federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Ya know..... !!!!

I tried to draw Ace into a discussion of his Austrian School beliefs way back and no one would join in. Now, I discover this thread hundreds of posts in, and everyone's pretty well taken away all the good arguments.

Thanks for nothing, gang!

Well, at least no one's started referring to "my precious"....

http://imagecache2.allposters.com/images/pic/ADVG/436~Gollum-Posters.jpg
 
TS,
Don't you realize that your fundamental thesis of why fiat money is "unfair" would also apply to gold? Say we did take up the gold standard, The big mining companies, the ma and pop mining operations, and the gold supplying countries like America and South Africa would be the "new receivers" of the gold while the rest of the world would be the "old receivers" and being ripped off. If we lived in your gold standard world, you'd still be crying foul.
 
And what happens to prices and exchange rates in this golden world of yours? To be more specific, which elements will determine the exchange rate and will there be a fixed rate of inflation? What will determine the change in prices?

As far as gold backed money is concerned, there is no exchange rate. One ounce of gold exchanges for one ounce of gold. If a dollar is defined as 1/20 of an ounce of gold, and some other currency is defined as 1/10 of an ounce of gold, then one of those would exchange for 2 dollars. Speaking of the "exchange rate" between gold-backed currency makes no more sense than speaking of the "exchange rate" between $5 bills and $10 bills.

As to prices, they are are determined by the interaction of supply and demand. Producers can ask any price they wish for their goods, and consumers are free to purchase or not, as they see fit.

Inflation is defined as an increase in the supply of money relative to the supply of goods and services generally. On a free market, the rate of profit tends toward being the same for all businesses, including gold mining. Whenever any business becomes more profitable than average, investors pull out of less profitable ventures, and invest in the more profitable. This increases competition, and increases the supply, thus driving down prices and profitability. When any business becomes less profitable than average, the reverse happens.

On the market, inflation occurs when the production of gold money exceeds the production of other goods. This will drive prices up generally, which is the same as saying that the value of gold has gone down, relative to everything else. This lowered value of gold means that gold mining has become less profitable, so investors will pull some assests out of gold, and seek a higher rate of return elsewhere. And, as with all other businesses, if gold production drops, the reverse happens.

Why gold? Why not hemp seeds?
Because the market selected gold. Historically, many things were used as money - seeds, seashells, cattle, salt, etc. Gold won.

Can you please repeat said explanations? I'd love to read it.
It is here.

Strongly absurd perhaps. When the Federal Reserve responds to a rise in the demand for money and decides to expand the money supply by lowering the amount of legal reserves, who's it stealing from? When The Fed does the same thing by buying CD's, who's it stealing from?
It is stealing real wealth from the late-receivers of the new money. In practice, individuals in the government, the banks, and government contractors win, basically everyone else loses.
 
Last edited:
Sorry Abby, did I miss your explanation for how fiat money creation can avoid wealth redistribution? Link me to it please.

Oh, no, bucky. You gave "proof" for your statement. I took it apart.

Here, I'll get specific, why do you believe that the velocity of money is fixed?

Also, please note, it's very difficult to argue with someone who (admittedly) doesn't understand the arguments.
 
Sorry Abby, did I miss your explanation for how fiat money creation can avoid wealth redistribution? Link me to it please.

This ain't really my field, but here's how I see's it.
It's not redist, it's an adding of the value of other commodities into the system. That, or there could billions of slivers of gold worth a trillion dollars each.
I mean, not exactly, of course. Or I am wrong...
 
Last edited:
Oh, no, bucky. You gave "proof" for your statement. I took it apart.

Here, I'll get specific, why do you believe that the velocity of money is fixed?

Also, please note, it's very difficult to argue with someone who (admittedly) doesn't understand the arguments.

Abby, the velocity of money is not fixed. For the lurkers, the velocity of money is the rate at which it is spent and then respent. I never said anything on this thread about velocity. Maybe you got confused with my airplane velocity study, a different subject. Abby, can you even go one post without falsely attributing statements to me?

Consumer time preference is central to Austrian theory. Time preference is the degree to which an individual prefers to spend and consume now, vs. saving now and consuming later. On the free market, the interest rate is determined by consumer time preference. Time preference also influences velocity.

I understand quite well Abby. You have not made any arguments. Not one. You attempted to criticize Murray Rothbard's money treatise by indicating that he doesn't make a distinction between expected and unexpected inflation. This is like criticizing Richard Dawkins for not discussing bible prophecy. The little sparknote page you referenced doesn't attempt to explain the cause of inflation, so I find it boring.

Now, again, the subject of this thread is the Fed. You claim to have addressed my argument that fiat money = theft, yet you actually haven't at all.

Please, the others here are counting on you Abby. Explain how fiat money creation could possibly not redistribute real wealth.
 
Ya know..... !!!!

I tried to draw Ace into a discussion of his Austrian School beliefs way back and no one would join in. Now, I discover this thread hundreds of posts in, and everyone's pretty well taken away all the good arguments.

What arguments?

I have argued here that fiat money is theft. No one has yet attempted to refute my argument.
 
Abby, the velocity of money is not fixed. For the lurkers, the velocity of money is the rate at which it is spent and then respent. I never said anything on this thread about velocity. Maybe you got confused with my airplane velocity study, a different subject. Abby, can you even go one post without falsely attributing statements to me?


I thought you said you agreed with the Quantity Theory of Money?

I understand quite well Abby. You have not made any arguments. Not one. You attempted to criticize Murray Rothbard's money treatise by indicating that he doesn't make a distinction between expected and unexpected inflation. This is like criticizing Richard Dawkins for not discussing bible prophecy. The little sparknote page you referenced doesn't attempt to explain the cause of inflation, so I find it boring.

Noooo, I said he doesn't address unexpected inflation at all. In fact he defines inflation only in expected terms. That's sorely neglectful in a discussion of inflation. (And in a discussion as to the reasons for inflation.)

I also discussed his idea that devaluation of the dollar is "embarrassing for governments". Then why do governments devalue the dollar on purpose for trade reasons?
 
What arguments?

I have argued here that fiat money is theft. No one has yet attempted to refute my argument.

You are suffering from the false idea that the only way inflation is created is through the money supply. Look up cost-push and demand-pull inflation.
 
I thought you said you agreed with the Quantity Theory of Money?

Noooo, I said he doesn't address unexpected inflation at all. In fact he defines inflation only in expected terms. That's sorely neglectful in a discussion of inflation. (And in a discussion as to the reasons for inflation.)

I also discussed his idea that devaluation of the dollar is "embarrassing for governments". Then why do governments devalue the dollar on purpose for trade reasons?

The quantity theory of money states that the amount of money spent is related to the amount of money that exists. It does not rule out changes in the velocity of money. Rather, it sees velocity as a symptom, not a cause. As money is devalued, people have a greater incentive to spend money more quickly. The same is true of demand-pull and cost-push. In the Austrian view, these are symptoms, not causes. You may disagree with the Austrian view, but if so, explain why.

Abby, I have three times stated Rothbard's definition of inflation:

Inflation is an increase in the supply of money exceeding the increase in the supply of goods and services.

Mainstream econ defines inflation as generally rising prices. In order to not talk past one another, let's call it "money supply inflation" and "price inflation". How's that?

Governments devalue the dollar, i.e. inflate the money supply, on purpose, because it enriches themselves and their friends. This is the subject of the thread, and the very subject of my argument. You have still been unable to offer any sort of critique of it.

Please, can you explain why the creation of fiat money would not redistribute wealth away from late-receivers?

I am still waiting, and so are your fans.
 
Last edited:
The quantity theory of money states that the amount of money spent is related to the amount of money that exists. It does not rule out changes in the velocity of money. Rather, it sees velocity as a symptom, not a cause. As money is devalued, people have a greater incentive to spend money more quickly.

False. The Quantity Theory of Money is based on this equation: V=(nominal GDP/money supply). It is dependent on Velocity being fixed.

Don't believe me? http://www.investopedia.com/articles/05/010705.asp

or here: http://www.economyprofessor.com/economictheories/quantity-theory-of-money.php

Or just google the thing and take a look at the equation and necessary assumptions.


Abby, I have three times stated Rothbards definition of inflation:

And, I've shown over and over that his thesis is weak.

Governments devalue the dollar, i.e. inflate the money supply, on purpose, because it enriches themselves and their friends. This is the subject of the thread, and the very subject of my argument. You have still been unable to offer any sort of critique of it.

And you continue to refuse to address the way that the devaluation helps the trade balance. (Of which the US is in a negative one. Look up the BP curve.)

Please, can you explain why the creation of fiat money would not redistribute wealth away from late-receivers?

I am still waiting, and so are your fans.

In your calculations of "late-receivers", you are ignoring the time it takes for the money supply to grow from an injection. This is one hundred percent dependent on the money multiplier. Something you've acknowledged you don't know of or understand.
 
TS,
Don't you realize that your fundamental thesis of why fiat money is "unfair" would also apply to gold? Say we did take up the gold standard, The big mining companies, the ma and pop mining operations, and the gold supplying countries like America and South Africa would be the "new receivers" of the gold while the rest of the world would be the "old receivers" and being ripped off. If we lived in your gold standard world, you'd still be crying foul.

Nope. Unlike fiat money, gold is real wealth. Increasing the supply of gold increases the amount of real wealth. Even more importantly, on the market, there is no monopoly of money creation. It is the monopoly which is inherently evil. Monopolies bad. Competition good.
 
Last edited:
Nope. Unlike fiat money, gold is real wealth. Increasing the supply of gold increases the amount of real wealth. Even more importantly, on the market, there is no monopoly of money creation. It is the monopoly which is inherently evil. Monopolies bad. Competition good.

So you'd have competing monetary bases?

Are all monopolies bad? Firepersons? Policemen? Armies? Local mass transits?

I sincerely suggest you pick up a basic macro book.
 
So you'd have competing monetary bases?

Are all monopolies bad? Firepersons? Policemen? Armies? Local mass transits?

I sincerely suggest you pick up a basic macro book.

Yes, from the standpoint of consumers, all monopolies are bad. Under a monopoly, prices will be higher, and/or quality will be lower than what would prevail under competition. Austro-libertarians apply this to all goods and services, including money, protection, dispute resolution, transportation, energy, etc. We can argue public goods theory later. Walter Block has done a great job of debunking it.

But this thread is about the Federal Reserve and fiat money.

Is there anyone who can provide an argument against the notion that fiat money = theft ?

Still waiting.
 
Last edited:
Respond to post 195 please.

And re: monopolies, you are forgetting about natural monopolies. May I assume you have no idea what I'm talking about?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom