Faith leads to evil.

Well... you're not a Mormon! :)

Nice of you to notice. :p

Nevertheless, you do seem to spend a lot of energy defending Scripture... Why is that?

Well, I'd say that I spend about 25% of my energy on this kind of discussion, and the rest on movies and books. Sometimes I get embroiled in a discussion on various computer games, though I'm hardly a gamer. I'd give it a 1%, maybe 2.79% ;)

But to address your question, Aristotle said, "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." (One of my favorite quotes, by the way.) I don't know that I have an educated mind, but I do attempt to entertain all sides of a discussion and arrive at my own conclusion. In a case like this, I've argued where I think an error has been made, as I believe thaiboxerken has. You'll also note that I've agreed to points that have been made against, and have certainly attempted to acknowledge where my understanding is limited. thaiboxerken's position seems intractable, but I didn't know that going into the discussion. I always assume people are reasonable and subject to logical argumentation until they prove otherwise. :D
 
You might want to also take a look at the versus on how slave owners are supposed to treat slaves. You might also want to check to see what the New Testament has to say about slave trading. You might also want to check how the early christians lived out the New Testament teachings. And you might also want to read the Rodney Stark book.

Why not have the very simple phrase "Do not keep slaves, lest ye be burned forever in hell"?

No. Instead, the NT condones slavery. And you are defending it. Remarkable.
 
But to address your question, Aristotle said, "It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." (One of my favorite quotes, by the way.) I don't know that I have an educated mind, but I do attempt to entertain all sides of a discussion and arrive at my own conclusion. In a case like this, I've argued where I think an error has been made, as I believe thaiboxerken has. You'll also note that I've agreed to points that have been made against, and have certainly attempted to acknowledge where my understanding is limited. thaiboxerken's position seems intractable, but I didn't know that going into the discussion. I always assume people are reasonable and subject to logical argumentation until they prove otherwise. :D

Well, you're certainly correct to do so.

However, when I see the types of mental gymnastics you're undertaking to avoid recognising the NT quotes as in favour of slavery, it's weird to watch, especially as you're (apparently) an atheist. It seems weird to me to be expending mental energy defending the indefensible. I understand that TBK is a little, shall we say, hardline, but I think he's broadly right in principle here.

Further, given that heaven and earth have not passed, quite clearly, it strikes me that even your defence of the OT passages (in that they have been "fulfilled") is on shaky ground too.
 
Why not have the very simple phrase "Do not keep slaves, lest ye be burned forever in hell"?

Because the original writers of the New Testament didn't think the system was necessarily wrong or evil. Because the system had been in place for so many generations. Because it was an accepted part of their social order and it didn't look like it was ever going to go away.

No. Instead, the NT condones slavery.

Citation for the New Testament on condoning slavery please. No one has been able to provide one yet.

And you are defending it. Remarkable.

I believe (and please feel free to correct me here Christian Skeptic) he was defending how it was used in defeating slavery. It was.
 
Citation for the New Testament on condoning slavery please. No one has been able to provide one yet.

Apart from :

Colossians 3:22 Servants, obey in all things your masters according to the flesh; not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but in singleness of heart, fearing God;

Ephesians 6:5: Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ.

Titus 2:9-10: Exhort servants to be obedient unto their own masters, and to please them well in all things; not answering again; Not purloining, but shewing all good fidelity; that they may adorn the doctrine of God our Saviour in all things.

1 Peter 2:18: Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear; not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward.
 
I believe (and please feel free to correct me here Christian Skeptic) he was defending how it was used in defeating slavery. It was.

...which neglects the point that it could just have easily have been used to justify exactly the opposite proposition. There are Bible verses (as you well know) that can be interpreted or presented as supporting slavery.

In other words, Christianity was incidental to the abolition of slavery.
 
I have made it clear that my own belief - that certain moral axioms are in fact true - is indeed incompatible with a materialistic view of the universe.

Okay. And I have already made it clear that I see that view as maladaptive. I could show you my posts on Guardasil, bring up issues of condom use and other instances where inability for morality to adapt has resulted in maladaptive behaviour. I guess none of these would matter to you, eh?

I'm not a Deuteronomy kind of guy, nor am I a fire and brimstone eternal torment kind of guy either. But I am someone who's words might possibly turn some away from their God.

westprog said:
So far I will go along with this.

So, at the very least I can claim I haven't misrepresented you, at least in this regard and at least so far?

westprog said:
I'll also add that this is close to how moral values are constructed for each person. People don't normally start out with a set of moral principles and solve each case as they encounter it. They judge whether things are right or wrong, and if they are interested enough, derive a set of moral values from that, and if they fit with an off the shlelf religion or philosophical viewpoint, they'll use it. If they are already attached to a particular viewpoint, they'll stick with it if it doesn't conflict too drastically with what they come to think is right and wrong.

How does off-the-shelf Christianity (or any of the trinity of monotheisms) fit your values? As a skeptic and non-theist condemned to death by stoning in Deut, it is in my interests to know these things, yes? As someone who posits a future beyond some mythical armageddon, this is of interest to me, yes? As someone who views humans as more than mere cogs in a dogmatic machine or some childish "plan," this is of interest to me, yes?

westprog said:
Which might be a significant difference in theory, but is insignificant in practice.

No, there is a very significant difference in practice. There is no prescriptive compulsion to murder in the non-absolutist viewpoint on the basis of moral values. Or are you one of those folks who think that ideas have no influence on behaviour...?

westprog said:
For the non-absolutist, it certainly seems difficult to determine between moral systems on anything but a pragmatic basis.

Hardly, I, as a non-absolutist, can still value things and still not view these values as absolute Truths. I can do this in exactly the same way I can have confidence in this or that theory while still not being certain about it. But this is a variant on the "where do your morals come from argument" and I've already covered that in the suggestion that morality can be viewed as a realm of reasonable expectations amongst a social group.

Here's the interesting thing. If you stop looking for Truths, the need for them vanishes. Honestly; Truth is a weird concept that way. It's kinda like television. We constantly have to be convinced that we want it, crave it, need it.

westprog said:
However, I can't see how the moral relativist can claim that such a moral system is inferior to any other moral system. If it's a matter of consensus, then the unfortunate Iranian atheist will have to agree that his moral system is supported by a smaller number of people that he deals with than the sharia version.

He very well might. Isn't this the case with anyone? In particular, isn't it also the case of those who think they can find moral Truth through conscience? No wait, the conscience type thinks he has direct access to moral Truth(tm).

Inferior and superior are normative-evaluative terms unless one wishes to speak in terms of superiority or inferiority with respect to some expressed result in which case they can be appraised using non-normative uses of "superior/inferior" in terms of efficacy.

westprog said:
The question of how to choose a moral system remains open. If personal conscience or faith is to be ruled out, then what is to be used?

A negotiated realm of reasonable expectations. :)

Faith, it seems to me, is the internalization of moral Truth. It doesn't determine a moral Truth (please do tell me how faith determines a moral Truth); it merely emotionally reinforces it - lends it allegiance and a determination to refuse to consider the non-Truth of the Truth. As a skeptic, with an open scope of inquiry, of course, this doesn't work for me.

As for conscience (qua determiner of morals), it is even more haphazard than what the absolutists fear about moral relativism. Conscience is a justification to go stark raving bonkers with absolute license and have a sense of certainty that one is somehow "Right" about doing so.

What the religious who truck with faith and conscience have done is taken how we negotiate social norms and turned it into something non-negotiable, either by dominating the negotiating table (faith) or refusing to recognize it (conscience).
 
Last edited:
Well, you're certainly correct to do so.

Thanks, I appreciate your endorsement.

However, when I see the types of mental gymnastics you're undertaking to avoid recognising the NT quotes as in favour of slavery, it's weird to watch . . .

I haven't seen a citation that shows the NT was in favor of slavery. There have been attempts to take certain sections out of context. I've addressed those until I became tired of being ignored.

Perhaps I'm drawing a fine line here. <shrug>

. . . especially as you're (apparently) an atheist.

Nopers, I'm not that either. :D

It seems weird to me to be expending mental energy defending the indefensible. I understand that TBK is a little, shall we say, hardline, but I think he's broadly right in principle here.

Obviously, I don't think it's indefensible, nor that the principle is correct on either count (1 - Condoning slavery. 2 - Concepts that led to abolition). I've cited the abolitionist movement, which was heavily Christian, heavily influenced to act because of their belief, and used the Bible to forward their case.

Further, given that heaven and earth have not passed, quite clearly, it strikes me that even your defence of the OT passages (in that they have been "fulfilled") is on shaky ground too.

That wasn't an Old Testament passage, that was a New Testament passage. :) But I'm just picking nits here.

Clearly, I'm not explaining the passage correctly. Jesus was saying that he was the fulfillment of the Old Testament laws, that in fulfilling them, they no longer required adherence. Adherence had been completed with Jesus. This was, as I understand it, part of his way of tying the two periods together, paying homage to the past, which led to him and his ministry. If we follow the thought here, by Jesus' coming, he met prophecy, completed the need for the old laws, and established a new order. He is referring to himself.

I don't know how to answer this any differently, as that's the commonly accepted and commonly understood meaning of Jesus' statements. Else, why would he then go on in the chapter to provide a new set of laws which trump the old? Kicks?

Well, who am I to deny the proclaimed Son of God his kicks?! :D

Or is it the "passing of heaven and earth" that you guys are being hung up on? I assumed that part was reasonably obvious, which is why I haven't gone into much detail.
 
...which neglects the point that it could just have easily have been used to justify exactly the opposite proposition. There are Bible verses (as you well know) that can be interpreted or presented as supporting slavery.

Oh, I didn't mean to neglect it. I thought it was widely known. There are some truly abhorrent speeches made that utilize "The Good Book" in this fashion, and clearly not for good.

This does go some way to showing just how easily it is to turn said book on its ear for almost any purpose, and ignore, as I mentioned earlier, the core message.

In other words, Christianity was incidental to the abolition of slavery.

Nopers. I go back to my earlier statement about the abolitionists, most of whom were Christians, most of whom felt compelled to act because of their faith, and who used The Bible to support their stance both in the US and in England.
 
Apart from :[snip]

None of these condone slavery. They talk about how people, adherents of the faith, should act in their duties. Basically they all say be good citizens. Nothing like the Old Testament which talks about how you are to treat your slaves, how you can buy or sell them, or sell your children, etc. That's clearly condoning. I see nothing of that nature in the New Testament. <shrug>
 
Just an observation:

I think many atheists would prefer God to spell all the do's and don'ts out for them instead of giving them two overall commandments and then having Him trust them to then apply it to situations and institutions in existence or that may come up.

Take slavery:
It was a (for all intents and purposes) and global economic and cultural institution in First Century Mediterranean world. It's non-existence was an alien concept. It was also different then the American System by the way. At any rate - it also had varying levels of social status within it to. blah, blah, blah. It didn't take long for the Christians to apply the Love Your Neighbor Commandment (combined with the equality between the sexes, social classes, ethnic groups preached by Paul) for them to begin going through the systems in their societies and finally unyoking themselves from them. And yes - they then turned a critical eye outward onto non-christians whom they loved and considered God's children even though they weren't Christians. By Aquinas time slavery in the west was essentially abolished - but then the Europeans navigated around Africa and the Africans began trading the African slaves they were keeping to the Europeans. And when the Church cried out "No! It's wrong!" the Church was ignored and slavery once again took root. I might add - the form it retook form as was purely economic.
 
Last edited:
...which neglects the point that it could just have easily have been used to justify exactly the opposite proposition. There are Bible verses (as you well know) that can be interpreted or presented as supporting slavery.

In other words, Christianity was incidental to the abolition of slavery.

No it wasn't. You're mistaking The Bible for Christianity; literalism for interpretation.
 
Apart from :

Colossians 3:22 Servants, obey in all things your masters according to the flesh; not with eyeservice, as menpleasers; but in singleness of heart, fearing God;

Ephesians 6:5: Servants, be obedient to them that are your masters according to the flesh, with fear and trembling, in singleness of your heart, as unto Christ.

Titus 2:9-10: Exhort servants to be obedient unto their own masters, and to please them well in all things; not answering again; Not purloining, but shewing all good fidelity; that they may adorn the doctrine of God our Saviour in all things.

1 Peter 2:18: Servants, be subject to your masters with all fear; not only to the good and gentle, but also to the froward.

You're making the classic mistake that many non-christians make. You're reading what it actually says instead of having a belief and making the scripture support that belief. RobRoy has proven that he's just another apologist with silly claims and assertions. At least he follows a more secularized version of christianity.
 
You're making the classic mistake that many non-christians make. You're reading what it actually says instead of having a belief and making the scripture support that belief. RobRoy has proven that he's just another apologist with silly claims and assertions. At least he follows a more secularized version of christianity.

ROFL. I suppose the internet saying is true that when all else fails, resort to the personal attack. Brings a tear to my eye to have been part of the system here today!
 
Last edited:
I'm sick of hitting my head against this particular wall, good luck with it.


If you talking about RR, he's a self important apologist... I've had him on ignore for some time, and only have the displeasure of reading him in your posts. He's a few brings shy of a full load.

Impenetrable and sure he's saying something sensible despite no feedback to suggest such.

Let him talks with the likes of Westprog and others of their ilk. I've never seen reason work on "defenders of faith".
 
Nopers, I'm not that either. :D

In another thread I could have sworn you said you were an atheist (or at least that you "lacked religious belief", which amounts to the same thing:

My wife has struggled from time to time with my lack of religious beliefs...


Obviously, I don't think it's indefensible, nor that the principle is correct on either count (1 - Condoning slavery. 2 - Concepts that led to abolition). I've cited the abolitionist movement, which was heavily Christian, heavily influenced to act because of their belief, and used the Bible to forward their case.

As I said up thread, the Bible and Christianity in general were incidental to abolitionism. It is perfectly possible to build a rhetorical case based in Scripture that is entirely supportive of slave ownership.

Abolition of slavery, as I understand it, grew out of the broad cultural background of Enlightenment philosophy - which, as I'm sure you know, has very little to do with Scriptural Christianity.


Clearly, I'm not explaining the passage correctly. Jesus was saying that he was the fulfillment of the Old Testament laws, that in fulfilling them, they no longer required adherence. Adherence had been completed with Jesus. This was, as I understand it, part of his way of tying the two periods together, paying homage to the past, which led to him and his ministry. If we follow the thought here, by Jesus' coming, he met prophecy, completed the need for the old laws, and established a new order. He is referring to himself.

That conveniently ignores the "until Heaven and Earth have passed" quote from Matthew, "It is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail." from Luke, "Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever" from Psalms etc. etc.

Of course, there are quotes from Romans and Galatians which state entirely the opposite, but then we're back into tarot reading again, aren't we? The Bible says whatever the reader wants it to say. No more, and no less. There is no "fundamental message" as Westprog was claiming earlier because the same set of texts can justify any set of behaviours you so choose.

You're just picking the set of interpretations which suits your particular agenda (which is a little obfuscated at the moment).

I don't know how to answer this any differently, as that's the commonly accepted and commonly understood meaning of Jesus' statements. Else, why would he then go on in the chapter to provide a new set of laws which trump the old? Kicks?

You mean this stuff is supposed to make sense? Or be internally narratively coherent?

Or is it the "passing of heaven and earth" that you guys are being hung up on? I assumed that part was reasonably obvious, which is why I haven't gone into much detail.


Not so much. Heaven and Earth haven't passed, have they? It doesn't even matter, given that Romans 6: 14 says "Ye are not under the law, but under grace", but then we're back where we started. Pick and mix beliefs at the same time as adherence to what is presented as a coherent creed. It seems pretty weird from where I'm standing.
 
.
Considered as being from the same source, the source is obviously screwed up.

And applying the knowlege that the bible was written over hundreds of years by many different hands, what does that lead us to?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom