Faith leads to evil.

I’ll make this very, very simple for you: show me one Christian denomination that doesn’t believe Jesus was a historical figure and I’ll eat volatile’s hat for him.

One thing that occurs to me that we may be miscommunicating. The congregationalist church I attend does not require members to believe that Jesus was an actual historical figure. That doesn't mean that many, perhaps most of the individual members don't feel that way. It means that the Church has no prescribed doctrine on the matter. They have no prescribed doctrine at all. It is up to each church to decide how they, as a congregation, choose to interpret and implement the teachings of Jesus found in the Bible. It is up to each individual to decide the same things for themselves and join (or not) a church that fits with thier beliefs. In the congregation of the church I attend, agnostics such as myself and even hard line atheists are welcome. More than that, it's not just words, I was made to feel very welcome by everyone I discussed the matter with who was a member.

I understand that some people feel I am not a 'True Christian Scotsman' for that reason. That's okay. I'm not entirely comfortable with label Christian myself as I've only recently joined. But some people label me 'Atheist' as I lack a belief in any god, and I'm not comfortable with that label either. Agnostic remains my primary self-identification on the matter.

At any rate, I'm liking it which surprises me greatly as Church was the bane of my existance as a child, consisting as it did of the two most boring hours of the week. But for much the same reasons D.R. outlined earlier in this thread, I feel my life is improved by attending and trying to become a better, more tolerant and less judgmental person.
 
Last edited:
If you subscribe to a relative, evolving version of ethics, which is based on consensus, it's difficult to see how you can unequivocally call something "evil". If you subscribe to a purely scientific and reason based universe, how can you objectively say that certain acts are ethically wrong?

It's possible to select an ethical system that works best for you. It's possible to have a consensus that it's pragmatically better insofar as it's in line with people's wishes. I don't see how you can derive, from that, the existence of evil in any sense.

Why is it so hard for you to grasp that the universe doesn't care whether you live or die? Only people do.


As far as the universe is concerned, all life forms, energy and matter have equal value. All life forms work and struggle to stay alive and reproduce, and whether you survive or the human papilloma virus survives is inconsequential. Whether you live to a ripe old age or get wiped out in a monsoon doesn't matter even the tiniest bit to the universe.

It only matters to people.

We call people that kill other people evil. We even call tornadoes, droughts, floods or inanimate objects evil when they kill people or do other things we don't like. "Evil" is a completely human construct.
 
Last edited:
If you subscribe to a relative, evolving version of ethics, which is based on consensus, it's difficult to see how you can unequivocally call something "evil". If you subscribe to a purely scientific and reason based universe, how can you objectively say that certain acts are ethically wrong?

It's possible to select an ethical system that works best for you. It's possible to have a consensus that it's pragmatically better insofar as it's in line with people's wishes. I don't see how you can derive, from that, the existence of evil in any sense.

How is that any different than a church changing its policies (evolving) on what is or isn't a sin to adapt to modern thinking?

I'm pretty sure that the "faith leads to evil" statement is meant on a purely scientific level. I think I understand what you are saying in that if there is no god there can be no evil, but that is evil purely from a religious standpoint.

As far as diving in to what is evil in general, it is basically a consensus in each subgroup of atheist and theist with overlapping agreements. I would suspect that everyone here would say that first degree murder is an evil act, but not everyone here might agree why it is evil. I don't think that it is evil because it is a commandment, but because I wouldn't want to be murdered or have a loved one murdered. IMO, this is why most athiest have a problem with the commandments used in the governement. It's not that we disagree with thou shalt not ____, it's that those things should be respected out of common sense and not because a higher authority has to tell us to do so. I expect my kids to know how to behave in public because they have ethics and not because they are afraid of what I will do to them.
 
Through reason. After learning, thinking, and studying different sociological systems, as well as historic societies and cultures, it is my somewhat educated opinion that not only are more egalitarian societies more successful and likely to thrive, but those societies also achieve a higher "quality" of life for more of its citizens. More citizens are capable of doing more than just scraping out a living, and are able to enjoy such pursuits as the development of art, music, and higher learning.




With reason. Even the most persistant selfish bully can understand that in a society where people just kill and take whatever they want, that the likelihood of him or his children getting killed is much higher than in a more peaceful society. Even an idiot can comprehend that no matter how strong you may be now, sooner or later someone stronger will come along. And most people can understand that if a great deal of your time and energy is spent just having to defend your own life and property, that less of your life is left to spend on more enjoyable pursuits.


It's all about rules of the game for living together. We discovered long ago that we live longer, and we live better when we band together as communities vs each individual fending for himself. All our morals and all our philosophies revolve around this concept; they are all attempts to define what makes a community, how our community interacts with the world, and what the roles we each play in it are.

I can see why a selfish person would want to live in a society where people band together in communities and act for each other. However, he might well decide that his own well being is best served by making use of such a society for his own ends.
 
Why is it so hard for you to grasp that the universe doesn't care whether you live or die? Only people do.


As far as the universe is concerned, all life forms, energy and matter have equal value. All life forms work and struggle to stay alive and reproduce, and whether you survive or the human papilloma virus survives is inconsequential. Whether you live to a ripe old age or get wiped out in a monsoon doesn't matter even the tiniest bit to the universe.

It only matters to people.

We call people that kill other people evil. We even call tornadoes, droughts, floods or inanimate objects evil when they kill people or do other things we don't like. "Evil" is a completely human construct.
.
I recall a prominent firearms person mentioning the "evil crocodiles" he'd encountered in Africa. Someone pointed out to him that crocs aren't evil, they're just repugnant. To people.
Only people are truly evil.
 
If it's subjective, then it's just a matter of whatever any individual chooses to describe as evil. There are plenty of people who describe gay marriage as evil, or pornography, or eating meat. Many people who believe these things don't have a religious belief. They seem to follow different principles to decide on a personal basis what evil means.

That's why in a secular society, we can sort those things out. Usually, the most evil things float to the top of the list. As in my last post, atheists and theists have overlapping agreement on what is or is not evil, but based on different reasons.
 
I can see why a selfish person would want to live in a society where people band together in communities and act for each other. However, he might well decide that his own well being is best served by making use of such a society for his own ends.
.
We do.
We pay taxes for the cops to keep the scum in the sewers.
The firemen to keep our houses smoke free.
Traffic planners to make roads that get us to the Mall to Starbucks.
It's in our own self-interest, to find like-minded folks who see the benefits to being community conscious while being selfish.
 
I can see why a selfish person would want to live in a society where people band together in communities and act for each other. However, he might well decide that his own well being is best served by making use of such a society for his own ends.

Well, he does. He has. People do.

That's why we create guidelines, rules, laws and punishments, and why we come up with ideas like "checks and balances" in our governments. And why sometimes countries decide to go to war and remove other countries' leaders.
 
How is that any different than a church changing its policies (evolving) on what is or isn't a sin to adapt to modern thinking?

I'm pretty sure that the "faith leads to evil" statement is meant on a purely scientific level. I think I understand what you are saying in that if there is no god there can be no evil, but that is evil purely from a religious standpoint.

I'm not actually saying that the existence of evil requires God to exist - but if it is to be treated as something real - rather than just an individual's preference - then I don't see that as being compatible with a purely materialistic universe - where such a universe is one governed solely by the laws of science.

As far as diving in to what is evil in general, it is basically a consensus in each subgroup of atheist and theist with overlapping agreements. I would suspect that everyone here would say that first degree murder is an evil act, but not everyone here might agree why it is evil. I don't think that it is evil because it is a commandment, but because I wouldn't want to be murdered or have a loved one murdered. IMO, this is why most athiest have a problem with the commandments used in the governement. It's not that we disagree with thou shalt not ____, it's that those things should be respected out of common sense and not because a higher authority has to tell us to do so. I expect my kids to know how to behave in public because they have ethics and not because they are afraid of what I will do to them.

I think the argument by empathy is the most convincing. We don't want bad things to happen to other people because we wouldn't want them to happen to us.

The next question is - does it matter, objectively, what happens to other people, or are we simply gratifying our feelings of empathy? If we are gratifying our feelings, or trying to create a society in which we will be happy, then our actions and morals are aimed only at our own good, and are hence no different from the posited entirely selfish person, who lacks such empathy.
 
.
I recall a prominent firearms person mentioning the "evil crocodiles" he'd encountered in Africa. Someone pointed out to him that crocs aren't evil, they're just repugnant. To people.
Only people are truly evil.

And my neighbor's cat. I know he's planning something as he stares through my window.
 
The next question is - does it matter, objectively, what happens to other people, or are we simply gratifying our feelings of empathy? If we are gratifying our feelings, or trying to create a society in which we will be happy, then our actions and morals are aimed only at our own good, and are hence no different from the posited entirely selfish person, who lacks such empathy.

That's a question that deserves an "ogres are like onions" answer. I actually typed out a post and deleted it for further thought.
 
The next question is - does it matter, objectively, what happens to other people, or are we simply gratifying our feelings of empathy? If we are gratifying our feelings, or trying to create a society in which we will be happy, then our actions and morals are aimed only at our own good, and are hence no different from the posited entirely selfish person, who lacks such empathy.

I believe I answered this above in post #282, but I will expound a little.

Does it matter to the universe what happens to people? No. The wind will still blow, the stars will still shine, the planets will still orbit their stars, microbes and bacteria and worms will eat our bodies and break down our chemical compounds to be recycled into other life forms.

Does it matter to people what happens to people? Of course. It is profoundly important to us all.
 
Sorry, I misunderstood what you were saying as a dodge rather than a concession. My bad! Sorry again for that.

No worries. I’m sure you’re not used to concessions in these kinds of arguments. ;)

I suppose it could be used as a counter argument, but it's a pretty weak one. It's an argument that the apparent contradiction between the common interpretation of Jesus' words and his new laws only exists because he didn't specifically restate every one of the old laws; whereas I would suggest there is a strong inference between his partial restating of the laws and the idea that the laws have therefore not been struck out.

If it’s a contradiction of common interpretation, then obviously I’ll have to withdraw it and with it concede the point. There’s no other recourse for this argument except to fall back on the author’s motive, which is tricky at best, as we’ve seen above, and not something I’d be inclined to do. The Christian church has accepted these words as scripture, as the literal words of Jesus, and thus to be followed. Author’s intent is a second-place argument at this point.

In other words, it is entirely possible for a slave owner to be a Christian - and if a slave has a Christian master, they are commanded to, "...not despise [him]..." It is that passage, more than 6:1, that I believe constitutes approval of slavery.

Agreed that a slave owner could be a Christian (and I wasn’t trying to dodge that, I was trying to take the whole thing in context of my comments), but I’m not certain we can make the leap to approval for slavery. It identifies slavery as an institution, which it certainly was, and an institution no one could really think would go away, but we still see the message aimed at everyone, not just the elite. Not groundbreaking, and not a condemnation, but certainly a step in the right direction, and one we can see that grew into a cultural condemnation from the Christian church.

We are then, as I like to put it, violently in agreement. ;)

I’ve always liked that term. ;)

I wouldn't go that far - I agree with him that other people were misreading parts of the scripture earlier on, even though I disagree (or disagreed, as there are a few points he seems to concede) with him on a number of other points.

I wouldn't tar him with the same brush as some of the other posters here - he seems quite reasonable and willing to have an honest discussion. A 'Darth Rotor' kind of person (if I had to make a comparison), rather than a...well, y'know.

Kind thanks, sir. I’ll gladly take that as a compliment. :D

There's no requirement that members believe as you are claiming they must. Christ centered - yes. Believe in the Bible - yes. Neither of those imply a literal interpretation is necessary.

Ummm, do you see your contradiction here. You say there’s no requirement, and then list the requirements. These are, by the way, the exact same requirements of belief that I stated.

I don’t know that there’s any convincing you, since you’re posting contradictions, but I’m still game to try.

The church can center itself around the teachings of Jesus as given in the bible without requiring literal belief in either.

Sorry this is just another plain contradiction of your previous statements, as well as the sites that I pulled direct quotations from. Or are you stating that those sites are wrong in what the Congregational church believes?. I’m guessing you don’t really know what your church’s beliefs are. No immediately fault there, but it would worry me to claim to be part of any organization that I wasn’t wholly cognizant of their fundamental values. It’s like belonging to the KKK but thinking they’re just a social club who don’t really believe in racial superiority!

westprog said:
Perhaps I wasn't clear. When I said that the message was hard to follow, I didn't mean it was hard to understand. I meant it was difficult to do.

I didn’t mean it was hard to understand either. I disagreed with exactly what you’re saying. What’s so hard about “do unto others”? Seems pretty straight-forward to me in both message and practice. The other messages may be tricky to decipher, but the core is right there.

I agree (violently even) with your statement that Christians will find justifications to do the things they want, “by poring through obscure passages of the New Testament. Things they know are wrong can be spuriously justified.” I just disagree that it is hard to follow the fundamental message. <shrug>

The atheist criticism of religion for this tendency is entirely justified. What's unjustified is the idea that Christians should do more of this, in order to conform to the atheist standard of what a Christian should be.

Sorry, you lost me on this one. Perhaps it’s just early and I’m already tired of work. Can you rephrase and provide an example. This isn’t a trap or anything, I honestly am not certain what you mean.
 
One thing that occurs to me that we may be miscommunicating. The congregationalist church I attend does not require members to believe that Jesus was an actual historical figure.

Nopers, I just think you don't understand what your own church professes as it's beliefs.

In the congregation of the church I attend, agnostics such as myself and even hard line atheists are welcome. More than that, it's not just words, I was made to feel very welcome by everyone I discussed the matter with who was a member.

Welcome does not mean member. I'm welcome in my wife's LDS church, with quite open arms (as befits a fundamentalist missionary driven faith). But my presence as a non-believer in their faith doesn't change the facts of the LDS church's beliefs. I would never make the claim that because I sit in a pew that the LDS church doesn't require members to believe in the literal Jesus because that would be a patently false lie.
 
I believe I answered this above in post #282, but I will expound a little.

Does it matter to the universe what happens to people? No. The wind will still blow, the stars will still shine, the planets will still orbit their stars, microbes and bacteria and worms will eat our bodies and break down our chemical compounds to be recycled into other life forms.

Does it matter to people what happens to people? Of course. It is profoundly important to us all.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think he gets that. The question is why does it matter to people. Why do we care? Is it selfish reasons? I tried to touch on this earlier in the thread somewhat about most "evil" not really being derived from religion, but religion is just another tool to help or hurt others with. A world without religion is just a world where people are more honest about why they commit "evil" acts against each other.

This is seperate from just plain silly OCD practices.:D
 
Well, he does. He has. People do.

That's why we create guidelines, rules, laws and punishments, and why we come up with ideas like "checks and balances" in our governments. And why sometimes countries decide to go to war and remove other countries' leaders.

That's a pragmatic answer - which certainly works. But does it matter absolutely that the supposed selfish person treats other people as objects - or is it just a matter of the system working less efficiently?
 
That's a pragmatic answer - which certainly works. But does it matter absolutely that the supposed selfish person treats other people as objects - or is it just a matter of the system working less efficiently?

Deleted: Meg clarified this statement for me through her answer below.
 
Last edited:
Why is it so hard for you to grasp that the universe doesn't care whether you live or die? Only people do.

Why is it hard to realize that you are making an assumption with this statement? Whether the universe cares about us or not, any response to that question other than 'I don't know how to tell the difference' requires us to make assumptions about the answer. I think it's actually a good way to make the distinction between atheists, agnostics and deists of any sort. Atheists and deists both think they know the "Truth" about the answer. Agnostics cannot fathom the certainty of either group.

Thanks meg. Your response led me to that insight that I think may be a good one in terms of how I at least, decide how to label other people.
 
That's a pragmatic answer - which certainly works. But does it matter absolutely that the supposed selfish person treats other people as objects - or is it just a matter of the system working less efficiently?

I don't know if its either. I suppose I've always just looked at it as an acknowledgment that all people are different, and that we all have varying levels of empathy, altruistic and selfish emotions, that occasionally cause us do selfish things. As a society we attempt to guard against those behaviors that could cause the most damages.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom