federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Price fixing is always a bad idea. Prices should always be free to fluctuate according to supply and demand.
You really want the value of a dollar pegged to the value of gold on the open market? :eek:

Wildcat, can you address the subject of the thread, the Fed conspiracy? I say the creation of fiat money is theft, for the reasons given.
Sorry, your reasons are utterly ridiculous. As ridiculous as your "no planes hit the towers" theory.
 
You had me until this part. Rent control makes no sense whatsoever, unless your goal is a shortage of rental units and high rents.

I here you, my fellow urbanite. However, without any type of rent control in NYC, we would have a Manhattan full of only the wealthy. However, we also have a combination of rent control and subsidies to try to alleviate the pressure on bldg owners.
 
You really want the value of a dollar pegged to the value of gold on the open market?


Actually, what Ace wants is to feel secure. He is really a remarkably fragile person and is absolutely terrified that his world is going to collapse at any moment.

He likes gold because, as Eddie Murphy taught us in Trading Places, gold is heavy. The idea of a monetary system pegged to faith is unbearable for him. Gold, though, is real. It weighs a lot. Money based on gold is more real, in his mind.

It's the same thing with 9/11. Nineteen guys who got lucky is just too randomly horrible for him to deal with. But if the whole thing was masterminded by a huge, overbearing, all-powerful government, there would be some stability. It's a perverse stability, to be sure, but it is still what his mind craves.

With Ace and people like him, the most instructive question to ask is why they believe what they do. In this case, the answer is that they care more about protecting their own sense of self than they do in perceiving the world as it really is.
 
Surely the claim is self evident

Major banking figure, with far greater knowledge of central banking than anyone here, catagorically confirms the misuse and dominance of banking power through the debt based credit system.

discuss

What should we discuss here? The fact that you are quoting an opinion without any analysis to back it up?

Come on, i think you can do better than a blatant appeal to authority.
 
I here you, my fellow urbanite. However, without any type of rent control in NYC, we would have a Manhattan full of only the wealthy. However, we also have a combination of rent control and subsidies to try to alleviate the pressure on bldg owners.

Has it really worked though? Rent in NYC is a horror show compared to any city on the East Coast and I don't know what other cities have tried rent control. Yet rents are much more reasonable in those cities. By comparison, NYC rents were always awful even when living in the Big Apple was not as popular as it is today.
 
What should we discuss here? The fact that you are quoting an opinion without any analysis to back it up?

Come on, i think you can do better than a blatant appeal to authority.



So there is no link between an extremely influential banking figure identifying the corrupt nature of the debt based credit system

and...

the reality that there exists a corrupt debt based credit system?


Surely you can do better than completely disregard a vital piece of evidence that massively corroborates the argument for reform. Even without supporting evidence, a person confessing to a crime makes them a prime suspect. Please be adult and intelligent enough to admit just this :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
You seem so sure of your point (whatever it might be) yet you can't come up with nothing else than an appeal to authority? That's just funny. When the best you can come up with is a logical fallacy i'd say that's enough to determine your views are incorrect.

Even without supporting evidence, a person confessing to a crime makes them a prime suspect.

So if a doctor says he murdered a thousand people, shall we consider all doctors to be mass murderers?

Come on man, you are not even trying.
 
You seem so sure of your point (whatever it might be) yet you can't come up with nothing else than an appeal to authority? That's just funny. When the best you can come up with is a logical fallacy i'd say that's enough to determine your views are incorrect.


Why are you assuming that this is the sole piece of evidence for my case - grow up

If I thought that a detailed discussion of economics would change some of the padlocked minds here don't you think I would have started on that foot. As people here put so much stock in 'conventional' mainstream wisdom and the opinions of 'well repected' experts, I introduced that quote to inspire your own investigation
 
Why are you assuming that this is the sole piece of evidence for my case - grow up

Well because after 5 pages that's the only thing you've brought up as an argument for your case (whatever it might be).
 
Has it really worked though? Rent in NYC is a horror show compared to any city on the East Coast and I don't know what other cities have tried rent control.
Toronto certainly has rent control, and has had it for many, many years. For a long time it was pegged as part of the reason for incredibly low vacancy rates (0.1%) but with low interest rates and a condo building boom, vacancy rates have gone up to 3%.
 
You really want the value of a dollar pegged to the value of gold on the open market? :eek:


Sorry, your reasons are utterly ridiculous. As ridiculous as your "no planes hit the towers" theory.

On the free market, a "dollar" is simply a name for a particular weight of gold, say 1/20 ounce. It does not fluctuate, any more than a "yard" is a name for "three feet". Transactions are negotiated in weight of gold. Actual gold does not need to be carried around, as paper or digital substitutes are perfectly fine, so long as they are redeemable in gold.


Now, if my "reasons are utterly ridiculous" for why fiat money = theft, then why don't you explain how it is so?

I have given a very clear explanation for why fiat money redistributes wealth, and to whom and from whom it does so. All you have offered is vacuous assertions.
 
He likes gold because, as Eddie Murphy taught us in Trading Places, gold is heavy. The idea of a monetary system pegged to faith is unbearable for him. Gold, though, is real. It weighs a lot. Money based on gold is more real, in his mind.

False. I like gold because the market chose it. If the market had chosen seashells, I would like them. If it had chosen slips of paper, I would like that. The selection of gold as the world money standard was not arbitrary. It was the result of thousands of years of natural selection. It spontaneously emerged as the best functioning money.

If I wanted to LL, I could make up all sorts of things about you, and what you like, and why. But I'm too intellectually honest to do that. You, on the other hand, are a lawyer.
 
Can anyone even attempt to counter the strong claim that fiat money creation = theft?


Still waiting. You all have lots of empty rhetoric, but so far no one has brought anything of substance.
 
@Truthseeker1234

On the free market, a "dollar" is simply a name for a particular weight of gold, say 1/20 ounce. It does not fluctuate, any more than a "yard" is a name for "three feet".

And what happens to prices and exchange rates in this golden world of yours? To be more specific, which elements will determine the exchange rate and will there be a fixed rate of inflation? What will determine the change in prices?

Why gold? Why not hemp seeds?

I have given a very clear explanation for why fiat money redistributes wealth, and to whom and from whom it does so.

Actually, you haven't. If you did, can you please repeat said explanations? I'd love to read it.

Can anyone even attempt to counter the strong claim that fiat money creation = theft?

Strongly absurd perhaps. When the Federal Reserve responds to a rise in the demand for money and decides to expand the money supply by lowering the amount of legal reserves, who's it stealing from? When The Fed does the same thing by buying CD's, who's it stealing from?
 
Why are you assuming that this is the sole piece of evidence for my case - grow up
Well, apparently it's the only "piece of evidence" you're willing to put forward. And it is not, in fact evidence. It's an opinion unsupported by fact.

If I thought that a detailed discussion of economics would change some of the padlocked minds here don't you think I would have started on that foot.
So basically it's our fault that you won't supply any evidence for your views?

Let me assure you, round here facts are the only things that change people's minds --- not the mere opinions of some dead Nazi plutocrat.

As people here put so much stock in 'conventional' mainstream wisdom and the opinions of 'well repected' experts...
But this is not "conventional mainstream wisdom" so much as classic Fascist paranoia; nor does he give any evidence for his views, which is what we actually put stock in round here.

As for him being "well-respected", he wrote propaganda for Herman Goering's magazine Die Vierjahresplan and attended the Nuremburg Rallies as a guest of Hitler. So he was well-respected by Hitler and Goering, yeah. But I, for one, think rather less of his judgement than they did.
 
If I wanted to LL, I could make up all sorts of things about you, and what you like, and why. But I'm too intellectually honest to do that. You, on the other hand, are a lawyer.



I'm gonna give you that one. That was funny.

It's not funny that you actually believe that my education and experience makes me less honest than lay people, but if you didn't really believe it then the comment would be suitably pithy.

If anybody's keeping score, that's one for Truthseeker1234. So totaling that up:

Truthseeker1234: 1
The rest of planet earth: 100,000,000,000,000,008
 
The nineteenth century saw a plethora of "Austrian" solutions and they resulted in bank panics, widespread poverty in the West, and dissolution of markets and trade. Shall we raise the banner of Tariff yet again Mr Truth Seeker?


You know what other austrian had a "solution"? That's right...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom