Faith leads to evil.

I would argue that faith represents a lack of respect for and appreciation of the truth of things - whether we talking about religious faith or any irrational belief system - and to the extent that disdain for the truth leads to evil, faith leads to evil.
 
ETA: RR--the new testament says it supports everything in the old testament... it doesn't say that the new rules alter the old ones... they just build upon them. If slavery was okay in the old testament, it didn't suddenly become "wrong" in the new.

Thought you had me on ignore? :confused:

In any case, I've already addressed this, so if you have a citation that proves this, kindly provide it.

He said they wouldn't all be fulfilled until "heaven and earth pass" and people must still obey them unless they want to be "least" in heaven.

Sorry, are you simply ignoring what I’ve written? I mean, that’s fine if you want to do that. It doesn’t really incline me to repeat what I’ve already said. But I’ll understand. :D

In what way is "Slaves must be obedient to their masters in everything, and do what is wanted without argument" NOT supporting slavery?

Because the object of what your citation from 1 Timothy is about, and which you’ve left off, is “so that the name of God and our teaching is not brought into disrepute.” That’s the crux of what’s being said. This is not a encyclical on how slavery is a good thing, but rather on how Jesus’ followers should act, whether they be free of slaves.

So, now, if you have a quote from the New Testament that condones slavery or prescribes how slaves should be treated, such as those in the Old Testament, please share.

The reason that Christians don't take their message from Atheist bible scholars is that the fundamental Christian message is quite simple, really. It's also difficult to actually practice.

While I agree that the message is simple, I disagree that it’s “difficult to actually practice”. What’s so hard about “do unto others as you would have them do unto you”? Seems a pretty easy thing to accomplish, and yet most Christians are so hung up on the particulars that they lose sight of this simple message. Then it becomes "do unto others until they believe the way I do". <shrug>
 
Last edited:
You claimed that “The abolishment of slavery is a secular value. It did not come from religion, but from reason and free thought.” This is patently false as I’ve already shown. I have not claimed that there was not secular thought involved in the concept of the abolishment of slavery, rather that it did not originate solely from a secular field. The concept of abolition was one that came from many different areas, some of them secular, some of them religious. Most of the abolitionists in the United States were, in varying degrees, religious folk. Of them, many used the Bible as a means to support their stance on an abhorrent practice. I hope that’s more clear to you now.

You still fail. The abolishment of slavery is a secular value because it transcends religion and is generally accepted regardless of religion. Also, while christians may think it's a christian value, there is NOTHING the Jesus said, or the bible says, that condemns slavery and says it is wrong. Other secular values include:

Equal rights for all people regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation or religion.
Freedom of speech, expression and religion.

And you’d be wrong as well. The citations Civilized Worm provided were from the New Testament, unless Matthew and Timothy somehow got moved in your version.

Which is part of the first point. Since it's NT, the excuse "oh it's old testament" doesn't work. You should work on your reading comprehension.

While there is some cross over use between the terms slaves and servants, it is just that: cross over use. The two are used reasonably synonymously in the Bible, and that’s a dead end argument;or “apologetic crap” as you put it.

Yep, and it's just one flavor of apologetic crap. I'm glad you don't like that flavor.

The first verse was taken out of context, though I’ll admit it’s a confusing verse to read. The second citation doesn’t address anything that we’re discussing in this argument. But thank you also for playing!

This is more apologetic crap, a flavor you seem to enjoy. "It's taken out of context!" Interestingly enough, you didn't put it into context for us. Typical.


Speaking of "out of context" let's look at some of these equality verses here.

KJV said:
Galatians
3:26 For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.
3:27 For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ have put on Christ.
3:28 There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus.
3:29 And if ye be Christ's, then are ye Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise.

Clearly, this is talking about equality only among Jesus's followers and doesn't even say anything about equality of how people should treat each other.

KJV said:
Luke 4:18 The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he hath anointed me to preach the gospel to the poor; he hath sent me to heal the brokenhearted, to preach deliverance to the captives, and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty them that are bruised,
4:19 To preach the acceptable year of the Lord.

Preaching to captives and poor people is condoning equal treatment of all people?

KJV said:
Ephesians 6:5 Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ;
6:6 Not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but as the servants of Christ, doing the will of God from the heart;
6:7 With good will doing service, as to the Lord, and not to men:
6:8 Knowing that whatsoever good thing any man doeth, the same shall he receive of the Lord, whether he be bond or free.

You posted Ephesians 6:8 clearly out of context.

Matthew 20: 11-13

Again, out of context. This fable/story is about a guy who hires people all throughout the day, but pays them all the same. It's to illustrate that the "kingdom of heaven" is like this, that it doesn't matter when you become faithful, you'll receive the same promised reward. The story doesn't condone equal treatment of people in anything other than "god's reward" for having faith. Even in this, other verses in the NT contradict it.






Clearly
 
Can you see that your religion is just a deck of tarot cards? No matter what situation you're in, you can flip through the bible and find some passage that will tell you to do exactly whatever it is that you already think you should do. If you want to forgive someone, it tells you to forgive them. If you want to seek revenge, it tells you to seek revenge. If you want to get rich, it tells you that's ok. If you want to give your money to the poor, it tells you to do so. If you want to believe that men should rule over women, the bible tells you it's so. If you want to believe that all people are equal, the bible tells you that's true, too.

The story you've picked out of the bible as "true" is just the story you've picked; that's all. You could get just as much insight and wisdom from your daily horoscope as you can from your bible. Your personal method of meditation is no better than a ouija board.

Rather than valuing reason and your own ability to think a situation through, you feel a need to pretend that you are divinely guided, and that your choices are what god wants. And that's where the potential for evil lies.
 
Sorry, are you simply ignoring what I’ve written? I mean, that’s fine if you want to do that. It doesn’t really incline me to repeat what I’ve already said. But I’ll understand. :D


I'm not ignoring you, I just think it's pretty clear that the law would not be "fulfilled" untill "heaven and earth pass".


Because the object of what your citation from 1 Timothy is about, and which you’ve left off, is “so that the name of God and our teaching is not brought into disrepute.” That’s the crux of what’s being said. This is not a encyclical on how slavery is a good thing, but rather on how Jesus’ followers should act, whether they be free of slaves.

So, now, if you have a quote from the New Testament that condones slavery or prescribes how slaves should be treated, such as those in the Old Testament, please share.


Colossians 3:22 Servants, obey in all things your masters according to the flesh; not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but in singleness of heart, fearing God;

Slaves obey your masters. Seems pretty clear to me but I'm sure you'll find some way around it.


While I agree that the message is simple, I disagree that it’s “difficult to actually practice”. What’s so hard about “do unto others as you would have them do unto you”? Seems a pretty easy thing to accomplish, and yet most Christians are so hung up on the particulars that they lose sight of this simple message. Then it becomes "do unto others until they believe the way I do". <shrug>[/QUOTE]
 
It seems to me that Westprog is making a rather serious assumption that is without basis. He rightly points out that logical analysis doesn't begin until one identifies premises and conclusions (or more to his point) axioms and derivations from the axioms. According to him, if I understand correctly, to develop of logic of a "moral" system, we must first posit axiomatic "principles" and then use logic afterwards to determine the internal consistency of the derivations from those axiomatic "principles." Quite so.

However, how one views those axioms (however one wants to describe them) is rather important. It is, by no stretch of the imagination, necessary to believe-in in the faith manner, internalize (or however else one wishes to characterize this function), or otherwise hold as True any axiom, even if we depict them as moral principles. One can, I think, perfectly coherently view the axioms as conditional and one can choose not to hold them as matters of faith. And this is where Westprog, and faith, goes awry.

I have made it clear that my own belief - that certain moral axioms are in fact true - is indeed incompatible with a materialistic view of the universe.

Now, interestingly enough, if we look at the "principles" or axioms as conditional on some desired result then we can then do away with normative language and move towards verifiability and, in this manner, we can, not span, but render uninteresting the is-ought barrier. In such a way of seeing things, we can replace words like "ought" and "should" with "must." If we value X then we must prohibit Y or make Z an obligation. Sometimes whether something is a matter of verifiability or not is in how one phrases the question...

Now Westprog, and possibly others, may claim that I've simply created an additional step in that now the values are listed as first principles, but the critical difference, again, is not in the fact that we posit axioms, but in the manner in which we view them. it is a radically different thing to say "I value this" as opposed to "This is valuable." Do we view them as practical matters or do we view them as Truths(tm)? This very simple, but profound difference, can significantly alter the frame of reference and change the character of the whole endeavor.

So far I will go along with this.

I'll also add that this is close to how moral values are constructed for each person. People don't normally start out with a set of moral principles and solve each case as they encounter it. They judge whether things are right or wrong, and if they are interested enough, derive a set of moral values from that, and if they fit with an off the shlelf religion or philosophical viewpoint, they'll use it. If they are already attached to a particular viewpoint, they'll stick with it if it doesn't conflict too drastically with what they come to think is right and wrong.

Faith is maladaptive precisely because matters of faith are not held as conditional - they are held as Truths or absolute.

It takes a moral relativist to say that murder is not Wrong, but it takes a moral absolutist to say that murder is Right.

Which might be a significant difference in theory, but is insignificant in practice.

This is another way of high-lighting the difference between positing as conditional and holding as a matter of faith. However, with a more sophisticated understanding of morality as a social function, as opposed to some kind of absolute Truth(tm), it is quite possible to speak of morality without speaking of Right or Wrong, Good or Evil.

To the absolutist, this makes morality slippery and difficult to understand as their vision of "moral." To the absolutist this is a reason to condemn lack of faith in moral principles as non-moral. Interestingly enough, we do have GreyICE claim that a non-faith-based principles of morality are not morality as he or she and/or most others understand it. I think GreyICE is correct about this, but does this indicate that we must work within the framework of the current understanding, even if widespread, or that we need a different understanding?

For the non-absolutist, it certainly seems difficult to determine between moral systems on anything but a pragmatic basis.


In the non-absolutist, however, this indicates a different approach to understanding of morality - one based more on reliance on negotiation of our understanding of what it is to be moral. It isn't "slippery" because it is subject to revision; it is adaptive to changing circumstances. This is not to say that non-absolutists must go this route, but only that it is possible. Functions of moral language can still be accounted for, if we feel it is necessary to do so: Universalizability may expressed in the scope and breadth of application of the axiom set. Prescriptivity can be developed as an understanding of morality as a negotiated realm of reasonable expectations.

However, and this is where it gets interesting, what are we to say of people who posit morality as a matter of faith (again, believe-in or internalize the principles as Truth or absolute), but who also posit that they have direct access to moral Truths by some function of their private internal realms - conscience, and who, at the same time, treat conscience as sacrosanct? Now, here's an entirely other scenario which can, and often does, have catastrophic results, because these folks hold on faith that their Truths are absolute while at the same time deriving them from knowledge with no external referents.

Somewhere we developed this bizarre idea that conscience leads to understanding of moral Truth. What it actually does is remove the understanding of morality from the public realm and places it firmly in the realm of the entirely private, non-verifiable and non-refutable and also, non-negotiable realm. Sometimes they don't even realize what they are doing. A prime example is the person who claims that Biblical content represents moral Truth, but who also contradict that content at will, still believing they are holding to absolute Truth. Interesting perspective, that.

However, I can't see how the moral relativist can claim that such a moral system is inferior to any other moral system. If it's a matter of consensus, then the unfortunate Iranian atheist will have to agree that his moral system is supported by a smaller number of people that he deals with than the sharia version.

The question of how to choose a moral system remains open. If personal conscience or faith is to be ruled out, then what is to be used?
 
You still fail.

Already addressed.

I do like how you doggedly keep moving the goal posts though. That shows moxy. Not too much on the articulate argumentation field, but moxy is a good place to start. Feel free to keep chasing your tail on this one. When you want to actually discuss the issues, I'm here for you.:)

Which is part of the first point. Since it's NT, the excuse "oh it's old testament" doesn't work. You should work on your reading comprehension.

ROFL.

Um, that's what I said in the very beginning. I said that your statement was based on the Old Testament teachings not the New Testament. I haven't changed that target. If you've got a citation that proves the New Testament advocates slavery in the same way the Old Testament does, have at. Otherwise, you're just pounding sand. Feel free if that's what you want, but I generally leave that to my son these days. He's damn cute at it. ;)

This is more apologetic crap, a flavor you seem to enjoy. "It's taken out of context!" Interestingly enough, you didn't put it into context for us. Typical.

Out of context is out of context. And I did put it into context. Refer above. I'll wait here.:o

Clearly, this is talking about equality only among Jesus's followers and doesn't even say anything about equality of how people should treat each other.

Moxy, moxy, moxy. Moving the target again, I see. Doesn't that get boring for you after awhile? Maybe you should try something else. Straw men? Tautology? Circular arguments? Take your pick! ;)

None of your points has anything to do with the issues I stepped in and addressed, which were:

1- Does the New Testament condone slavery as the Old Testament does.
2 - Does the New Testament espouse concepts that led to the abolition movement.

You haven't shown where the New Testament does the first. I've shown where the New Testament did the second. I also put those into the historical context of the abolition movement. If you've got some new information to provide, great. I'm all ears, eyes, and fingers for it! :cool:

meg said:
Can you see that your religion is just a deck of tarot cards?

Ooops. As with volatile, you've just failed your reading comprehension test.

Thank you and please come again! :D

Civilized Worm said:
I'm not ignoring you, I just think it's pretty clear that the law would not be "fulfilled" untill "heaven and earth pass".

You must be, since I've already addressed the "fulfilled" argument at least twice now. You're welcome to go back and re-read it. I'll wait here for you as well :cool:.
 
Meg and I are certainly not mistaken. It certainly seems that you don't seem to know as much about the Bible as you should, given your professions of faith.

You can say I'm wrong, but it might help if you could explain why that's the case. Civilized Worm is doing a fine job of illustrating your blind spots.
 
You must be, since I've already addressed the "fulfilled" argument at least twice now. You're welcome to go back and re-read it. I'll wait here for you as well :cool:.

Have heaven and Earth passed?
 
1- Does the New Testament condone slavery as the Old Testament does.
2 - Does the New Testament espouse concepts that led to the abolition movement.

You are wrong on both accounts, as anyone reading the thread can see. It's been pointed out in the NT where it does condone slavery. When slaves are told to obey their masters, that is a condonation of slavery.

You have failed to show the concept of equality being condoned in the NT.

That's ok, if you really want to believe that equality and freedom are christian values, feel free to do so. I'd rather you be wrong in that than to go the other route and actually support the slavery condoned by the bible. I'm glad you have a secularized interpretation of the bible that twists it to support equality.
 
1- Does the New Testament condone slavery as the Old Testament does.

I note you snipped the part of CW's post where he quoted:

Colossians 3:22 Servants, obey in all things your masters according to the flesh; not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but in singleness of heart, fearing God;


Let's also add:

Ephesians 6:5: Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ.

Titus 2:9-10: Exhort servants to be obedient unto their own masters, and to please them well in all things; not answering again; Not purloining, but shewing all good fidelity; that they may adorn the doctrine of God our Saviour in all things.

1 Peter 2:18: Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear; not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward.

---------------

In what way are these not statements condoning slavery?

ETA: As if to prove Meg's point that Bible verses can be used to justify whichever position suits your extra-Biblical moral position, see SAB's list of verses on the subject 'Does God approve of Slavery?', which includes a list of pro- and anti-slavery verses in the Bible. Note that some of the pro- and anti-slavery verses appear in the same Book of the Bible!
 
Last edited:
I note you snipped the part of CW's post where he quoted:

Colossians 3:22 Servants, obey in all things your masters according to the flesh; not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but in singleness of heart, fearing God;


Let's also add:

Ephesians 6:5: Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ.

Titus 2:9-10: Exhort servants to be obedient unto their own masters, and to please them well in all things; not answering again; Not purloining, but shewing all good fidelity; that they may adorn the doctrine of God our Saviour in all things.

1 Peter 2:18: Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear; not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward.

---------------

You might want to also take a look at the versus on how slave owners are supposed to treat slaves. You might also want to check to see what the New Testament has to say about slave trading. You might also want to check how the early christians lived out the New Testament teachings. And you might also want to read the Rodney Stark book.
 
I give you a shot. You spend 90 minutes deliriously happy, then die, ensuring you never suffer again. I have moved your lifetime suffering to a dead minimum.

However, my friends and family now suffer considerably knowing that my life has been cut short, my ambitions left unfulfilled, and a me-shaped hole left in their lifes. They grieve unashamedly as they are forced to attend my funeral decades too soon.

Similarly, I stop an Olympic athlete from working out, because he is frequently in pain after a long training session.

The Olympic athlete now falls into a state of depression, no longer able to compete in the event for which they had been training all their lives. They endure mental anguish in the ruins of their shattered dreams.

I am doing good, in a logical manner.

No, you're actually causing quite a bit of harm, by not considering the consequences of your actions.
 
Meg and I are certainly not mistaken. It certainly seems that you don't seem to know as much about the Bible as you should, given your professions of faith.

You can say I'm wrong, but it might help if you could explain why that's the case. Civilized Worm is doing a fine job of illustrating your blind spots.

Alright, I'll bite: what's my "professions of faith"? Go ahead, I'm all a twitter with anticipation over this one. :D
 
People in Communist Russia had faith in the Party. People in the PRNK have faith in the Great Leader.

It's faith (that is - the unquestioning deference to and willingness to be supine to a higher, inerrant and imposed authority) that's inherently the problem here, not what the faith is in, necessarily. Communism, authoritarian fascism or personality cults are just as faith-based as the monotheisms are, and trying to highlight them as examples of faith-free or even atheist states is naive.

In essence, states like Nazi Germany, Communist Russia, Turkmenistan, North Korea etc. use the tools of faith to their own ends. When people believe in something without question (that is, they have faith), then evil ensues.
While well said, Erich Hoffer was about fifty years ahead of you. :cool:

DR
 
Alright, I'll bite: what's my "professions of faith"? Go ahead, I'm all a twitter with anticipation over this one. :D

Well... you're not a Mormon! :)

Nevertheless, you do seem to spend a lot of energy defending Scripture... Why is that?
 
Last edited:
You still fail. The abolishment of slavery is a secular value because it transcends religion and is generally accepted regardless of religion. Also, while christians may think it's a christian value, there is NOTHING the Jesus said, or the bible says, that condemns slavery and says it is wrong. Other secular values include:

Equal rights for all people regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation or religion.
Freedom of speech, expression and religion.

Which is part of the first point. Since it's NT, the excuse "oh it's old testament" doesn't work. You should work on your reading comprehension.

Yep, and it's just one flavor of apologetic crap. I'm glad you don't like that flavor.

This is more apologetic crap, a flavor you seem to enjoy. "It's taken out of context!" Interestingly enough, you didn't put it into context for us. Typical.

Speaking of "out of context" let's look at some of these equality verses here.

Clearly, this is talking about equality only among Jesus's followers and doesn't even say anything about equality of how people should treat each other.

Preaching to captives and poor people is condoning equal treatment of all people?

You posted Ephesians 6:8 clearly out of context.

Again, out of context. This fable/story is about a guy who hires people all throughout the day, but pays them all the same. It's to illustrate that the "kingdom of heaven" is like this, that it doesn't matter when you become faithful, you'll receive the same promised reward. The story doesn't condone equal treatment of people in anything other than "god's reward" for having faith. Even in this, other verses in the NT contradict it.
For all your analysis, you choose not to see the forest for the trees.

Ken, you are making the same sola scriptura conceptual error that Fundies make when claiming that the earth 6000 years old. Irony abounds. Pretending that Christian philosophy and practice is static is a profound perceptual mistake.

See Wilberforce. His abolitionist was informed by Evangelical Christianity that was a rising ideological force in England in the 18th and 19th centuries, a movement that in many cases crossed the pond (see Methodism among other movements) and that contributed to the support for the Zionist movement that led to the founding of the state of Israel. (See Barbara Tuchman, Bible and Sword.)

This stuff doesn't happen in isolation, but as a synthesis. Implementation of Christian practice (which vary) are a part of that synthesis.

DR
 
Last edited:
Darth, what is there to be praised about unquestioning deference to a higher authority (aka: faith)? I know you pop up in these threads to defend religion, but you never seem to make a straight case as to why it deserves defending...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom