money supply based on the existing supply of currency. The money multiplier does not exist in the real world. It is an abstract mathematical construct.

Nor did I forget the time element in my theoretical argument. In fact, it is crucial to the argument. Because it takes time for the money supply to grow, some people receive new money before prices have gone up, others are not so lucky. Remember, that's the whole point. Time is money. And fiat money is theft.
 
So you'd have competing monetary bases?

Are all monopolies bad? Firepersons? Policemen? Armies? Local mass transits?

<SNIP>.

Don't forget courthouses. In one thread, Ace actually proposed that an open and competitive judicial system would work. "Hey, I ain't going to that court any more! I got two to five there last time. I'm going over to Judge Feelgood's Court of Vast Appeal... He's advertising probation, no waiting, air conditioned holding cells...."

I can see Dog, The Bounty Hunter deciding to branch out from bailbondsman to magistrate. Hey, it's a free world!

I know libertarians who'd cringe at the fact that certain persons call themselves same.
 
Last edited:
Well, apparently it's the only "piece of evidence" you're willing to put forward. And it is not, in fact evidence. It's an opinion unsupported by fact.

So basically it's our fault that you won't supply any evidence for your views?

Let me assure you, round here facts are the only things that change people's minds --- not the mere opinions of some dead Nazi plutocrat.

But this is not "conventional mainstream wisdom" so much as classic Fascist paranoia; nor does he give any evidence for his views, which is what we actually put stock in round here.

As for him being "well-respected", he wrote propaganda for Herman Goering's magazine Die Vierjahresplan and attended the Nuremburg Rallies as a guest of Hitler. So he was well-respected by Hitler and Goering, yeah. But I, for one, think rather less of his judgement than they did.

I'll take this to 10 pages if it can shed light on one point - sorry Im not going to give you lots of arguments to arrogantly swot away like flies one by on - The prefered method of discourse round here.

If links to the nazi regime make someone 'kooky' or not 'conventional', then apparently there are a couple of American presidents who are not 'mainstream' enough for you.

Its like saying people in the darwinst movement were linked to irrational fascism,therefore natural selection is irrational - can we please get a bit more sophisticated?

I feel I need to tell you that 'facts' will always be interpreted subjectively. Two highly intelligent people with moral fibre acceptable to you will see the same facts differently - deal with it. Sometimes the insight of important people sheds light on the argument. You may know that that many other significant people in history have been very candid about the credit based system too.
 
Last edited:
I'll take this to 10 pages if it can shed light on one point - sorry Im not going to give you lots of arguments to arrogantly swot away like flies one by on - The prefered method of discourse round here.

If links to the nazi regime make someone 'kooky' or not 'conventional', then apparently there are a couple of American presidents who are not 'mainstream' enough for you.

Its like saying people in the darwinst movement were linked to irrational fascism,therefore natural selection is irrational - can we please get a bit more sophisticated?

I feel I need to tell you that 'facts' will always be interpreted subjectively. Two highly intelligent people with moral fibre acceptable to you will see the same facts differently - deal with it. Sometimes the insight of important people sheds light on the argument. You may know that that many other significant people in history have been very candid about the credit based system too.

If you can shed light on one point, you might take this to forty pages. Keep trying. I'll keep count. So far, you've tallied a score of... well, let's see now.... that'd be ..... Zero!

As to your latest derail. We can start with that one. You can shed light on it without even going to a new page. One post will do it.

Please list all the American presidents who attended the Nuremberg rallies and who made speeches in defence of Hitler.

Here, I'll save you the trouble:

Oh Noes! Is it the dreaded Bush's Grandaddy's Ties To Hitler theme? Kennedy's daddy's London connections? Lindbergh in '48????

(Other than those, I haven't seen a lot of pics of Roosevelt, Truman, or even Hoover, meeting up with and chatting with that paper-hanging fellow.)
 
@Truthseeker1234

Man you seriously should read and introductory economics book and leave all that conspiracy economics b.s. behind. I suggest you take a look at Mankiw's pre-grad book (can't remember the name right, i'll look it up).

As far as gold backed money is concerned, there is no exchange rate.

That is absurd. Plain and simple, saying that there is no exchange rate mean there's a global parity between all currencies and that's just nonsense.

If a dollar is defined as 1/20 of an ounce of gold, and some other currency is defined as 1/10 of an ounce of gold, then one of those would exchange for 2 dollars.

So now there is an exchange rate, make up your mind. So basically in your golden world what determines the exchange rate is what the value (measured in gold) the monetary authorities for each country "define" for their currency ... so if Cuba "defines" that their peso is worth 0.5 ounces of gold while the U.S.'s authorities "define" that the dollar is worth 0.25, then the Cuban peso has by default a higher value. Wow.

Since the exchange rate (when existing) is determined by some "definition" then the interest rates follow the same pattern ... problem is, since gold is a finite resource there's going to be a point where demand is higher than supply and the interest rates will be pressured to go up, which in turn will lead to a not so healthy situation: rising interest rates and a fixed exchange rate ... seems like you learned nothing from the Asian monetary crisis.

And since we are talking about a global fixed exchange rate regime, i suggest you do some reading on the Brazil 1998 and see the problems that arise when you have a fixed exchange rate in just one country. If you don't like Brazil you can try Chile 1979 or Mexico from 1996.

Sorry sport, "defining the value" is not a good monetary policy.

Speaking of the "exchange rate" between gold-backed currency makes no more sense than speaking of the "exchange rate" between $5 bills and $10 bills.

It is not a case of whether it makes sense or not, the problem is with the exchange rate regime that you would have to use. You are proposing a fixed exchange rate regime which is only good in time crisis and has to be dropped as soon as you move away from the crisis.

Inflation is defined as an increase in the supply of money relative to the supply of goods and services generally.

No, inflation is defined as the change (measured in %) in the price level. This is the generally accepted view shared by most (if not all) economists. If you like i can quote a few textbooks for you.

On the market, inflation occurs when the production of gold money exceeds the production of other goods. This will drive prices up generally, which is the same as saying that the value of gold has gone down, relative to everything else. This lowered value of gold means that gold mining has become less profitable, so investors will pull some assests out of gold, and seek a higher rate of return elsewhere. And, as with all other businesses, if gold production drops, the reverse happens.

Inflation will also occur when there's scarcity or a quality improvement. So in your golden model if there's inflation because demand was higher than supply then your investors will "pull some assets out of gold" ... but this will have a negative effect, demand will still be higher than supply and now producers will have to pay more for the credit because of a rising interest rate due to less gold being mined and available to be lent. To pay their obligations producers will have to raise their prices and matters will get worse.

Good thing you are seeking for the truth and not drafting monetary policy for any country.

Because the market selected gold. Historically, many things were used as money - seeds, seashells, cattle, salt, etc. Gold won.

Since you respect the decisions of the market so much, why don't you respect its decision to use fiat money instead of commodity money?

It is stealing real wealth from the late-receivers of the new money. In practice, individuals in the government, the banks, and government contractors win, basically everyone else loses.

That makes no sense, do you even know what contracting the legal base is? How is wealth stolen from anyone when the banks are required to keep less money in their reserves?

In the case of buying CD's your point gets ridiculous. When you go and sell a deposit certificate they don't steal it from you nor anyone, you get your money and go home to spend it on whatever you want and The Fed keeps the security in its possession so they can sell it later on when the need to expand the money supply arises.
 
How can you purport to criticize something you won't even read? Do you even understand the premise and logic underpinning my study? It doesn't seem so.

The premise is that everything is fake except your theory.

Your eyes will detect very unstable motion on the plane.

Yes. Hand-held cameras tend to do that.

Still photos are easier to fake than video. If they can fabricate one, they can fabricate 100.

Yes, Ace. Everything is fake. Everything.

It isn't any kind of litmus test. In order to fulfill your request, I would need to know the full range of possible movements for a powerloader, which I currently don't know. Then we could compare that to what is observed, to see if there is anything impossible being depicted.

Another good hint is the shadow of the crane that holds the thing from the back...
 
Once you start claiming evidence that contradicts your theory is fake, unless you can prove it your argument is lost.

Simply claiming contrary evidence could be faked with no further comment is lazy.
 
Nope. Unlike fiat money, gold is real wealth. Increasing the supply of gold increases the amount of real wealth. Even more importantly, on the market, there is no monopoly of money creation. It is the monopoly which is inherently evil. Monopolies bad. Competition good.

That is incredibly simplistic, Ace. Gold production needn't be monopolized (although gold mining certainly could be - another matter) because gold has an inherently limited supply. A free-floating currency must be restricted somehow or people will simply print their own money, and it will be valueless. That is the reason why paper assets need to be pledged to the government to create additional money, and why states and banks can no longer print their own currency.

Gold is "real wealth" only in that people are willing to pay for it. You seemed to clearly understand this when talking to me, now apparently gold is elevated above every other commodity.

Increasing the supply of gold doesn't "increase" the real wealth anymore than increasing the supply of paper money. If, suddenly, ten trillion tons of gold were rained down from space (in addition to everyone dying), gold would probably be worthless. Scarcity of an accepted medium of exchange tends to increase value, abundance tends to decrease value. That's the core principle behind inflation and deflation.

You claim that "fiat money = theft" is meaningless, because theft requires that someone take something from someone else. Although excessive production of currency can reduce overall wealth through excessive inflation, that is not necessarily the case. More to the point, that inflation wouldn't help anyone, it would hurt everyone who has a stake in the economy based on that currency, including the wealthy.

You still haven't answered my question:

-Why did those bankers in the late 1800's want the gold standard so damn badly? Why the pressure by the debtors to have the President take our money off the gold standard?

Additionally: Why would Woodrow Wilson, fierce opponent of the trusts and the bankers, work to take the US off the gold standard and set up the Reserve? What was the effect of the subsequent return to the gold standard? Any idea why the US went back off it again?

I suspect you haven't examined much of the history of the late 1800's and early 1900's around when the gold standard was revoked, reinstated, and revoked again. You paint this as a simple issue of greedy bankers stealing money from the poor, oppressed masses. It just isn't that simple, and the conspiracy sites only present a hollow picture of the issue.

Speaking of history, all laws regarding the private prohibition of gold ownership were repealed in 1975, Ace. The only thing still illegal is monetary gold (i.e. money backed by a fixed amount of gold - or a contract to that effect), but you're perfectly free to trade it in any way you see fit.
 
Price fixing is always a bad idea. Prices should always be free to fluctuate according to supply and demand.

And people should be allowed to use the money they want to use, not just gold.

On the free market, a "dollar" is simply a name for a particular weight of gold, say 1/20 ounce.

Actually, on the free masket, EVERYTHING is simply a name for a particular quantity of something else.

It was the result of thousands of years of natural selection. It spontaneously emerged as the best functioning money.

And yet it has no actual value.

Can anyone even attempt to counter the strong claim that fiat money creation = theft?

Yes. It's false. Next.

Because it takes time for the money supply to grow, some people receive new money before prices have gone up, others are not so lucky. Remember, that's the whole point. Time is money. And fiat money is theft.

So you're basing your conclusion on an expression ?

Wow.
 
The Austrians most certainly do not say velocity is constant. As I said before, time preference is central to Austrian theory. Velocity, wage-push, demand-pull are not ignored in Austrian theory. Rather, since rising prices must be a result of increasing quantity of money, these are treated as symptoms, not causes.

The Quantity Theory of Money, is the QToM. Regardless of who's behind it, the assumptions are the same.

Rather, since rising prices must be a result of increasing quantity of money, these are treated as symptoms, not causes.

Only if the Velocity of money is fixed. Do you even understand the equation?

This whole discussion is Sisyphean at best.
 
Does anyone else find it amusing that while some conspiracists are busy ranting about how all money is worthless, the rest of them are ranting about how everyone should horde as much of it as possible because it will be worth so much when the revolution comes?
 
I'll take this to 10 pages if it can shed light on one point - sorry Im not going to give you lots of arguments to arrogantly swot away like flies one by on - The prefered method of discourse round here.
You so very very nearly have insight into your situation.

If links to the nazi regime make someone 'kooky' or not 'conventional', then apparently there are a couple of American presidents who are not 'mainstream' enough for you.
Which American presidents supported Nazism, wrote propaganda for Goering, and attended the Nuremburg Rally as a guest of Hitler?

Its like saying people in the darwinst movement were linked to irrational fascism,therefore natural selection is irrational ...
No, it's not in the least like that. But I do appreciate that you can't argue with what I actually said. Feel free to hack away at your stupid straw man with you silly little toy sword.

I feel I need to tell you that 'facts' will always be interpreted subjectively. Two highly intelligent people with moral fibre acceptable to you will see the same facts differently - deal with it. Sometimes the insight of important people sheds light on the argument.
What's most funny is that after this prissy little homily, you immediately go on to say:

You may know that that many other significant people in history have been very candid about the credit based system too.
--- as though the mark of candor is agreeing with you.
 
Last edited:
@Truthseeker1234

Man you seriously should read and introductory economics book and leave all that conspiracy economics b.s. behind. I suggest you take a look at Mankiw's pre-grad book (can't remember the name right, i'll look it up).

I'm quite knowledgeable in undergrad econ, thank you. For those seeking a good introduction, I still recommend Hazlitt's classic "Economics in one Lesson". Sowell's "Basic Economics" is more recent, and also very good.

That is absurd. Plain and simple, saying that there is no exchange rate mean there's a global parity between all currencies and that's just nonsense.
Learn history and learn theory. Originally, currencies were based on precious metals, notably gold and silver. The British "pound" was exactly that, 1 pound of silver. A certificate for one pound of silver will exchange for another certificate for one pound of silver, regardless of what names are printed on the certificates.

On the market, there will indeed be fluctuating exchange rates between gold and silver, the same as there are for any two commodities. But to think that there would be an exchange rate from one gold back currency to another gold backed currency misses the whole point. Gold is gold.

Rothbard discusses this in "For a New Liberty". Chapter 5 is "The decline from weight to name". Here is that chapter on audio:

http://www.mises.org/multimedia/mp3/audiobooks/rothbard/money/6.mp3

So basically in your golden world what determines the exchange rate is what the value (measured in gold) the monetary authorities for each country "define" for their currency ... so if Cuba "defines" that their peso is worth 0.5 ounces of gold while the U.S.'s authorities "define" that the dollar is worth 0.25, then the Cuban peso has by default a higher value. Wow.
http://www.mises.org/multimedia/mp3/audiobooks/rothbard/money/6.mp3

Rothbard clears up your confusion. Purchases are made in weights of gold. Paper money, or magnetic card digits, are simply a method to keep track of the weights being exchanged. 0.23 ounces for lobster dinner and a glass of wine.

On the market, money is not issued by governments. It is issued by anyone who wants to issue it. People are free to accept or reject money in payment as they see fit, the same as they are free to accept or reject any sort of offer.

Since the exchange rate (when existing) is determined by some "definition" then the interest rates follow the same pattern ... problem is, since gold is a finite resource there's going to be a point where demand is higher than supply and the interest rates will be pressured to go up, which in turn will lead to a not so healthy situation: rising interest rates and a fixed exchange rate ... seems like you learned nothing from the Asian monetary crisis.
The monetary crises are a problem of fiat money and fractional reserve systems, not gold. Under gold, there is no exchange rate. An ounce of gold is an ounce of gold.

And since we are talking about a global fixed exchange rate regime, i suggest you do some reading on the Brazil 1998 and see the problems that arise when you have a fixed exchange rate in just one country. If you don't like Brazil you can try Chile 1979 or Mexico from 1996.
Same as above.

Sorry sport, "defining the value" is not a good monetary policy.
Under a gold standard, a paper note is simply a receipt redeemable for a certain amount of gold. The paper does not define the value of gold, anymore than a pink slip defines the value of a car. It is a receipt, a title.

It is not a case of whether it makes sense or not, the problem is with the exchange rate regime that you would have to use. You are proposing a fixed exchange rate regime which is only good in time crisis and has to be dropped as soon as you move away from the crisis.
Please get this straight. The gold standard is not a "fixed exchange rate", it is no exchange rate. An ounce of gold is an ounce of gold. Gold is money, the pieces of paper are simply receipts. They don't set values for anything.

No, inflation is defined as the change (measured in %) in the price level. This is the generally accepted view shared by most (if not all) economists. If you like i can quote a few textbooks for you.
This is a semantic issue only, I've addressed it. Yes, mainstream econ defines inflation as a sustained rise in prices. Austrians define it as an increase in the money supply beyond good and services.

To avoid confusion, we will simply refer to "price inflation" and "money supply inflation".

Inflation will also occur when there's scarcity or a quality improvement.
Changes in supply and demand move prices of individual goods up and down, of course. This is not a sustained, general change in price level. The current value of the dollar is less than 1/100 what it was in 1913. To explain that change in overall price level in terms of reduced supply would require a greater reduction in economic output than occurred after the fall of the Roman Empire. Instead, we see tremendously greater economic output than what was present in 1913, yet prices are more than 100 times greater. Not 100%, 100 times. The only explanation for this is that the money supply has expanded 100 times more than the production of goods and services. Actually, much more than that, because it ignores the great increases in efficiency, which serve to lower prices. Under sound money, the tendency is for prices to fall gradually, as production methods become more and more efficient. This serves to make money increase in value as it is held. In our inflationary economy, money loses value as it is held.

So in your golden model if there's inflation because demand was higher than supply then your investors will "pull some assets out of gold" ... but this will have a negative effect, demand will still be higher than supply and now producers will have to pay more for the credit because of a rising interest rate due to less gold being mined and available to be lent. To pay their obligations producers will have to raise their prices and matters will get worse.
On the market, the rate of profit tends to be equal for all businesses, including the production of money, and the lending of money. Anytime any activity becomes more profitable than average, it will attract more producers, thus increasing the supply, lowering prices and pushing profitability down towards the average. Anytime any activity becomes less profitable than average, it will repel some producers, thus decreasing the supply, increasing prices and pushing profitability up towards the average.

Since you respect the decisions of the market so much, why don't you respect its decision to use fiat money instead of commodity money?
How many times must I repeat this?

The market did not select fiat money. Fiat money was imposed by force, by government. The U.S. government made it a felony to refuse paper money, and eventually confiscated all the monetary gold.

How is wealth stolen from anyone when the banks are required to keep less money in their reserves?
Explained here.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom