Faith leads to evil.

There are many possible teachings in Huck Finn, The Grapes of Wrath and Gone With the Wind, too.

But they aren't didactic. Unlike, say, Rand, Marx, Montessori or Hitler. Who do have followers.

Even George Lucas has created disciples.
 
For the Bible, I've disagreed with Westprof that that fundamental message is, as he claimed hard to follow. That seems to be a retcon for the proclaimed Christians who did bad things in their time.

Perhaps I wasn't clear. When I said that the message was hard to follow, I didn't mean it was hard to understand. I meant it was difficult to do.

Which is part of the problem with the practice, as opposed to the ideal of Christianity. Clearly, slavery is incompatible with living like Christ. Objectively, many things are wrong in the eyes of Christ - but people want to do them. So they'll find justification for them, often by poring through obscure passages of the New Testament. Things they know are wrong can be spuriously justified.

The atheist criticism of religion for this tendency is entirely justified. What's unjustified is the idea that Christians should do more of this, in order to conform to the atheist standard of what a Christian should be.
 
:confused:

You have no religious beliefs, but are not an atheist? Really?

An atheist is someone who does have a particular belief. He might claim that it is the default, rational belief, but it's a belief nevertheless.

Some people haven't committed themselves fully. I sometimes think that's the only rational position.
 
What a strange, and incorrect, criticism. I don't need to show who is regarded as a neighbour for my argument to work. I merely need to show that slaves belong to a class of things that are not neighbours. Slaves are property, and property cannot be my neighbour (it is something owned by me, and therefore not equal to me).

And a despised racial enemy is? The funny thing is that most modern Christians do manage to interpret that text in relation to slavery. The anti-slavery campaigners managed to interpret it. The people who didn't, didn't because they didn't want to.
 
It's strange how RobRoy stretches the meaning of the scriptures so much that it causes tensile failure, yet thinks everyone else is reading it wrongly. Not only that, but he claims not to be christian.

That's why I call him an "apologist"... he may as well be a religious because he thinks like a religious person. He apologizes for religion. Plus we have a lot of people claiming not to believe in something or other who definitely believe in that something or other-- but they hope to be taken more seriously if they say they don't.

Talking to him is like talking to a teenager to me. It would be like talking to Tom Cruise about the problems with Scientology, I think. His brain can't hear what is being said and invents things being said that have not been said. I hope he's young so that it might be fixable.

But I agree with Moby that he's more of a "Darth Rotor" than a Westprog. I just have low tolerance... I've spent to much time in the arena with creationists.
 
Last edited:
I hope he's young so that it might be fixable.

I have visions of Articulett making an appointment with the vet.

But I agree with Moby that he's more of a "Darth Rotor" than a Westprog.

Only here a few days and already I'm part of the ranking system.

I just have low tolerance...

Can't argue with that.

I've spent to much time in the arena with creationists.

That would explain a lot.
 
It only struck me after pages of posts on this topic that the phrase "Faith leads to evil" is itself an irrational statement. It presupposes a belief in evil as real, even though there is no scientific evidence that any such thing exists. It's impossible to believe that evil exists without the use of faith.

I'm still engaged with MobySeven in an analysis of exactly what a rational, scientific ethics consists of. However, such an ethical system can't, IMO, include a belief that evil is real.

That depends if you are meaning evil like one that lurks in the shadows of hell or acts that are ethically wrong. You can use a "religious" term and it not be directly related to theism. I can say a murderer is evil, but I know he is not a minion of Satan. I took evil in the thread to be more on the ethical side, which has evolved over time.
 
My other nitpick regarding the "Love thy neighbor" and slavery is that the concept of slavery was different in the Middle East than the institution most Americans are used to thinking of. Someone please correct me if I am wrong, but I had thought that most slaves in biblical times were either taken through warfare, or were born into it. So if your slave used to be your enemy (or your father's enemy, etc.), were they ever your neighbor? Does anyone know if "neighbor" is the best translation of the original term?

I can see how a modern interpretation can be used to disavow slavery (and I would agree with that interpretation), but I cannot be as confident about a contextual interpretation.

I'm glad Moby reposted this. That is very true. Slaves over time were very different. Without totally derailing the thread, many slaves had status with who they were owned by. Many were taken through war, but many also offered servitude to have a life of security (much like taking a job as a butler, maid, or personal assistant). They could have families and lives outside the service. To be real, life was ◊◊◊◊◊ hard then and much like some people today like living in prison to know they can eat every day, the same can be said back then. Not to say every slave had it good in every culture , but not every slave's situation was like watching "Roots".
 
Why do you consider it [slavery] to be evil?

Well, I think the first thing to do is to attempt to define what "evil" and its opposite "good" are. I think of them both, not as immovable constants, but as reference points on a sliding scale. My own opinion is that "good" refers to those things, behaviors and actions that respect and promote human life, human liberty, and human happiness as well as those things that increase the ability of many humans to peacefully coexist. And evil refers to those things, behaviors and actions that limit or reduce human life, human liberties, or human happiness, as well as those things that decrease our ability to peacefully coexist.

I also hold as a basic premise of my moral code that all humans have a fundamental right to their own life, liberty and happiness, so actions that, all other factors being equal, increase my happiness by equally decreasing your happiness, (like me stealing your money, for example) are not neutral, but actually usually sit on the "evil" side of the spectrum.


That said, I believe slavery sits on the "very evil" side of the spectrum, because it removes all the human fundamental rights; it reduces human life, it reduces human liberties, it decreases human happiness, and it reduces our ability to peacefully coexist.
 
And a despised racial enemy is? The funny thing is that most modern Christians do manage to interpret that text in relation to slavery. The anti-slavery campaigners managed to interpret it. The people who didn't, didn't because they didn't want to.

Many words, signifying nothing and making no attempt to do so.
 
That depends if you are meaning evil like one that lurks in the shadows of hell or acts that are ethically wrong. You can use a "religious" term and it not be directly related to theism. I can say a murderer is evil, but I know he is not a minion of Satan. I took evil in the thread to be more on the ethical side, which has evolved over time.

If you subscribe to a relative, evolving version of ethics, which is based on consensus, it's difficult to see how you can unequivocally call something "evil". If you subscribe to a purely scientific and reason based universe, how can you objectively say that certain acts are ethically wrong?

It's possible to select an ethical system that works best for you. It's possible to have a consensus that it's pragmatically better insofar as it's in line with people's wishes. I don't see how you can derive, from that, the existence of evil in any sense.
 
Well, I think the first thing to do is to attempt to define what "evil" and its opposite "good" are. I think of them both, not as immovable constants, but as reference points on a sliding scale. My own opinion is that "good" refers to those things, behaviors and actions that respect and promote human life, human liberty, and human happiness as well as those things that increase the ability of many humans to peacefully coexist. And evil refers to those things, behaviors and actions that limit or reduce human life, human liberties, or human happiness, as well as those things that decrease our ability to peacefully coexist.

I also hold as a basic premise of my moral code that all humans have a fundamental right to their own life, liberty and happiness, so actions that, all other factors being equal, increase my happiness by equally decreasing your happiness, (like me stealing your money, for example) are not neutral, but actually usually sit on the "evil" side of the spectrum.


That said, I believe slavery sits on the "very evil" side of the spectrum, because it removes all the human fundamental rights; it reduces human life, it reduces human liberties, it decreases human happiness, and it reduces our ability to peacefully coexist.

OK, that's fairly clear - but how do you decide that human life, human liberties, or human happiness are things to be generally preserved and supported? And how do you convince somebody who thinks that, say, his own personal life, liberty and happiness is all that matters that his view is incorrect?
 
It's impossible to believe that evil exists without the use of faith.

Evil is very real, however it is a subjective term. Why do theists like to play such silly games and try to convince non-believers that they have faith too?
 
Originally Posted by volatile View Post
I think Darth and Westprog were trying to say that the act of enslaving someone is itself unneighbourly, and would indicate a breach in your love.

Makes sense as a rationalisation. Not so much as an explanation in the context of the NT, though.
That explanation would only make sense if you considered the person a neighbour in the first place. If you don't consider them your neighbour, it's fine to enslave them, and once they're your slave you still don't need to consider them your neighbour.
.
I just saw Justice Scalia declare that torture was not punishment. Because he says it isn't. That's what he said. And smirked while saying it.
I guess his mindset is the same as D& W's.
 
WP wrote:"And how do you convince somebody who thinks that, say, his own personal life, liberty and happiness is all that matters that his view is incorrect?"
.
It isn't, as long as the swinging of his arms fails to impact my nose.
Otherwise, we have institutions prepared to handle those who step beyond that boundary.
 
Evil is very real, however it is a subjective term. Why do theists like to play such silly games and try to convince non-believers that they have faith too?

How can it be subjective and real?

If it's subjective, then it's just a matter of whatever any individual chooses to describe as evil. There are plenty of people who describe gay marriage as evil, or pornography, or eating meat. Many people who believe these things don't have a religious belief. They seem to follow different principles to decide on a personal basis what evil means.
 
.
I just saw Justice Scalia declare that torture was not punishment. Because he says it isn't. That's what he said. And smirked while saying it.
I guess his mindset is the same as D& W's.

Clearly since Darth and I both think that Christians should be against slavery, we would be in favour of torture. That's an obvious link.
 
WP wrote:"And how do you convince somebody who thinks that, say, his own personal life, liberty and happiness is all that matters that his view is incorrect?"
.
It isn't, as long as the swinging of his arms fails to impact my nose.
Otherwise, we have institutions prepared to handle those who step beyond that boundary.

There are plenty of ways that someone can act "selfishly" (which would apply to someone whose actions are motivated by his own LLH), without breaching the restrictions of those institutions. A lot of the time that will cause impacts on his neighbours.
 
OK, that's fairly clear - but how do you decide that human life, human liberties, or human happiness are things to be generally preserved and supported?


Through reason. After learning, thinking, and studying different sociological systems, as well as historic societies and cultures, it is my somewhat educated opinion that not only are more egalitarian societies more successful and likely to thrive, but those societies also achieve a higher "quality" of life for more of its citizens. More citizens are capable of doing more than just scraping out a living, and are able to enjoy such pursuits as the development of art, music, and higher learning.


And how do you convince somebody who thinks that, say, his own personal life, liberty and happiness is all that matters that his view is incorrect?

With reason. Even the most persistant selfish bully can understand that in a society where people just kill and take whatever they want, that the likelihood of him or his children getting killed is much higher than in a more peaceful society. Even an idiot can comprehend that no matter how strong you may be now, sooner or later someone stronger will come along. And most people can understand that if a great deal of your time and energy is spent just having to defend your own life and property, that less of your life is left to spend on more enjoyable pursuits.



It's all about rules of the game for living together. We discovered long ago that we live longer, and we live better when we band together as communities vs each individual fending for himself. All our morals and all our philosophies revolve around this concept; they are all attempts to define what makes a community, how our community interacts with the world, and what the roles we each play in it are.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom