First westprog wrote:
The next question is - does it matter, objectively, what happens to other people, or are we simply gratifying our feelings of empathy? If we are gratifying our feelings, or trying to create a society in which we will be happy, then our actions and morals are aimed only at our own good, and are hence no different from the posited entirely selfish person, who lacks such empathy.
Then I wrote some stuff about how the universe doesn't care..
And Tailgater responded:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think he gets that. The question is why does it matter to people. Why do we care? Is it selfish reasons? I tried to touch on this earlier in the thread somewhat about most "evil" not really being derived from religion, but religion is just another tool to help or hurt others with. A world without religion is just a world where people are more honest about why they commit "evil" acts against each other.
This is seperate from just plain silly OCD practices.
Ok, looking back, I suppose you're right. He probably is asking
why does it matter to us?
I guess my answer has two levels. On the first level, it matters to us because we want to live. Physically, every cell in our bodies, every drop of hormones coursing through our veins, every bit of code in our DNA is pushing us to survive and reproduce. We started developing moral and ethical systems to help us survive, and we still use them for that. Is this selfish? Yes. But I think it's important in this case, to divorce the word "selfish" from the bad connotation we usually give it. I mean, are goats selfish because they naturally form herds? Are ants selfish for living in colonies? Are geese selfish for joining up in flocks? There is no "good" or "bad" about this. It just is what it is.
It matters to us on another level because we want to do more than just live. While we may have originally grouped together as a survival strategy, what we've evolved our society into allows us to do so much more. Because of our complex sociological associations, we've created an environment where people have a lot more time to think. And as a result, we can study our universe and attempt to solve its riddles. We can fly in the air, we can delve deep into the sea. We can shoot ourselves into space, and visit the moon. Soon we'll even visit Mars. Someday, perhaps, we'll have human colonies on many planets all over the universe. We make art. We make music. We continuously astound each other with our own complexity and constantly changing beauty.
All of this depends, though, on our ability to not destroy our planet, and to not destroy each other to the point that we end up just going back to survival mode, or just completely wipe ourselves out.
So getting back to the original question, I think that when you are positing "what's the difference" between those people that choose empathy and happiness vs those self centered persons that just take what they want, when we're talking about just the first level, there isn't really much difference. Both are survival mechanisms. However, the group of multiple people is probably better able to defend themselves against the one selfish intruder. The bigger the group, the more powerful the defense.
On the second level, it is only the group that can come together that can do more, build more, be more. One person alone can never build a spaceship. If he wants to, the first thing he will figure out is that he's going to have to find a way to get other people to cooperate. And that goes right back to figuring out how to get people to live and work together, and creating a moral system that works.