Long post to address all the lovely discussion points. Apologies ahead of time.
In another thread I could have sworn you said you were an atheist (or at least that you "lacked religious belief", which amounts to the same thing:
It does? I didn't know that having a lack of religious beliefs made me an atheist. <shrug>
Abolition of slavery, as I understand it, grew out of the broad cultural background of Enlightenment philosophy - which, as I'm sure you know, has very little to do with Scriptural Christianity.
Which I've disagreed with. But I don't think we're going to come to any kind of resolution in that regard. I feel that the majority of abolitionists were Christians, who felt compelled to act because of their faith, and that faith was instrumental in their arguments.
That the same text was used to counter them is unfortunate. But it doesn't render their faith any less fundamental to their cause. If you can show me this is not the case, then we might have something. Right now, I'm not seeing it, and everyone on that side of the fence seems to think this makes me an apologist. Okey dokey then!
That conveniently ignores the "until Heaven and Earth have passed" quote from Matthew, "It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail." from Luke, "Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever" from Psalms etc. etc.
It wasn't meant to be convenient. Jesus was saying that the law had to be fulfilled, that it was fulfilled through him, and that therefor the law hadn't failed. There is no need for heaven and earth to pass away, since the law didn't fail, and it was fulfilled. I can try to restate it again, but I think you're just going to keep getting hung up on the trees in this forest in order to make your argument. It doesn't suit you and your particular beliefs (or lack) so there it is. <shrug>
Of course, there are quotes from Romans and Galatians which state entirely the opposite, but then we're back into tarot reading again, aren't we? The Bible says whatever the reader wants it to say. No more, and no less. There is no "fundamental message" as Westprog was claiming earlier because the same set of texts can justify any set of behaviours you so choose.
Sure, depending on where you pull them and how you use them, you can pretty much justify anything. No argument there.
But I do think there is a fundamental message. I think all religious texts have a fundamental message. For the Bible, I've disagreed with Westprof that that fundamental message is, as he claimed hard to follow. That seems to be a retcon for the proclaimed Christians who did bad things in their time.
You're just picking the set of interpretations which suits your particular agenda (which is a little obfuscated at the moment).
No agenda than that which I stated: thaiboxerken was making false statements. I've provided several times the two points that I felt were incorrect. You are welcome to go back up and re-read them. I believe I numbered them at least twice, so they shouldn't be tricky to find.
You mean this stuff is supposed to make sense? Or be internally narratively coherent?
To the Christian point of view, yeah. Since we're looking at this through that lens, asking what it means, then I don't automatically disregard that claim because it's inconvenient.
If you're asking me personally, then that's a different matter entirely.
Seriously? You don't think "Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ" or "Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear, not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward" are not condoning the servitude of slaves to their masters?
Do you have a job? I have a job. I’ve worked for several companies in my time. Some rather large. You may have heard of them. For almost all of them I was generally rated pretty highly on performance reviews. I was “obedient” to my boss, though perhaps not with “fear and trembling”, but I usually worked with a “singleness of” purpose, even if it wasn’t imbedded in my heart.
So yeah, seriously, that’s what I think is being said. Which is vastly different, as I also said, from the Old Testament view of slaves. <shrug>
meg said:
Just exactly what is so great about this "faith"? Why do people wear their faith so proudly? Why do christians laud other people's faith?
Overall, I’d say nothing is so great about faith. I think people “wear their faith so proudly” because it lends an us-versus-them mentality, it’s nice to be “right,” and there is certainly strength in numbers. Christians seem to laud other faiths for this same reason. They can point to someone they consider great, attach the moniker of “powerful faith” to them, and hold them up to others to show that “our God is better than your God”.
volatile said:
ACS? RR? Any thoughts on the above?
Nopers. I’ve never argued against this notion.
Mobyseven said:
So, I really don't see how you can say that the old law was abolished by Jesus, when his own words speak otherwise.
I suppose I can’t. I’ve done my best to explain how I understand the scripture to be interpreted (and widely, not in a limited sense to this discussion).

But I do appreciate that you understood that Jesus was providing an either-or scenerio. I don’t know why I wasn’t able to get that portion of the text across to volatile and others before.
As for the quotes, no, I didn’t miss them. We’ve discussed them all along.
westprog said:
At least Articulett has permitted you to talk to me and my ilk. Bloody generous of her.
Indeed. She’s gracious and giving like that.
Actually, I was quite shocked when she elected to put me on ignore. We only ever crossed swords in one discussion. Other times I found her reasonable, rational and to some degree lived up to her moniker. <shrug>
Beth said:
No, wrong. Depends on the particular denomination. In addition, some passages are considered factual by students of the history of that place and time. Asimov's guide to the bible is illuminating in that regard.
You’ve just contradicted yourself here. What volatile is saying (and volatile, correct me if I’m misinterpreting you) is that in order to be Christian, some aspects of the Bible have to be taken literally. There was literally a Jesus, he literally taught, preached, died, rose, etc. There were literally other figures of the Bible who are historic figures like David, Saul, Moses, etc.
There is not a single Christian denomination that interprets the Bible as one big figurative piece of fiction.