Faith leads to evil.

You are making the mistake of assuming that an act performed entirely for the good of oneself cannot also be good for society as a whole.

Much (but not all) of what I do is motivated by selfish desires - I freely admit to that. But I also try not to cause harm to society or those around me when I act. I try to choose actions that are beneficial for me, and also beneficial for those around me. Occasionally, I do things from which I gain no benefit, entirely for altruistic purposes - but that is the exception, not the rule.

In general, people who act selfishly to the detriment of others are penalised for doing so. Yes, some of them get away with it - but the odds are significantly against them.

Human history is full of examples of selfish behaviour to the detriment of others. In fact, one could almost use that as a description of human history. Admittedly such behaviour becomes easier the less the connection with the people to whom suffering is caused.

I don't think that it's possible to objectively conclude that a strategy of selfishness - by which I mean not only acting for oneself, but with disregard for others - will automatically fail. There may be circumstances where altruism - or at least consideration - is a better strategy. There are other times when it isn't.

There's a good case for saying it's a good strategy for humanity as a whole, but even then it's not clear. Given two tribes competing for limited resources, it's usually a good for a single tribe to stick together. It might also be a good idea for them to eradicate the other tribe.
 
Care to name something that is purely altruistic in nature? No trap here, I'm just curious.

Rescuing someone you didn't like and weren't related to from a burning building, knowing that you would die. I haven't done this myself, of course. If I did, I'd like to think it was for altruistic motives.

And those who act selfishly but benefit others tend to receive high praise, or garner great prestige.

I'd assume that in this case, I'd expect to be blamed for the fire by the person I rescued.

However, I agree that proving that any act is purely altruistic is difficult. If one even just does things because it gives a nice warm glow, that can be its own reward.
 
You didn't provide proof, but evidence.

Nopers, I provided proof for the statements I was making.

And the evidence you provided can be interpreted more than one way.

Not according to what volatile turned up here and not according to what I turned up here.

There's very little doubt in the quotes that we provided that the Congregational church believes in Jesus as a literal, historic figure.

Which one is more likely to be a correct assessment of the beliefs of that church?

Statements of belief made by the Congregational Church on their official websites trump anecdotal evidence by a "member" who lacks belief in God but shuns the title of atheist any day of the week and twice on the Sabbath*. :D






*Not available in all areas. Subject to store participation. Check for local listings.
 
Last edited:
Rescuing someone you didn't like and weren't related to from a burning building, knowing that you would die. I haven't done this myself, of course. If I did, I'd like to think it was for altruistic motives.

I wasn't asking for a general example of an altruistic action. Mobyseven identified that he performs such actions from time to time, and I was curious what those were.

However, I agree that proving that any act is purely altruistic is difficult. If one even just does things because it gives a nice warm glow, that can be its own reward.

Yeppers, exactly my point. :D
 
Nopers, I provided proof for the statements I was making.



Not according to what volatile turned up here and not according to what I turned up here.

There's very little doubt in the quotes that we provided that the Congregational church believes in Jesus as a literal, historic figure.

Hmm, any doubt at all implies that it isn't proof. As I've seen more than sufficient evidence to the contrary, I'll continue to disagree.

Statements of belief made by the Congregational Church on their official websites trump anecdotal evidence by a "member" who lacks belief in God but shuns the title of atheist any day of the week and twice on the Sabbath*. :D

<shrug> You're entitled to decide for yourself what value you place on the testimonial evidence available to you. I've no quarrel if you elect to disbelieve me. Presumably you'll understand why I take the word of 3 successive ministers of the church I belong to over the your interpretation of the statements of you've found.

Se la vie.
 
Human history is full of examples of selfish behaviour to the detriment of others. In fact, one could almost use that as a description of human history. Admittedly such behaviour becomes easier the less the connection with the people to whom suffering is caused.

I don't think that it's possible to objectively conclude that a strategy of selfishness - by which I mean not only acting for oneself, but with disregard for others - will automatically fail. There may be circumstances where altruism - or at least consideration - is a better strategy. There are other times when it isn't.

There's a good case for saying it's a good strategy for humanity as a whole, but even then it's not clear. Given two tribes competing for limited resources, it's usually a good for a single tribe to stick together. It might also be a good idea for them to eradicate the other tribe.
How about altruism for altruism's sake? Jumping on a grenade, for instance? Your model doesn't seem to account for that.
 
Hmm, any doubt at all implies that it isn't proof.

No, a reasonable doubt might imply that we rethink our original supposition. A requirement of "any doubt" is just silly, as we can doubt our very existence. See Descartes for the entire analysis of that one. :D

As I've seen more than sufficient evidence to the contrary, I'll continue to disagree.

Great. Kindly provide some for the rest of the class! ;)

Presumably you'll understand why I take the word of 3 successive ministers of the church I belong to over the your interpretation of the statements of you've found.

I'll understand if you'll reasonably reinterpret the following to prove that the Congregational church doesn't believe in a literal Jesus:

"God's salvation is a free gift received only by grace, only through faith in the Lord Jesus Christ." (Congregational Christian Church, FAQ)

Remember to show all your work for partial credit. :D
 
Last edited:
No, a reasonable doubt might imply that we rethink our original supposition. A requirement of "any doubt" is just silly, as we can doubt our very existence. See Descartes for the entire analysis of that one. :D
Sorry. I'm a professional mathematician. That's how I always think of proof. I understand what you're saying though. I'll concede the point in regards to your weighting of the evidence.
Great. Kindly provide some for the rest of the class! ;)
I did. I referenced a book written by one of the ministers of the church.
I'll understand if you'll reasonably reinterpret the following to prove that the Congregational church doesn't believe in a literal Jesus:

"God's salvation is a free gift received only by grace, only through faith in the Lord Jesus Christ." (Congregational Christian Church, FAQ)

Remember to show all your work for partial credit. :D

I'm a little confused here. How is it that this statement implies belief in a literal historical Jesus? I just don't see what you obviously feel is obvious. If it said "God's salvation is a free gift received only by grace, only through faith in the Holy Spirit" would that imply that the Holy Spirit was a literal thing with existance in the material world? 'cause I don't think it would.
 
Last edited:
How about altruism for altruism's sake? Jumping on a grenade, for instance? Your model doesn't seem to account for that.

I think it's been established that it makes sense, genetically speaking, to sacrifice yourself for two siblings or four first cousins.
 
Most of us "feel good" when we "lift up" others-- make them laugh, educate them, share what we have... and we "hurt" when we hurt others. This is the basis of empathy... it's why we love drama and stories... it has a lot to do with mirror neurons... not religion.

We have evolved to "feel good" when we do good. That is what is meant by it's "selfish" to do good. Maybe not everyone... and maybe some people need the training wheels religion provides. But Randi and others appear to give quite a lot of themselves without believing that some invisible guy demands it.

When we give to our kids-- it's instinctive... just as it is in other mammals... we hurt when our kids hurt... we laugh when they laugh... we are mentally rewarded for "giving" to some people... and we suffer when we can't give to them or fix what ails them.

Would religious people suddenly become the boobs of society if they lost their faith? Did they not evolve these rather strong social behaviors?
 
I did. I referenced a book written by one of the ministers of the church.

Perfect! :) Two points will clinch this argument for you:

1 - Provide the quote where the Reverend Cox says an individual can be a Christian and not believe in Jesus.

2 - Provide the quote where the Reverend Cox is speaking from an ecclesiastical standpoint for the beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole.

I will not only concede, I'll make good my promise to eat volatile's hat! :D

I'm a little confused here. How is it that this statement implies belief in a literal historical Jesus? I just don't see what you obviously feel is obvious.

Because they are answering the question of what gospel they believe. It's a pretty straight-forward question and answer.:cool:

If it said "God's salvation is a free gift received only by grace, only through faith in the Holy Spirit" would that imply that the Holy Spirit was a literal thing with existance in the material world? 'cause I don't think it would.

Yes, it would. Now you're getting it! :D
 
Care to name something that is purely altruistic in nature? No trap here, I'm just curious.

Giving to charity (one's that I've done a bit of research on, mind you). It's a reasonably rare occurance, but when I do there's no selfish motive behind it - I don't benefit personally from the act, nor do I achieve recognition.

And those who act selfishly but benefit others tend to receive high praise, or garner great prestige.

Yep. Someday, I hope to be one of them... :D
 
Human history is full of examples of selfish behaviour to the detriment of others. In fact, one could almost use that as a description of human history. Admittedly such behaviour becomes easier the less the connection with the people to whom suffering is caused.

I don't think that it's possible to objectively conclude that a strategy of selfishness - by which I mean not only acting for oneself, but with disregard for others - will automatically fail. There may be circumstances where altruism - or at least consideration - is a better strategy. There are other times when it isn't.

There's a good case for saying it's a good strategy for humanity as a whole, but even then it's not clear. Given two tribes competing for limited resources, it's usually a good for a single tribe to stick together. It might also be a good idea for them to eradicate the other tribe.

Certainly it might. And that would benefit not only you, but your society as well.

Of course, now we live in a more complex society, where it isn't just 'two tribes fighting over limited resources'. In many ways, we now live in a global society, and moreover we have (most of us) built up a moral system that frowns upon genocide.

I suppose my question is: What's your point? You're trying to prove that people who act selfishly and to the detriment of others can succeed - I've already pointed out that while they can occasionally, the odds are heavily against them. I have game theory and evidence on my side. What do you have on yours?
 
They use blood donation as an example of altruism... it can be painful and you are giving to a stranger. Non believers are over represented as blood donors. I think they are also over represented on the bone marrow registry compared with their numbers in the general population. That is also a painful procedure.

They may be over represented, however, because scientists are more aware of how these save lives and scientists are more likely to be non-believers than the general population.
 
Rescuing someone you didn't like and weren't related to from a burning building, knowing that you would die. I haven't done this myself, of course. If I did, I'd like to think it was for altruistic motives.

Forgive me RobRoy, for I have sinned. I have not done something quite so drastic as rescuing somene I don't like and aren't related to from a burning building, with knowledge that it would cause my death.

Really now, must an act be quite so drastic in order to classify as altruistic? Could you not consider simple actions instead?
 
I think there are many altruistic things we do every day without even really thinking about them.

Slowing down to let another car into your lane.

Seeing someone has unknowingly dropped something and bringing it back to them.

Holding the elevator for someone.

Giving money to a beggar.

Doing anything just to try to brighten someone's day.

Letting someone go ahead of you in a line just because you see they're in a hurry.

Seeing someone else have an accident and rushing over to help.
 
Perfect! :) Two points will clinch this argument for you:

1 - Provide the quote where the Reverend Cox says an individual can be a Christian and not believe in Jesus.
So if I put something in quote marks, somehow it's more believable? I referenced the book so you didn't have to rely on my report of what it says. Further, I don't own it, I checked out of the Library, so I can't look up quotes in it any easier than you can. If you really care, you can evaluate the evidence for yourself. If you don't, that's okay. :)

2 - Provide the quote where the Reverend Cox is speaking from an ecclesiastical standpoint for the beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole.
He isn't speaking for the beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole. No one does. That's the point. It's called a creedless church for a reason - they have no dogma or set of beliefs.
I will not only concede, I'll make good my promise to eat volatile's hat! :D

That's okay. I wouldn't want to deprive volatile of his hat. :)

Because they are answering the question of what gospel they believe. It's a pretty straight-forward question and answer.:cool:
Yes, it would. Now you're getting it! :D

Well, I think we've at least arrived at the crux of the disagreement we have. As I said, I don't interpret it that way. Once again, why is your interpretation to be preferred over that of the members and ministers of that church?
 
Forgive me RobRoy, for I have sinned. I have not done something quite so drastic as rescuing somene I don't like and aren't related to from a burning building, with knowledge that it would cause my death.

Really now, must an act be quite so drastic in order to classify as altruistic? Could you not consider simple actions instead?

It depends how you define "altruistic". If it just means acting for the benefit of other people, everyone who sells a second hand car is an altruist. If it means anything, it means acting for someone else's benefit, without gain to oneself.

So if you're acting based on game theory, or due to the fact that empathy makes you feel good, that's not altruism. That's acting for one's own benefit, with the side effect of benefitting someone else.

If we apply such criteria strictly, altruism becomes almost impossible.
 
Self-Interest. Today's God. Another concept that "explains" everything, but prohibits nothing. Have we learned nothing? :rolleyes:
 
It depends how you define "altruistic". If it just means acting for the benefit of other people, everyone who sells a second hand car is an altruist. If it means anything, it means acting for someone else's benefit, without gain to oneself.

Which is the definition I used. So, for example, my giving to charity is an example of an altruistic action.

So if you're acting based on game theory, or due to the fact that empathy makes you feel good, that's not altruism. That's acting for one's own benefit, with the side effect of benefitting someone else.

Bullcrap. All you're doing is defining altruism as impossible, by saying that if you perform an altruistic action and then have the gall to feel good because you did it, it ceases to be an altruistic action. That's complete and utter nonsense - an action does not cease to be altruistic just because a person feels good about doing it. 'Feeling good' is not a 'gain' in this sense of the word (you don't get extra resources because you 'feel good', you don't have a better chance of finding a mate because you 'feel good', and so on).

If we apply such criteria strictly, altruism becomes almost impossible.

Yeah, because you've tried to twist the meaning of words to fit your argument. All you've done is come up with a 'theory of altruism' that explains nothing, because you've defined altruism as impossible.

You can't commit the fallacy of equivocation and then pretend that your unfalsifiable hypothesis has won an argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom