Faith leads to evil.

No it wasn't. You're mistaking The Bible for Christianity; literalism for interpretation.

In order to be a Christian, you have to take at least some of the Bible literally, right? Otherwise, what is it to be a Christian at all? To be a Christian is to subscribe to the literal truth of at least one section of the Bible, right?

And so we're back to where we started, aren't we? Picking and choosing based on extra-Biblical morality, filtering out the nasty bits and re-interpreting the other bits on a whim. Having some bits as literal and some bits as allegorical, some bits as old and some bits as rejected and just making it up as you go along. Like the rest of us do.

I'm honestly confused. What is the point of calling yourself a Christian if you're going to 'interpret' it all, lock, stock and barrel? I happen to think Passage to India is a fantastic piece of literature that has an interesting take on the human condition (and it's internally consistent to boot!) but I don't call myself a Forsterian.
 
That conveniently ignores the "until Heaven and Earth have passed" quote from Matthew, "It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail." from Luke, "Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever" from Psalms etc. etc.

Not to mention deuteronomy 12:32

'Whatever I command you, you shall be careful to do; you shall not add to nor take away from it.'

Even if the "Jesus doing away with the bad stuff" has some validity, I have still yet to hear a single explanation why God, in his infinite wisdom, declared that non-virgins be stoned to death on their fathers doorsteps. Even if the "People in those days lived harsh lives and needed to be treated very differently by God" argument is used, you have to ask what possible progressive furthering could be reached with this law. It serves no purpose other than outright evil.

Then if we hear the old: "It's Christians, not OldTestamentians", the question posed is: Why not take out the Old Testament and do away from it in church? But no, standing in every church across the land, is a book that advocates the most horrific system of barbarity there could possibly be in a modern world.

It's interesting how so many Christians get heated up about pornography near schools yet entrust their children with a book that contains in 50% of it some of the worst morals you could ever learn.
 
Last edited:
It was a (for all intents and purposes) and global economic and cultural institution in First Century Mediterranean world. It's non-existence was an alien concept.

Isn't God omniscient? Didn't Jesus come to Earth to teach human beings how to behave?

Take a step back, ACS. Look at this with an ounce of rationality, won't you? If the Bible is the Word of God (even if only in parts!), and if Jesus came to Earth to spread the message you claim Christianity supports, why's the Bible so woolly? And, from where I'm sitting, why does it seem to support precisely the opposite to what you say it does?

Of course the abolition of slavery was an alien concept to the Early Christians. That's the entire point of our argument. If there was something inherently powerful in Christianity which allows it to be used as a moral guide, then it wouldn't have been! If there was something inherently anti-Slavery in Christian doctrine, it would have been abolished far before the Enlightenment, which, as I'm sure you know, was essentially a Europe-wide step away from Christian theism.

Morality is extra-Biblical. The example of slavery and its abolition happens to demonstrate this quite neatly.
 
And applying the knowlege that the bible was written over hundreds of years by many different hands, what does that lead us to?

That the Bible is not the Word of God at all, but the writings of geographically and chronologically distinct, superstitious individuals who were repeating their murky and imprecise oral traditions, compiled into a collection hundreds of years later for transparent political reasons of the Catholic Church?

Or is that the wrong answer?
 
Sufficient cause to avoid claiming certainty about its veracity?


sufficient cause to say it's man made manipulation and barbarism held as a "holy book" via force and abuse of those who questioned it's authority

sufficient cause to not that there is nothing divine about it... an omniscient god wouldn't have left his words to such mixed interpretation and alteration... and he probably would have put a few scientific concepts too-- say "germ theory".

The thing that bugs me about the apologist is that they would know right away how weak their arguments sounded if it was coming out of the mouth of someone with a different woo.
 
Last edited:
None of these condone slavery. They talk about how people, adherents of the faith, should act in their duties. Basically they all say be good citizens. Nothing like the Old Testament which talks about how you are to treat your slaves, how you can buy or sell them, or sell your children, etc. That's clearly condoning. I see nothing of that nature in the New Testament. <shrug>

Seriously? You don't think "Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ" or "Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear, not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward" are not condoning the servitude of slaves to their masters?

These passages say that if you are a slave, then you should be obedient to and indeed fearful of your masters. In what way is this not condoning servitude in general, and slavery specifically? If you were a slave and you read this, what would you take from it? If you were a slave owner and you read this, what would you take from it?

It strikes me that the clear interpretation of these verses is that God thinks slave-owning is OK. You can hand-wave all you like, but the words are right there on the page - "Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters".
 
There's an interesting paper here: www.biblesociety.org.uk/exploratory/articles/sandersspring07.doc about how both sides of the slavery issue were using the bible to justify their cause, by Carl Sanders, Associate Professor and Chair of the Department of Biblical and Theological Studies at Washington Bible College in Lanham, Maryland.


In the period leading up to the Civil War, Christians in the United States were engaged in intense battles over the issue of slavery. American evangelicals’ opinions on slavery were divided into two broad categories.

The first party regarded slavery as intrinsically evil. Radical abolitionists like William Lloyd Garrison believed in the evil of slavery despite biblical teaching which seemed to contradict that belief. Less extreme abolitionists like Albert Barnes believed the spirit of the Bible opposed slavery, despite the appearance that Scripture tolerated the institution. On the other side were those who defended slavery. The most vocal members of this group, centred on the Southern states where slavery was prevalent, included renowned churchmen and theologians like Robert Dabney and James Henry Thornwell. They argued that the Bible positively endorsed slavery. Others, like Charles Hodge of Princeton Seminary, advocated a moderate path, seeking for a gradual end to slavery. Hodge and like-minded abolitionists had serious reservations about the advisability of slavery, at least as practiced in the United States. These debates over slavery led not only to dissension and strife in individual congregations, but also contributed to schism in every major denominational body in the United States.

and

..Because of these assumptions, pro-slavery arguments carried the day in the United States in the first half of the nineteenth century. Abolitionists went so far as to say that the greatest obstacle to their cause was the text of the Bible!3

The opponents of slavery were required to be more creative and imaginative in their interpretive approach. They could not appeal to explicit anti-slavery texts, so they relied on broader theological and ethical arguments. Cumulatively, they made an intriguing, but not universally persuasive, case against slavery. Abolitionists used two major strategies for biblical application to the slavery debate.
 
My suspicions are thus confirmed. Cheers, Meg.

ACS? RR? Any thoughts on the above?
 
In order to be a Christian, you have to take at least some of the Bible literally, right? Otherwise, what is it to be a Christian at all? To be a Christian is to subscribe to the literal truth of at least one section of the Bible, right?

Well, I'd say the only literal truths of it are the ones the follower requires in order to be a basis for their actions. For some, maybe it's a very simple idea of God or Jesus, as they believe the Bible means. Important part is two Christians could be equally basing their faith on it or on God, yet both genuinely interpret something like slavery differently.

And so we're back to where we started, aren't we? Picking and choosing based on extra-Biblical morality, filtering out the nasty bits and re-interpreting the other bits on a whim. Having some bits as literal and some bits as allegorical, some bits as old and some bits as rejected and just making it up as you go along. Like the rest of us do.

I'm honestly confused. What is the point of calling yourself a Christian if you're going to 'interpret' it all, lock, stock and barrel? I happen to think Passage to India is a fantastic piece of literature that has an interesting take on the human condition (and it's internally consistent to boot!) but I don't call myself a Forsterian.

Morality is extra-Biblical. The example of slavery and its abolition happens to demonstrate this quite neatly.

Morality is extra-everything. No matter the moral system it has an arbitrary base. If any future society changes its views it can revisit an earlier subsystem and reinterpret it or throw it out wholesale. If you disagree with that I'd ask you to cite the one, true moral system.

Any system can be used for evil purpose, or interpreted thusly, or failed to be ignored when parts of it become socially irrelevant or dangerous. Even rational systems. Such as one system always calling slavery immoral, and another calling it morally acceptable if in enslaving one person two slaves are freed. This doesn't mean rationality is "evil". If I previously followed one of those systems then changed my mind or saw a greater rationality in the other and switched, it wouldn't render the prior system "evil".

If the output of systems based on A and B are X, then with new evidence or change in society/self values the outcome of each becomes Y, I fail to see why A would be "evil" and B would get a pass.
 
The thing that bugs me about the apologist is that they would know right away how weak their arguments sounded if it was coming out of the mouth of someone with a different woo.

The same can be said for some atheists, skeptics, and rationalists.
 
Yeah, it's a pretty confusing passage, as I said. So no fault of yours that you didn't get it. Jesus here is applying the law to himself, and, as I said, he's claiming it is "fulfilled" and thus no longer necessary, which is why he then goes on to provide new laws.

Strange...the interpretation you have doesn't actually seem to be supported by the passages we're talking about here.

While Matthew 5:17 does say, "Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil," the very next passage reads...

"For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled." - Matthew 5:18

So, from what is said here, nothing shall pass from the law until either heaven and earth pass, or all of the law (not just the old law) has been fulfilled. In other words, the old laws still stand (which may be why he says that he hasn't come to destroy the law or the prophets).

As well as that, the idea that the old law has not been abolished is supported by the new laws he introduces, as none of them contradict the old law, and indeed many of them actively extend it. So, for example, while adultery was a sin, now lust is also considered a sin, as it is adultery in the heart. While murder was a sin, now anger is also considered a sin. New concepts, such as 'love thy enemy' may seem contrary to the old testament, but they do not contradict any old commandments (there was never a commandment to 'hate thy enemy').

So, I really don't see how you can say that the old law was abolished by Jesus, when his own words speak otherwise.

Sorry if I was unclear. The argument was that the New Testament supports and condones slavery. This quote doesn't reflect support or condoning slavery.

Er...what about all these? Didja miss them before?
 
What I don't understand is: If one christian's faith leads him to be pro-slavery, and another christian's faith leads him to be an abolutionist; if one christian's faith leads him to condemn homosexuals while another christian's faith leads him to fight for gay rights; if one christian's faith leads him to promote sexism while another christian's faith leads him to promote equal rights; and there are many more faithful christians that just kind of believe Jesus was a really good guy..

Just exactly what is so great about this "faith"? Why do people wear their faith so proudly? Why do christians laud other people's faith?

What exactly do you think faith does?
 
What I don't understand is: If one christian's faith leads him to be pro-slavery, and another christian's faith leads him to be an abolutionist; if one christian's faith leads him to condemn homosexuals while another christian's faith leads him to fight for gay rights; if one christian's faith leads him to promote sexism while another christian's faith leads him to promote equal rights; and there are many more faithful christians that just kind of believe Jesus was a really good guy..

Just exactly what is so great about this "faith"? Why do people wear their faith so proudly? Why do christians laud other people's faith?

What exactly do you think faith does?

It grants surety to their conclusions.

What exactly do you think rationality does? Not all rationalists agree on conclusions or basic methods of logic. Sometimes leading to large macro disagreements on the very topics you raise.

Difference is theists surety is "false" according to rationalists. And rationalists don't believe in as strong a sense of "surety". But homogeneity certainly isn't required by either in order for them to appreciate and advocate the basis of their systems as superior to alternatives.
 
Here is some more history for everyone.

P.29 The Victory of Reason said:
Slavery ended in medeival Europe only because the church extended its sacraments to all slaves and then managed to impose a ban on the enslavement of Christians (and of Jews). With the context of medeival Europe, that prohibition was effectively a rule of universal abolition.
In the beginning, the church asserted the legitimacy of slavery but did so with a certain ambiguity. Consider the most cited New Testament passage on slavery. Writing to the Ephesians (6:5,8) Paul admonished:”Slaves, be obedient to those who are your earthly masters, in fear and trembling, in singleness of heart, as to Christ … knowing that whatever good any one does, he will receive the same again from the Lord, whether he is slave or free” Those who eagerly quote this passage very seldom go on to quote the next verse “Masters, do the same to them, and forbear threatening, knowing that he who is both their Master and yours in heaven, and that there is no partiality with him” That God treats all equally is fundamental to the Christian message: all may be saved. It was this that encouraged the early church to convert slaves and when possible to purchase their freedom – Pope Callistus (died 236) had himself been a slave.
 
Last edited:
And some more:

P.29 said:
So long as the Roman empire stood, the church continued to affirm the legitimacy of slavery. In 324, the Christian Coucil of Granges condemned anyone who encouraged discontent among slaves, which suggests, of course, that such activites were taking place. However, the tension between support for slavery and emphasis on the equality of all in the eyes of God continued to grow, and with the demise of the empire, the strain grew ever more intense because the church continued to extend its embrace to those in slavery, denying them only ordination into the priesthood. Pierre bonnassie has expressed the matter as well as anyone: “A slave … was baptised [and] had a soul. He was, then, unambiguously a man.”
With slaves fully recognized as human and Christian, priests began to urge owners to free their slaves as an “infinitely commendable act” that helped ensure their own salvation. Many manumissions were recorded in surviving wills. The doctrine that slaves were humans and not cattle has another important consequence: intermarriage.
 
Last edited:
And a bit more:

P.31 said:
“The theological conclusion that slavery is sinful has been unique to Christianity (although several early Jewish sects also rejected slavery). Here too can be seen the principle of theological progress at work, making it possible for theologians to propose new interpretations without endangering charges of heresy. As noted, the other major religions are strongly oriented to the past, and to the principle that, if anything, history is regressive and later generations are prone to error.
…
While Christian theologians could plausibly correct saint Paul’s understanding of God’s will concerning slavery, such corrections were (and are) essentially precluded in the other faiths --- except as heresies. “
 
This you might find interesting:
P. 23 said:
The blessings of a theology of reason were not confined to the sciences. From its earliest days, Christianity was equally inventive in its conception of human nature and in confronting issues of morality. Chief among these were propositions concerning fundamental human rights such as liberty and freedom. And underlying these ideas was something even more basic: the "discovery" of individualism - of the self."
 
Here you go:

P.8-9 said:
Things might have been different had Jesus left a written scripture. But unlike Muhammad or Moses, whose texts were accepted as divine transmissions and therefore encouraged literalism, Jesus wrote nothing, and from the very start the church fathers were forced to reason as to the implications of a collection of his remembered sayings - the New Testament is not a unified scripture but and anthology. Consequently, the precedent for a theology of deduction and inference and for the idea of theological progress began with Paul: "For our knowledge is imperfect and our prophesy is imperfect."
...
From the very early days, Christian theologians have assumed that the application of reason can yield an increasingly accurate understanding of God's will.

...

(P. 11-12)
The Christian image of God is that of a rational being who believes in human progress, more fully revealing himself as humans gain the capacity to better understand. Moreoever, because God is a rational being and the universe is his personal creation, it necessarily has a rational, lawful, stable structure, awaiting increased human comprehension. This was the key to many intellectual undertakings, among them the rise of science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom