I have made it clear that my own belief - that certain moral axioms are in fact true - is indeed incompatible with a materialistic view of the universe.
Okay. And I have already made it clear that I see that view as maladaptive. I could show you my posts on Guardasil, bring up issues of condom use and other instances where inability for morality to adapt has resulted in maladaptive behaviour. I guess none of these would matter to you, eh?
I'm not a Deuteronomy kind of guy, nor am I a fire and brimstone eternal torment kind of guy either. But I am someone who's words might possibly turn some away from their God.
westprog said:
So far I will go along with this.
So, at the very least I can claim I haven't misrepresented you, at least in this regard and at least so far?
westprog said:
I'll also add that this is close to how moral values are constructed for each person. People don't normally start out with a set of moral principles and solve each case as they encounter it. They judge whether things are right or wrong, and if they are interested enough, derive a set of moral values from that, and if they fit with an off the shlelf religion or philosophical viewpoint, they'll use it. If they are already attached to a particular viewpoint, they'll stick with it if it doesn't conflict too drastically with what they come to think is right and wrong.
How does off-the-shelf Christianity (or any of the trinity of monotheisms) fit your values? As a skeptic and non-theist condemned to death by stoning in Deut, it is in my interests to know these things, yes? As someone who posits a future beyond some mythical armageddon, this is of interest to me, yes? As someone who views humans as more than mere cogs in a dogmatic machine or some childish "plan," this is of interest to me, yes?
westprog said:
Which might be a significant difference in theory, but is insignificant in practice.
No, there is a very significant difference in practice. There is no prescriptive compulsion to murder in the non-absolutist viewpoint on the basis of moral values. Or are you one of those folks who think that ideas have no influence on behaviour...?
westprog said:
For the non-absolutist, it certainly seems difficult to determine between moral systems on anything but a pragmatic basis.
Hardly, I, as a non-absolutist, can still value things and still not view these values as absolute Truths. I can do this in exactly the same way I can have confidence in this or that theory while still not being certain about it. But this is a variant on the "where do your morals come from argument" and I've already covered that in the suggestion that morality can be viewed as a realm of reasonable expectations amongst a social group.
Here's the interesting thing. If you stop looking for Truths, the need for them vanishes. Honestly; Truth is a weird concept that way. It's kinda like television. We constantly have to be convinced that we want it, crave it, need it.
westprog said:
However, I can't see how the moral relativist can claim that such a moral system is inferior to any other moral system. If it's a matter of consensus, then the unfortunate Iranian atheist will have to agree that his moral system is supported by a smaller number of people that he deals with than the sharia version.
He very well might. Isn't this the case with anyone? In particular, isn't it also the case of those who think they can find moral Truth through conscience? No wait, the conscience type thinks he has direct access to moral Truth(tm).
Inferior and superior are normative-evaluative terms unless one wishes to speak in terms of superiority or inferiority with respect to some expressed result in which case they can be appraised using non-normative uses of "superior/inferior" in terms of efficacy.
westprog said:
The question of how to choose a moral system remains open. If personal conscience or faith is to be ruled out, then what is to be used?
A negotiated realm of reasonable expectations.
Faith, it seems to me, is the internalization of moral Truth. It doesn't
determine a moral Truth (please do tell me how faith
determines a moral Truth); it merely emotionally reinforces it - lends it allegiance and a determination to refuse to consider the non-Truth of the Truth. As a skeptic, with an open scope of inquiry, of course, this doesn't work for me.
As for conscience (qua determiner of morals), it is even more haphazard than what the absolutists fear about moral relativism. Conscience is a justification to go stark raving bonkers with absolute license and have a sense of certainty that one is somehow "Right" about doing so.
What the religious who truck with faith and conscience have done is taken how we negotiate social norms and turned it into something non-negotiable, either by dominating the negotiating table (faith) or refusing to recognize it (conscience).