Faith leads to evil.

And these people don't really like talking seriously about their religion or the bible, because it means they would have to actually look hard at it, and deep down they know it doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but they don't want to stop, so they just choose to not talk about it much.

Oh, I understand that entirely. But from what I've seen of Darth's posts, this doesn't seem like it would apply to him. Whilst me may not like being called "a sceptic", he certainly demonstrates a keen ability to apply the tools of scepticism in all areas other than this one. He's also pretty smart, and pretty straight-up, so the contention that somehow he knows deeps down how silly it all is doesn't seem to fit.

That's why I'm curious.
 
What a strange, and incorrect, criticism. I don't need to show who is regarded as a neighbour for my argument to work. I merely need to show that slaves belong to a class of things that are not neighbours. Slaves are property, and property cannot be my neighbour (it is something owned by me, and therefore not equal to me).

Honestly, westprog, I would invest in some logic lessons if I were you. Your understanding of formal logic is extremely flawed.

I think Darth and Westprog were trying to say that the act of enslaving someone is itself unneighbourly, and would indicate a breach in your love.

Makes sense as a rationalisation. Not so much as an explanation in the context of the NT, though.
 
Last edited:
This just goes to show that in order to be religious AND skeptical, one must compartmentalize their thought process. The sacred cows are exempt from skepticism for these people.
 
I just want have a conversation, though you make it rather difficult. I want to understand how a rational and intelligent human being holds what seem to me to be quite clearly irrational thoughts. I've tried to explain why I think they're irrational, but you haven't even uttered a word on the subject. Your entire scope of discourse on this topic (and this topic alone, I note) seems to be "Not telling!". If anyone could clearly explain why it is sensible and rational to hold Christian beliefs, you'd be him. But you won't.

Not to speak for him either, but we make plenty of rational decisions based on an irrational premise. If we're in love for example--sure, we could break down the reasons for love from an evolutionary or brain chemistry standpoint, etc.--but it wouldn't affect the power of the feeling (or more importantly we may not want it to). Nor would it likely prevent us from being upset if the thing we loved were taken from us. So, based on an irrational emotion we make rational decisions for how to keep it, or how to respond to it.

I can accept that faith is irrational, based on epiphany, or culture, or emotion or whatever. And at some point after the irrational basis, a faithful person can act completely rationally based on that faith, or later rationalizations.

Same might hold true for rational moral systems, with an example irrational premise being that humans have an innate value that deserves protection. The rationalist may explore everything around the premise, but since the premise is inherent to the system, stop short of rationalizing it out of existence.

A counterargument may be that humans having innate value isn't an irrational idea, but I don't see much if any difference between that and a leap-of-faith premise that a theist may have.
 
I think Darth and Westprog were trying to say that the act of enslaving someone is itself unneighbourly, and would indicate a breach in your love.

Makes sense as a rationalisation. Not so much as an explanation in the context of the NT, though.

Just wondering - what if someone thought slavetrading was wrong? Would it mean that slave owning was right even if never condemned? If so - how?
 
Last edited:
While the whole "slaves are not neighbors" argument is really cool (probably deserving its own thread, ahem), did faith lead to this "evil"? Or was it economic? Racist? Maybe christianity was used as a tool by those wanting to keep the slaves once the majority was convinced slavery was inhumane, but it certaintly wasn't the root of slavery. It did not require christianity to look at another race as less than human or as an animal. Slaves existed long before religion and were justified by other reasons.

ETA:remember, this was spawned from the statement "faith leads to evil" and the responding OP.
 
Last edited:
Just wondering - what if someone thought slavetrading was wrong? Would it mean that slave owning was right even if never condemned? If so - how?

Errrm. What?

If someone though slave-trading was wrong, it would mean slave-owning was right? That's just babbling nonsense.

How about actually thinking about the arguments presented - particularly the quotes Meg posted which seem to suggest that Biblical adherence was an impediment rather than an aid to emancipation; my explanation that the simple chronology of events does not support your argument; and M7's discussions of where your Scriptural readings seem to fail?
 
While the whole "slaves are not neighbors" argument is really cool (probably deserving its own thread, ahem), did faith lead to this "evil"? Or was it economic? Racist? Maybe christianity was used as a tool by those wanting to keep the slaves once the majority was convinced slavery was inhumane, but it certaintly wasn't the root of slavery. It did not require christianity to look at another race as less than human or as an animal. Slaves existed long before religion and were justified by other reasons.

I don't think anyone has said that religion (or at least Christianity) initiated slavery. Nevertheless, do you think it is pure coincidence that the emancipation of the slaves occurred at the same time as the philosophical Enlightenment, which sought a re-evaluation of faith-based principles based on a mere Humanistic interpretation?

As I said earlier on, faith leads to evil. It's not the only thing that leads to evil, and nor does faith always lead to evil (or at least, great evil), but faith certainly creates a particularly fertile environment which allows evil to flourish and perpetuate.
 
Out of all of your examples, not a single one reflects your claim of a metaphorical or figurative Jesus. All of them begin with the divinity of Jesus who walked the planet.
I didn't post the examples originally. That was volatile. At any rate, even if all began that way, the different denominations have changed over the centuries. Not all are still that way.
By definition, to be a Christian, you have to believe that Jesus was a real, historical figure.
No. In fact, according to a book I read, there are some rather highly placed religious authorities who felt differently. Such a belief may be required by many Christian churches, but one counterexample suffices to prove that it is not required by all.
Which one of these is your church? Or is yours not listed?
I attend a Congregationalist Christian Church. Each church is an independent self-governing organization, not responsible to any heirarchical structure and able to set their policies as the membership pleases. I'm agnostic myself, but apparently no one, including the minister there, has any problem with that. Atheists are welcome as well.

Nopers, sorry. An individual can claim whatever they want, but fundamental to being a Christian, survey says you're 100% wrong.
I think that survey may have missed a key demographic then. I wouldn't trust the results too far. :D

Incidently, some people think Catholics don't qualify as Christian. Others are okay with Catholics but reject the Mormons. Opinions vary as to what beliefs ought to be required to be a Christian, but close examination of varying denominations makes it clear that there isn't any set of beliefs that are common to all people who consider themselves Christian, not even the belief that Jesus actually existed.
 
Errrm. What?

If someone though slave-trading was wrong, it would mean slave-owning was right? That's just babbling nonsense.

How about actually thinking about the arguments presented - particularly the quotes Meg posted which seem to suggest that Biblical adherence was an impediment rather than an aid to emancipation; my explanation that the simple chronology of events does not support your argument; and M7's discussions of where your Scriptural readings seem to fail?

1) Paul condemned slave traders.

2) The times Paul writes about slaves is when the issue arises in the early church on how Christian slaves and Christian slaveowners are to act within the social roles they were born or found themselves in before they became Christians (at that time - in future centuries people were sometimes Christians before becoming slaves). In other words - once they became Christians they began looking at Jesus teachings and began questioning the societal cultural roles they had taken as a given and for granted.

Read all those quotes from Rodney Starks book to follow along with the progression of the early Christians and their attitudes towards slavery and the abolition of it by Aquinas time (1200's). This was a continual process insigated long before the enlightenment.
 
Last edited:
Faith is the prison that enslaves a person by shackling the freedom of rational thought and reason, at least in the field where the faith takes precedence. Sure, not all slaves do evil deeds, but the slavery itself is evil.
 
I don't think anyone has said that religion (or at least Christianity) initiated slavery. Nevertheless, do you think it is pure coincidence that the emancipation of the slaves occurred at the same time as the philosophical Enlightenment, which sought a re-evaluation of faith-based principles based on a mere Humanistic interpretation?

Agreed. I was trying to pull us closer to the OP. Many changes in history were also caused by the mixing of continents and cultures. Tribes found in the forest with no touch of civilization were having children in what was then a "modern" society and showing themselves as more than animalistic.

As I said earlier on, faith leads to evil. It's not the only thing that leads to evil, and nor does faith always lead to evil (or at least, great evil), but faith certainly creates a particularly fertile environment which allows evil to flourish and perpetuate.

True, but what doesn't. The human experiment is just a more complicated version of pavlov's dog. You think without religion in the US, we would have less murderers, rapists, pedophiles, robberies, etc? If faith leads to evil, then what percentage of all evil is caused by religion? I would guess a very small percentage as compared to evil from primal instinct. Many religions were to tame such instincts and manifested into other problems or outdated practices, but it didn't cause the evil, only redirected it.
 
Faith is the prison that enslaves a person by shackling the freedom of rational thought and reason, at least in the field where the faith takes precedence. Sure, not all slaves do evil deeds, but the slavery itself is evil.

People are prisoners of their own lives. Or uneducated. Or bipolar. Or low on luck. For many, faith is what holds them together. I know several people that would be dead without it. Damn they are annoying, but they are alive and contributing.
 
Read all those quotes from Rodney Starks book to follow along with the progression of the early Christians and their attitudes towards slavery and the abolition of it Aquinas time (1200's). This was a continual process insigated long before the enlightenment.

I read all your quotes, and I think they represent a not very broad view of history. For instance, there were many other factors besides christianity in medieval Europe that led to the slavery ebbing and serfdom expanding. And slavery was not completely abolished in Europe until much later. There also is a lot of evidence that the church went along for several centuries with slavery in canonical law. For instance, there were several places in the 11th century, where christians were only forbidden from keeping other christians as slaves. It was ok to keep muslims and pagans as slaves. Your quotes also fail to notice that slavery in Europe picked back up after the Renaissance.

But I really don't see the point of debating whether certain scriptures really promote slavery or not. And I really don't understand the point of debating how much christians had to do with the end of slavery or not.

I think the main point to think about is that at various times, self proclaimed christians, and "christian nations" conducted slavery, and they honestly believed their actions were justified by god, by their faith, and by the bible.

This particular faith has been used to commit something we consider to be evil.

While this certainly does not show that faith always leads to evil, I think it does show that faith most certainly does not prevent evil, nor is it a cure for evil.
 
I don't respond well to stupid loaded questions. See bolded words. My core objection to some of the complaints here is that they toss the baby out with the bathwater, and dwell only on the negative aspects of organized religion, in particular Christianity. No surprise on the latter, as familiarity breeds contempt, and we see few if any people willing to discuss Islam in depth. We have had some interesting discussions on Bhuddism, which I have always found refreshing.

Lose your Christian in a Kilt attitude, and you might find me less cynical. (Or not, I've been cynical for a long time, and I'm working my way up to curmudgeon. Seven years is my schedule.)

As I pointed out months ago, I am not formally trained in Christian apologetics. Any attempt I would make in that vein would be substandard, and probably not up to my own standards.

My faith works for me, and my family.

If it doesn't work for you, fine. Get on with it.

If you want to stand about kvetching about how awful Christians are, by engaging in the standard group think, country club attitude of self-reinforcing bias that screams off of the pages of this forum, that's fine too. Be aware that the darks, as well as the self appointed brights, are also in the club, Massa Volatile.

ETA: Reconcile "love thy neighbor as thyself" with the practice of slavery, if you can.

DR

My neighbor is so ignorant of Christ that is an act of love to enslave him and bring him to god.

note: actually used by slavers.
 
I would far prefer it if you would address my argument, rather than just telling me that I'm incorrect. If I'm incorrect, why am I incorrect?

Sorry, I thought in saying “I suppose I can’t” in response to your question to me, you would see that I was saying you appeared to be quite correct in your interpretation. It appears that I am incorrect, not you. I didn’t know that was confusing.

However, on further review of this, I suppose the counter argument would be that Jesus only extends specific laws, and the rest can be considered to fall by the wayside with his fulfillment.

How can the bible address slaves owned by Christians in such a manner, and not have it considered approval of slavery?

Because it is addressing the behavior of believers, and addressing all believers, whether they were “under the yoke of slavery” or not (1 Timothy 6:1), it was not addressing the institution of slavery itself. As I said earlier, the New Testament doesn’t condemn slavery (except in some periphery scripture), and mores the pity, but it doesn’t condone it either.

Nearly the same thing. I recognise that the primary part of the verse is that nothing shall be removed until the law has been fulfilled. I wouldn't say it was an either-or statement: "Till heaven and earth come to pass" seems to me to be a hyperbolic metaphor - a way of saying, the only way this is ever going to happen is if the law is fulfilled. Sort of like if I said, "I'll buy a small Greek island if I work really, really hard the rest of my life...or win the lottery twenty times in a row." The second part isn't going to happen - it's just there to emphasise how hard I'd need to work to buy a Greek island.

However you want to state it, I’m in agreement with this interpretation. This was exactly what I was trying to put forth, and apparently failed to do.

At any rate, even if all began that way, the different denominations have changed over the centuries. Not all are still that way.[snip]

I’ll make this very, very simple for you: show me one Christian denomination that doesn’t believe Jesus was a historical figure and I’ll eat volatile’s hat for him.
 
Nobody doubts Christianity works for you DR. It is just that people like volatie and I wonder how this is any different from declaring that the religion of the Ancient Egyptian's works as a guiding principle in your life. I think we would both agree that if someone came on here declaring their belief in Osiris, we would think them either insane or a fool. Why is Christianity not treated the same?
Insane? No. A fool? We are all foolish in one way or another.

Since I stand by the right of people to choose, which is an exercise of practical free will, then choose away and let the chips fall where they may.

Choose. Pick one. Run with it. Be prepared for the consequences of your choices.
I'm still bemused as to how slavery can be said to be anti-Christian when it is condoned in the New Testament more than a couple of times. If "Love your neighbour as yourself" is exempt from intense interpretation, why are the verses advocating the keeping of slaves not treated with the same literalism?
See my above comment on Christian practice and philosophy not being static. History shows us this, at the least.

I seem to recall any number of posts on this forum that correctly point out a variety of seeming inconsistencies and contradictions in Scripture. The effect of this lays out a general policy document that leaves considerable wiggle room, and as history has shown, room for interpretation. I am of the opinion that this provides the Almighty with a continuing source of innocent merriment.

To pretend that there can be only one interpretation of the entire anthology is to fall into the trap that the literalists set for themselves.

Are you keen to wear a Fundy's cloak? :confused:

DR
 
I’ll make this very, very simple for you: show me one Christian denomination that doesn’t believe Jesus was a historical figure and I’ll eat volatile’s hat for him.

The church I attend, a congregational church, does not require that. If you don't want to trust me on that, you can try reading "Think Again: A Response to Fundamentalism's Claim on Christianity" which devotes a chapter to explaining why it isn't necessary to believe that. Although the author does believe in the historical Jesus, he discusses why that belief isn't necessary to be a Christian. It was written by Rev. Gary Cox, who was the pastor of the church I attend until his death a couple of years ago.
 
Nevertheless, do you think it is pure coincidence that the emancipation of the slaves occurred at the same time as the philosophical Enlightenment, which sought a re-evaluation of faith-based principles based on a mere Humanistic interpretation?

Be careful you don't cherry-pick as numerologists do. I could counterpoint to Moses, with faith as the great agent, and ask whether it was pure coincidence those slaves were freed at the same time as he got his Ten Commandments. And forms of rationalism go back for millenia, as do many instances of slaves, freeing slaves, repeat for a multitude of reasons.

One could just as easily point to the Industrial Revolution and other economic boons as the major cause, and perhaps more importantly, the major reason it hasn't reoccurred yet in so many numbers. By automating a lot of manual labor the necessitude of slavery was lessened, allowing free thinkers and Christians alike to reexamine or more strongly push their notions of morality. Jefferson for example kept slaves only until he could afford to free them, his happy rhetoric before then didn't free them all on its own.

As an aside, rationalists and secular humanists etc. currently enslave and kill millions or billions of sentient or quasi-sentient beings (or are culpable agents in the process), with no apparent moral conflict. In that case my morals have much more in common with faith-based Buddhism than rationalism-based humanism. I suppose there are some rationalists or humanists who feel as I do, but I suppose there are some Christians that do as well.
 
Darth. A serious question: Are you embarrassed by why you believe what you believe?
No. Why would I be? :confused: It took me a long and convoluted journey to get where I am, and the journey forward is also on a winding road.
You don't need to justify yourself to me. I just want have a conversation, though you make it rather difficult. I want to understand how a rational and intelligent human being holds what seem to me to be quite clearly irrational thoughts.
What you hold as irrational is theoretical. What attracted me, at long last, was the people who applied service to Christ in their lives in a particular style. That was how the door was opened within me. As I said, I'm not there yet (evidence of my less than charitable nature abounds on the JREF sets of forums) but that's where I am headed.
I've tried to explain why I think they're irrational, but you haven't even uttered a word on the subject. Your entire scope of discourse on this topic (and this topic alone, I note) seems to be "Not telling!". If anyone could clearly explain why it is sensible and rational to hold Christian beliefs, you'd be him. But you won't.
You are asking for an answer that in my case is only partly formed, as the answer is entirely based on the fusion of the experiential and the application of selflessness and sacrifice as a daily habit.
I can't work out why that is. You're obviously capable of explaining your reasoning. You're obviously wise enough to have given this some serious thought. You're obviously open enough to discuss plenty of other things here, and you're obviously sufficiently sceptical of extra-ordinary and irrational claims to be dogged in your pursuit of them whence they arrive. So what's so different about this conversation?
Because my journey began via trial and error. What I have found is that when applied, the guiding principles make my life better, and bring me closer to peace. So, as I said, it works. As a rational and practical person, when it works, I tend to reinforce success. I've had enough practice at reinforcing failure in my life to try and avoid doing so.
You presume some ulterior motive. I have none. I admit I have made some assumptions about you, but in the absence of any forthcoming information from your own mouth, you can't blame me for that, can you?
No, I can't blame you, and won't. You can hardly blame me for being wary in a hostile environment: this sub forum in particular.

DR
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom