Faith leads to evil.

Is there anything particularly good about faith? ....
.
I'm thinking there is. It gives many people guidelines for living that otherwise they may never develop on their own.
Just knowing what other people might expect of your behavior can civilize the spoiled-rottens to some extent.
Holding out the ultimate carrot of eternal life makes many people behave properly.
But faith when overemphasized leads to destructive behavior, singly and in groups.
I feel many of those suicide bombers would be normal people, if their faith hadn't subverted their reason, most commonly by suppressing any reason to question any of the commands either embedded in the doctrine, or promoted by the loonies leading the congregations and inducing these poor souls into monstrous acts, as acts of "faith".
 
.
I'm thinking there is. It gives many people guidelines for living that otherwise they may never develop on their own.
Just knowing what other people might expect of your behavior can civilize the spoiled-rottens to some extent.
Holding out the ultimate carrot of eternal life makes many people behave properly.

I know that's the thinking, but is there any evidence that it works? How do you explain Pedophiliac in the clergy... or this: http://moses.creighton.edu/JRS/2005/2005-11.html

There is evidence that within the U.S. strong disparities in religious belief versus acceptance of evolution are correlated with similarly varying rates of societal dysfunction, the strongly theistic, anti-evolution south and mid-west having markedly worse homicide, mortality, STD, youth pregnancy, marital and related problems than the northeast where societal conditions, secularization, and acceptance of evolution approach European norms (Aral and Holmes; Beeghley, Doyle, 2002).

Are we to assume these folks would be WORSE without religion. Where is the evidence that this works for anything or in any measurable way in regards to benefiting society or morality.

I know the idea behind the thinking that it does, but I'm beginning to think it's a huge lie since it's lots of talk, but no data at all. What would we expect to see differently or better in the faithful than in non-believers... what could we measure? Atheists are under represented in prisons and have lower than average divorce rates. So where the hell is the evidence that religion "works" as implied?
 
And Sylvia Browne.

But the vast majority of gods, leaders, gurus, priest, prophets and those claiming revelation are folks with a Y chromosome.
.
Pastor Melissa Scott, widow of Dr. Gene Scott.. She's quite a babe!
Same apparent mental problems as her hubby, but nice eye candy.
A diversion at oh-two-early when it's difficult to get back to sleep.
 
If you subscribe to a relative, evolving version of ethics, which is based on consensus, it's difficult to see how you can unequivocally call something "evil". If you subscribe to a purely scientific and reason based universe, how can you objectively say that certain acts are ethically wrong?

You don't. You subjectively say that certain acts are ethically wrong.
 
I can see why a selfish person would want to live in a society where people band together in communities and act for each other. However, he might well decide that his own well being is best served by making use of such a society for his own ends.

Then he would have a very poor understanding of game theory, and indeed life in general.
 
...some people label me 'Atheist' as I lack a belief in any god, and I'm not comfortable with that label either.

Did you know that some people have the audacity to label me white just because I'm a caucasian, with Germanic and British heritage back a number of generations? Honestly, I'm just not comfortable being called 'white'.

None whatsoever :) Do you have any evidence to assume the opposite? That something as large, complex and constantly evolving as the entire universe is as wholely unaware unthinking and unfeeling as the diamond in my wedding ring, an unchanging crystalline lattice of pure carbon atoms? I have no evidence whatsoever to justify making that assumption either.

:rolleyes: Still haven't read about 'burden of proof', have we?
 
Then he would have a very poor understanding of game theory, and indeed life in general.


Most primates have social groups without religion. Lemurs are female centered and they protect the group as a team from marauding young males trying to get lucky and stir things up.

No religion though. Even bees have a highly organized social system. Bees who make trouble from getting drunk of fermented nectar are controlled by "bouncer" bees.

When you genes survive better through cooperation, the genes that encourage cooperation get passed on preferentially. Ants have been doing this (and leaf cutter ants have been engaging in agriculture) for over 50 million years. Gods are a fairly recent invention.

As for your comment that you don't like being called white. When my son was young, he had no idea what was meant by "black" and "white" people... he thought it must have something to do with their clothing. He considered himself a "tan" person... or a person with tan skin... and in his world everyone had a variation from tan to brown... I remember him being very confused in his Los Angeles first grade class learning about Martin Luther King and "black rights". His best friend had a Russian mother and a Nigerian father, and he didn't understand the dividing labels people had.

To me, Beth would be an atheist if she truly lacked a belief in gods... as would anyone who lacked a belief in gods... just as those who lack a sex drive or reproduce by cloning are "asexual"... just as the universe is "amoral"... I think Beth fears being labeled an atheist because of her own prejudices against the term... but I also think she's not an atheist... more of a deist with new agey god vapidity that makes her feel good but sound vague. She feels good or saved or special for believing in whatever vague something she believes in and she feels more "moral" or "less strident" than those who aren't afraid to call themselves atheists.

The notion that "faith is good" relies on the belief that lacking it is "bad"... and boy are those I term the "apologists" good at spinning this semantic nothingness.
 
Last edited:
Then he would have a very poor understanding of game theory, and indeed life in general.

Cheats never prosper? Not my experience. I don't see it as particularly difficult to do well in a society by acting for one's own good instead of the good of everyone else.
 
Interesting article in Science Daily today:

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/05/080501163455.htm

Selfishness May Be Altruism's Unexpected Ally

ScienceDaily (May 2, 2008) — Just as religions dwell upon the eternal battle between good and evil, angels and devils, evolutionary theorists dwell upon the eternal battle between altruistic and selfish behaviors in the Darwinian struggle for existence. In a new study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), evolutionary theorists at Binghamton University suggest that selfishness might not be such a villain after all.
 
Oh, I believe you. ;) But you're confusing individual belief and the stated beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole. My citations support that. You've offered nothing that discounts them.
I don't discount them. I'm telling you that you are interpreting them differently than members of the church do. You are assuming a literal interpretation is implicit in the statement quoted. I'm telling you it's not.
 
Why is it so hard for you to grasp that the universe doesn't care whether you live or die? Only people do.


As far as the universe is concerned, all life forms, energy and matter have equal value. All life forms work and struggle to stay alive and reproduce, and whether you survive or the human papilloma virus survives is inconsequential. Whether you live to a ripe old age or get wiped out in a monsoon doesn't matter even the tiniest bit to the universe.

Just don't say that the universe is indifferent.

It only matters to people.

We call people that kill other people evil. We even call tornadoes, droughts, floods or inanimate objects evil when they kill people or do other things we don't like. "Evil" is a completely human construct.

Aren't people just another part of the universe? All they are is a different assemblage of atoms. There's no difference between a flood and a psychopath as far as the universe is concerned. If we call people "evil" we just mean that they are acting in a way that we don't want.
 
I don't discount them. I'm telling you that you are interpreting them differently than members of the church do. You are assuming a literal interpretation is implicit in the statement quoted. I'm telling you it's not.

I'm not assuming. I provided proof. That proof says you're wrong.

Where's your proof showing you're right? :D

Did you know that some people have the audacity to label me white just because I'm a caucasian, with Germanic and British heritage back a number of generations? Honestly, I'm just not comfortable being called 'white'.

Those fiends! Who are they? I will hunt them down and give them a stern talking to! :D
 
Last edited:
Another interesting one from a couple of days ago that kind of relates:

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/04/080428094212.htm
Decision Making: Is It All 'Me, Me, Me'?

ScienceDaily (Apr. 29, 2008) — People act in their own best interests, according to traditional views of how and why we make the decisions that we do. However, psychologists at the Universities of Leicester and Exeter have recently found evidence that this assumption is not necessarily true. In fact the research, funded by the Economic and Social Research Council, shows that most of us will act in the best interest of our team -- often at our own expense.
 
I would be very surprised to find that altruistic behaviour was the only thing that worked for human beings. There are too many examples of non-altruistic successes out there.

Too many nothing. Almost all examples of success are from primarily selfish (i.e. non-altruistic) behaviors. You'd be hard pressed to name more than a handful of truly altruistic behaviors. Even in the offered article, the heart of their termed "altruistic behavior" is still survival for the individual and out-competing. In a term, a selfish goal.
 
Cheats never prosper? Not my experience. I don't see it as particularly difficult to do well in a society by acting for one's own good instead of the good of everyone else.

You are making the mistake of assuming that an act performed entirely for the good of oneself cannot also be good for society as a whole.

Much (but not all) of what I do is motivated by selfish desires - I freely admit to that. But I also try not to cause harm to society or those around me when I act. I try to choose actions that are beneficial for me, and also beneficial for those around me. Occasionally, I do things from which I gain no benefit, entirely for altruistic purposes - but that is the exception, not the rule.

In general, people who act selfishly to the detriment of others are penalised for doing so. Yes, some of them get away with it - but the odds are significantly against them.
 
Much (but not all) of what I do is motivated by selfish desires - I freely admit to that. But I also try not to cause harm to society or those around me when I act. I try to choose actions that are beneficial for me, and also beneficial for those around me. Occasionally, I do things from which I gain no benefit, entirely for altruistic purposes - but that is the exception, not the rule.

Care to name something that is purely altruistic in nature? No trap here, I'm just curious.

In general, people who act selfishly to the detriment of others are penalised for doing so. Yes, some of them get away with it - but the odds are significantly against them.

And those who act selfishly but benefit others tend to receive high praise, or garner great prestige.
 
I'm not assuming. I provided proof. That proof says you're wrong.

Where's your proof showing you're right? :D
You didn't provide proof, but evidence. And the evidence you provided can be interpreted more than one way. I'm pointing out your interpretation is at odds with the interpretation of members of that church. Which one is more likely to be a correct assessment of the beliefs of that church?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom