"Except for cases of rape or incest". Why?

That only applies if you think of abortion as a moral issue.

Of course it's a moral issue. That doesn't mean it's not also a legal issue, an economic issue, etc., but you can't pretend that the moral aspects don't exist. And for most people, the legal issue isn't inseparable from the moral one, even if you allow for some daylight between the two.
 
Reading in Gould talking about Jane Goodall's observations about a chimpanzee tribe one female member of which would kill all the newborns as quickly as it could get access, sometimes assisted by her daughter.
For several years.
Then it stopped doing that.
Late term abortions bother me, when babies born prematurely at times early than the usual late term point can survive with massive aid.
Seems to me that once this date (survival outside the mother is possible (practical?)) in a pregnancy is passed, then no abortion can be performed, only live delivery.
 
Because if a foetus is a person, then this innocent person is involuntarily paying the biggest consequence of all for something they had no choice in. Abortion then becomes primarily making someone else pay the consequences.

If you believe a foetus is a person, then this follows logically. If you do not believe a foetus is a person, it does not. That is, has been, and probably always will be the central moral question regarding abortion: what constitutes a person. And there is no definitive answer, no way to prove one side right or wrong.

Well, that's right, as far as it goes.

But we can add this, at least: we must not, on pain of begging an important question, define personhood as conferring the right to be brought to term inside a woman's body or conferring any other right that amounts to a duty imposed on the woman.

If the notion of personhood is to play a part in the argument, it has to be defined independently of abortion.
 
Actually, contraception isn't as easy as all that. The pill becomes less safe as a woman gets older, dangerous if she is over 30 and smokes. Condoms alone are one of the least effective forms of birth control (although much, much better that nothing.) The methods in between have their own problems.

There are methods that are near enough to 100% effective, especially with an older couple that don't want children.

Woman can remain fertile into their late 40's/early 50's. The older a woman a gets, the more problematic pregnancy can become. It is not uncommon for a woman to become pregnant after the age of 30 but it carries additional risks to the fetus and mother. There are many fertile years when the most effective birth control is not available.

And I have no issues where there are serious dangers involved for a mother carrying a child to term. I have know three women that were told if they got pregnant that they could very likely die. One chose to get a tubal ligation, one stayed with the Pill, and the other chose to actually try for a baby and ended up in a coma for three weeks after hemeraging and very nearly dying during birth. My point being that the only one of the three that got pregnant actually chose that course of action, the other chose courses that would minimise or eliminate the possibility.

For example, a married woman who is 35 might not be able to take the pill, other forms of birth control are less effective and abstinence is not an option. She is at risk for unwanted pregnancy.

Or she could get her husband to get a vasectomy.

Considering that 70% of the women in your statistics are over 25, there is a good chance that many of them fall into some variation of this.

I suggest you redo the math, 23+30+70=123%
 
The best birth control is only around 99% effective.

Care to cite this stat? For instance Depo-Provera® Hormonal Injections are claimed at greater than 99% effectiveness, and obviously if you use more than one form, for example, Hormonal Injections, a male Condom, and spermacide, then even using the typical failure rates you would drop your chance of getting pregnant to around 0.000364% or about 1:3,000. If you use them properly you can drop the chance to 0.000045%, or 1 in 20,000.
 
Because that's the way our society works. If you drive drunk and end lose your leg in a car accident as a result, the law doesn't allow you to get a prosthesis -- you have to take responsibility for your actions by living for the rest of your life with one leg. If you play with matches and start a fire that causes third-degree burns on your body, no doctor in his right mind will give you skin grafting treatment. If you smoke and contract lung cancer in any civilized country, you die a horrific death because lung cancer treatment is reserved for those who didn't contract the illness in a stupid way.

We're grown-ups who take responsibility for our actions. It's that simple.

So you honesty think that a 9-month pregnancy that most women manage to deal with, with little disruption to their daily lives for the majority of that time, is exactly the same as a lifetime debilitating injury or life-threatening disease?
 
So you honesty think that a 9-month pregnancy that most women manage to deal with, with little disruption to their daily lives for the majority of that time, is exactly the same as a lifetime debilitating injury or life-threatening disease?

I think that is very telling: "most women manage to deal with". So freaking what?
 
A late-term abortion (or the murder of a live infant) is just inefficient. It should be discouraged for that reason alone.

The whole concept of "personhood" never has to enter into it.


Whoa, man.

I see what you are saying and where you are coming from but, really, are you serious?

Late term abortion and infanticide should be discouraged because they are "just inefficient"?! No offense but are you for real?

Yes, from the viewpoint of selection and as a method of abortion/population control, they probably are- but that isn't even close to the real issue.

That's as if some said- searching for an analogy here- "Well, the death penalty by whipping someone to death over the course of a week or two and then slowly making them bleed to death by cutting off their toes is just inefficient. We should discourage it for that reason alone. Society would function much more smoothly if we just shot them all in prison, you know. Or didn't have the death penalty at all. That would be much less inefficient."

It doesn't even come close to discussing the real pro vs. con arguments of the death penalty.

Even the real practical arguments for or against it.

Which debatably shouldn't even figure into it at all.

So maybe I'm a bit more of a dreamer than you are but, to me, morality- whether it is something we have all made up or something more solid with a base in the world- and concepts like "person hood" have to enter into it.
 
Last edited:
The effectiveness of various forms of contraception is irrelevant. If contraceptives fail, an unwanted pregnancy ensues. It matters not a jot whether that happens one time or a million times.
Should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue that pregnancy?
 
But for the fewest of exceptions, abortion is murder for convenience to accommodate hedonistic decadence. Western societies are killing themselves and replacing themselves with foreigners.
Abortion is the suicide of a culture.
 
But for the fewest of exceptions, abortion is murder for convenience to accommodate hedonistic decadence. Western societies are killing themselves and replacing themselves with foreigners.
Abortion is the suicide of a culture.

Ah well: suicide is a personal choice so we will just have to put up with it ;)
 
But for the fewest of exceptions, abortion is murder for convenience to accommodate hedonistic decadence. Western societies are killing themselves and replacing themselves with foreigners.
Abortion is the suicide of a culture.

Ah, can't have them foreigners taking over now can we?
So, compulsory permanent pregnancy I guess it is. Preferably using fertility drugs to ensure multiple feotuses per pregnancy.
 
Uh, no. There's no "apparently" about it: she wouldn't. Your premise about what constitutes manslaughter is absurdly wrong, so your conclusion that treating a fetus legally like an adult (abortion = murder) would lead to criminal charges for miscarriages simply does not follow.
Not necessarily criminal charges -- just investigations.

Imagine that the couple across the street from you have a three-month-old baby. One day, you realize that you haven't seen the baby in several days. You ask the parents if she's okay. "No, she died," they say. "We didn't want to make a fuss, so we buried her in the back yard."

Would you, or would you not, report this to the police?

That would be called giving birth.
Seriously, do you think that any woman would wait all that time to decide she didn't actually want to be pregnant?
I've seen this preposterous strawman put forward many times: there seems to be this notion in the anti-choice community that every week or so, somewhere, a woman seven months pregnant -- happily pregnant, eagerly looking forward to having a child -- comes home from a day of shopping for layette sets and nursery furniture, finds an invitation in her mailbox, and cries in dismay, "Oh, no! This party is only a week away! However will I fit into a sexy dress?"

No, aborting the fetus during the 39th week would be called a third trimester abortion.
No, aborting a fetus in the 39th week would be called medically impossible.

A few years ago here there was a newspaper article about students doing exactly this, having unprotected group sex, with the guys all putting money into a pool so they could pay for an abortion if needed. Do you consider that acceptable behaviour?
Could you possibly be a little more vague?

Just for a bit of balance, I've heard some pro-choicer points of view that have seemed just as morally inconsistent as some of the pro-lifers'. For example some of them talk about babies and foetues as if something magical happens at the moment of birth that imbues the child with personhood. I don't know how anyone can believe that its perfectly ok to abort a foetus in the 38th week (where there is no medical reason for it), but a terrible crime to kill a newborn slightly premature baby. Now I know such a late abortion for non medical reasons just doesn't happen, but I have still heard some pro-choicers argue this point.
Yeah, crazy, isn't it? Some people just have the weirdest ideas. I've seen some people talk about husbands and bachelors as if something magical happens at the moment of marriage that imbues the bachelor with husbandhood! I've even heard some people suggest that something magical happens to an American child on its eighteenth birthday that magically imbues it with the right to vote!
 
Last edited:
The effectiveness of various forms of contraception is irrelevant. If contraceptives fail, an unwanted pregnancy ensues. It matters not a jot whether that happens one time or a million times.
Should a woman with an unwanted pregnancy be forced to continue that pregnancy?

Do you think it's acceptable to flout the law because you don't want to use birth control?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom