Faith leads to evil.

Volatile, I certainly don't mean to speak for Darth Rotor as I have no idea of his personal beliefs, but I think I can speak for some of the christians I know that are also what I consider to be good thinkers.

As far as I can tell, there are a number of christians that intentionally don't think too much about the virgin birth, contradictions of scriptures, holy trinity, physical ascension and all that sort of religious stuff, but instead they choose to believe that Jesus was a smart dude who taught some good things about how we should be more forgiving, how we should try to love one another, and how we should take care of each other. And they enjoy going to a place that regularly reminds them and encourages them to think about these good things, and try to do them in their life. They feel their life is improved by doing this.
Sorta, and the latter is in my case true, though I tend to learn via interactions outside of a Sunday service moreso than during Mass.
And sometimes they get ticked off by people that seem to assume all christians are rabid lying self aggrandizing proselytizers and feel a need to at least half heartedly chime in with a "well not all christians are like that, ya know."
Just as many blacks get irritated by people assuming all blacks are gangsta rappers.
Sometimes they jump to the conclusion that anyone that seriously questions their religion is one of the above, because they are regularly taught at church that this is so.
No. I've got enough ego that I don't need a parson or priest to incite me to get all froggy. ;) When you see stereotyping, you recognize it. So do I.
And these people don't really like talking seriously about their religion or the bible, because it means they would have to actually look hard at it, and deep down they know it doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but they don't want to stop, so they just choose to not talk about it much.
I am better off if I walk the walk than if I do a lot of talk, eh? (Doh, that means that posting here is, for me, completely counterproductive. Maybe I just oughta STFU and GTFO. )
As I said before, I'm most definitely NOT trying to speak for Darth Rotor. I'm just saying, this is what I've observed in some other people.
When one accepts that Christians have a gift for getting in one another's knickers about inane doctrinal disagreement (see the Schism between Constantinople and Rome as an extreme example) one can also accept that no matter how good a Christian you try to be, there will be another giving you a ration of crap about how badly you are doing. It's a people thing.

For a non Christian to barge in and continue in that vein is most often taken by me, quite frankly, as a cue to suggest that one (whoever is so barging in) mind one's own business.

You want me to be a better Christian? Fine, you be one, and you be a better one, and I'll follow your lead. Otherwise, you're just another critic. Critics are a dime a dozen.

As TR once so eloquently pointed out, it is not the critic who counts.

Thanks for the thought, meg, I appreciate the spirit in which it was offered. :)

DR
 
Last edited:
The church I attend, a congregational church, does not require that.

Okey dokey, then you're quite wrong in what they hold to be their faith. According to this Congregation Christian Church site: "We are a Christ-centered and Bible-believing church." On their FAQ in response to "What is the gospel that you preach?" it states: "God's salvation is a free gift received only by grace, only through faith in the Lord Jesus Christ."

The National Association of Congregational Christian Churches site states under the membership section, "As Christians . . . We Belong to The Body of Christ . . . The Congregational Way is a way of following Christ . . . We seek to grow through:
Study of the Bible . . . Openness to the leading of the Holy Spirit."

It seems pretty clear that the Congregational believes in Jesus, that he was a real person, that he was the Christ, and also in the Holy Spirit. All literal points made by the Bible. <shrug>
 
Last edited:
You skipped a step. Sloppy of you. How is making the slave property consistent with "love thy neighbor as thyself."

Thanks for the reply, though, it got a grin out of me.

DR


Love thy neighbor wasn't a new teaching of Christ's, it first comes from Leviticus:

19:18 Thou shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of thy people, but thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself: I am the LORD

But two down and it's telling us the penalty for ****ing engaged slaves:

19:20 And whosoever lieth carnally with a woman, that is a bondmaid, betrothed to an husband, and not at all redeemed, nor freedom given her; she shall be scourged; they shall not be put to death, because she was not free
 
The church I attend, a congregational church, does not require that.

Hi Beth,

Does your congregation have a minimum set of beliefs to adhere to to become a member as opposed to simply attending the church there. I've been to a variety and many have a statement of faith or creed and often also require the person to be baptised.

I've also been to many where they'll accept anyone there in fellowship and to learn, but they wouldn't actually be considered a member.

I've never heard of a church like your describing except Unitarian churches. So it's interesting.

Thanks.
 
And applying the knowlege that the bible was written over hundreds of years by many different hands, what does that lead us to?


It leads me to the conclusion that it's worthless as any kind of reliable historical document, and yet many people consider it reliable enough to establish that people rose from the grave.
 
I've never heard of a church like your describing except Unitarian churches. So it's interesting.

If it's really a Congregational church, then her description is wrong in regards to their professed faith.

Even Unitarians claim to believe in the teachings of Jesus, which again, is volatile's point. There isn't a Christian church that doesn't hold at least some part of the Bible to be literally true.
 
Not to speak for him either, but we make plenty of rational decisions based on an irrational premise. If we're in love for example--sure, we could break down the reasons for love from an evolutionary or brain chemistry standpoint, etc.--but it wouldn't affect the power of the feeling (or more importantly we may not want it to). Nor would it likely prevent us from being upset if the thing we loved were taken from us. So, based on an irrational emotion we make rational decisions for how to keep it, or how to respond to it.

I can accept that faith is irrational, based on epiphany, or culture, or emotion or whatever. And at some point after the irrational basis, a faithful person can act completely rationally based on that faith, or later rationalizations.

Same might hold true for rational moral systems, with an example irrational premise being that humans have an innate value that deserves protection. The rationalist may explore everything around the premise, but since the premise is inherent to the system, stop short of rationalizing it out of existence.

A counterargument may be that humans having innate value isn't an irrational idea, but I don't see much if any difference between that and a leap-of-faith premise that a theist may have.

This post was looking like it was in danger of being completely passed by.

It struck me as a very astute observation. Great point, Dragoonster!

It's worth remembering that we humans aren't entirely rational beings...and that's not always a bad thing.
 
Okey dokey, then you're quite wrong in what they hold to be their faith. According to this Congregation Christian Church site: "We are a Christ-centered and Bible-believing church." On their FAQ in response to "What is the gospel that you preach?" it states: "God's salvation is a free gift received only by grace, only through faith in the Lord Jesus Christ."

The National Association of Congregational Christian Churches site states under the membership section, "As Christians . . . We Belong to The Body of Christ . . . The Congregational Way is a way of following Christ . . . We seek to grow through:
Study of the Bible . . . Openness to the leading of the Holy Spirit."

It seems pretty clear that the Congregational believes in Jesus, that he was a real person, that he was the Christ, and also in the Holy Spirit. All literal points made by the Bible. <shrug>

There's no requirement that members believe as you are claiming they must. Christ centered - yes. Believe in the Bible - yes. Neither of those imply a literal interpretation is necessary. The church can center itself around the teachings of Jesus as given in the bible without requiring literal belief in either.
 
Last edited:
Love thy neighbor wasn't a new teaching of Christ's, it first comes from Leviticus:

19:18 Thou shalt not avenge, nor bear any grudge against the children of thy people, but thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself: I am the LORD

But two down and it's telling us the penalty for ****ing engaged slaves:

19:20 And whosoever lieth carnally with a woman, that is a bondmaid, betrothed to an husband, and not at all redeemed, nor freedom given her; she shall be scourged; they shall not be put to death, because she was not free


My other nitpick regarding the "Love thy neighbor" and slavery is that the concept of slavery was different in the Middle East than the institution most Americans are used to thinking of. Someone please correct me if I am wrong, but I had thought that most slaves in biblical times were either taken through warfare, or were born into it. So if your slave used to be your enemy (or your father's enemy, etc.), were they ever your neighbor? Does anyone know if "neighbor" is the best translation of the original term?

I can see how a modern interpretation can be used to disavow slavery (and I would agree with that interpretation), but I cannot be as confident about a contextual interpretation.
 
If I remember correctly they were forbidden from taking other jews as slaves unless they were paying off a debt.
 
My other nitpick regarding the "Love thy neighbor" and slavery is that the concept of slavery was different in the Middle East than the institution most Americans are used to thinking of. Someone please correct me if I am wrong, but I had thought that most slaves in biblical times were either taken through warfare, or were born into it. So if your slave used to be your enemy (or your father's enemy, etc.), were they ever your neighbor? Does anyone know if "neighbor" is the best translation of the original term?

I don't know. However in both Exodus and Deuteronomy, one of the commandments listed states

Exodus 20:17 You must not want to take your neighbor's house. You must not want his wife or his male or female slaves, or his ox or his donkey, or anything that belongs to your neighbor.

So apparently your neighbor could have slaves.
 
There's no requirement that members beleive as you are claiming they must. Christ centered - yes. Believe in the Bible - yes. Neither of those imply a literal interpretation is necessary. The church can center itself around the teachings of Jesus as given in the bible without requiring literal belief in either.

So do these people that believe the bible is entirely fiction and that Jesus was a fictional character pray to a god?
 
The Code of Hammurabi, which provided a lot of what is in the OT, would be as good a code to live by, without all the drama the OT and NT provide, fleshing out the rules. And it's a bit more consistent. And there's even a reference or three to god, to give it extra-terrestial authority.
.
"
When Anu the Sublime, King of the Anunaki, and Bel, the lord of Heaven and earth, who decreed the fate of the land, assigned to Marduk, the over-ruling son of Ea, God of righteousness, dominion over earthly man, and made him great among the Igigi, they called Babylon by his illustrious name, made it great on earth, and founded an everlasting kingdom in it, whose foundations are laid so solidly as those of heaven and earth; then Anu and Bel called by name me, Hammurabi, the exalted prince, who feared God, to bring about the rule of righteousness in the land, to destroy the wicked and the evil-doers; so that the strong should not harm the weak; so that I should rule over the black-headed people like Shamash, and enlighten the land, to further the well-being of mankind. "
...
Lots of nifty thou-shalt-nots and civil rules follow.
 
I think Darth and Westprog were trying to say that the act of enslaving someone is itself unneighbourly, and would indicate a breach in your love.

Makes sense as a rationalisation. Not so much as an explanation in the context of the NT, though.

That explanation would only make sense if you considered the person a neighbour in the first place. If you don't consider them your neighbour, it's fine to enslave them, and once they're your slave you still don't need to consider them your neighbour.

Just wondering - what if someone thought slavetrading was wrong? Would it mean that slave owning was right even if never condemned? If so - how?
Errrm. What?

If someone though slave-trading was wrong, it would mean slave-owning was right? That's just babbling nonsense.

Actually, it's a misrepresentation of my argument earlier, where I pointed out that there were legitimate and illegitimate ways of obtaining slaves back then, and just because someone condemns the illegitimate slave traders, it doesn't mean that they are condemning slavery in general, nor slave owners.

Sorry, I thought in saying “I suppose I can’t” in response to your question to me, you would see that I was saying you appeared to be quite correct in your interpretation. It appears that I am incorrect, not you. I didn’t know that was confusing.

Sorry, I misunderstood what you were saying as a dodge rather than a concession. My bad! Sorry again for that.

However, on further review of this, I suppose the counter argument would be that Jesus only extends specific laws, and the rest can be considered to fall by the wayside with his fulfillment.

I suppose it could be used as a counter argument, but it's a pretty weak one. It's an argument that the apparent contradiction between the common interpretation of Jesus' words and his new laws only exists because he didn't specifically restate every one of the old laws; whereas I would suggest there is a strong inference between his partial restating of the laws and the idea that the laws have therefore not been struck out.

Because it is addressing the behavior of believers, and addressing all believers, whether they were “under the yoke of slavery” or not (1 Timothy 6:1), it was not addressing the institution of slavery itself. As I said earlier, the New Testament doesn’t condemn slavery (except in some periphery scripture), and mores the pity, but it doesn’t condone it either.

Well, yes, that's what 6:1 says. I'm more interested in 6:2, "And they that have believing masters, let them not despise [them], because they are brethren; but rather do [them] service, because they are faithful and beloved, partakers of the benefit."

In other words, it is entirely possible for a slave owner to be a Christian - and if a slave has a Christian master, they are commanded to, "...not despise [him]..." It is that passage, more than 6:1, that I believe constitutes approval of slavery.

However you want to state it, I’m in agreement with this interpretation. This was exactly what I was trying to put forth, and apparently failed to do.

We are then, as I like to put it, violently in agreement. ;)
 
It's strange how RobRoy stretches the meaning of the scriptures so much that it causes tensile failure, yet thinks everyone else is reading it wrongly. Not only that, but he claims not to be christian.
 
My other nitpick regarding the "Love thy neighbor" and slavery is that the concept of slavery was different in the Middle East than the institution most Americans are used to thinking of. Someone please correct me if I am wrong, but I had thought that most slaves in biblical times were either taken through warfare, or were born into it. So if your slave used to be your enemy (or your father's enemy, etc.), were they ever your neighbor? Does anyone know if "neighbor" is the best translation of the original term?

I can see how a modern interpretation can be used to disavow slavery (and I would agree with that interpretation), but I cannot be as confident about a contextual interpretation.

QFT.
 
It's strange how RobRoy stretches the meaning of the scriptures so much that it causes tensile failure, yet thinks everyone else is reading it wrongly.

I wouldn't go that far - I agree with him that other people were misreading parts of the scripture earlier on, even though I disagree (or disagreed, as there are a few points he seems to concede) with him on a number of other points.

I wouldn't tar him with the same brush as some of the other posters here - he seems quite reasonable and willing to have an honest discussion. A 'Darth Rotor' kind of person (if I had to make a comparison), rather than a...well, y'know.
 
This post was looking like it was in danger of being completely passed by.

It struck me as a very astute observation. Great point, Dragoonster!

It's worth remembering that we humans aren't entirely rational beings...and that's not always a bad thing.

It only struck me after pages of posts on this topic that the phrase "Faith leads to evil" is itself an irrational statement. It presupposes a belief in evil as real, even though there is no scientific evidence that any such thing exists. It's impossible to believe that evil exists without the use of faith.

I'm still engaged with MobySeven in an analysis of exactly what a rational, scientific ethics consists of. However, such an ethical system can't, IMO, include a belief that evil is real.
 
You can be a Christian if you think the entire Bible is a fiction? Really?


What would you call someone who tries to live their lives according to the teachings of Christ? Or her interpretation of the teachings of Christ?

The idea that you could be a Christian without necessarily believing that Christ existed is certainly out there on the boundaries, but if someone wants to call herself a Christian, it's already such a wide church I'd hesitate to exclude her.
 
I don't respond well to stupid loaded questions. See bolded words. My core objection to some of the complaints here is that they toss the baby out with the bathwater, and dwell only on the negative aspects of organized religion, in particular Christianity. No surprise on the latter, as familiarity breeds contempt, and we see few if any people willing to discuss Islam in depth. We have had some interesting discussions on Bhuddism, which I have always found refreshing.

Lose your Christian in a Kilt attitude, and you might find me less cynical. (Or not, I've been cynical for a long time, and I'm working my way up to curmudgeon. Seven years is my schedule.)

As I pointed out months ago, I am not formally trained in Christian apologetics. Any attempt I would make in that vein would be substandard, and probably not up to my own standards.

My faith works for me, and my family.

If it doesn't work for you, fine. Get on with it.

If you want to stand about kvetching about how awful Christians are, by engaging in the standard group think, country club attitude of self-reinforcing bias that screams off of the pages of this forum, that's fine too. Be aware that the darks, as well as the self appointed brights, are also in the club, Massa Volatile.

ETA: Reconcile "love thy neighbor as thyself" with the practice of slavery, if you can.

DR

When I first started this topic, I'd hoped for some kind of objective statements of why faith led to evil. The people who believe this tend to trust science, so I was hoping for some kind of analytical approach. Instead the response has largely been from atheist bible scholars, and complaints that Christians just believe whatever that want, or just do what they're told, and all points in between.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom