westprog
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2006
- Messages
- 8,928
You are making the mistake of assuming that an act performed entirely for the good of oneself cannot also be good for society as a whole.
Much (but not all) of what I do is motivated by selfish desires - I freely admit to that. But I also try not to cause harm to society or those around me when I act. I try to choose actions that are beneficial for me, and also beneficial for those around me. Occasionally, I do things from which I gain no benefit, entirely for altruistic purposes - but that is the exception, not the rule.
In general, people who act selfishly to the detriment of others are penalised for doing so. Yes, some of them get away with it - but the odds are significantly against them.
Human history is full of examples of selfish behaviour to the detriment of others. In fact, one could almost use that as a description of human history. Admittedly such behaviour becomes easier the less the connection with the people to whom suffering is caused.
I don't think that it's possible to objectively conclude that a strategy of selfishness - by which I mean not only acting for oneself, but with disregard for others - will automatically fail. There may be circumstances where altruism - or at least consideration - is a better strategy. There are other times when it isn't.
There's a good case for saying it's a good strategy for humanity as a whole, but even then it's not clear. Given two tribes competing for limited resources, it's usually a good for a single tribe to stick together. It might also be a good idea for them to eradicate the other tribe.