Faith leads to evil.

This you might find interesting:
Originally Posted by P. 23, The Victory of Reason, Rodney Stark
The blessings of a theology of reason were not confined to the sciences. From its earliest days, Christianity was equally inventive in its conception of human nature and in confronting issues of morality. Chief among these were propositions concerning fundamental human rights such as liberty and freedom. And underlying these ideas was something even more basic: the "discovery" of individualism - of the self."
Highly interesting. I will have to track it down and find those sources.

"From it's earliest days" - let the record show that Christianity for many centuries enthusiastically allied itself to absolutist monarchs and the concept of "Divine Right".

And most Christians seem to regard individualism and self as things to be denied, abnegated and submitted to the Divine Will.

C.S. Lewis, for example, gives individualism and self-regard as one of the chief reasons to be damned in "Problem of Pain".

So I look forward to finding Stark's sources and examples.
 
It grants surety to their conclusions.

What exactly do you think rationality does? Not all rationalists agree on conclusions or basic methods of logic. Sometimes leading to large macro disagreements on the very topics you raise.

Difference is theists surety is "false" according to rationalists. And rationalists don't believe in as strong a sense of "surety". But homogeneity certainly isn't required by either in order for them to appreciate and advocate the basis of their systems as superior to alternatives.

Well, I guess I think that rationality provides a better method for understanding social problems, exploring their consequences and striving for solutions. And since most rationalists don't even pretend that their conclusions are "true" or "final", they are better able to change their minds and adjust their methods than someone who believes they know "The Answer", because they found a quote in the bible that says it.
 
A Christian Sceptic, I don't quite understand what you're getting at with your quotes, other than what we've already covered; that the christian church was active both in endorsing slavery as well as attempting to abolish it at different points in history.
 
...(combined with the equality between the sexes, social classes, ethnic groups preached by Paul)...


Paul definitely did not teach equality between sexes. Jesus, maybe. Paul, nope.

1 Timothy 2:11-14

"Let a woman learn in silence with all submissiveness. I permit no woman to teach or to have authority over men; she is to keep silent. For Adam was formed first, then Eve; and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor."

I have heard the argument that it wasn't Paul who wrote these words, but that they were a later addition. Regardless, they are accredited to him, and there is plenty more where that came from.
 
Well, I guess I think that rationality provides a better method for understanding social problems, exploring their consequences and striving for solutions. And since most rationalists don't even pretend that their conclusions are "true" or "final", they are better able to change their minds and adjust their methods than someone who believes they know "The Answer", because they found a quote in the bible that says it.

Agreed. Though, the method (faith vs. rationality) is only as good as the system that comes from it. And/or the outcome of that system. There are some pretty cold moralities based on rationalism out there, imo.
 
Paul definitely did not teach equality between sexes. Jesus, maybe. Paul, nope.

1 Timothy 2:11-14

"Let a woman learn in silence with all submissiveness. I permit no woman to teach or to have authority over men; she is to keep silent. For Adam was formed first, then Eve; and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor."

I have heard the argument that it wasn't Paul who wrote these words, but that they were a later addition. Regardless, they are accredited to him, and there is plenty more where that came from.

Maybe that was too vague a statement I made. I was writing in the context of how applying Jesus teachings into areas he never explicitly talked about brought about progressive and positive change. Here's another quote from Professor Stark.

p. 76-77 said:
Jesus asserted a revolutionary conception of moral equality, not only in words but in deeds. Over and over again he ignored major status boundaries and associated with stigmatized people, including Samaritans, publicans, immoral women, beggars, and various other outcasts, thereby giving divine sanction to spiritual inclusiveness. And it was precisely in this spirit that Paul admonished:"There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus." How could this be? Paul hardly meant that there were no Christian slaves or that women had the same rights as men. What he meant was that, regardless of worldly inequalities, there is no inequality in the most important sense: in the eyes of God and in the life to come. Indeed, Paul warned slave masters of this very point when he admonished them to treat their slaves well, since "he who is both their Master and yours is in heaven, and there is no partiality with him." In that statement, as in many others in the New Testament, Paul makes it clear that equality in the eyes of God has implications for how people ought to be treated in this world, as Jesus demonstrated.
Thus was the pattern set. In an extremely status-conscious Roman world, early Christians strove to embrace a universalistic conception of humanity.
 
Last edited:
Maybe that was too vague a statement I made. I was writing in the context of how applying Jesus teachings into areas he never explicitly talked about brought about progressive and positive change. Here's another quote from Professor Stark.


I disagree with Stark's analysis. When read as a whole (particularly the Pauline letters), the overall message seems to be more "Accept your status in this world. Don't rock the boat and the next life will be better." Instead of suggesting that the masters treat the slaves well (or that the Romans should treat the Christians better), slaves, women, and yes, Christians, should accept their lot and in some senses, embrace the concept of a martyr. Submission seems to be a greater Christian virtue than revolution. For example, read the Beatitudes.
 
Well, I'd say the only literal truths of it are the ones the follower requires in order to be a basis for their actions. For some, maybe it's a very simple idea of God or Jesus, as they believe the Bible means. Important part is two Christians could be equally basing their faith on it or on God, yet both genuinely interpret something like slavery differently.

As I said, to be a Christian you need to take at the very least one part of the Bible absolutely literally.

Morality is extra-everything.

No it isn't. Moral philosophy is borne out of reason and out of evolutionary biology, and changes in the moral Zeitgeist occur through reasoned debate and consensus change.

No matter the moral system it has an arbitrary base. If any future society changes its views it can revisit an earlier subsystem and reinterpret it or throw it out wholesale. If you disagree with that I'd ask you to cite the one, true moral system.

This, however, is true. Which makes any claims that the Bible is a source of morality to be absolute nonsense.
 
In order to be a Christian, you have to take at least some of the Bible literally, right? Otherwise, what is it to be a Christian at all? To be a Christian is to subscribe to the literal truth of at least one section of the Bible, right?
No, wrong. Depends on the particular denomination. In addition, some passages are considered factual by students of the history of that place and time. Asimov's guide to the bible is illuminating in that regard.
And so we're back to where we started, aren't we? Picking and choosing based on extra-Biblical morality, filtering out the nasty bits and re-interpreting the other bits on a whim. Having some bits as literal and some bits as allegorical, some bits as old and some bits as rejected and just making it up as you go along. Like the rest of us do.
ALL denominations do this. Even the most literal of fundamentalist sects will pick and choose some passages to ignore and others to elevate.
I'm honestly confused. What is the point of calling yourself a Christian if you're going to 'interpret' it all, lock, stock and barrel? I happen to think Passage to India is a fantastic piece of literature that has an interesting take on the human condition (and it's internally consistent to boot!) but I don't call myself a Forsterian.

The point is belonging to a community of people who share your values. For many, perhaps even most Christian denominations, the core value is "love your neighbor as yourself" with varying weights ascribed to their interpretation of other key passages.
 
Last edited:
ROFL. I suppose the internet saying is true that when all else fails, resort to the personal attack. Brings a tear to my eye to have been part of the system here today!

At least Articulett has permitted you to talk to me and my ilk. Bloody generous of her.
 
Right. And does that equate to necessarily ignoring any of the possible teachings within? Well, clearly for many people.

There are many possible teachings in Huck Finn, The Grapes of Wrath and Gone With the Wind, too.
 
Last edited:
No, wrong.

Really? You can be Christian and not believe one single word of the Bible is true? Not the bits about Jesus? Not the bits about Heaven? Not the bots about the crucifixion and resurrection?

You can be a Christian if you think the entire Bible is a fiction? Really?

Depends on the particular denomination.

Which self-proclaimed Christian denomination does not believe in the literal truth of a single sentence of the Bible? Show me one and I'll eat my hat.

ALL denominations do this. Even the most literal of fundamentalist sects will pick and choose some passages to ignore and others to elevate.

Which is my entire point.
 
Darth, what is there to be praised about unquestioning deference to a higher authority (aka: faith)? I know you pop up in these threads to defend religion, but you never seem to make a straight case as to why it deserves defending...
I don't respond well to stupid loaded questions. See bolded words. My core objection to some of the complaints here is that they toss the baby out with the bathwater, and dwell only on the negative aspects of organized religion, in particular Christianity. No surprise on the latter, as familiarity breeds contempt, and we see few if any people willing to discuss Islam in depth. We have had some interesting discussions on Bhuddism, which I have always found refreshing.

Lose your Christian in a Kilt attitude, and you might find me less cynical. (Or not, I've been cynical for a long time, and I'm working my way up to curmudgeon. Seven years is my schedule.)

As I pointed out months ago, I am not formally trained in Christian apologetics. Any attempt I would make in that vein would be substandard, and probably not up to my own standards.

My faith works for me, and my family.

If it doesn't work for you, fine. Get on with it.

If you want to stand about kvetching about how awful Christians are, by engaging in the standard group think, country club attitude of self-reinforcing bias that screams off of the pages of this forum, that's fine too. Be aware that the darks, as well as the self appointed brights, are also in the club, Massa Volatile.

ETA: Reconcile "love thy neighbor as thyself" with the practice of slavery, if you can.

DR
 
Last edited:
There are many possible teachings in Huck Finn, The Grapes of Wrath and Gone With the Wind, too.

All excellent books with teachings that could be interpreted in many different ways, but so far, no churchs have sprung up around then. OTOH, you left out the works of Elvis Presley There's definitely a cult that's grown around him! There are even claims that he's still around on earth. :D

My guess is that founding a new religion requires a Charismatic leader.
 
Really? You can be Christian and not believe one single word of the Bible is true? Not the bits about Jesus? Not the bits about Heaven? Not the bots about the crucifixion and resurrection?
Not as I understand it. As I understand the core doctrinal similarities between all sects/denominations, the one consistent agreement is in the divinity of Jesus and his resurrection. (I'd be obliged for whoever can correct me if that is in error.) It doesn't take long for argument and divergence to arise outside of that.
You can be a Christian if you think the entire Bible is a fiction? Really?
I don't think so.
Which self-proclaimed Christian denomination does not believe in the literal truth of a single sentence of the Bible? Show me one and I'll eat my hat.
Your hat is most likely safe. (By the way, did you get a free bowl of soup with that hat? :cool: )
Which is my entire point.
Why does it bother you? (Maybe it doesn't, but it seems that way.) If you don't care for Christianity, why do the variations in its practice cause you a problem?

DR
 
Last edited:
Doesn't cause me a problem, really. Just confuses the hell out of me. It's weird. It's irrational. It's unjustifiable (as your consistent refusal to justify or even clarify
your faith professes). I do not understand it at all, particularly from someone who proclaims to be sceptical.

I'm a curious guy. I do curious for a living. So I ask questions. I have no desire to ask 'loaded' questions, they are the just the questions as they occur to me. They are the obvious, glaring questions that need answers, and I'm always confused as to why I never get a straight answer.

You're a sceptic. You're a rational guy. An eloquent, rational guy. So maybe you're the one that can finally explain to me how theism is compatible with rationality. I know you've thought about this, and I know you must have some rationalisation process. I'd just like to hear it, that's all.

It's strange to watch you get all high and mighty every time this question is asked of you, because you're so open and honest and forthright and clear in every other area of thought. It's actually quite frustrating, and even a little depressing.

As for reconciliation, can you reconcile "love thy neighbour" with:

"Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword. For I am come to set a man at variance against his father, and the daughter against her mother, and the daughter in law against her mother in law", or

"Who knowing the judgment of God, that they which commit such things are worthy of death, not only do the same, but have pleasure in them that do them", or

"For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy; and mercy rejoiceth against judgment"?

As we said before, the Bible can be reconciled with whatever you want to reconcile it with. I'm sure you know this, as history testifies that this is the case. So why do you subscribe to it? What about it convinces you of not only its utility, but also its veracity?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom