Faith leads to evil.

Why is it hard to realize that you are making an assumption with this statement? Whether the universe cares about us or not, any response to that question other than 'I don't know how to tell the difference' requires us to make assumptions about the answer. I think it's actually a good way to make the distinction between atheists, agnostics and deists of any sort. Atheists and deists both think they know the "Truth" about the answer. Agnostics cannot fathom the certainty of either group.

Thanks meg. Your response led me to that insight that I think may be a good one in terms of how I at least, decide how to label other people.

But as an agnostic (which will be argued as atheist in this forum), I can still agree with her statement to a degree of probability. Putting the rest of her post in context of that sentence, it is likely that a tornado does not "care" what happens to us even though I can't fathom whether it does or not. I only hold the possibility that anything is possible, but that god being a truth in our form (or any explanation for existence) is like playing the lottery with infinite numbers.
 
Why is it hard to realize that you are making an assumption with this statement? Whether the universe cares about us or not, any response to that question other than 'I don't know how to tell the difference' requires us to make assumptions about the answer. I think it's actually a good way to make the distinction between atheists, agnostics and deists of any sort. Atheists and deists both think they know the "Truth" about the answer. Agnostics cannot fathom the certainty of either group.

Thanks meg. Your response led me to that insight that I think may be a good one in terms of how I at least, decide how to label other people.

Your welcome, I guess :)

Perhaps I am being extremely bullheaded here, but I am having a very hard time figuring out whether I've made an unreasonable assumption in assuming the universe doesn't care whether I or you live or die. How do you figure?

Do you have any evidence in any form that might lead one to think that the universe has emotions or that it shows a preference to certain life forms over others, or that it even prefers life forms over non living things?
 
Your welcome, I guess :)

Perhaps I am being extremely bullheaded here, but I am having a very hard time figuring out whether I've made an unreasonable assumption in assuming the universe doesn't care whether I or you live or die. How do you figure?

Do you have any evidence in any form that might lead one to think that the universe has emotions or that it shows a preference to certain life forms over others, or that it even prefers life forms over non living things?

From here, it looks like you are talking about the material universe and she is assuming you are equating that universe with a diety. Just my .02.
 
Last edited:
Ummm, do you see your contradiction here. You say there’s no requirement, and then list the requirements. These are, by the way, the exact same requirements of belief that I stated.

I don’t know that there’s any convincing you, since you’re posting contradictions, but I’m still game to try.



Sorry this is just another plain contradiction of your previous statements, as well as the sites that I pulled direct quotations from. Or are you stating that those sites are wrong in what the Congregational church believes?. I’m guessing you don’t really know what your church’s beliefs are. No immediately fault there, but it would worry me to claim to be part of any organization that I wasn’t wholly cognizant of their fundamental values. It’s like belonging to the KKK but thinking they’re just a social club who don’t really believe in racial superiority!
LOL. I understand that you find it hard to believe. I guess you can assume I'm mistaken or lying. I had a hard time believing they were sincere about it too. But I've asked the question to 3 different ministers of that church starting with the first minister who wrote the book I referenced earlier. Then the interim minister. Then the current one who is the permanent replacement for the first. They all gave the same answer. No problem. Everyone is free to interpret the scripture as they wish. I feel that one can believe in the essential truths of the bible just as one can believe in the essential truths of "Star Wars" without believing either is literally true. If that is how I wish to interpret it, that is fine and I am given to understand I am not alone.


Nopers, I just think you don't understand what your own church professes as it's beliefs.

Welcome does not mean member. I'm welcome in my wife's LDS church, with quite open arms (as befits a fundamentalist missionary driven faith). But my presence as a non-believer in their faith doesn't change the facts of the LDS church's beliefs. I would never make the claim that because I sit in a pew that the LDS church doesn't require members to believe in the literal Jesus because that would be a patently false lie.

Nopers, I attended a 3 week long introductory class designed to teach new members about the history of the church and what beliefs they adhered to. Belief in the central message of the Bible, which they express succintly as "Love Everybody, Judge Nobody" is pretty much it. There is a more formal statement which is similar to what you've quoted above, though not quite identical. They've made it clear to me that the four word motto quoted above can be considered the central thesis of the church. It's a sentiment I'm quite comfortable with elevating to a position of central importance in my value system.

There are no requirements for tithing, attendance, or anything like that. I just to had to sign a statement indicating my desire to become a member. Then I was.

If you don't believe me, okay. I can't prove it over the internet. But I hope you'll at least have less confidence in those sweeping generatizations of christians that are so common around this forum.
 
religion is just another tool to help or hurt others with.
I quite agree with this.
A world without religion is just a world where people are more honest about why they commit "evil" acts against each other. .:D

Why would you think this? Does the lack of availablity of one type of tool imply that no other will do?
 
Your welcome, I guess :)

Perhaps I am being extremely bullheaded here, but I am having a very hard time figuring out whether I've made an unreasonable assumption in assuming the universe doesn't care whether I or you live or die. How do you figure?

Do you have any evidence in any form that might lead one to think that the universe has emotions or that it shows a preference to certain life forms over others, or that it even prefers life forms over non living things?

None whatsoever :) Do you have any evidence to assume the opposite? That something as large, complex and constantly evolving as the entire universe is as wholely unaware unthinking and unfeeling as the diamond in my wedding ring, an unchanging crystalline lattice of pure carbon atoms? I have no evidence whatsoever to justify making that assumption either. That's why I'm agnostic.
 
From here, it looks like you are talking about the material universe and she is assuming you are equating that universe with a diety. Just my .02.

Close. I'm not assuming that meg is equating the universe to a diety. I'm making that argument. Many people essentially do equate the universe with their belief in a deity. I have no compelling rational argument as to why they must be wrong.
 
First westprog wrote:
The next question is - does it matter, objectively, what happens to other people, or are we simply gratifying our feelings of empathy? If we are gratifying our feelings, or trying to create a society in which we will be happy, then our actions and morals are aimed only at our own good, and are hence no different from the posited entirely selfish person, who lacks such empathy.

Then I wrote some stuff about how the universe doesn't care..

And Tailgater responded:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think he gets that. The question is why does it matter to people. Why do we care? Is it selfish reasons? I tried to touch on this earlier in the thread somewhat about most "evil" not really being derived from religion, but religion is just another tool to help or hurt others with. A world without religion is just a world where people are more honest about why they commit "evil" acts against each other.

This is seperate from just plain silly OCD practices.:D

Ok, looking back, I suppose you're right. He probably is asking why does it matter to us?


I guess my answer has two levels. On the first level, it matters to us because we want to live. Physically, every cell in our bodies, every drop of hormones coursing through our veins, every bit of code in our DNA is pushing us to survive and reproduce. We started developing moral and ethical systems to help us survive, and we still use them for that. Is this selfish? Yes. But I think it's important in this case, to divorce the word "selfish" from the bad connotation we usually give it. I mean, are goats selfish because they naturally form herds? Are ants selfish for living in colonies? Are geese selfish for joining up in flocks? There is no "good" or "bad" about this. It just is what it is.


It matters to us on another level because we want to do more than just live. While we may have originally grouped together as a survival strategy, what we've evolved our society into allows us to do so much more. Because of our complex sociological associations, we've created an environment where people have a lot more time to think. And as a result, we can study our universe and attempt to solve its riddles. We can fly in the air, we can delve deep into the sea. We can shoot ourselves into space, and visit the moon. Soon we'll even visit Mars. Someday, perhaps, we'll have human colonies on many planets all over the universe. We make art. We make music. We continuously astound each other with our own complexity and constantly changing beauty.

All of this depends, though, on our ability to not destroy our planet, and to not destroy each other to the point that we end up just going back to survival mode, or just completely wipe ourselves out.

So getting back to the original question, I think that when you are positing "what's the difference" between those people that choose empathy and happiness vs those self centered persons that just take what they want, when we're talking about just the first level, there isn't really much difference. Both are survival mechanisms. However, the group of multiple people is probably better able to defend themselves against the one selfish intruder. The bigger the group, the more powerful the defense.

On the second level, it is only the group that can come together that can do more, build more, be more. One person alone can never build a spaceship. If he wants to, the first thing he will figure out is that he's going to have to find a way to get other people to cooperate. And that goes right back to figuring out how to get people to live and work together, and creating a moral system that works.
 
If you don't believe me, okay. I can't prove it over the internet. But I hope you'll at least have less confidence in those sweeping generatizations of christians that are so common around this forum.

Oh, I believe you. ;) But you're confusing individual belief and the stated beliefs of the Congregational church as a whole. My citations support that. You've offered nothing that discounts them.

Thus, volatile is quite correct in his assessment that there isn't a single Christian church that doesn't hold some part of the Bible literally true. Members, stated members, individual interpreters, etc. have no bearing on that.
 
None whatsoever :) Do you have any evidence to assume the opposite? That something as large, complex and constantly evolving as the entire universe is as wholely unaware unthinking and unfeeling as the diamond in my wedding ring, an unchanging crystalline lattice of pure carbon atoms? I have no evidence whatsoever to justify making that assumption either. That's why I'm agnostic.

Hi Beth,

Here are a few things that lead me to some assumptions:

1. Most of the universe that we know about is inhospitable to human life.

2. Most of our own planet is inhospitable to human life.

3. The places on the planet that are hospitable to human life are also filled with creatures that would like to eat us, infect us, parasitize us, use us as a host for their offspring, or eat up our food. Every other species on the planet has the same problem.

4. The places on the planet that are hospitable to human life also regularly cycle through heat waves, freezes, storms, floods, droughts and other natural events that kill many of us every year.

5. Every human dies.


Looking at these, I think either

The universe is emotionless.

OR

The universe doesn't have any particular emotions about us.

OR

The universe does have emotions, and it really doesn't like us.


I tend to think it's the first one.
 
Is there anything particularly good about faith? I'm talking about faith in general-- so it would have to include all faiths... Muslims, Moonies, Christians, Scientologists, New Age believers, Jews-- anything that appeals to the supernatural and gets tax breaks allotted to religions... ?

What is it good for? Is there any evidence that it's good for anything other than manipulating people. I think it's sick to tell people that they need to believe a certain way to avoid hell or earn heaven. I guess it can make some people feel good or righteous... but is there any evidence that it's good for anything... or that it's potential benefits outweigh it's potential harms?

What wouldn't you do if you truly believed your eternity and/or the eternity of someone you loved was at stake? That's the mind set of the extremely faithful right-- the ones who pray until their kid dies when medicine could have saved them; the hijackers; Phelps; martyrs, Andrea Yates.

And if faith is good, how do you prove you have it-- except by doing something you wouldn't do normally to prove you have faith in the invisible guy who commands it.

Even when it's not evil, is it good to encourage it or give it special status as though it is ennobling. Has it ever lead to true or useful knowledge. Is there any proven efficacy of faith as a means of making people behave more morally--and if so, it what way?

I just don't see the benefits and I think the risks are clear-- stupidity and brain washing and arrogance coupled with ignorance and fear and delusional ideas of being "in on" divine secretes or "saved" for "believing" the right unbelievable story.

Is there any reason not to treat it like other woo (other than the kicking and screaming fo theists and apologists, I mean)
 
Last edited:
Yes. If you're the authority that people have faith in, you have obedient slaves that don't need any other motivation to do your bidding.

It seems that pretty much only works for guys... (claiming to be a prophet, guru, "dear leader" and such)

On the other hand, that makes the guys who reveal faith for the BS that it is all the more admirable, don't you think?

That's why I like Randi.

Skepticism leads to good.
 
Last edited:
Is there anything particularly good about faith?


This might do better as a new thread, but off the top...

I dated a girl who was catholic and accompanied her to mass on a couple of occasions. The church itself displayed some beautiful architecture and they had one of the most interesting drinking fountains in the back; really clean water but no spout (made drinking from it a bit awkward). :p

...one other possibility: an option for those who choose it in a free country like the USA.
 
Last edited:
Is there anything particularly good about faith?

What is it good for? Is there any evidence that it's good for anything other than manipulating people. I think it's sick to tell people that they need to believe a certain way to avoid hell or earn heaven. I guess it can make some people feel good or righteous... but is there any evidence that it's good for anything... or that it's potential benefits outweigh it's potential harms?

This may be two different questions--weighing the value of it for individuals vs. society.

Just from my experiences with some theists in Virginia, I'd say the "good" it does for them is giving them a contentment of purpose. Basically an adult blankie for their beliefs. It lets them get on with everyday life without having to commit time or effort to criticizing their values. Good for them, and as they were raised to hold these beliefs, it doesn't generally cause troublesome conflicts within them.

This is just how it is, and whether their faith is in something real or not seems irrelevant (when the topic is the good of the individual). Replace "faith" with "schizophrenia" or "egoism" and a typical Christian with Charles Manson, and both could do good for the individual in giving him a plausible and comforting basis for his actions, even if according to society both lead to very evil things.

For social effect, take single moral metric A, and measure how closely the faithful get to A. If the faithful's output gets close to A (or perhaps at least 51% of A), then it may be good for society as well. If they veer more towards not-A, then it's evil/bad for society. The variable here would be who makes the definition of A. In our society the faithful define this so it's a bit hard to tell if A is actually a credible goal for a moral (or legal) metric.

What wouldn't you do if you truly believed your eternity and/or the eternity of someone you loved was at stake? That's the mind set of the extremely faithful right-- the ones who pray until their kid dies when medicine could have saved them; the hijackers; Phelps; martyrs, Andrea Yates.

And if faith is good, how do you prove you have it-- except by doing something you wouldn't do normally to prove you have faith in the invisible guy who commands it.

Probably just the ostentatious demonstrations, the prayer meetings, eating that wafer at communion, wearing a cross, as long as they believe it's a substantive action. Of course to the theists they have important reasons for being truly faithful, if they believe it & lack of sin will get them into heaven. I don't doubt many of them truly believe their prayers will lead to something good, and truly think that when it doesn't it was just "God's will".

As for doing something you normally wouldn't do, an example may be a spouse who is about to commit adultery but stops due to whatever doctrines their faith enforce on them. That doesn't mean faith is good, it's still neutral--the reason he didn't do it could as easily be due to a system based on rationality, or nihilism, or whatever else he's basing his actions on.

ETA: Original post changed while I was typing. Want to respond to:

Is there any reason not to treat it like other woo (other than the kicking and screaming fo theists and apologists, I mean)

No reason not to treat it as any other woo. But no reason to deny that it can lead to a good outcome for either the individual believing in it or the society. Same as other placebo effects, this one effecting morality.

editing thing keeps jumping to top of this post so may have repeated something.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom